Win a fitness package worth more than £3,000

Six years of fighting for justice left Lotfi Raissi an emotional and physical wreck and his marriage close to ruin. But yesterday, the Algerian pilot falsely accused of training the September 11 terrorists heard, finally, that he was “completely exonerated” of any part in the attacks on the twin towers.
As Mr Raissi pored over the Court of Appeal’s densely worded judgment, the lengths to which the authorities had bent the rules to detain him in the febrile days after September 11 became clear.
Three of Britain’s most senior judges condemned the Metropolitan Police and the Crown Prosecution Service for abusing the court process, presenting false allegations and not disclosing evidence.
But it was not until page 44, paragraph 154, line 17 that Mr Raissi’s eyes settled upon the words he had been praying for. The judges ruled that the charge that he was a terrorist and had trained the September 11 hijackers was one of which he should be “completely exonerated”. His only “crime” was to learn his skills at the same Florida flying school as two of the hijackers.
Mr Raissi’s eyes filled with tears and he “wept with relief”. Outside the Royal Courts of Justice yesterday he told The Times: “I’ve regained my dignity, it feels as if I can breathe and I am free again. The judges have said there were serious faults and an abuse of process in my case and that has restored my faith in British justice. I knew this day would come.”
The judges also ordered the Home Office and the Ministry of Justice to reconsider the repeated refusal to compensate Mr Raissi for locking him in Belmarsh prison for six months and accusing him of the murders of thousands of people. Solicitors for Mr Raissi, 33, are expected to lodge a claim for compensation which — taking into account his loss of a career as an airline pilot, wrongful imprisonment and damage to his health — is expected to exceed £2 million.
But it will take more than money to repair Mr Raissi’s damaged life. His mental and physical health have deteriorated, his marriage to his French wife, Sonia, has suffered and his childhood dream of being a pilot is shattered for ever.
After the September 11 attacks a frightened world waited, dreading the next atrocity. Across the Atlantic, the FBI, the CIA and every law enforcement agency were chasing leads on the background of the 19 terrorists who had hijacked the four airliners.
In Phoneix, Arizona, they came across a flight school called Sawyer Aviation where Hani Hanjour — who crashed an airliner into the Pentagon — had trained. The school was popular with Middle Eastern trainees and one of those at Sawyer at the same time as Hanjour was Mr Raissi.
He had, checks quickly established, left the US and was now living in Britain. On September 17, a letter from the legal attaché at the US Embassy in London was delivered to Scotland Yard’s anti-terrorist branch.
“The FBI request that this matter be handled as expeditiously and discreetly as possible,” the letter said. The words “expeditiously” and “discreetly” were typed in bold.
Ten days later Scotland Yard executed its response to the American request. Armed officers smashed down the door of Mr Raissi’s flat in Colnbrook, Berkshire, not far from Heathrow, and arrested him and his wife at gunpoint. The media hailed the arrest in Britain of the first suspects in the global hunt for the men who planned the worst terrorist attacks ever seen. An extradition warrant was issued for Mr Raissi on a “holding charge” that he had failed to disclose a theft conviction on his US immigration application. But in the courts, British lawyers representing the US Government made much more serious allegations.
Industry sectors news at a glance. Interactive heatmap, video and podcast
The inside track on current trends in the charity, not for profit and social enterprise sectors
Read our exclusive 100 Years of Fleming and Bond interactive timeline, packed with original Times articles and reviews
Everything the Business Traveller needs to know to make a better trip
Shortcuts to help you find sections and articles
05/2005
£13,500
08/2008
£109,950
2006
£10,750
Great car insurance deals online
£Excellent+ executive benefits
Torres and Partners
London
£49,229 - £62,035 pro rata
Charity Commission
London/Liverpool/Taunton
Alstom Power
Europe
Six Figure
Rolls Royce
Midlands/Europe
From £89,950
Great Investment, River Views
Special Offers now available
New Year in the USA!
.
Cruise the Islands of Hawaii - Pride of America
List your property with two leading travel websites
Great travel insurance deals online
Contact our advertising team for advertising and sponsorship in Times Online, The Times and The Sunday Times, or place your advertisement.
Times Online Services: Dating | Jobs | Property Search | Used Cars | Holidays | Births, Marriages, Deaths
News International associated websites: Globrix | Property Finder | Milkround
Copyright 2008 Times Newspapers Ltd.
This service is provided on Times Newspapers' standard Terms and Conditions. Please read our Privacy Policy.To inquire about a licence to reproduce material from Times Online, The Times or The Sunday Times, click here.This website is published by a member of the News International Group. News International Limited, 1 Virginia St, London E98 1XY, is the holding company for the News International group and is registered in England No 81701. VAT number GB 243 8054 69.
Who can you sue...let's see...how about who ordered the worlds elite defense system to stand down? How about who ignored all the warnings? How about who scheduled all the "War Games" going on that morning to "confuse" the radar folks? How about suing whoever planted the thermite explosives in the THREE buildings that were imploded?
Or maybe just cut to the chase and sue the CIA for creating this phony bogey man Al Queada and arch villain Bin Laden. It is all a farce, to frighten us into giving up our freedoms and to accept things like false imprisonment, no access to lawyers or family, no habeas corpus, torture , on and on. You all may be spared some of the worst over there but we here in Amerika are headed for a real fascist nightmare............unless we can get the truth out soon.
John Burke, Baltimore, USA
Mr. Raissi should be grateful that he had a trial in the British courts. Had he, or anyone else for that matter, been held in US custody, there is no doubt that he would have been tortured and no amount of evidence proving his innocence would probably been admitted. Similar stories of others in US custody in Guantanamo are beginning to emerge. Luckily, This unfortunate man was able to present his case in a court of law and show that it was not even an accident that he had been incorrectly held in custody for all these years.
Now, it is time to bring justice to those who used unfair and illicit means to destroy this man's life.
Andy Jones, Bermuda, Bermuda
I totally agree with Martin Gheczy but you are the ones that put yourselves up to be better, what good is it to invade a country under the pretext of creating Democarcy and then act like people you are ejecting.
If you say you are better, you need to act that way as well. Torture in Guantánamo, detention without trial etc. Walk the walk !!
We never believed you then, we dont believe you now, you have proved it.
Frank Louw, Joburg, RSA
It doesn't happen often, but at times like this I'm proud to be British. The cheating of Mr Raissi is probably small beer compared with some of the other things we've done on behalf of the torturers and perverts, but we can and should do the decent thing and compensate our victim in this case.
Andy Dyer, London, UK,
For all the comments already listed - both funny and serious - where are the ones asking who is going to make the police and the CPS answer for this. They have pandered to US prejudice, wasted taxpayers money, wasted the court's time, and that's before we even get to effects on the poor individual concerned.
HOW MANY POLICE OFFICERS AND LAWYERS ARE GOING TO JAIL BECAUSE OF THIS FARCE??
KR, Stockport,
Martin. I agree with you. However, as a civilized society, we must ensure that everyone is treated fairly and equally under the law. Terrorism and extremism must be addressed, but the basic rights of the indivisual must be respected.
Hamad Lone, London, England
how come the british taxpayer is going to have this guy compensation when we acting on bahalf of the USA?
Garth Wiseman, london, england
Quite rightly we should compensate Mr Raissi for his appalling treatment he has received.
Yet again the taxpayer has to pay for inept government and the lies of the state police.
Shame on the the ones arguing against this, you are NOT fit to live in a decent country, then again, none of us do in the UK
Tab-a Sadam, West Yorkshire, UK
I do wish there was anything in the islamic world that would even come close to the British justice system. That muslims in the Western world enjoy the same rights as christians or people of any other faith is something that to Muslims seems quite natural and only fair. Maybe just as natural as the fact that non-muslims are discriminated against in much of the muslim world (after all they are just bleeding infidels ...)?
Martin Gheczy, Lucerne, Switzerland
The rule of law and due process is beginning to return to this country as the judges begin to fight back at the Blairite "guilt by accusation" police state.
In recent days we have seen a judge abolish the gestapo-esque thought-crimes agenda, and now another judge has dared contradict the anti-freedom authoritarian tendencies of Blairite ministers.
Is there any surprise that the Metropolitan Police routinely breaks the 1,000 year-old legal privelege of confidentiality between lawyer and client when it's chief secretly bugged conversations between him and the country's leading legal officials.
If the nation cannot rely on its discredited, snouts-in-trough members of parliament, at least we can rely on the judges to protect our liberties.
Time to abolish state tyranny.
Ben Franklin, Freetown, Liberia
Many people forget about the high feelings after 9/11 and other terrorist atrocities, notably those in London. Mr Raissi's arrest was a mistake, it seems. Fine. It happens often, in every country. There were other mistakes, such as Jean Charles de Menezes's.
But the extremists started it, not us. Had all these atrocities not happened, there would have been no Raissi case and no Menezes death. Some cynics could call it collateral damage.
It seems Mr Raissi is trying to make a buck out of the British taxpayer. Give him what he's owed and kick him out. He's Algerian, he's got no right to be here.
Peter, London,
£2m - not bad pay for 5 months inconvenience. Where do I apply for this wonderful opportunity at the UK taxpayers expense
Steven, Chalfont,
David, Nigel, I believe you are both missing the point that the pilot had no invovlement in 9/11. The only reason he was held etc was because he happened to go to the same flight school.
I would assume that neither of you would like to be held without trial just on the off chance you may have been involved based on zero evidence.
David, I truely hope that one day actual justice will be done for your suffering.
Conoe, Belfast, Ireland
They call it the information age, this just confirms it's the compensation age we're all living in - further confirmed by another news story I heard this morning about William Hill who are being sued by a customer, because they didn't stop him.
Perhaps in the case of Mr. Raissi though, he deserves any compensation he will receive because there is no evidence that proves he is a terrorist, particularly as his career as a pilot lies in ruins.
Hassan Azam, Banbury , Oxfordshire, England
When a person; such as Mr. Raissi, is arrested under the Terrorism Act in such a typical manner; and by that I mean early morning raid on his home, public arrest etc. Then the Police must have cause for such action, and I am sure that in this case they believed they did. If in the end however, it is shown that the Police made a mistake or their intelligence was incorrect, then they must bare the burden of apology. In a case such as this, where a man has built a career in aviation; one that take many years of training and qualification, to have that career halted and essentially made worthless, it is incumbent upon the police and the courts to ensure that this man âgets his life backâ. I personally believe that the Police; and in this particular case due to the very public nature of it the government, should apologize and give this man every opportunity to rebuild his life, his career and his relationships.
It is understandable that in todayâs world there will be early morning raids on homes etc and it is understandable that the police are doing the job that we ask of them. But it should also be âunderstandableâ that sometimes (though they hate to admit it â and sometimes cannot admit it) the police get it wrong and there must be a system to put back the lives that are shattered as a result of those unfortunate events.
David Parrack, Dubai, UAE
What a terrible mark of shame this has caused the authorities.
To get a guilty verdict at any cost is not new to them.
I shudder to think of the no doubt many others incarcerated in jails who shouldn't be there.
Thankfully the appeal process is still untainted.
They can't compensate this man enough.
richard, bangkok,
Dear Mr. MacDonald,
As a criminal lawyer for 32 years, my experience is that anyone can get wrongly or rightly accused,you pray then that there is someone good and brave enough to give you a good defence.
You should thank someone, that you still have an independent court of Appeal, who are not the lackies of the ruling party of the day, maybe you'd feel more comfortable living in Pakistan at the moment, their judges seem to do what the powers that be ,wish them to do.
I do wish that you will have your door kicked in by the police at 5 a.m. and a gun shoved in your face, if you are lucky they shoot you 7 times in the head and call it a sad mistake like some poor Brazilian.
If you are not lucky they persecute you and destroy your life and family and incarcerate you and after 10 years, someone might say you are innocent and it was all a bad mistake.
I am sure you will understand and because you are a Christian you will forgive those who trespassed against you and not seek damages.
Alberto Eduardo Noronha, Maitland, N.S.W., Australia
"Further proof that the Law in this country has nothing to do with Law or Justice, but the manipulation of legal technicalities. How many more terrorists are the Court of Appeal going to let free - perhaps they should be made a target. - Nigel MacDonald, Camborne, UK"
Really? I thought we were telling those Iraqis that we, the greatest democracy of all, are the epitome of law and justice. Make up your mind.
It is the selective perception and narrow-mindedness of people like you that gets us into these messes in the first place. It would defeat the point of the principles of karma for one to hope that karma finds you.
MC, London,
Just to add to Mr Knight's comments, this bloke had no connection whatsoever with any of the terrorists.
Rob, Brum, UK
Let us hope Mr MacDonald you do not have the 'bad luck' to have your door kicked in at 3am in the morning, perhaps you would have a different view then. Just to clarify there was no evidence then (2001) or now (2008) and one assumes in the intervening years of this man having anything to do with the crime. Your facts are also wrong the Court of Appeal did not release him, he has never been charged or convicted of anything at all connected with the attacks. Law and justice should be about the right person or people being convicted of the right crime. Unfortunately, not for the first time and certainly not the last the CPS and the police have got it wrong. Hopefully your door is not next.
Mr Knight, London, England
Further proof that the Law in this country has nothing to do with Law or Justice, but the manipulation of legal technicalities. How many more terrorists are the Court of Appeal going to let free - perhaps they should be made a target.
Nigel MacDonald, Camborne, UK
It's sad to hear of your suffering David.
However, that does not excuse the fact that this man's life was destroyed for nothing and that he was denied justice by our government. He deserves justice, exoneration and compensation.
As do you. If there were true justice in the world, you would be able to sue the US government. Sadly, that's not possible.
I wish you the best, as I do Mr Raissi.
Liberte, London, England
Who can I sue over the years of PTSD and suicidal depression I have suffered since experiencing 9/11. Since that fateful day in New York I have been through my own hell; my career has been interrupted and my family life is in turmoil. 9/11 triggered such a dreadful time for me that it is only now that I am slowly and with much help from doctors finding my feet again. Who can I sue?
David Turnbull, London, United Kingdom