AA Gill
Free Elizabeth Arden gift and goodie bags to be won
In a week of lamentations, we had three deaths, three final curtain calls through the invisible fourth wall among those who put on the motley. The rude mechanicals must now cast aside Thalia’s smiling mask to wear Melpomene’s tragic visage. Anthony Minghella, whose shocking exit came just as his last film was about to be shown; Paul Scofield, a truly heroic actor. I watched the six o’clock news as the caster, some Autocue plug-in with a muted accent from semidetached nowhere, arranged his face into that bland gravitas they keep for the latterly famous and freshly demised. He said: “Today, a great and dearly loved actor passed away, best known for his portrayal of one of the old gits in Last of the Summer Wine, and the prison officer who wasn’t the main one in Porridge. Brian Wilde will be greatly missed.” Then we saw a couple of unfunny clips and a hasty interview with a cardiganed denizen of decrepit sitcoms, and it was back to the studio, where the Noddy rote-reader added his own little “Sadly missed”, and looked up at the Autocue with a flicker of panic.
Oh no, there was another dead actor. What were the chances he had peaked too early, already using up his famous-deceased face? So, he quickly slipped into the one reserved for announcing small tornadoes in Cornwall and said: “Another actor died today: Paul Scofield, best known as that religious bloke in A Man for All Weathers.” There was a blurred photograph of Scofield from behind, as Lear, and it was back to weather or sport or an alsatian that was living in sin with a duckling. This happened on both ITV and the BBC early-evening news.
I don’t often bellow at the television. I don’t have to. I can do this instead. But I went properly radio rental – the complete Basil Fawlty, all on my own in the living room, screaming at the inoffensive, lick-spittle, Andrex-puppy newsmonger and the smiley, culturally relative, accessible, nonjudgmental, multi-cultural, mouthwashed, soulless, fearful Tristrams who, in the final billing of death, had placed the man with two supporting parts in defunct comedies before one of the truly great postwar British actors.
This was not Wilde’s fault, but not even his agent would claim he was a panoramic, life-changing talent. I know that, as both approached the pearly gates, Brian would have said: “After you, old man.”
What made me, and still makes me, angry is that this cultural faux pas wasn’t made on some kids’ magazine programme or a funky satellite celebrity round-up - it was the six o’clock news. The biggest job in all news is setting the running order, deciding what is and isn’t important enough to be broadcast. News is the one part of public broadcasting that can’t be dictated by public opinion, but only by public service - not what we want to know, but what we should and need to know. And I know exactly why some smiley, young, pulsating gumboil of a know-nothing, sneery, cynical, bearded relativist thought a minor sitcom actor was more important than Paul Scofield. He thought it was a small, sniggering blow against elitism, hardback culture, the Establishment and snobbery - and probably fox-hunting, global warming and the invasion of Tibet. I’ve never called for anyone to be fired in this column, but this little prat should be. Not just fired - he should be handed over, naked and sobbing, to the Royal Shakespeare Company to play Yorick. I still don’t feel any better.
Minghella’s last production was, on the face of it, an odd choice for the man who directed The English Patient and operas. The No 1 Ladies’ Detective Agency(Sunday, BBC1) was adapted for television by Richard Curtis, and financed and facilitated in part by the Botswana government as a tourist commercial. I should admit to not having read any of Alexander McCall Smith’s books, but I watched this with a couple of women who had, and I understand that to read them is to love them, and that almost everybody has.
Botswana is the flattest country on earth. It was a protectorate, never a colony, and it is one of my favourite places. It did look ravishing. How nice to have an African programme actually shot in the country it says it is and not a bit of southern Spain. Within 10 minutes, I was getting a not entirely euphoric Herriot recall. Curtis and Minghella have, between them, attempted to do the hardest thing in television drama. It’s what they call charm and you and I know as whimsy. If you can get the audience to swallow whimsy without regurgitating, they will curl up in your palm every Sunday for as long as you can be bothered to spoon it to them. I was less convinced by it all than the people who watched it with me, who kept telling me how true to the feelings of the book it was. I found the laid-back pace somnambulant. I did like the way it showed Africa as a parochial, funny and magical place, however. Those who say this portrait is patronising and naive and lacks grit never seem to complain about the bogus romanticism of Coronation Street or EastEnders or anything with Martin Clunes in it. Africa deserves this bright alternative after decades of charity appeals. Whether the main character and her softly comic accomplices, solving simple, unexciting crimes with parable denouement, can win Sunday-evening hearts, who can tell? Yet I can’t think of a good reason why they shouldn’t.
He Kills Coppers (Sunday, ITV1) was an adaptation of Jake Arnott’s book, which, in turn, was a factionalisation of the murders of three policemen in London, taking us through the now overfamiliar television territory of Soho in the 1960s, when organised crime was run by cuddly Maltese and not Albanians or Russians. Innocent times - when murder victims were placed neatly in left-luggage offices, human trafficking meant a couple of fat girls down from Wigan and drugs were nicked out of your mum’s handbag. This production nearly drowns in its period detail and the terrible self-conscious smoking everyone takes part in, as if it were public oral sex. Fags are this year’s dramatic tic to provide 20th-century atmosphere. The best thing about it - apart from Maureen Lipman, always a pleasure - was that Rafe Spall has finally found a role that properly utilises his undoubted, though narrow, talent as a particular weak sort of unsympathetic bully. His recent roles in costume drama have all been casting directors’ wishful thinking. He has an undoubtable, watchable power, but it only goes this far. The sooner he gets himself typecast, the better.
Gossip Girl(Thursday, ITV2) is a meritless exploitation of puritan press intrusion and internet scandal-mongering into the lives of meritless people, following the vapid snobberies and prim sexual peccadilloes of the young and rich with shiny hair. American drama, as I noted last week, is captivated by salivating, envious window-shopping for the fantasy lives of rich people. These programmes are more of a sign of imminent financial depression than anything on Bloomberg. This particular nose pressed against the window of wealth porn was immoral, ugly and dispiriting. If you think The No 1 Ladies’ Detective Agency is an unlikely view of Africa, it’s nothing to the fairy-tale propaganda of this Dante-esque vision of New York.
Follow our three athletes' progress in their preparations for the London Triathlon, and pick up training tips and more
Enjoy screenings of all the classic films you love, plus take advantage of two-for-one tickets
We explore leisure activities that are safe and suitable for all of the family
Times Online's new TV show helps you make the right decisions for your pet
Read our exclusive 100 Years of Fleming and Bond interactive timeline, packed with original Times articles and reviews
The latest travel news plus the best hotels and gadgets for business travellers

Times Exclusive Tickets £25
£129,500
Bentley Edinburgh
£79,850
Mercedes-Benz of Northampton
£26,995
Unit 1, Woodfield Business Unit, Kidderminster Road, Ombersley, Worcester.
Great car insurance deals online
90k + Bonus + Options
Confidential
London
£23,716 +
Highways Agency
National
£
£43,405 - £48,228 pa
Notting Hill Housing
London
£38k
Barclaycard
Various Locations
Live in One of London's Most Vibrant Areas
From £249,950
Beautiful Gardens w/ stunning Thames Views
Studios £33K, 1 Beds £60K, 2 beds £79K
Mortgages, bank acc & money transfers to help you buy abroad
Explore mystical Jordan
From £1030 for 7nts 4*
to USA's Most Cosmopolitan City; San Francisco!
£POA
Book Now for Winter 08/09 and Get 10% off!
Great travel insurance deals online
Contact our advertising team for advertising and sponsorship in Times Online, The Times and The Sunday Times. Search globrix.com to buy or rent UK property. Visit our classified services and find jobs, used cars, property or holidays. Use our dating service, read our births, marriages and deaths announcements, or place your advertisement.
Copyright 2008 Times Newspapers Ltd.
This service is provided on Times Newspapers' standard Terms and Conditions. Please read our Privacy Policy.To inquire about a licence to reproduce material from Times Online, The Times or The Sunday Times, click here.This website is published by a member of the News International Group. News International Limited, 1 Virginia St, London E98 1XY, is the holding company for the News International group and is registered in England No 81701. VAT number GB 243 8054 69.
Stephen from Glasgow's diatribe about the monstrous abomination that is Richard Curtis dialogue will have every pompous luvvie in the land braying with approval. Stephen from Glasgow will argue otherwise, but his comment in his final paragraph absolutely reeks of snobbery.
I adored the scripting of No 1 Ladies not so much because it borrowed so much from the books, and captured their spirit perfectly in the original sections - although that's a perfectly valid reason in itself - but because it annoys the likes of Stephen from Glasgow.
Stuart, Bristol,
Greetings from Oregon, USA!! ...where we have a medical marijuana law that allows sufferers of diseases such as multiple sclerosis, AIDS, to benefit, for instance, from marijuana's well-documented pain-killer and appetite enhancement effects.
Mr. Gordon Brown seems to not believe the many reports on
marijuana's medical benefits; perhaps he should read said reports!
Charles Thieleman, Eugene, Oregon, USA
"I was watching Jonathon Ross on Friday and Natasha Kaplinsky seems to think a news reader's job is rather difficult, but then listening to John Humphries the other day I got the impression he thought it wasn't difficult. Who to believe. "
Both of them. One finds it challenging, the other easy. Make of that what you will...
Jamie, Bolton, UK
If Paul Scofield had accepted a knighthood on one of the three times he was offered one, then it would have reversed the order. They would have been exhalting his memory with a vast array of long words. The fact that it is far more interesting that he was not a knight seems to have passed them by. I was watching Jonathon Ross on Friday and Natasha Kaplinsky seems to think a news reader's job is rather difficult, but then listening to John Humphries the other day I got the impression he thought it wasn't difficult. Who to believe.
Alex, London,
Thank you Angus Gill for protesting about the BBC's curious treatment of Paul Scofield. Generations of theatregoers remember him with affection and awe.
When the other great actors of the 20th century died - an obituary programme was shown - on all channels and a film also shown later.
The other curious BBC Radio 4 response was Mark Lawson's mention of Paul Scofield's passing. Why did they not have Peter Brook or Peter Hall on the telephone instead of an actor 'who had seen him as a schoolboy play Lear' Scofield's Cordelia - Dame Diana Rigg, or his other leading ladies i.e. Claire Bloom, Felicity Kendal, Vanessa Redgrave or Eileen Atkins? Richard Eyre directed what sadly turned out to be his last stage performance but Brook and Hall worked with him during his long career.
I am of Angus Gill's opinion. It was simply not good enough news reporting. Thank you AA Gill.
diane susans, London W1W 6HL, England
How many people, hand on heart can say they have seen Paul Schofield in anything ever. Classical theatre is, for good or bad, a minority sport. On the other hand, millions of licence fee payers have seen, and liked, Brian Wilde.
Sedgwick, London, UK
What in heaven's name was A A Gill doing, watching the BBC six o'clock news? If his job description really requires him to submit himself to this nightly ordeal by dumbo, any good contract lawyer should be able to have the offending clause removed as being terminally deleterious to Mr G's (mental) health and safety (of the intellect).
Robin Surtees, Leicester, England
Christopher Hart has given Howard Brenton's "Never So Good" at the Lyttelton, National Three Stars -
which in your scoring guide equates to "Two in the Circle". My sister and I were those "Two in the second row of the Circle" last week and we left at the Interval as neither of us could hear Jeremy Irons or appreciate the play which Christopher Hart saw. Perhaps you had to be within the first ten rows to catch the acting as it faded before it reached the Circle. There were some enormously loud pyrotechnics and a fire on stage which were alarming without adding much to an altogether disappointing evening.
Christine Bull, Chislehurst, Kent, UK
Which is more worrying - that some Tristram took a conscious decision to "run" Paul Schofield behind Brian Wilde or the possibility that he genuinely couldn't differentiate the impact of their respective careers? Equating the achievements of a minor comic turn who was as funny as lead poisoning with a revered classical actor is not a blow for the zeitgist; it is a symptom of the sane lack of depth, illiteracy and plain old ignorance that has allowed cardboard cutouts like Jamie Oliver and Alan Titchmarsh to become "national treasures". It's not snobbery to find this slightly disturbing, just a desire to hold on to some standards of intellectual rigour and a yearning to turn back the tsunami of saccharine and lachrymose mediocrity that is engulfing us.
Esther, London,
I read recently that AA Gill is dyslexic. That explains those words which he uses that I have never seen before. I still enjoy his witterings though.
brian corbett, Miami, Florida
Why get so worked up about the running order of a couple of obituaries? Brian Wilde probably gave as much pleasure in his work as Paul Schofield, and certainly to many more people.
John Harry, London, England
To what you said and how you feel about Mr. Scofield, I say "Amen." The best of actors, the best of men.
Sharon M. Kennedy, Laurel, USA/Maryland
AA Gill's diatribe about the monstrous slur the BBC perpetrated on Paul Scofield will have every pompous luvvie in the land braying with approval. Mr Gill will argue otherwise, but his comments in the first five paragraphs absolutely reek of snobbery.
I agree with the running order the BBC chose for announcing the passing of Brian Wilde and Paul Scofield, not so much because far more people were acquainted with Brian's work - although that's a perfectly valid reason in itself - but because it annoys the likes of Mr Gill.
As for The No.1 Ladies' Detective Agency, the strange remark about Coronation Street aside, I'm afraid I'll have to take our reviewer's word for it, as I'm allergic to anything scripted by the unfathomably successful Richard Curtis.
Stephen, Glasgow,
Maureen Lipman, always a pleasure?
I seem to recall a splendid and splenetic tirade by your good self against none other than Ms Lipman some years ago that was not too dissimilar from the one you've heaped here upon the news organising Tristram. It included the wonderful description of the actress as a "three flush floater". I've never been able to watch her in the same way since. Thank you.
Kevin Browne, Reading, Berkshire, England