A scrapbook page painting, given depth by an indication of horizon and a distant 'flying' elephant (which didn't work) hence the filamentous legs. Definitely not one of his best pictures. My top three. The burning giraffe, Mae West and the body tearing itself apart... the classic image of civilwar

Douglas Miller, Fulham,

Matchless!

Ramesh Parida, Delhi, India

A classic in the same sense of many a tattooed forearm.

RD, San Miguel de Allende, Mexico

It's pretty average. I'll start the bidding at $100.

Dean, Brisbane, Australia

I have visited Dali's birthplace to see his work several times.I do think this is a classic,I recall as a child the prayer "If I die and do not wake pray to god my soul to take"I think this is in the same vain/sentiment a sort of epitaph that covers life and death with equal passion.Out of body!!

Mary E Hoult , Leeds,

Whatever one makes of the drama unfolding, the utter audacity of its conception is marvelously matched by the manifest virtuosity of its execution. For this reason alone it should rank as a classic of its kind, but otherwise merely a curiosity.

James Parker, Toronto, Canada

"Creat art" often recognized AFTER artist's death and era ended. Turner paintings described as: Tending to imbecility - by head of Royal Academy. Impressionists'work didn't sell in their lifetime. Dali's work projects HIM - and brilliant technique. It's essentially of its class - surrealism.

Leigh Vernier, Riyadh, Saudi Arabia

Of course it's a classic. Knowing precious little about art, if I were asked to picture a surrealist painting, it would be either this one or Dali's other one with the melting clocks (told you I know precious little). It's quite simply one of the 2 foremost surrealist paintings.

DC, Glasgow,

To be a "classic" a work of art has to stand out well above similar works, and I don't think this painting does that. It is, however, a very good picture, initially obscure but then truly thought provoking. The composition is superb; it's just a pity about the title.

Ray R, London, England

This is the painting that hung as a poster over my bed when I was a student. The more I looked at it, the more fitting I found the title. So, to me, it's a "classic".

Christopher Stevens, Lille, France

why would it not be a classic? Too many other pieces of art are classed as a 'classic' when they do little more to enhance art other than another painting in some long forgotten library. There shouldn't be such a large gap between classic painting and recent painting. Dali should be remembered.

Tim Newman, Leeds, England

Fish....

wilko, Buckingham, UK

I could look at this for hours, but is it a classic? Doesn't "classic" imply that multitudes recognize it as some kind of icon? I think it could be a classic, probably should be a classic, but whether it is or not depends on your definition of the word..

Jim McIntyre, Phoenix, America