Alice Miles
Download 'Too Hot', an exclusive Specials track from iTunes
So the subtext is revealed. The real reason for inviting Peter Mandelson back into government was to get him to spill the beans on the Conservative leadership's connections with the elite and the super-rich.
If Lord Mandelson does nothing else for Labour ever again, then giving the press an excuse to publish that picture of George Osborne posing with the Bullingdon Club will be service enough.
I had forgotten that Mr Osborne was a member too. So familiar has the picture of David Cameron in Bullingdon pose become - that funny little jacket, the bow-tie, Boris Johnson somehow already dishevelled on the step below - it is easy to forget that the third most senior Tory in the country was also in the Oxford club for the elite. The picture of Osborne with Nathaniel Rothschild and friends is agony: look at the arrogance, the ghastly smug waistcoated born-to-rule insouciance of the lot of them. Labour could do worse than have that picture printed on its election posters.
This is not about class war. It was a big mistake for Labour to allow one of its trump cards - the far more prosaic life experiences of its senior figures and their consequent ability to understand the lives that ordinary people live - to be hijacked by those in the party who launched a crass and childish attack on “Tory toffs”. It doesn't matter if you are born rich and privileged - that isn't your fault; what matters is what you do with it. To wheel around Oxford in a super-rich drinking club, join Tory Central Office and marry the daughter of a member of the political or landed aristocracy doesn't suggest that you have been much exposed to the plight of the less advantaged, or that you cared much about them before political opportunity came knocking.
As one voter, a single mother, confronted Mr Cameron on Panorama recently: “Several members of your Cabinet are millionaires... What matters is, how can you understand (us)?”
With difficulty, is the answer, as Iain Duncan Smith has honestly admitted. Having embarked on an intensive study of poverty in Britain since departing the Tory party leadership, he discovered “levels of breakdown that even I had not possibly begun to conceive of”, as he put it in an interview with The Times two years ago. He set about educating the Shadow Cabinet, organising visits for them to impoverished inner-city areas, a sort of poverty tourism for Central Office. The sons of Eton and Oxford, of lords and baronets, signed up.
“Small community groups in the inner-city areas put them there for a week so that they can learn actually what life is really like in these areas,” Mr Duncan Smith said. “And it's fascinating, somebody said what do you want to achieve out of it? And I said I only want to achieve three words from them when they come back. If they say the three words to me, then I know we've succeeded; and they are ‘I never realised'. And they all have said ‘I never realised'.” I never realised. Well you wouldn't, would you, not if you had gone through life and politics never having met a poor person unless they were serving you with drinks? “Using the phrase social justice is very challenging to Conservatives,” IDS added, which I have always thought an astonishing admission.
Perhaps Lord Mandelson's forays into the world of the super-rich are his own fact-finding missions on behalf of the Labour Party. Mandelson is an aberration within Labour, as was Tony Blair: Labour people do not, on the whole, hobnob with the very rich. They feel uncomfortable with them.
Can you imagine Gordon Brown swanning around the Greek islands with a gang of multimillionaires on yachts? He would loathe it.
By their friends shall you know them. The last thing the Cameron Conservatives need is for voters to be reminded of their exclusive backgrounds through the imagery of yachts and billionaires and old allegiances from the Bullingdon Club. Nor, as Mr Osborne must now realise, are the super-rich just harmless playmates with nice holidays on offer.
The circle in which Lord Mandelson appears to have been moving these past few years is beyond politics: it is an amoral international elite for whom politics is at best one of the toys at their disposal, something to be played with for a while and then discarded when it gets dull. I have met some of these people on the fringes: their interest in anything political is barely skin-deep, it lasts as long as the tan acquired on the summer yacht. Only because Zac Goldsmith, their British figurehead, appears to take politics seriously is it even acceptable in this country to show a temporary interest in politics. Normally the political world (Lord Mandelson aside, for novelty value) would be considered a bit common.
I remember one summer one bored lady (they are all bored) from a fabulously wealthy family lecturing me about the need for mothers not to work but to stay at home with their children; she had spent some of her family money sponsoring a report confirming what she already believed and was about to publish it. This was her politics. She might have had a little more credibility were I not watching her two children being taken care of by her third nanny, employed for the holiday, her two other full-time nannies being given a couple of weeks off. A different world, you see. These people are beyond ridicule. They shouldn't be allowed anywhere near serious politics.
But they have been toying with the new Tories, temporarily fashionable and, in Mr Cameron and Mr Osborne, offering house guests wealthy in their own right and connected to the British aristocracy to boot. They do not care about them, or about the Conservative Party. They are not political like that. Now Mr Osborne appears to have broken the fundamental rule of this social circle: omertà. Never, ever talk to the press. And his old Bullingdon mate Nat Rothschild is making him pay for it.
“Perhaps in future it would be better if all involved accepted the age-old adage that private parties are just that,” Mr Rothschild wrote to The Times. Not in politics, they are not. And not when (as has been alleged and denied) you discuss breaking the rules banning foreign donations, and with a dubious Russian businessman at that. But of course, boring little things like rules do not apply to the super-rich elite. They look down on them, and on most of us. Caveat emptor, George.
Alice Miles has been with The Times since 1999. She began as a Parliamentary Sketch writer before becoming a columnist, writing mainly on politics and national issues such as education and health. She won Columnist of the Year in 2007.
Win a luxury weekend to Newcastle and its neighbour Gateshead, find out more here
Risk, resilience and embracing new technology
Industry sectors news at a glance. Interactive heatmap, video and podcast
Discover the power of collective thinking. Submit a solution and be in with a chance to win a Media Hub Home Entertainment System
The inside track on current trends in the charity, not for profit and social enterprise sectors
Everything the Business Traveller needs to know to make a better trip
Make the most of the summer and enter our fabulous photographic competition, you could win a £5000 holiday
Corsica is an island of beauty and contrast, an ideal holiday destination
Enjoy further reading from Travel to Fashion, Business to Sport, discover more
Shortcuts to help you find sections and articles
The clever way to lease a new car is with Car leasing made simple™
2009
per month on 36-month
Personal Contract Hire (PCH)
2008
42850
Car Insurance
£24,250 - £30,346
MI5
London
£60,000
The Environment Agency
Bristol
Up to £90K
Boots
Midlands
OTE £85k
Credit Protection Association
Nationwide Opportunities
Completely London
Luxury Condo's in Manhattan with NYC views
The best new homes in Wimbledon?
Nationwide
Fabulous Cruise And Cruise & Stay Offers Including Virgin Atlantic Flights Prices Start From Only £699pp!
Last Minute Cruise And Cruise & Stay Offers. Med From £499pp, Caribbean From £699pp!
5 star quality at a 3 star price.
8 fabulous Canadian cities ...you won’t find cheaper
Contact our advertising team for advertising and sponsorship in Times Online, The Times and The Sunday Times, or place your advertisement.
Times Online Services: Dating | Jobs | Property Search | Used Cars | Holidays | Births, Marriages, Deaths | Subscriptions | E-paper
News International associated websites: Globrix Property Search | Property Finder | Milkround
Copyright 2009 Times Newspapers Ltd.
This service is provided on Times Newspapers' standard Terms and Conditions. Please read our Privacy Policy.To inquire about a licence to reproduce material from Times Online, The Times or The Sunday Times, click here.This website is published by a member of the News International Group. News International Limited, 1 Virginia St, London E98 1XY, is the holding company for the News International group and is registered in England No 81701. VAT number GB 243 8054 69.
One of Britain's failings is its obsession with class and "toffs". However coming from the new world I cannot but admire people who make their own wealth and despise those who inherit and somehow think that gives them a 'right' to rule.
Pity the French revolution never came to the UK.
Richard, Epsom/Ewell, GB
You're absolutely right, this won't convince voters that the Tories have changed. But the point is they haven't changed!
Their primary motivation is still to keep the economy ticking over for the rich, and spend as little as possible on helping the poor. Trickledown economics, basically.
Owen, London, UK
"Can you imagine Gordon Brown swanning around the Greek islands with a gang of multimillionaires on yachts?"
No, He'd much rather spend his time No 10/11 finding new ways helping people pile more debt on themselves, as tax-payers, or trough the "live now pay tomorrow" culture.
Richard, Nottingham,
Surely Rothschild should have known that inviting Mandelson and Osborne on the same holiday was a potentially explosive combination? There's something that doesn't quite add up here...
Alex, London,
Oh dear Oh dear ! Why has everyone forgotten Crash Gordons new buddy Mandy was on the boat !!
It is not compulsory to follow where Robert Peston and the beeb lead- you are allowed to think for yourself you know!
edward, bolton, uk
The mega rich are so on account of their greed, corruption and political influence. For that reason alone, anyone connected with honest goverment would know with absolute certainty to avoid them.
Steve, London, UK
"Tories turn down dodgy money - that's the story?"
No - the story is not that they turned down dodgy money (it was never offered) but that they considered soliciting it.
Watch the bouncing ball...
Mike S, London,
The Russians believe that good relats are possible with UK , but for Russian oligarchs working with dynastic western families to achieve deals (eg alum/gold/oil) - dressed up as politics. A lot of vitriol is whispered in HMG's ear about RF not by the FCO, but by Oligarch/UK elites who will benefit.
Tim, London,
Oh please!
"...much exposed to the plight of the less advantaged.."
Whereas grammar school, University, the Bar or a cosy job in the civil service and a final salary pension makes you a real working class hero!!
Class war nonsense. I went thru the same back in the 80s. Here we go again.
Mark, Berkhamsted,
"Can you imagine Gordon Brown swanning around the Greek islands with a gang of multimillionaires on yachts? He would loathe it."
Which is presumably why he relies on others to do it for him.
Barbara, Crewe, UK
It would be a scary world if the super rich didn't exist. Read Atlas Shrugged to get a good perspective.
Charles, Ely, UK
Or even John Prescott at the Billionaires ranch to play cowboy so that he could push through the Super Casino's....
Not all of us have the memory span of a gold-fish......
Mike, MK,
Total unmitigated rubbish! Gordon Brown has never had a proper job - how can he relate to us? Milliband, Balls, Cooper, have never worked in finance or industry. And why do we hear about the yacht - because Mandleson was there and slagged off Brown. Tories turn down dodgy money - that's the story?
Tim, London,
'It was a big mistake for Labour to allow one of its trump cards - the far more prosaic life experiences of its senior figures and their consequent ability to understand the lives that ordinary people live ...'.
Tell me how many ministers went to public school and how much money they have.
dhr, cardiff, uk
Now that it's almost impossible for the rich to buy their peerages and knighthoods they will become even less interested in politics. The present Government should think about a nice fat tax on their wealth before the Tories take over and make them even richer.
Ken Rodford, Bedford, UK
'What matters is, how can you understand (us)?...With difficulty, is the answer'
What so beggars belief is not that the Tories may lack understanding but that the present shambles is due in part to those in goverment who allegedly are expected to understand e.g abolition of 10p tax rate fiasco.
m collins, Leeds,
A simple rule for all Tories. Don't go anywhere Mandelson is.
Jeremy James, St. Maurice de Lignon, France
Your right Alice - instead Labour gives us endless hours of parliamentary time taken up to ban fox hunting, gestures about 42 days detention and ID cards. Meanwhile pensions goes down the tube and the govt fails over 10 years to put a energy policy in place that will ensure our future as a nation...
K Thompson, Reading, UK
Unbelievable. Alice Miles is attacked in these comments. The real point is easy: it is about a kind of person and mindset. Historically, the more right-wing you are the less you truly care. Labour by tradition has a monopoly on those who genuinely do. Cameron/Osborne are of the former and fakes.
Peter, Widnes., England.
'Labour people do not, on the whole, hobnob with the very rich. They feel uncomfortable with them.'
Eh? you have short memory. Who can forget those freebie Summer holidays the Blairs had with the rich and famous?
meral, London, UK
I hope that once he has resigned Georgina will be found a new job serving the drinks on one of his old friends' super yachts.
bob, london, uk
There isn't much to convince me that New Labour are down to earth. What about the rows of the Labour front and back benches who have never held a proper job but been propelled from student, local politics and some god awful think tank?
Marc, Singapore,
'Mandelson is an aberration within Labour, as was Tony Blair'
The UK voted for Tony Blair three times. Some aberration within the party you so clearly support.
We deeply dislike Labour because it is made up of bossy, middle class oxbridge/Russell Group mafia who think they know reality.
You don't.
P Orrell, London, UK
Much as I think this is a ridiculous non story in which no money changed hands and no laws were broken, it has exposed Osborne to be as useless as many of us have been saying for months. Even when he'd done nothing wrong he still messed up. He should be moved but can Cameron bring himself to do it?
Paul Owen, Birmingham, UK