If Britain had still to elect its first woman prime minister, I doubt very much if Margaret Hodge, Ruth Kelly, Jacqui Smith, Theresa May etc. would be worthy pioneers. Similarly, if Barack Obama loses the U.S. presidential election, I am sure he will do so entirely on his own merits.

Kevin, London,

Its funny:
Many moderate, Reps, Dems and indepentants support or at least respect Obama, and hard-core Reps oppose him because he is a "Liberal Elitist" and a "Euro-Socialist" (things they would say about anyone with similar policies). Only the left/liberals are saying "A black man can't win".

Andrew, Taunton,

I think America is ready to elect a black president; just not Obama.

Nan, Houston, USA

Mr Obama is a CREDIBLE person...But in American politics, we know very well that the Corporate Media controls the election. They had to bring down his credibility by ASSOCIATIONS. Freedom of Expressionj, is DEAD. So if Rev WRight says things then Obama should be BLAMED. If Ayers says something bad

rabby, flushing, usa

"16 per cent of white Democratic voters considered race an important factor..."

You didn't mention anything about black voters considering race an important factor. I think we all know why.

Black man good. White man bad.

Pathetic!

Tonigol, Brisbane, Australia

"Is not Obama a black and white person? --Kevin Straw, Leicester,"

You're joking right Kevin? Please see the "one drop" rule. It is so ingrained that it is simply taken for granted.

Joe, Ontario, Canada

Mrs. Clinton and Mr. Barack sincere? You are pulling everybody's leg ant' you?

I thought that Mr. Kaletsky was a learned man. It kept puzzling me how ignorant I am.

SEBASTIAN PERONI , HALIFAX, VA, USA

Is not Obama a black and white person?

Kevin Straw, Leicester,

Anti-black racism is so ubiquitous in the USA it is invisible to them.

Obama was always unelectable, and it was always because he was black.

Keith S, Winnipeg, Canada

Sir,
Race is an important factor, as our concepts of nationality are essentially derived from tribalism. The US is a nation where the concept of race is amongst the most studied & politicised in the entire world. Those who prefer not to see the elephant in the room are quite simply in denial.

SC, London, United Kingdom

Some American people pounce on Britsh media & people. But not only the Brits think Obama can't win becse of race :many French and Spaniards I know, do feel the same too.
Though evryone of us hope to be mistaken eventually...

Eka, Soissons,

I keep hearing Americans accusing Brits of having a poor understanding of your electoral system. Perhaps it's because we can't understand how a system that doesn't give equal weight each citizens ballot can truly claim to be a democracy - we assume we must be missing something.

Esther, London,

Anatole Kaletsky is correct, I believe in his analysis. Clinton leading a 'dream ticket' is the only way for the Democrats now to win particularly after today's words from Rev Wright . Sadly for the Free World, Democratic leaders will probably ignore all the polls and therefore hand it to McCain!

Mike , Manchester, England

Hillary and Obama are both doctrinaire left-liberals, and both have awful personal liabilities which would make either one unelectable. Democrats got caught up in the mystique of having both a black and a woman to choose between that they forgot that one cannot have the cake and eat it too! Fools.

J Cline, Seattle,

Clinton is, " intelligent, sincere, articulate and in command of the issues" and McCain is none of those things?

McCain may not be as articulate, but he's certainly more sincere than Clinton.

Andrew, Abu Dhabi,

I am from the US & if it is anyone who makes it a racial thing, it is the african americans doing so. Nevermind that Clinton is more experienced, they simply want a black to win the nomination. For THEM it is about skin color. Everywhere I go I hear they want a black man in office.

Kim, Rocky Mount, NC, USA

Obama will lose, but not because of his race. He'll lose because, when all is said and done, he's just not ready to be president. He's still too green. Plus, I really believe that many of the folks who did vote for him (in the primaries) did so because they dislike Hillary.

Nancy, Valencia, CA, USA

To Padrig Hogan, Tampa, Fl, USA

"If Clinton or Obama win, can I move to the land down under? ...I own guns, so that makes me scared of Obama and Clinton"

Unfortunately you won't be able to move "down under" mate, as we have outlawed guns unless you have mitigating circumstances, e.g farmer

Tessa, Sydney,

The claim that McCain is insincere, unintelligent and inarticulate is not borne out by the talk he gave to the BBC a year ago. He was subjected to many difficult questions by the invited audience and answered them fluently and without prevarication. He may have other faults, but not these.

David, London, UK

Whatever said and done.....Racism will play a major role prior to and after the elections. Its ingrained in the minds of the Whites. Its all talk and being politically correct. Be it Europe or the US or Australia. Racism spans every issue in life if a coloured person encroaches into the White space

John, cambridge, UK

Obama will lose, but not because of his skin color per se. He's aligned with a minority mindset called 'black identity' which is not 'American identity.' The Presidency is not an 'equal opportunity' position. If Obama was a medal of honor winner, he'd waltz into the White House.

Canaan P., New York, NY, United States

The reason votes in Florida hardly count is because we were told our votes WOULD NOT COUNT. Many Floridians decided not to vote because of this. Obama wasn't even on the ballot in Michigan, and there was no option to write a name down.

Jasmine, Pembroke Pines, FL, USA

No Greek tragedy here, just democracy in action. Regardless of who wins, we will have a vast improvement. Is Obama not qualified to be president just because he is a two-year senator? Our nation remains together thanks to a two-year senator who became president, Lincoln, thank you very much.

Ben, Austin, TX, USA

Those who believe Americans are not ready for a black president don't really get us. We are blamed for being ignorant about the world, yet the world cannot understand that the reasons we became a superpower are the same reasons why come next January Barack Obama will be president. God Bless America

Ben, Austin, TX, USA

I will not give up on hope to promote, endorse, or vote for the certain detriment of our country (represented by either Clinton or McCain). Obama is our ONLY hope for change and a better America. The only thing that you have demonstrated with this article, sir, is the audacity of hubris.

Fran, BEAVERTON, USA

I dont know about y'all but i can't take the sight of either of them anymore. If I am bored and poisoned by them, imagine how Independents and Republicans feel. So as in the article, McCain will probably win.

Jim, Montreal, Canada

Americans should not have to look exactly like folk that came from Europe a thousand years ago; yet these are exactly the ones accepted without question.

David , lafayette, USA

Julian. We do not elect a "head of government" in the United Kingdom. We elect a party to govern. The labour party was elected, Gordon Brown was elected as a MP by the people of his constituency and was elected to be the leader of his party by party members. All done very fairly.

Taff, Newport, South Wales

Thank god you Brits can't vote in our election!

CAK, Denver, USA

The British criticize American provincialism, yet have a stunningly poor understanding of our electoral system. Polls show Obama will easily carry many of the states that he lost to HRC -- NY, California -- and will win different swing states that result in a net gain of electoral votes over HRC.

John Durrant, Los Angeles,

The Democratic Party set up the rules for the "Super Delegates" not the US government. So they have no one to blame but themselves.

Jim, Atlanta, USA

The American generosity of spirit will ensure that after so many decades; prejudice will not matter and Obama may make it to the White House.

Devasis Chowdhury, bangalore, India

'the renewal of America, its youthful and inclusive politics (i.e. Obama) is deeply threatening to European identity.' Er,what?Really,the inability of Americans to come up with a coherant argument is truly dazzling.If you guys travelled the world rather than invading it you might undestand it better

simon, cardiff, wales

Hey, "John in London"--no, America is NOT a Democracy. You are. We "left home" to become a Constitutional Republic ON PURPOSE.... cheers, though, we still love you.

Daneen Petty, Las Vegas, USA

I am black, not American and was excited by Obama's rise. I still think he's the best candicate out there; at least two economics Nobel Laureates think so as well. But you know what? Forget it, he should just give up. Some of the reasons given here, it's ridiculous. Let them be.

Joe, London,

People talk about experience in becoming a president, but what experience, other than a great understanding of history and current events, a level head, and a will to put knowledge into action, does a president need? I think Obama excels in all those respects.

Jasmine, Pembroke Pines, FL, USA

Its sad i told everyone this would happen. if the Clinton get back into office it will be a disaster for our country. The Country needs change. I will not vote for Clinton never ever i was a strong Democrate. I felt they cared for blacks what i have seen in these past months. most people want change

Myra Washington, SAN DIEGO, usa

America does not want the socialism being spewed out by Clinton or Obama. Free Markets will always solve the problems in the best way. Government interference never works and creates a beaurocratic nightmare. McCain will defeat either Clinton or Obama in the general election

David, Nashville, USA

obama is the right candidate

john smith, london, uk

Hillary and Barack do not share the values of most of America (whether you Europeans like that or not), and are particularly unqualified for the job. In one year's time, you will be welcoming President McCain to your country. Better get ready!

Mark Dickens, Memphis, USA

I agree with your conclusion, but not with your reasoning. Obama is not losing the largest states solely based on his race. He is not connecting with working class voters, because he is elitist. People are worried about gas, jobs, foreclosures and health care. Clinton offers specific solutions.

fran, Hillsdale, NY

Mr Obama and his supporters imagine he must be able to transcend the racial divide simply because he is black. Unfortunately he has more racial baggage than all the other hopefuls combined and is not about to transcend any such thing. A Colin Powell or Mrs Rice might do so, but not Obama.

John B, Teesside, UK

Senator Obama will never be able to win the general election this Fall. True or not - the narrative against him is not hard to put together - the video clips of Wright are damaging enough, but add Ayers and Michelle Obama's thesis - and he simply cannot win.
Not sure Clinton can, but Obama cannot.

Adam, New York, USA

Obama can't lose.
While I love McCain (I really do) I have to acknowledge the Bush base that will betray him. Nobody on the right knows if he will tow the Bush line. Nobody on the left trusts him to rise above it. I haven't met anyone who likes Hillary. I haven't met anyone who hates Obama.

Dennis, Omaha, USA

"Mr Obama and Mrs Clinton are both such impressive candidates, intelligent, sincere, articulate and in command of the issues"
Obama and Clinton are two stunningly unqualified candidates. The American system's major weakness is that such people can be elected. (Cf. Carter,Bill Clinton,&Bush II)

tom farrelly, seattle, USA

When it comes right down to it, the Presidency is the toughest job in the world and the political dance is the hardest in that position.

Obama is leading for two reasons 1) he is Black and 20 the press gives him a free ride.

As a one term Senator he is not qualified for the position.

Richard Cole, Richmond, United States

SIR,
In your analysis of the three candidates with all the superlatives that you use to describe the two socialists...err, democrats as you compare them to the "oh so lacking" McCain you forget another comparison: they are both LAWYERS, McCain is not..that alone should disqualify them.

Dr. Mark, Omaha, USA

I have to say, at the risk of sounding elitist, that these Americans crack me up... You're afraid of European style socialism and lack of growth?!! You all should be so damned lucky! What is that you're all afraid of exactly? Universal health care?? Go ahead and vote for Bush MkII. What a sad bunch!

john, London,

The world doesnot need one more stupid american president
after George W Bush. I support a notion of "dream ticket" led by Mrs Clinton with Mr Obama as vice president.

Rahman, Karachi,

The underlying issue is experience. McCain has as much as one can want to have, Obama as little as possible to run for President. Although I am a Democrat and no racist -- I would have voted for Colin Powell -- I can't see Obama having the full powers and responsibilities of the Presidency.

Joe, Baltimore, USA

Race may be an issue, but clearly stated views is the biggest isue. Obama calls for 'change' but is less specific about which changes he hopes to make. His rhetoric is fine, but what is his bottom line? Having a Muslim father is a minus. Being educated in Catholic schools is another minus,Wright..

Joseph, London, UK

Florida and Michigan completely Irrelevant? 28 Million people? -Spoken like a true liberal Massachussetts Dem.

D. Todd, PC, Florida, USA

Whichever way you look at it, the Democrats are going to lose. When your candidates are either the 'first woman president' or 'first black president', prejudice against both will be the downfall when it comes to the real election, unfortunately.

JR, Bristol,

It is because of political correctness Americans spend 18 months choosing a president who turns out ridiculous.We have to accept we are all human with human frailities otherwise government can't function. Race, Sex, Age, did you really choose the best available, or the least like to offend?

ged, manchester, england

Bruce McLarron in Tucson - What, you think it's better over here? At least you guys elected your head of government!

Julian, Warwick, UK

It is wrong that people's voting is influenced by race?! Being a non-white man does not make his policies/beliefs any less credible that Mrs being a woman. Surely it would be better for the American nation to be led by Hilary or Barack than the much less knowledgable Republicans.

Julia Goolia, Glasgow, Scotland

This article makes it seem that we live in Russia. This is a true Democratic Republic which the founding fathers wanted NOT a true Democracy.

Another thing will be that until we can address the RACE ISSUE this country will always have problems. I see blacks use that card all the time.

Figus, Charleston, US of A

What a myopic view, the analogy of Hilary & Barack as "noble heroes and heroines forced to follow a course to catastrophe" and John as "militarily belligerent and economically unqualified". Both sides are as bad as each other, I didn't realise that we need a Democrat to win for the sake of humanity.

Ken, Ashford, England

Daniel, Palo Alto writes:

'Let Americans handle their own politics'

As well as the politics of whichever other countries they decide to invade in the name of 'democracy' right?

Gabriel Casey, Belfast,

I stopped reading this article when he referred to Mrs. Clinton as being "sincere".

Nick, NY,

Tell me again how many black Prime Ministers the U.K. has had? To call people racist because their politics are different is a stretch. Obama isn't qualified and yet he's a frontrunner BECAUSE of his race.

Pam, Washington, USA

Many UK citizens are interested in USA. We think USA elections are important to the whole world. Many people in UK have relatives in USA and scattered all over the globe. What happens in USA and elsewhere does have effects in UK. This is why some of us are interested. Would you rather we were not?

grace kelly, stirling, scotland

New Jersey has a large working-class consituency? HAH! You're talking about the richest state in the union! Ohio, sure. Pennsylvania, sure. But what's this about Florida and Michigan? No one but Hillary even campaigned in either state--they're both completely irrelevant, much like this article.

Jack, Boston, US

Americans are generally more conservative than their European counterparts. Obama won't be rejected because of his skin, it will be his liberal views. His social views don't agree with many in the Bible belt or even those of conservative Catholics, of which there are many.

Jake, Baltimore, USA

Why does no one mention the fact that all three that are getting attention from the media are members of the Council on Foreign Relations? That said, as an citizen of the USA, I don't think race should have ANYTHING to do with who will be the POTUS.

Andrew Heermans, NYC, United States

With comments including phrases such as "Hogwash!”,
“you tools”, “bunch of tripe” and “shafted themselves”; maybe us Brits have more in common with you Americans than I first thought!

This has been an entertaining read, and I would also love for Ms Rice to run for US President.

Sally, London, England

I live in London and am smart enough not to comment on British Politics - because I grew up in America and don't understand the complexity of the political landscape which is exactly the reason that Mr. Kaletsky's column holds no credibility. All politics is local, pay heed Sir.

Aaron Schaal, London,

Clinton and Obama are "in command of issues" because you agree with their political agendas. When will you understand a vote against Obama or Clinton is not racism or miscogyny, but against far left liberalism. Does the name Michael Dukakis mean anything to you?

Steve, Rochester,

Obama? Sorry! Just his wife being in the white house scares the hell out of me!

Sabre460, Martinez, USA

Obama won (by landslide) in many lily white states: Iowa, Kansas, Minnesota, Wisconsin, Maine, Washington, Missouri, Connecticut, Colorado, Wyoming. She won PA, OH because the Governors mobilized their entire machinery for her, not because Americans are racist.

Lem , Las Vegas, USA

This is an article built on sand. Obama is not 'in command of the issues' he flounders when speaking in other than meaningless generalisations & Clintons attack machine could teach the Republicans a thing or two. & why no mention of crossover voting, or 'Operation Chaos' (no space left, Google it)

Kev Wilson, Slough,

If McCain wins this election, which unfortunately I think he will, then you can expect another 4 yrs of the same Bush nonsense! HELP!! I'm going to UK!

White middle-class USA is NOT ready to put a young inexperienced black man in charge of their affairs! Trust me!

Obama ruined it for Clinton!!

Bruce McClarron, Tucson, USA

The only principle in 'proper democracy', Mr Kaletsky, is that the democratic majority wins. Get used to it.

Terry, London, UK

i posted this yesterday, but somehow it was censored, so again.

Let's give BA three strikes:
-he's a democrat- strike one
-he's a liberal- strike two
-he's unqualified- strike three
There's nothing "politically incorrect" about it.

lee ho, norfolk,

If a black or a woman wins the BBC won't be able to use its standard sneering jeering tone every time it mentions the president. It will cost a fortune in retraining

John Ledbury, Kings Lynn, England

Kaletsky truly is clueless. To suggest McCain, a senior senator, is somehow unqualified, but two junior senators are highly qualified for the job of president is really quite something. I'd like to know what makes Obama so qualified? Oh, I get it. Kaletsky agrees with his ideology and not McCain's

Ninette, Los Angeles, USA

Forget the candidates for a moment and lets look at the people who will be in their "cabinet".We are entering one of the most challenging periods of History.The World's Superpower must have a strong leader with the very finest advisors from ALL political parties.Otherwise we're all in trouble.

EDWARD SYNGE, TISBURY, UK

I guess some in Europe still don't get it that just because you guys hate Bush, doesn't mean 50.1% of Americans do.

Ken, Irvine, CA, USA

This is rubbish. So far more than 10 million whites have voted for Obama and as a result, he's the virtually certain Democratic nominee. In head-to-head polls with McCain, he's generally stronger the Clinton. If he loses to McCain, it will be because McCain is a moderate and Obama is too left.

John, New York, USA

Ben, Obama's reason is that it's ridiculous to suggest that by doing so makes you more patriotic than not doing so. It's not him that looks ridiculous, but the people who believe that this is important and vital for the display of ones patriotism. People show patriotism in different ways.

Taff, Newport, South Wales.

Deeply flawed argument. Let Americans handle their own politics. Stick to what you know best; financial matters. Thanks.

Daniel, Palo Alto, USA

Barack Hussein Obama wants a vague "change"!

Hillary wants "EuroSocialism"!

An "oppressed" liberal in America has ay least one late model vehicle, several large screen TVs, Cable or satellite TV service,
a dishwasher, DVD, a home or apartment bigger than in any foreign country, and a large representative republic (not a democracy!) country with no restrictions on where the live or travel or how much they can legally earn.

Jungle Jim , Pompano Beach, Florida, United States of America

Well that's excellent because there's no black presidential candidate only 2 1/2 whites! What's the deal?

Barack Obama is half black so there's no full black president in the race. Finally we can drop the race card!

Noelio, Gander, Canada

I am SO going to enjoy watching Obama crash and burn come November, assuming that the Democrat party and especially its superdelegates are too stupid and too blind to see the McGovernesque wipe-out that's coming their way. I'm going to enjoy even more the tears of young, idealistic Obama voters.

Right-wing Conspirator, Menifee, CA, USA

To all those saying Obama isnt "black"...well you are seriously delusional. The man is black as black gets, he just doesnt use the street slang, but his wife is "straight outta the hood" and Americans will not vote for these types. Americans will not elect a black President, not ever most likely.

Mike, Smalltown, USA

This is obviously an article written by a Republican, who knows how lame their OLD and creaking candidate is, and therefore the plan is to try and exploit the race card and to promote the politics of savagery and fear! IT WON'T WORK THIS TIME. IT IS TIME TO TURN THAT OLD SMELLY PAGE!

Elias, Stevenage, UK

Since we're talking about race, who are those white presidents that black people have been voting for from late 1800's til now?

Whether their vote was actually counted is a whole different topic.

Larry, San Francisco, USA

Don't underestimate Clinton fatigue. Hillary can't achieve orbit because she's weighed down by Bill. They claim the Clinton years were great, but most people recall the scandals. Obama 's advantage is he's fresh and voters will give him a chance. Race is overestimated, this isn't the 1950's anymore.

Jigs, Hawaii, USA

Amazing that you would cheer Mrs. Clinton for being articulate. I guess you think that being articulate is better than being honest. Ditto for Senator Obama.

MJ Hoeber, Miami, Florida USA

It is always Europeans who argue that Obama MUSTN'T win. This says a lot about Europeans, who need a backwards/declining America as a foil to conceal their own decay, racism, etc... the renewal of America, its youthful and inclusive politics (i.e. Obama) is deeply threatening to European identity.

Andrew, San Francisco / Oxford, US / UK

Obama wasn't even on the ballot in Michigan you tool!

Roger Donalds, Omaha, U.S.

Seeing Americans on this forum refer to Obama or Clinton as a Marxist, socialist etc. just demonstrates how incredibly clueless they are of politics and ideology

As for the article it is spot on! II've been saying this for months now.

Natasha, Manchester, UK

We never really have that much to say about politics in the UK as we admit that we don't know that much. But why is it that every European thinks they have a clue about what's going on in the US? Not only Democrats are interested in fairness and Bush is hardly a Republican. Go back to making tea.

Felix, Westport, USA

Spot on ! If 90% of black people in places like Pennsylvania vote along racial lines then why wouldn't you expect white voters to do the same when it comes down to the crunch? I fully agree with the view that the US is not ready to vote in a black president. It's human nature, right or wrong.

Alan, buenos aires,

Obama is a man who has made calculated decisions to NOT put his hand over his heart during our national anthem and to NOT wear an American flag lapel pin. This makes him look ridiculous and is not emblematic of someone we want leading our nation. He deflects any tough question he is asked; pathetic.

Ben Sivright, Boston, MA, USA

I would vote for Condi Rice over B.O. in an instant so there goes your theory. Oh wait! Condi is "objectively" white in liberal lexicon, so I am still guilty. Time after time liberals reveal their true passions - identity politics and wealth redistribution or racism and stealing in common terms.

TOM, Alexandria,

Race does not matter.Gender does not matter.What matters is experience & certain issues.Obama's elitiest, uninformed comments, and past voting record have made me decide against him. He is not prepared to be president and the audacity/arrogance of the man to think so. Hold my nose & vote for McCain.

Susan, Fort Collins, USA

I'm all for a black president, or a women president, or a octogenarian president; but if they're engrossed in their blackness or their womanness or in their age, that's creepy. Beyond that, I want a president that considers themselves moreso of a victor, rather than a victim, of life.

BarneyCrush, Huntington Beach, USA

The Democraps have shafted themselves. When it comes right down to the wire many may realize that they only supported Hill or Obama to prove to themselves that they are neither chauvinistic nor racist. With that epiphany will come realization that McCain is the least of all all evils.

Karla H, Margate, USA

Qualifications more than race will be what keeps Obama out of the Whitehouse. If anything, race is the one thing keeping Obama in: the overwhelming majority of blacks are voting for him. Democrats should be happy to have McCain as their next President since he's practically a Democrat himself.

Sean, Manhattan, USA

I think that this article raises a very true fact that race will be significant in this election. If even the Democratic primaries are showing racial fissures, do we honestly think the general will be any different?

Steve, Greenville SC, USA

Agree w/ Hugh: I am not a bigot. I have no reservations with race, but I don't like Obama. He is inexperienced and comes off as arrogant and condescending. Don't care about his shady associations either-- if you weren't born with a silver spoon than you just might have to make deals with the devil.

Phoebe, Paoli, PA, USA

The idea that the United States isn't ready for an African-American president is incredulous. Be it a man or woman of any color, Americans want the best person to be commander-in-chief.

Todd Gibson, Woodway, USA

America is ready for a black president. If that black president is, say, Condoleeza Rice.

The Dude, SoCal,

Obama never apologized for the "church and guns" remark. To qualify as an apology the words, "I'm sorry" have to be uttered.

billy, houston, united states

I wish Colin Powell was running for President. I would vote for him in a heartbeat regardless of his party affiliation. And I'm a white male, registered Republican from Mississippi. A few years ago many voters were practically begging him to run.

Christopher S., Hattiesburg, MS, USA

It is sad, and I had hoped that Americans would see Sen. Obama as a new vision of hope to bring us all together. I still believe that he can if given a chance. Obama can change the divisions between the parties and races; get us out of this downward spiraling economic slump & end the war. Chance!

Marci Browne, Hampton, USA

"left-wing parites care more about fairness than about power"...oh, yes, Stalin, Mao, and Pol Pot were very fair! Time to read a bit more history Mr. K, and a little less European coffee house dribble...

Adam, New York, USA

What a bunch of tripe
Rationalizing hillary's win in Pa because white people wont support Obama is absurd
Pa was a closed primary, no Independents allowed to vote, only registered dems. When independents get thrown into the mix, the numbers go overwhelmingly toward Obama
OBAMA will be President

Alex Morris, NYC,

Family in USA makes me an interested spectator.
I do not see the Democrats winning in November. Wrong candidates - neither popular enough in general population. Nothing to do with gender or race.
I will be amazed if McCain loses!
I sit on my rock and watch from afar with interest!!

Grace Kelly, Stirling, Scotland

"I await eagerly the election of first black or asian Prime Minister. I worry, however, that maybe you Brits aren't quite ready."

We do NOT elect our Prime Ministers. We have plenty of black and asian MP's. If their party choses them to lead - then win an election - THEN we have a blck /asn PM

Grace Kelly, Stirling, Scotland

Mr. Kaletsky misperceives American politics. Half the voting public will not vote for Ms. Clinton due to her history. Mr. Obama, one of the Senate's most liberal members, has no record of bi-partisanship. Even those disagreeing with McCain genuinely admire him as a war hero, bi-partisan maverick.

Brian Rosner, New York, USA

I do not view this is racial as more ignorance. Bill pardoned two members of the Weather Underground in 2001, Rev. Wright visited the White House and counseled the Clintons, backed NAFTA in 95. See a pattern? Incite the populous against Obama, play dumb on any rebuttle. HRC voters do not fact check.

Spirro, Chicago,

Since when has America been a "civilisation"?. At best, it's a hotch- potch of different cultures, some of which have accidently melded together well, while others have acted like opposing magnetic poles.

Bill Peter, Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia

America voted for change in 2006 & got it's Democratic Congress. Gas is over $3.50. Unemployment up 10%. $2.3 trillion in stock & mutual fund losses. $1.2 trillion drop in home equity. 1% of American homes in foreclosure. They wanted change.. well they got it!

Evan Pickus, Morganville, NJ, USA

Obama's delegate lead is entirely from states that held caucus votes rather than open primaries and particularly from states that seldom vote Democratic in the general election. Just check the results in the 2 Texas contests to see the difference in victory margins and delegate apportionment.

Steve S, L.A., USA

I wouldn't care if it was Karl Marx himself instead of Obama, I would never want to see another two faced Clinton in the whitehouse. At least you know what you're gonna get with Obama

Rich, Tillamook, Oregon, USA

you are missing the point completely - it is not about Race - it is about the direction of the country, and following a European socialist approach to wealth transfer doesn't wash in the USA. We have no wish for a "Nanny State". Less government, not more - that's the heart and soul of the USA.

E D Gil, Calabasas, California, USA

<i>The future of America is a racially-mixed progressive one. In the future most Americans will look a lot like Brazillians.
Obama represents our future. The only people holding that back are the small-minded.</i>

It's small minded to not want to turn this country into Brazil?!! More like sane.

Marc, Alexandria, USA

I'm tired of bigots saying they won't vote for Obama because other people are too bigoted against blacks to vote for him.

Roughly just as many bigots won't vote for a woman as won't vote for a black man.

If you won't vote for Obama because he is black, have the courage to face your own prejudice.

Keith S, Winnipeg, Canada

I'm sorry, but America was very ready to have a black president. Look at Obama's popularity and polling before all of the skeletons came out of his closet!

It isn't that America isn't ready, Obama just isn't the guy for us. To radical, to far left, too much controversy.

Mr. Brown, Carencro, US

You can't tell Americans that they are racist. They all have "a friend that is black" Sadly though, you are correct. A black man could not get elected to national office in the US of A. Witness the majority of comments. This from the more educated Americans that are drawn to your paper.

Dave McEvoy, ottawa, canada

America has long been ready for a black president–it's the Democrats who aren't. If Obama were a Ronald Reagan conservative, he’d have the election locked up.

Nick Costantino, Ridgefield, New Jersey, U.S.A.

Hogwash! As a white male, aged 50, college educated and a raving conservative, I call hogwash. My choice in candidates has nothing to do with race or gender. It does have a lot to do with values.
No I won't vote for Obama or Hillary. I'd have no trouble voting for Dr. Rice if she were to run.

Russ Jansen, Kaysville, USA

Bigots are the new minority. During this urgent election, the vast majority of Americans will put race aside. Obama is like a neo-Lincoln, uniting a politically divided country.

Nigel , San Francisco,

Its not that America wouldn't elect a black president, they just don't trust a liberal one.

Rdc, modesto,

If Obama had been willing to be VP on the dream ticket in the very beginning when the Democrats had a clear path and Hillary had a commanding lead is a prime reason I won't vote for him - in running for president and specifically catering to the liberal left showed he's not a team player.

ted, raleigh,

Bob, I don't vote against Obama because I'm a racist. I vote against Obama because I'm not a socialist.

Andrew, Greencastle, Pennsylvania, US

Black candidates have rarely, if ever, lived up to their poll numbers. No one admits their racism in public but it has always come out in the privacy of the polling booth.

Dave McEvoy, ottawa, canada

This author fawns over the democratic candidates, apparently incapable of seeing into the Clintons' amoral lust for power and Obama's anti-capitalist and socialist nature. McCain is not without faults but he represents the segment of America that knows that this is a hardball world.

Jim Graves, Tampa,

Americans are perfectly prepared to elect a black candidate -- had Colin Powell run in 1996 (or, more precisely, had his wife allowed him to run), he most assuredly would have defeated Clinton. What Americans are not prepared to elect is an EXTREME LEFT-WING candidate, of whatever colour.

Jack Jolis, New York, USA

What an entirely cynical point of view. Obama may loose to McCain but that is in the future. Right now he should be supported for what he is and for what he stands for. If he is to be defeated because of prejudice, so be it. His nomination will be a first . Even in loss the US community may grow.

Ted Keating, Queensland, Australia

Not to mention that McCain has been the favorite Republican of many Democratic voters for nearly a decade now. I've personally heard more than a few AZ Dems speak openly about their admiration for him. And the GOP campaign attack machine hasn't even started yet! Obama doesn't stand a chance.

Matthew, Tucson, USA

The Clintons brought up race. America is perfectly ready for a black president, just not a one who thinks European socialism and government-controlled economy, with its attendant high unemployment and lack of growth, is a good vision for our country.

Mary McLemore, Pike Road, Alabama, USA

And further more, should we elect or give extra consideration to a candidate BECAUSE they are black? I don't think so. I've heard it said that a liberal American is a conservative European, so please realize that to us (US citizens) Obama is pretty far out in Left field.

Dave, Dallas, USA

I have no problem with a black man or a woman in the White House. The issue is Obama and Hillary; can't stand either one of them. I feel lied to every time Obama or Hillary opens their mouth. I'm so tired of hearing the word 'change'. What change, show me something, say something, do something

Debbie, Sunnyvale, USA

The ONLY artical that is the factualy stated situation in this Primary is by Mr.A.Kaletsky. It dos not take a Genius-only a literate person to read it and understand English. Mc Cain Vs Obama- I am giving 10 to 1 odds--any takers?? I could use some easy US Bucks. Good luck Yanks!

Adam, Vancouver,

After reading this article and several of the UK and European comments, it is inreasingly apparent just how ignorant we are on American politics. As ignorant as they are perceived to be on world politics! I wonder who's really wearing the blinkers?

Rob D, Dulwich, uk

Actually, the tragic component of this political campaign is that the Left has become completely intolerant, is accusing anyone and everyone of being a racist for no reason other than the fact they don't vote Obama. The result is an erosion of the democratic process and the first amendment.

Sofia, Chicago, USA

Are you kidding me. I have no problem voting for a black person, and I have no problem voting for a women either.

I'd vote for Condi Rice in a heartbeat. What a stupid article.

Ed, North Bend, WA

i fear that both deserving democratswill lose to the terrifying mcCain (as in mark of) due to the divisive nature of two such popular candidates running against each other when mcCains run is unopposed for the republicans - obama - clinton - toss a coin - loser endorses the winner

fc, newcastle upon tyne, uk

To say you have no idea what you're talking about is an understatement. First of all, America would elect a black president. Second of all, it is John McCain who has the smart economic policies. And it is Hillary and Barak that espouse the same old liberal socialist big government propaganda.

Ryan, Austin, USA

To John who stated: "It is a shame that America is not a democracy. If it was then the superdelegates would not be able to overrule the democratic wish of the American people."

The "Democratic" Party chooses its nominee with Super-Delagates the Republicans choose the nominee based only on votes.

Kurt Strawhecker, Omaha, USA

As a country we have yet to grow up, other countries have had black leaders and women leaders, we still hold racist and gender problems and it's evident by the voting. we are behind in the way this country teaches children in values and in schooling.

Bob, Boston,

If Hillary messes up her term as much as Bill did, then VP Obama would be as likely to win as Gore was. Come on people, let's remember what a mess the Clinton's were when he was in office. There was a scandal almost every week, and his trade policies helped create the economic problems that we face.

kelly, wheaton, USA

Everyone has the right to voice their opinions, yet I can't help but ask...how can Anatole Kaletsky be so obtuse? That question is, of course, rhetorical. It's quite understandable how someone who does not actually live in the U.S. would have little "real world" knowlege of what America is all about

Rick, Portland, USA

Whites/Hispanics are racist for voting 66% for a white candidate but blacks are not racist when they vote 90%+ for black candidates and ADMIT that they do so based on race.

Go figure.

Rich Gonzalez, Philadelphia, PA, USA

Obama wasn't a senator when they voted to invade Iraq. So, it's easy for him to say he was against it, he wasn't there to vote either way. The American people have little affinity for Obama nor Hillary. They'll both lose.

J.G. Wentworth, santa cruz , USA

This article was right on the money. If Obama were half as smart at some assume, he would be excited to run as VP with Hillary. That is the only way he will ever be president. If this ticket does not materialize, then John McCain will be the next president and we will have war with Iran!
rusty

rusty, helena,

America is indeed ready for a female or a black president. Condoleeza Rice, Michael Steele, Colin Powell and JC Watts are examples of black Americans who could be elected president. They are not liberal, radical, socialists as is Obama. THAT is why Obama will never be President.

Doug, Houston, USA

I was born in Pennsylvania, and I've been observing elections for years. The results of the PA primary are in no way predictive of the American election. The only state older than PA is Florida, and seniors skew for Clinton in a big way. The national polls have Obama leading McCain.

Leslie, New York, USA

Democrats easily forget that Hillary voted for this ridiculoius war along with John McCain. Now she sells herself as the candidate of "Change." If you are a democrat, your only logical choice is Obama as they are almost identical on policy except the War in Iraq, which is the most important issue.

Jason, Scottsdale, AZ, U.S.A

Im a white female from PA. My family all white from PA. We have poor ones and not so poor ones too. Im sorry I dont agree with you. I do belive that the republicans that switched over to vote for Hillary to keep this alive voted to reflect your argurment. B will not be here just on the blk vote. NO

Linda, PA, USA

The author shows his ignorance of American politics...president has NOTHING to do with the economy...read the USConst. if you can stand it...republican crossovers voted for Clinton because they believe,well,figure it out..Talks about how bad Obama is,then mentions a "dream ticket" with...Obama...lol

tc, oakland, USA

Saying that we Americans won't elect a black president is absurb. We just don't like Obama who cannot close the deal. BTW, would someone please point out that Mr. Obama is bi-racial? He isn't a true black candidate no matter what the media thinks or says.

Matt Keegan, Cary, North Carolina

Please quit whining about the Republicans. Both parties are equally guility of inappropraite personal attacks against individuals of the opposing party. It is simply inappropriate no matter what party one supports. To think one party is more inappropriate than another is absurd and childish.

Gray, Cheboygan, USA

I'll make a deal with you: You can help elect our presidents just as soon as we can elect your Prime Ministers and Parliament.

Jeanette, Rock Hill, USA

In the absence of Obama candidacy. I will vote Mccain/Rice clear and simple.

Dotun Olusi, London, UK

Socialism is already in american policies, from nation building, farm subsidies, energy credits, the progressive tax system, deduction of state taxes paid to you because you own a house, the department of education, federally funded student loans, small business loans. so stop with the straw man!

Micheaux, Columbus , USA

Actually, for me, race is not an issue. The man's politics are what will prohibit me from voting for him. I can't vote for a blatant Marxist - Leninist. Nobody takes one or more pieces of my "pie" and gives it to someone else. I worked for my "pie", government doesn't have a right to divy it up.

Fred, Burns, USA

Barack just got 96% of the black male vote in Penn and 92% overall. Suggesting white Americans are not ready to elect a black is absolutely ludicrous. Barack overwhelmingly won states like Wyoming were you could count the black people on one hand so drop the white racist America NONSENSE.

Mike OBrien, seattle, wa, usa

America will get what America deserves in this election. In true Hollywood style the voters are blinded by the dazzle that's presented them then queue up as lambs for the next big scare tactic awaiting them. A trick played cruelly time and again upon them by those with interest in keeping them down.

darren, brisbane, australia

Is it possible that America is actually not ready to elect a FAR-LEFT candidate? Forget whether the guy is black or not. I am not voting for Obama because of his politics, not because of his skin color. If that is truly a factor in whether the man becomes President or not, then we are in trouble.

Erik, Charleston,

I'd vote for Condi Rice.... I think she is Black .... but not a man mmmm???? But she's the most qualifed

George, Harrisburg, USA

Boo hoo hoo! Will you liberal losers ever stop whining? President Bush has brilliantly led us through the war on terror and has made this country safe. I only wish we had a true conservative candidate to take over for him instead of a left leaning blue-blood like McCain. Long live Reagan!!

Brian O'Laidhigh, Corning, NY, USA

McCain more fairly represents American values than tax and spend Democrats who promise entitlements and redistribution of wealth without having a plan on how to repair our crumbling infrastructure. Americans are still patriotic and believe that democracy and freedom are still worth fighting for.

Jennifer, Palo Alto, CA, USA

I believe that both Clinton and Obama have failed to present themselves as intelligent people who are really concerned about the welfare of the US of A.. We need neither.
I do not think that this article presenting the two democrats as so much better than John McCain is at all proper or correct.

Bill Bewley, Waco, US of A

To say that we should give legitimacy to the bigots in the United States is a defeatist and fudamentally FLAWED concept. If we had given in to those people in the 60's Obama would not even be able to run for President. No ,what we have to do is overwhelm those bigots with what is right.

gail, Rock Hill, USA

Uhhhh....Excuse me how dare you say that WE the United States are not ready for a black president!! And you called hillary clinton 'sincere' LOL have you been to the US? she has the worst ratings ever on being honest and trustworthy out of all 3 that are left! HE WILL BE THE NOMINEE and win!

mike, Fort LAuderdale, USA!!!!!

Sad commentary on the supposed US white majority . Last I knew, a "gaffe" (which Mr. Obama has been accused of) is a social blunder, while a "lie" (of which several have been accorded to Mrs. Clinton) is a false statement with deliberate intent to deceive. I'll take a "gaffer" over a "liar" any day

Barbara Allen, Boston, USA

No Sir!... 16 per cent will not decide this election....We are not prisoners to bigotry!....Mr Kaletksy needs to understand that our country is worthy of its heritage. We will elect this fine young man and will reap the benefits. Power comes from all the people NOT the just bigots or conspirators.

howard, New Milfford, Connecticut, USA

As a British-American living in London, I must say that the Brits can be so annoyingly smug and self-righteous when it comes to politics. Why not write a piece about McCain's endorsement from a pastor (Hagee) who said that Katrina was well-deserved because of 'the gays'? Falwell, Robertson?

Mark, London, UK

Ouit trying to put us Hispanic Americans against blacks as one poster tried to do. Maybe Asian and whites. But stop trying to group all of us against them. The Hispanic and Latino in large part agree with Senator Obama. Don't let the media fool you.

GH, Jacksonville, USA

Given the appalling performance of the Bush gang over the past 8 years the democrats should be sleepwalking to victory with a chance to right so many wrongs. It seems to an unbiased observer that the democrat camp only opens their mouths to change feet thus allowing McCain to regain the momentum.

Neil, matamata, New Zealand

Mr. Kaletsky, please cite one achievement of either Clinton or O'Bama to support your claim that they are in "command of the issues."

Also please cite one fact to support that either of them is "economically" qualified as you contend McCain is not.

Ernest T. Bass, Mayberry, N.C., U.S.A.

Love the narrative: If Obama fails it's because of Americans' racist attitudes. If Obama succeeds, it will be in spite of Americans' racist attitudes.

I await eagerly the election of first black or asian Prime Minister. I worry, however, that maybe you Brits aren't quite ready.

Ryan, St Andrews, Scotland

The very last paragraph is a howler...I haven't read such irony since Twain or Swift.

Jim, Mint Hill, USA

I know you in Europe support the Democrats but Becareful what you wish for.With China Russia Iran and other unfriendly Goverments getting stronger and bolder.The last thing you want is a Leftist cut and run weak paper tiger liberal democrat running America.Think about it.

tyrone, fairview, USA

I love the smug British assessment that Americans are inherently racist. Excuse me, who was the last black Prime Minister of Great Britain...?

Steven R., Salt Lake City, UT,

You called Hillary Clinton "sincere." That creates a credibility problem for the rest of your piece.

Paul, Detroit,

As an Obama supporter I have to admit that the author makes a very compelling point here. The most eloquent I have seen yet. I hope he's wrong.

Bert, ft lauderdale , usa

The two Senators who actually know how to run the country (and the world actually--too bad for you) Biden and Dodd lasted about 30 seconds in the primaries...Have to wonder why...We would be better off appointing any one of 50 governors at random as president..We need Divine Guidance on this one.

Mike Leahan, Sun Prairie, Wisconsin, USA

Obama is also half white.

That is why I am voting for him.

The future of America is a racially-mixed progressive one. In the future most Americans will look a lot like Brazillians.

Obama represents our future. The only people holding that back are the small-minded.

bob, Oakland, CA,

I think gender matters more than race in this election. I am a 26-year-old white male liberal attorney living in Dallas, Texas. I just can't see a woman running the US. The young white vote is all for Obama. Plain and Simple.

Clayton, Dallas, Texas, USA

how many congregates make up reverend wright's church - maybe 1,000-1,500. i assume that 99.9% of them aren't specifically militant, anti-U.S., anti-white. so it comes down to this - what reverend wright has been saying to a large degree resonates with everday black folk.

christian, brooklyn, ny

If Obama loses, It is not that America is not willing to elect a black man for president. It is that we are not willing to elect THAT man to president. It would not matter if he was Black, green, white, or purple.

Steve Watson, Winston Salem , USA

I suppose that I could vote for a negro, if he was a conservative.

Daniel, Nashville, USA

You can't be serious. Maybe these people just don't trust Obama anymore. He has too many ties to Anti-Americans, )Ayers, Michelle Obama, Rev. Wright, etc...)! Look at Iowa, mostly white state, voted in Obama as their candidate. Pennsylvanians just cant vote for him due to his associates.

Erika , Kihei, USA

Senator Obama is a Dan Quayle who can spell "potato" and talk about potatoes in an inspiring way, but has all the nutritive value of a McDonald's Supersized Fries.. He is a party hack from Chicago with little experience in national government. I'm voting for John McCain.

Gregory Baker, Odenton, Maryland, USA

Way to be an objective journalist when it matters. You really are quite a talented and important person. Please keep writing your posts.

Jeff, Boston, USA

Although other commenters have already said it, I will say it again: it is Democrats who obsess over race and sex. Republicans look at the individual. We also look at character, and Obama has shown, through his advisors and others, that he is sorely lacking in this area. He will lose in November.

Scott, San Francisco , US

People hate Hillary. That's what these "thinkers" conveniently forget. Obama could be green, and some people may or may not like him, but a lot of people absolutely hate Hillary. A Hillary nomination would be the best fundraising event the Republicans could ever have.

Meg, Rhinebeck,

Mr. Kaletsky underestimates the huge number of people, incuding an increasing number of Democrats, who won't vote for Hillary under any circumstances. On the other hand, most of the people who won't vote for Obama because of race are voting Republican anyway.

Peter, Atlanta, USA

It's unfortunate that Obama decided to run against Hillary while he is so inexperienced. He should have experienced an election or two beforehand and been vetted. He should have built up a record of accomplishments. He is still too green.

Steve Jamieson, Charlotte NC, USA

Obama's loss in Pennsylvania has precious little to do with racism. I wouldn't vote for Obama, but it's not because he's black. It's because he's a LIBERAL, he's naive and inexperienced, and I disagree with him about most issues. If Michael Steele were to run, I would vote for him in a heartbeat.

Brenda Tighe, Marietta (Atlanta), Georgia, USA

Please, Americans won't vote for Obama because he is an extreme left winger who chooses to associate with unrepentant former terrorists and people of ill repute. Oh, and by the way, Obama hasn't "tried harder" to disassociate himself with Reverend Wright, he defended this man.

Brian, Alexandria, USA

"As for US Democrats being "Socialists" - They are further right than our Conservatives!"

Yes, and for that we pity you.

Bruce, austin,

Operation Chaos. We won in PA. Keep up the offensive in IN. Watch our flank (NBC,CNN,ABC) and keep our powder dry for the general election. March on!

Mike, West Chester, USA

Anatole's hero and heroine are not paying the price of inheritance, but the cost of the flaws in their own lives and behaviour. Place the blame where it is merited. Neither of them is Presidential material. America wants evidence of a candidate having done the hard stuff. Fluffiness won't do.

John Thom, Charleston, USA

Who are the racists keeping a black man from becoming president? The media. It refuses to give any attention to some of our great black conservatives. The last thing they want is for people to know more about individuals like Dr. Keyes, which is why they basically kicked him out of the debates.

Peter, Houston, TX,

so far i have not seen anyone focus on the black vote for obama. it would appear the black is as racist as the white. to attempt to convince anyone that 92% of blacks voting for obama is not racist , is drinking too much kool-aide.

ralph reuss, safety harbor.fl , usa

The article exposes how very little understanding Europeans have of American politics. Obama and Clinton have almost no experience and promise everything to everyone. Transfer of wealth in the US to further socialist "goals" will rob us of any chance we have to secure our future prosperity.

Dave, Redmond, USA

Mr. Koletsky bases his opinion on Mr. McCain from a European point of view. I am an intelligent, informed American voter and I support John McCain unabashedly. He stands for the values that most Americans feel are important.

Andy G, Canton, Ohio, USA

The fact that Mr Obama and Mrs Clinton are both such impressive candidates, intelligent, sincere, articulate and in command of the issues, while John McCain does not qualify on any of these criteria only makes matters worse.

Are you really serious you believe this

Niles Olsen, McAlester,

Big surprise - you missed the point. Here it is: America is not ready to elect a LIBERAL - whether he/she is black, yellow, red, white, male or female.

Clinton had to move to the center to win, and he never won with over 50% of the vote. He won because of 3rd-party conservative candidates.

Ted Knutson, Spokane, USA

Obama and Clinton are both well qualified. Why then are we pulling the collective race card? Is America really that unconscious that it would rather create a political monopoly of only two families ruling over a 20 yr period than to vote for A New Earth? Give Peace & America a Chance. 1865 is over

Bibi Angola, Long Beach, CA, USA

Operation Chaos....I Love It

Mitch, Atlanta,

Right, like only the Republicans go on the attack. Look at what the democrats are doing to each other. Wait till they take the gloves off against McCain. They'll call him everything but human. If Clinton & Obama., are the standard bearers for the Democrats, you're already in a heap of trouble.

Mike Harris, Beckly, United States

It has been stated so many times in these comments that it really does have some impact when this many readers of this article acknowledge that there are plenty of smart, intelligent, women, and other-than-caucasian peole that could serve as president/vice. Obama's history is now exposed.

Dennis, Omaha, USA

Florida is lost to Obama because of his pro Castro comments. Ohio is lost to the Republicans because of the past governor who makes even this Republican blush with his incompetence. The fact that Obama can't win what Hillary can is a tribute to his socialism, not his race.

Robert Nagel, Wabash, IN, USA

America won't elect a liberal. Reagan won in a 49 state landslide, Bush (1st), less conservative, won a similar landslide against an Massachusetts liberal. The Democrats haven't won with more than 50% since 1976 and no landslide since Franklin Roosevelt. Obama is on the left, he can't win.

Robert Nagel, Wabash, IN, USA

Whenever she talks etc. she doesn't deal with her HUGE negatives. Nearly 6 out of every 10 Americans say she is untrustworthy; Republicans it is 5 out of every 6. Like the guy and his friend running from the bear, I don't have outrun you, just the bear. Obama: Some chance: Hillary: No chance!!!

Alex Campbell, Rockville MD , USA

The common thread throughout this entire article is that Anatole Kaletsky is clueless. Good work Anatole.

John A. Jauregui, Garden Valley, USA

I am most certainly a white woman who voted for Obama in the Virginia primary ... and will support him in the presidential election if he is the Democratic nominee. He is the best candidate ... and I look forward to his presidency

Marlene, Alexandria, VA, usa

Isn't it just possible that instead of country full of bigots, not ready for a black president, that we simply don't like this guy's politics. I beleive most folks in the US are ready for a good president, black, white or otherwise.

Hugh, Buena Vista, USA

In my experience, Russians, at least those living in the US, are heavily pro-Republican...

Holly, Washington, DC,

You're forgetting the critical black vote which will not be there for Hillary in much higher numbers than the white vote which won't be there for Obama. NINE out of ten African-Americans vote Obama and are 13 percent of the population almost all democrat.

colleen, santa barbara, ca, usa

I agree with Kent from Pittsburgh. We its not that we don't want a woman or black president; its just that neither Hillary or Barrack deserve the oval office as they demonstrated with their campaigns. Whats the alternative? John Mccain who is still a frightening prospect as our leader!

Ken, Phoenix, AZ

I won't vote for Obama because he is not the strongest candidate running for president.

Marty, San Diego,

To be correct in one aspect of his analysis he should specify that white Democrats are not ready to elect an "African American" (eventhough he is also Caucasian). If Obama loses it will be white Democrats' fault. Republicans won't vote for him or Hillary. So you can't blame them.

Cedric, Santa Ana,

My choice hasn't got a thing to do with whether the candidate is white, black, male or female. Of course, I'm a Republican, so race and sex don't matter to me. Those things only matter to Democrats.

Hurley, Houston, TX, USA

Barack Obama would lose forty or more states in this or any future presidential election not because he is black, but because he is far to the left on issues that matter most to voters: taxes, terrorism, trade and most importantly, trust.

Tom Armstrong, east hanover, New Jersey , USA

In response to criticism that the UK hasn't elected a black PM, it should be noted that we don't actually have a separate vote for our first minister - that person is the leader of the party who gains a majority at the General Election. This leader is not decided by a vote from the general public.

simon, cardiff, wales

Before the Clintons started on the race, nobody even thought of Obama as black, or white. He is actually half and half, so some of the racists may reconsider ?

He is not 'associated' with racists (black) leaders, and I support him because his sound judgment on the war, and other issues.

S. A Jones, Naples FL, USA

Surely if whites won't vote for Obama then how come so many have already voted for him? Also isn't Hillary supposed to be disliked by a large part of the American electorate?

Dan, Winchester, UK

Funny how closet neo-cons believe that Democrats, who are registering to vote in record numbers, will fail to show up in November. Or that they will magically switch to McCain's camp if Obama is the nominee, even though centrist Republicans are voting for Obama in record numbers. Fact!

Charles, Seattle, USA

I'd like to point out - We in UK do not elect our Prime Ministers. The Prime Minister is the leader of the Party which wins the elections.
As for US Democrats being "Socialists" - They are further right than our Conservatives!
Many Moslem, Catholic, Women, Black, Brown and White people are MP's

Grace Kelly, Stirling, Scotland

The issue is really quite simple. Elect McCain if you wish to spend your taxes on wars which produce zero monetary gain for the United States, or vote Democrat to put money back into America's failing infrastructure, create jobs, increase GPD, and fund Universal Health-Care.

Curt, San Diego, CA, U.S.A.

The biggest divide in America about race is between young and old. If only voters under the age of 45 had counted in Pennsylvania, Obama would have won by more than 15 points. The memories of the sixties and the racial tension make older Americans wary of a Obama. The youth carry no such fears.

Jason F., Medford, USA

Sorry to dissappoint you but America does not care that Obama is black. We care that his policies are socialist and that his associations with racist leaders are indicative of his bad judgements. That is why America won't vote for him. We would love a black candidate such as Colin Powell or C Rice.

Dave, Phoenix,

I am tired of hearing about the Republican attack machine. What about the Democrats' attack machine?

I am a conservative who believes America is ready for a black or female president. I just don't think we are ready for this black or female president.

Kent Schoffstall, Pittsburgh, USA

"Obama and Clinton impressive candidates" Are you kidding me

Kaletsly has evidently swallowed the DNC Kool Aid. Obama was a state senator before beginning his first term in the senate, and Hillary is riding her husbands coattails and a sense of entitlement. This qualifies to run for president

Neil Pearce, Columbus, USA

Wrong. Hillary controls the party, so she wins every "closed Primary" contest (closed to official party members only).

Barack wins the caucuses by huge margins, which are open to all voters and I think that represents the true feeling amoung voters. He would win the general election easily.

Steve, Dallas, USA

Whatever makes you feel better at night, Mr. Kaletsky. I refuse to be lectured by Europeans who instigated two world wars and a more recent Bosnian war over racial lines/geography. If Mr. Obama wasn't recycling post-feudal marxism, that has been proven not to work, then he would sailing in the race.

Chris, Boise, ID, USA

The real hero is President Bush. Despite being relentlessly attacked by liberal hacks in the media and DNC, he has perservered to free 50 million people, eliminate 7000 ruthless thugs, keep America safe from attack, sustained lower unemployment rates, higher GDP, higher stock averages than Clinton.

robin, greenville,

Is this guy in the tank for Dem's or what? How about the simple fact that both Obama and Clinton or Socialist and the American people are not ready for a Socialist to be president.

Nick, Dallas, Dallas

Obama has 4 years experience. Clinton has 8 years experience and neither have any notable successes. McCain has served in the Senate for a long time and has served and honored his country with his service. Belligerent war mongerer - NOT!!! The only adult in the race.

Tom Jordan, Valley Stream, NY, USA

Colin Powell would be a black man that I would have no problem voting for. It's not the color of the man skin, it's that the country is more moderate than both of the democratic candidates. No one really knows who Obama is and now we're finding out and don't like what we learn.

Brenda C, Portland, United States

Race HAD NOTHING to do with Obama's electability. He now looks like a racist for following a racist preacher for 20 years & raising his children in the church. This has hurt him. Also the notion that obama and Hill are a dream team is silly. Whose dream- socialists? not mainstream America.

Daria, Enfield, USA

Sean in NY
If you are lacking the courage to stand up and fight in a just war against totalitaianism, I am willing, as a woman, to stand up and fight in your place.
Sara in Pennsylvania

Sara, Pennsylvania, USA

I always find it interesting that Obama is described as "Black" even though he has a parents of both African and European origins so really is half-white half-black. In the UK usually mixed raced people use the term half-(whatever ancestry) to describe themselves

raymond, the norf, UK

No, Mr. Kaletsky, America is not ready (thank God) to elect a socialist. Were a mainstream black candidate such as Michael Steele to run for president, he would be swept into office.

TJ Pierce, Alameda, CA, USA

"It is a shame that America is not a democracy. If it was then the
superdelegates would not be able to overrule the democratic wishes of the American people.

John, LONDON, ENGLAND"

The USA is a representative republic with democratic procedures. I can't think of any true Democacry.

Sean, NY, USA

Poorly written and absurd. Congrats!

Sam, Napa, United Sates

"...militarily belligerent and economically unqualified Republican candidate..." I commend Mr. McCain's military background/service, his understanding of the military's responsibilities/requirements/ procedures/protocol = hardly "belligerent.&quo