Anatole Kaletsky: Economic View
Take a trip to New York and see the city from the air
So the sky did not fall in. While the Chicken Littles of the world economy, led by Gordon Brown, George Soros and Warren Buffett, may still repeat mechanically the IMF’s surprising judgment that the world - especially America - faces its worst financial crisis since the 1930s, their hearts are no longer in it. Mr Brown, after last week’s election woe, can no longer blame the world economy for his political failure. Mr Buffett, having speculated against the dollar for years and declared that credit derivatives are financial weapons of mass destruction, has finally begun to find attractive opportunities to invest his money and told his shareholders last week that the worst of the credit crisis was probably over. Mr Soros, in his forthcoming book, The New Paradigm for Financial Markets, states unequivocally: “We are in the midst of a financial crisis the likes of which has not been seen since the Great Depression.” But after making $3 billion for Quantum Endowment Fund by anticipating last year’s bear markets, he is now hedging his bets, as is only to be expected from the world’s most successful hedge fund manager. “I may well be proven wrong,” he told The New York Times last week, adding that he might yet again turn out to be “the boy who cried wolf”.
The main explanation for all this revisionism is simply the change in facts. The near-unanimity of a few weeks ago that the US was sinking into a deep, prolonged recession has been dispelled by recent data on jobs, GDP, business confidence, industrial orders and consumer spending – all telling a consistent story that although the US economy weakened abruptly last autumn, it is not nearly as weak as at the start of previous recessions, and that there have been no signs of further deterioration since February in the key economic variables apart from house prices.
Moreover, the time of greatest risk of a US recession is almost past, since tax rebates worth more than 1 per cent of disposable income will start landing in US taxpayers’ bank accounts from this week, almost guaranteeing that consumer spending will pick up, at least temporarily, in the year’s second half. And just as the stimulus to consumption from tax cuts runs out, benefits of the Fed’s big cuts in interest rates should start to be felt fully in the first few months of 2009. So, it is increasingly likely that the US economy will not experience even a minor recession, at least as defined in the official statistics, as a result of the credit crunch last year.
Even more important than the relatively benign statistics is the news from the financial markets. Signs that the worst of the banking crisis may be over appeared to be confirmed by rallies in financial markets worldwide last week. Financial markets’ better mood is partly related to stabilisation in US economic statistics. But mainly it is a consequence of radical steps by governments and central banks all over the world since it became clear that private financial markets would not resolve the credit crunch.
As a result of these government interventions, culminating in the Bear Stearns rescue and nationalisation of Northern Rock, one financial market after another has started to return to something nearing normality. Straight after the Bear rescue, there was a narrowing of credit spreads on top-quality securities such as government-backed mortgages in the US. Next, two weeks after liquidity returned to credit markets following the Bear rescue, the yield on US Treasury bonds stopped collapsing and reversed, implying that markets no longer saw need for panic cuts in US interest. In turn, the steepening of the US yield curve that followed the return of more normal conditions to the bond market helped to put a floor under the dollar two weeks ago. Finally – though this is still a more tentative conclusion - dwindling fears of a freefall in the dollar seemed to take some of the wind out of speculation in commodities and oil.
Of course, it is impossible to be sure of the sustainability of improvement in the four markets that have been causing all the trouble - credit, bonds, currencies and commodities. But what seems fairly clear is that the real economy of jobs, profits, investment and consumer spending in America has so far suffered almost entirely as a direct result of weaker housebuilding and construction employment – and not in response to the negative wealth effects and bank-credit contractions in the nightmare scenarios of Wall Street analysts.
To pessimists, this means that the worst is still to come, since the real consumer reaction to falling housing wealth and bank deleveraging has not even started. An alternative view more consistent with economic theory and historic experience was suggested by the Bank of England’s Stability Report last week: “Credit markets are likely to overstate significantly the losses that will ultimately be felt by the financial system and the economy as a whole . . . They will exaggerate to an even greater extent the potential damage to the real economy.”
As noted in that report, the pricing of many bonds and credit derivatives in financial markets already assumes bigger losses from US sub-prime mortgages and other dubious assets than anything implied by plausible worst-case scenarios. This is true of highest-quality credits, with AAA and AA ratings, whose unexpected collapse has done the greatest damage to bank balance sheets. The Bank’s sums suggest that the highest-quality mortgage-backed bonds are now undervalued by 25 per cent (see chart). It now seems that, contrary to the Chicken Little rantings of many analysts in the City and Wall Street, these bonds face almost no risk of serious defaults even in the event of far bigger falls in US housing prices than any that have happened so far.
Indeed, the Bank’s calculations suggest that present pricing of mortgage-related bonds in financial markets has probably overstated the future losses on US sub-prime lending by about double.
None of this means that the credit crunch has been a storm in a teacup, as I originally thought. Changing attitudes to borrowing and lending will have a dramatic impact on the world economy, reducing long-term growth in consumption in economies that have been driven by powerful housing and mortgage cycles, including Britain, Spain and France. As Mr Soros says in his book, global growth can no longer rely on these economies and must depend on consumption and infrastructure investment in China, India and other emerging markets. These are momentous changes, and while they are quite far advanced in America, they have hardly started in Britain and Europe. But if economic news continues to deteriorate for a while - as it almost certainly will in the UK – investors and business should realise that the really important story in the world economy today is not the threat of a sudden collapse in the financial system, but a gradual long-term adjustment in the world economy in favour of emerging markets. This may at times be an uncomfortable process – but the sky will not fall in.

Anatole Kaletsky writes for The Times Comment pages on Thursdays. One of the country's leading commentators on economics, he was formerly Economics Editor and is now an Associate Editor of The Times. He has won many awards for his financial and political journalism. Before joining The Times, he worked for 12 years on the Financial Times
Follow our three athletes' progress in their preparations for the London Triathlon, and pick up training tips and more
Enjoy screenings of all the classic films you love, plus take advantage of two-for-one tickets
We explore leisure activities that are safe and suitable for all of the family
Times Online's new TV show helps you make the right decisions for your pet
Read our exclusive 100 Years of Fleming and Bond interactive timeline, packed with original Times articles and reviews
The latest travel news plus the best hotels and gadgets for business travellers


Why good girls pay good money for bad-girl baubles

Search The Times Births, Marriages & Deaths
£129,500
Bentley Edinburgh
£79,850
Mercedes-Benz of Northampton
£26,995
Unit 1, Woodfield Business Unit, Kidderminster Road, Ombersley, Worcester.
Great car insurance deals online
90k + Bonus + Options
Confidential
London
£23,716 +
Highways Agency
National
£
£43,405 - £48,228 pa
Notting Hill Housing
London
£30,000 base, £100,000 OTE
Riches Consulting
London/South
Live in One of London's Most Vibrant Areas
From £249,950
Beautiful Gardens w/ stunning Thames Views
Studios £33K, 1 Beds £60K, 2 beds £79K
Mortgages, bank acc & money transfers to help you buy abroad
Explore mystical Jordan
From £1030 for 7nts 4*
to USA's Most Cosmopolitan City; San Francisco!
£POA
Book Now for Winter 08/09 and Get 10% off!
Great travel insurance deals online
Contact our advertising team for advertising and sponsorship in Times Online, The Times and The Sunday Times. Search globrix.com to buy or rent UK property. Visit our classified services and find jobs, used cars, property or holidays. Use our dating service, read our births, marriages and deaths announcements, or place your advertisement.
Copyright 2008 Times Newspapers Ltd.
This service is provided on Times Newspapers' standard Terms and Conditions. Please read our Privacy Policy.To inquire about a licence to reproduce material from Times Online, The Times or The Sunday Times, click here.This website is published by a member of the News International Group. News International Limited, 1 Virginia St, London E98 1XY, is the holding company for the News International group and is registered in England No 81701. VAT number GB 243 8054 69.
This article is only a month old, and already events are making it look unduly optimistic, to say the least....
Dean Hallett, Basingstoke, UK
The days of pretending that things are OK, when really they are not are almost over.
The British and American economies are in a disgracefull state, and all because the powers that be, are in bed with, and even protect, the institutions that have created this situation, THE CENTRAL BANKERS.
A Snowden, Keighley, Britain
"a gradual...adjustment ...in favour of emerging markets"
These markets ain't going to emerge much if the US and the west cannot afford the goods they make.
The sort of items China makes are the first things people will cut back on.
There is far too much evidence to rubbish this report anyways.
Np, Cornwall, UK
Quarterly GDP statistics can be flattered by weak imports (a sign of weak domestic demand) and by a rise in inventories (as nothing is selling). That is what happened in the US recently.
The impact on the real economy is only now starting.
Trevor, South east,
The US 1 percent of disposable income tax rebate will go to outstanding debts and/or immediate basic expenses. There has been NO net job growth since 2000. Real wages are growing less than the rate of inflation, resulting in a net income and discretionary spending LOSS. ....
S Waugh , Jersey City, USA
Sorry but the credit crunch is far from over. US house prices continue to fall showing no sign of stopping leaving the banks with more big loses in unknown locations.
On top of that you have the British sub prime effect is starting with all our bad lending surfacing as house prices fall.
Gavin, London,
These bankers who are saying it is all over are the same ones who were claiming in 2005/2006 that there was no house price bubble about to burst.
Which pretty much sums up how savvy they are.
Paul, Dubai, UAE
This smells like the 'Bear Trap'. A minor recovery before the real slide into despondency begins.Keep your cash in your pocket!
Matt, Knutsford, UK
Anatole Kaletsky is like the very worst kind of politician....changes his mind every 5 minutes if he thinks the uptake is likely to be better.
Michael Clarke, Windsor, UK
Anatole Ker-plunksky. Wrong before, and still wrong
Keith Frankland, London,
Remember Anatole's record. Now is the time to be afraid... be very afraid.
Stratford Tony, Salisbury, UK
If we avoid recession then it's likely that the inflationary pressures will not go away, as key to the hope that they would diminish in the coming months was the expectation that the US would be in recession. Are we caught between a rock & a hard place?
russell, valletta, Malta
Anatole,
hee hee hee haa haa hee, you crack me up!
Stratford Tony, Salisbury, UK
Good article. It's important to distinguish between the stock and bond markets which live in a world of their own and the market for goods and services which is the real world in which we all live.
The pain may not be over yet and hopefully the credit crunch may help to contain inflation.
Jimmy, London,
Another rose-tinted Times article saying all is hunky-dorey and we shouldn't panic.
Easy to pretend you have GDP growth if you lie about inflation.
Specially whilst the brokers engineer an artificial food crisis whilst speculating on commodities to claw back their subprime losses...
Voland, Caen, France
Forget about Gdp and Non-farm payroll data last week. The books have definitely been cooked and the real figures will tell you the US is in recession, but thanks to statistical spin will probably avoid depression.
Graeme Dickson, Guildford,
Don't worry that the US owes the rest of the world the equivalent of 27 Eiffel towers made of solid gold.
I'm sure everything will clear itself up by the end of the year.
Ian Bear, Gloucester,
I have argued that Britain and Europe are following a similar cycle to US, but 12-18 months later. If US house prices hit bottom this autumn, British house prices will continue to fall until late 2009. If the peak to trough fall in US prices turns out to be 20%, then 20-30% seems likely in Britain.
anatole kaletsky, london, uk
It's JUST the end of a cycle. Finance reflects the REAL economy. That means that Financial assets can't grow forever on a 2 to 2 percent overall economic growth. It had to stop; And now life goes on on some other system where speculators can rip off wannabies... as always.
Rui, Lisbon, Portugal
Phase I of crisis contained. Job done (according to the ineffable AC) Now get prepared for the aftershocks of staglfation, repossessions, falling demand, the fiscal crisis of government, unemployment, declining property values and debt tsunamis. This downturn has only just begun.
Frank L, London, UK
Mr Kaletsky, where does this improving macroeconomic picture leave your doom and gloom prediction a couple of weeks ago of a fall in UK house prices by up to 30%? Surely if credit spreads are narrowing and wholesale money markets are becoming more liquid, mortgages will become more readily available
Jonathan, London, UK
This analysis article under estimates the impact of reduced credit and consumers new found reluctance to take on further credit. The economic events of the past 12 months is the first of a few step-downs in the economic capacity of both America and Britain.
Costas, Cyprus,
Mr. kaletsky is spot on. We are just going through a reality adjustment that will settle down over the next year as the losses are costed out. This will include more homeowners losing their homes unfortunately. I am thinking some emerging market bonds will benifit the most from this.
Brian Stewart, Los Angeles, usa
As taxes are up, prices of energy up, the shopping bill up etc. A significant reduction in consumer consumption is on the cards as people pay back the loans for the consumption that wasn't really earned.
Is this factored into the article above? Business as usual, credit for all? I think not!
Alan, Luton, UK
personally I can do without a home depot every two miles. the idea is the bigger you are the more you get paid - but there is a reason why things like trees have maximum growth sizes and hormonal injections of cash to grow and merge companies, like amphetamines, often lead to misery
glenn schaefer, holbrook, usa
I would like to give a valuable boost to the ailing British economy by spending much more in the shops and restaurants, so I think the Government here should adopt the US method of averting recession. When will Mr.A.Darling be returning all my tax?
eric campbell, harrogate, uk
And of course it's anyone's bet how long economies like China will stay cheap enough. Has everyone forgotten how recently Russia was seen as a "cheap" economy and Moscow as a "cheap" city?
jon livesey, Sunnyvale, CA/USA
Given your track record so far during this whole credit crisis I think I will use you as a contrarian indicator from now on.
JP, London,