Alice Miles
Win a fitness package worth more than £3,000
No man is an island - Gordon Brown quoted John Donne in India last month - “and he was writing in defiance of a world and a time which had more reason to think of itself just as individuals pursuing their own ends. But as he suggested, in the world of 2008, our self-interest and our shared interest should be seen as one and the same.”
Sorry to plunge you straight into the turgid stuff.
Intimating that Donne was making suggestions about “the world of 2008”, meditating morbidly upon Alistair Darling and Northern Rock, seems stretching it to me, but I suppose you never know. Certainly an awful lot of things have come crashing home to land on Mr Brown's beach this week.
For the nationalisation of the Rock wasn't really about Mr Darling, or the competence of the Treasury. It wasn't really even about Northern Rock; most people are not unduly concerned about that - the bank had clearly become part of the public sector already, propped up by government subsidy, and the Conservatives' hysterical overreaction only made them look young and stupid. Public outrage will erupt if the Rock's shareholders are compensated, but only then.
So, no, Monday wasn't about any of those. It was about the Prime Minister, his Government, his character.
Mr Brown looked shattered on Monday. Not at the Downing Street press conference, but during Mr Darling's statement to the Commons, when the morning's make-up had presumably worn off and the Prime Minister, sitting next to the Chancellor, may have forgotten that the cameras were still trained on him. He looked as if he could barely keep his eyes open. Mind you, you could hardly see his eyes for the heavy black circles engulfing them. One of them twitched nervously, or angrily, or just tiredly. Whether or not it is true, as reported at the weekend, that Mr Brown is surviving on three hours' sleep a night, it is easy to believe. Even his own Communities Secretary, Hazel Blears, has publicly advised him to find some “balance” in his life: “a bit of fun as well as a bit of hard work”.
The easy badinage among the ministers surrounding him on the front bench on Monday never penetrated the Prime Minister's small black pod; it wouldn't have been able to find its way in.
No man is an island... For many months, the Prime Minister has been undermining his colleagues. The most obvious example was the cack-handed briefing from No 10 against a pro-European speech made by the Foreign Secretary, David Miliband, last November. But the Prime Minister is also a publicity thief. He steals announcements on security from the Home Secretary, Jacqui Smith, and allows his old mate Jack Straw to nick much of the rest of her brief. He swiped the announcement on using the private sector to get people off welfare and into work from the new Pensions Secretary last month. Watch him steal Ms Smith's thunder again today, overshadowing her Green Paper with a speech on citizenship.
When it isn't Mr Brown personally, it's his henchman and trainee PM, the Schools Secretary, Ed Balls, who muscles in on anything he can, from the drive against obesity unveiled by Alan Johnson last month (Mr Balls announced part of it a day earlier) to the new Culture Secretary's plan to introduce culture into schools.
Undermining his colleagues makes Mr Brown look small. A Prime Minister afraid of being surrounded by strong characters diminishes himself. A man unable to let others grow in stature only succeeds in making himself look petty and afraid.
Conversely, the way to succeed as prime minister is to foster strong characters around you. (Not necessarily as strong as Tony Blair allowed his Chancellor to be, but that's another argument.) I never thought I would say it, but listening to him interviewed on the radio this weekend, I found myself thinking how much we miss John Prescott.
No one has been more diminished than Mr Brown's Chancellor, forced to jump and bend to the will and whim of No 10 and then to account for their decisions. If Mr Darling is not big enough now to draw the flak from the Prime Minister, that is the Prime Minister's fault.
But the Chancellor is beginning to show signs of independence, letting it be known that he has had his disagreements with Mr Brown, and even suggesting in an interview at the weekend that any “robust exchanges” he has enjoyed with the Prime Minister are being saved for his memoirs. He looked a lot more relaxed than Mr Brown has this week. And other ministers - Alan Johnson at health, Mr Miliband, Mr Purnell - are beginning at last to make an impact in their own right.
In the meantime, the pieces of Northern Rock litter No 10. Move away from Westminster and hear what people think: that these are Mr Brown's chickens coming home to roost, a Chancellor and now Prime Minister who floated a public spending boom off the back of a greedy financial sector betting in increasingly convoluted structures not understood by politicians on rising house prices artificially inflated by foreign billionaires, the whole underpinned by ordinary people unprotected by a weak regulatory system put in place by the same man now intent upon using our money to prop up votes in his northern heartlands. Or something like that. Welcome to Britain, 2008: caustic, cynical, furious, and agog at the impotence of politicians in the face of the amoral, international super-rich.
As Mr Brown didn't quote the miserable Donne as continuing, never send to know for whom the bell tolls - it tolls for thee.

Alice Miles has been with The Times since 1999. She began as a Parliamentary Sketch writer before becoming a columnist, writing mainly on politics and national issues such as education and health. She won Columnist of the Year in 2007.
Industry sectors news at a glance. Interactive heatmap, video and podcast
The inside track on current trends in the charity, not for profit and social enterprise sectors
Read our exclusive 100 Years of Fleming and Bond interactive timeline, packed with original Times articles and reviews
Everything the Business Traveller needs to know to make a better trip
Shortcuts to help you find sections and articles
05/2005
£13,500
08/2008
£109,950
2006
£10,750
Great car insurance deals online
£Excellent+ executive benefits
Torres and Partners
London
£49,229 - £62,035 pro rata
Charity Commission
London/Liverpool/Taunton
Alstom Power
Europe
Six Figure
Rolls Royce
Midlands/Europe
From £89,950
Great Investment, River Views
Special Offers now available
At the new sophisticated
Encore Las Vegas Resort!
Cruise the Islands of Hawaii - Pride of America
List your property with two leading travel websites
Great travel insurance deals online
Contact our advertising team for advertising and sponsorship in Times Online, The Times and The Sunday Times, or place your advertisement.
Times Online Services: Dating | Jobs | Property Search | Used Cars | Holidays | Births, Marriages, Deaths
News International associated websites: Globrix | Property Finder | Milkround
Copyright 2008 Times Newspapers Ltd.
This service is provided on Times Newspapers' standard Terms and Conditions. Please read our Privacy Policy.To inquire about a licence to reproduce material from Times Online, The Times or The Sunday Times, click here.This website is published by a member of the News International Group. News International Limited, 1 Virginia St, London E98 1XY, is the holding company for the News International group and is registered in England No 81701. VAT number GB 243 8054 69.
So the gist of Alice's argument here is that Brown is a bad PM because ... because ... he looks shattered? Does that mean that his decidedly non-shattered appearance at PMQs today when he wiped the floor with Dave "student debater" Cameron means that he is now a good PM? Alice, you're scraping the barrel for anti-Brown arguments here.
Bob, London,
Don't think much of Brown. Didn't think much of the article either.
Mark, Glasgow,
SK - We may appear more wealthy than 10 years ago but it has been done using the illusion of debt.
Perhaps one of Mr Brown's greatest achievements is to convince us of this.
The piper has to be paid at some point.
Granville, London, UK
Is another government acievement inter- planetary travel. Must be, as SK is clearly living on a different one!
Ian, Menorca, Spain
The penny has dropped! Thanks to Gordon Brown's extortionate stamp duty tax on first time buyers all these years the market has been encouraged to loan these poor unfortunate young people 125% of a houses value. Unjust, hypocritical and deeply worrying for our children as they struggle with this unfair system and for the rest of us as the rug is pulled from under the banking system. This instability is self inflicted poor macro management based on a tax and spend that is now unravelling after cunning concealment and much self praise and arrogance..
Pudsey, London, UK
Tony Blair has stood in the way of the former Chancellor way and has I think coloured the waters for him which would explain the current circumstances. Unfortunately for Gordon Brown he has not got the coat tails of a spin doctor to hide behind. And selling off the gold reserves may also prove to be a fatal error with a depression on the way.
Marie-Claire Oliver, Bath, United Kingdom
"Miserable" Donne? Rubbish - the poem celebrates our shared humanity and mortality, but miserable it is not. Brown is though
Jeremy Poynton, Frome, England
The Emperor s clothes Press is missing an obvious point. It has been the performance of the British economy that has made Gordon Brown s reputation, for reasons that cannot be divulged for fear of embarrassing the Emperor s subjects, not vice versa. And it is that particular condition which has caused, or resulted in, the increasing centralisation of the polity and the rise of Treasury control. This isn t going to change when Gordon Brown eventually leaves, but to disguise this point, and in the interest of facilitating the transition, he is conveniently being blamed for all the associated aggro this process has caused. Thus he is still implicitly the responsible party by the way his relationship with Alastair Darling has been represented.
By attaching all these other incidences, such as Northern Rock, to his debit, the environment on his departure can be portrayed in an improved light. But in fact that will disguise the point that it will be largely unchanged, and the underlying trends exhibited in recent years will continue whoever succeeds Brown.
Henry Percy, London, UK
Wish I knew how sk sussex comes to his/her opinion.
Try heating, petrol, food, water, mortgages, education, todays university dropouts, immigration, benefit swindlers, where does it stop.
Also sk, try living on a pension, or a meagre one, then you will know the difference.
brenda norwood, York,
Don't think I would write off Brown and Darlings adventures in banking as an aside, but certainly a symptom of Gordons pigheadedness. Watching our spineless, unelected leader always puts me in mind of a weak swimmer with a puncture in their rubber ring! The more he thrashes about, the faster he sinks! Brown and his corruption riddled party are now doing nothing more than keeping their collective head above water. It's fascinating fun watching from the sidelines, trying to judge when they will slip under the surface, never to return.......
craig pond, stoke-on-trent, England
Settle down folks. SK doesn't believe it any more than you do. He only said that to see how many would bite.
Letahead, Troon,
sk, do we actually live in the same country?
From where I am standing things have got so much worse. As a single, well educated, employed 30 something still only able to essentially live a student life style i.e. in shared housing, I really do wonder where you people come from. Borrowing is totally out of control and the pyramid system called the housing market will have to collapse or you will lose a generation overseas.
Never mid all the other tinkering in different depts. This article is a breath of fresh air!
spot on, Cambridge,
Brown set up the regulatory system that were warn numerous
times about the sub-prime market. And so Brown should now go: because he is has proved- quite a few times; he is not fit for purpose.
We now have a banking system: that they take the profits; the
taxpayers pickup the losses.
A Walton, Leicester, England
BINGO!
'In the meantime, the pieces of Northern Rock litter No 10. Move away from Westminster and hear what people think: that these are Mr Brown's chickens coming home to roost, a Chancellor and now Prime Minister who floated a public spending boom off the back of a greedy financial sector betting in increasingly convoluted structures not understood by politicians on rising house prices artificially inflated by foreign billionaires, the whole underpinned by ordinary people unprotected by a weak regulatory system put in place by the same man now intent upon using our money to prop up votes in his northern heartlands. Or something like that. Welcome to Britain, 2008: caustic, cynical, furious, and agog at the impotence of politicians in the face of the amoral, international super-rich.'
Try explaining this to Hazel Blears. Good luck.
joe, Berwickshire, Scotland
True, things have improved as 'sk of East Sussex' states. But at what cost? The Government is living on 'tick' like a drunkard. Thouands of Families are wracked by personal and mortgage debt - but that is/was their choice. Public spending policy is in array as Millions, if not Billions of Taxpayers money has been wasted on dubious IT and other projects. The obsession for 'PFI' has been a disaster in many cases. The Private Companies involved in 'PFI' projects are 'Laffing All the Way to Their Banks'. Corporate Lawyers and Accountants have tied this 'Prudence' Government into legal knots and contracts for years to come -- They, the Private Contractors will make Billions of Pounds, and all NU Labour 'Pillock-ticians' can muttle is "Value for Money, Value For Money" like so many demented Parrots!
Not so 'Prudence' now are we Mr Mc Has-Bean? Will we see the undedifying picture of Pa Broon going cap-in-hand to the IMF to raise 'Junk Bonds' to pay for spendrift ways. "Squander-Bugs"
B Clarke, Chelmsford, Essex UK
Bring back Ken Clarke before it is too late- he could have even defeated Blair. This Brown led NuLabour lot are useless. There is no talent there and very little left in the Tory party.Emigrate
Given up with UK, Scarborough, England
How is the Rock still in trouble after managing to still borrow the money that it needed and failed to borrow from the American sub prime market ? it all goes to show that even if the Rock had managed to get the money from the sub prime market that it would not of helped it out and that the Rock was still going bust regardless because it did manage to get the money it needed, only from the bank of England instead, so what was the real reason for it`s present day troubles as it now cannot be blamed on the American sub prime market ?
paddy conroy, newcastle upon tyne, england
sk.... yer avin a laarf - A very good piece of satire!!
pt, and jem have answered some of your misguided points, but there are many more.
Discrimination?; -failing to control massive immigration has produced far more racial discrimination. They have encouraged new discriminations too - the obese and smokers, to name but two!
medicine?; - postcode lottery provision?
Transparency?;- well, they got found out, if that's what you mean! or do you mean that 'spin' is becoming more subtle and effective?
Affluent?;- my net wealth, and that of many others have been gradually reduced over the last 10 years by stealth taxes etc.
How many of those home owners are going to lose them due to Gordon's economic incompetence.
Protection at work? - or protection from the need to work?
It's not just the press who attribute all the downsides to the Govt. - Anyone who has an ounce of common sense agrees with much of what the press highlight.
This article is spot-on!
winstonian, Darlington,
Gordon Brown is deaf to everyone and everything, he will never hear the bell already tolling at this, the beginning of his ill-fated premiership. Gordon Brown awake, it tolls for thee - worst Prime Minister ever!
Dave, York, England
Its not everyday that the government sponsors a premier league football club -I wonder if Northern Rock will continue to sponsor Newcastle Utd FC.
If so how could the govt square subsidising premiership footballers exorbitent wages whilst pensionners are having to choose between food or heat and sell their homes to afford care.
Perhaps Gordon Brown will now be able to put some meat behind his proclamation of 'British jobs for British workers' and get rid of Newcastles non British players.
Rob, London,
re sk, East Suusex ; because much of what afflicts this country is the fault of this Government. for they have embarked on permanent change in the NHS which has left it dysfunctional, with their new plan to change the one area of the NHS which works, the Primary care arrangement. They have pushed through Parliament a never ending stream of Home Office bills which has left that department unfit for purpose. They have swamped this country with immigrants overloading the infrastructure and services . And on Financial matters Brown has spent, taxed and spent, and borrowed, taxed and spent, and built an economy built on debt, both public and private, underwritten by a bubble housing market, which places the Northern Rock wreck at Gordon Browns door, not only in the structural economic situation which has led us to this point , but also in the tri-partite arrangement he put in place but an arrangement which failed.
Iain, Andover , Hants
sk, East Sussex,
More people dont own their own homes, more people than ever rent them from the bank for more than they have ever done before.
How are we more affluent when we owe £1trillion on credit cards?
Dominic, Manchester, UK
sk - precisely how deep is your head in the sand?
Fuel prices at an all time high, the property market completely out of control, the highest taxation in Europe, our armed forces diminished and under budgeted, our personal information constantly getting 'mislaid' and a Home Secretary who says she wouldn't want to walk the streets at night alone - damn right there is still a lot to do and this Administration really has a great deal to answer over its dangerous ineptitude over the last 10 years.
PT, Rickmansworth, United Kingdom
Not much good has come out of the NR fiasco - but at least, yet again, it has shown how immature Cameron and Osborne are. 'Young and stupid' indeed. Their reaction to the nationalisation - prancing, foot-stamping and screeching like adolescents - was immensely damaging to them and to the Tory Party. The grown-up Conservatives might like to make a note of this episode for when the leadersip is next discussed.
eric campbell, harrogate, uk
ah, sk.... that's so sweet. personally, I think alice should have expanded her second to last paragraph into a whole article. maybe two. real problems have been caused by brown as chancellor. prudent according to one g. brown. and that's without mentioning the rest of the spin, sleaze, waste, lies, etc. I'm guessing you must be one of the turkeys.
jem, london, uk
Alice,
How well written " Certainly an awful lot of things have come crashing home to land on Mr Brown's beach this week "
Over the years the New Labour Spin Factory have been able to hand out piecemeal explanations and excuses to the varying degrees of fallout from their questionable policies, mandates and sleaze however they're not quite so prepared for the volumous assault on the very fabric of their being that is happening right now,
If this were a time to 'Bury Bad News' then the burial mound would be akin to Everest where the tip of Big Ben would be far from view!
Please though, help me dispell the myth, that up here the North is a Labour Heartland.
We should have listened to Browns critics, of his single minded, unyielding autocratic style that would not be good for governement. But there you have it, how do we now expect those too weak to challenge him when it mattered to do so now.
Those who are strong enough however will show him at the next election!
Shaun, Newcastle, Tyne and Wear
This country has improved enormously over the last 10 years. We are more affluent, more own their own homes, we are more healthy (we are all living much longer despite the dire warnings of obesity), the environment is much improved, medicine has lept forward, we are protected at work and in society against discrimination and, yes we do have some extremely wealthy people in our society - so what. There is still a lot to do, but why does the Press attribute all the downsides to the Government which is more transparent than it has every been.
sk, East Sussex,
Bravo Alice, all is forgiven.
colbeck, jersey,