Caitlin Moran
Win a fitness package worth more than £3,000
At present, the Government is preparing a new law: to protect women's rights to breastfeed legally in public. This follows a high-profile case in which the National Gallery in London stopped a mother breastfeeding in one of its galleries and subsequently had to issue an apology. With inspiringly apt irony, the mother and child in question were in the same room as Tintoretto's The Origin of the Milky Way, in which Juno breastfeeds Hercules.
This legislation is to roll out by the end of the year, following the lead of the Scottish Parliament, which introduced similar laws four years ago, so soon we'll be able to lactate in the Tate, whip out our boobs in White Cube, utilise our mammaries in the Royal Academies. This is a huge coup for those of us who like to claim the moral high ground by breastfeeding, when the truth of the matter is that we're just too slatternly to sterilise umpteen bottles a day, and find that the smell of Milton's Fluid makes us pukey. But it also highlights the extraordinary fact that, until this law kicks in, it is actually illegal to breastfeed publicly in this country. Illegal. Indeed, it's so illegal that there are two, separate, acts under which a breastfeeder can be prosecuted: public order laws, or laws of public decency. Conceivably, if a woman got busted* after a very long feed, one involving both breasts, the left one could be charged under the public order laws and get away with a light fine, while the right one, having offended public decency, could be looking at a seven-to-ten stretch in the pen.
And ladies, let's face it: after breastfeeding, your bosom-area looks like it's done time in the slammer anyway. Whenever I take my bra off now and check myself in the mirror, my breasts look knackered. But be this as it may, I can assure you of one thing: there's barely a mother in this country who knows that it's illegal to breastfeed in public. I did a quick text-round of all my 24-hour post-partum people and they were amazed that the third most physically crucial aspect of motherhood - after hoiking the baby out into the world, and then not leaving it on a cliff edge while having a fag - is prosecutable. For many, it's been like finding out that it's illegal to put your child on a swing, feed it carrot sticks and hoummos or beat it with a spiky oaken paddle named “Mr Whackbum”.
“The logical conclusion of this legislation is that the British believe a woman should not leave her house - not even once - until her baby is weaned,” said one friend, on her mobile phone from Beachy Head, between drags on a Rothmans.
Of course, in many ways, it's quite heartening to find out that it's still illegal to breastfeed in public. It's almost comforting. Women tend to blame themselves for everything. British mothers had, therefore, presumed that the reason why England has the lowest breastfeeding rates in the world - only 25 per cent breastfeed up to six months (frankly, worms do better, and they don't lactate) was simply All Our Fault. We didn't have the commitment, the selflessness or the nerve to get the big boys out and feed the little boys (or girls) in public. Because it takes nerve to breastfeed in public. There is a lexicon of Acceptable Public Breasts, and those who have a baby on the end don't make the list. You can have statue breasts (classy tits), native tribeswoman breasts (educational tits) and 18-year-old girls looking down at their Nuts tits with a combination of pride and surprise (tits somehow fundamental to the continuation of the smooth running of this country). But a hurriedly bared wet nipple at a bus station in January being waved, semi-despairingly, at a wailing child just doesn't make it into this pantheon. These breasts - the useful breasts - must be kept hidden.
I'm apt to blame this baffling aesthetic and moral schism on a gigantic as-yet untackled seam of rampant misogyny. It bears all the hallmarks of The Patriarchy, ie, a world tilted in favour of perky tits, normal women made to feel bad. Damn you, The Patriarchy! I shake my fist at you, again! Indeed, I keep meaning to replace the F11 key on my Mac with a “Patriarchy Alert” button so that when I press it all my open windows fly off the screen, leaving me to stare at an inspiring and soothing screensaver picture of Mary Wollstonecraft.
So what will it take to increase breastfeeding rates in this country, other than stopping it being illegal in the 99.99999 per cent of the British Isles that isn't the lactating mothers' front rooms, of course? For myself, I was a constant, militant, public breastfeeder - but I can't now, three years later, remember quite why. Briefly analysing it, I would say it was probably a combination of: 7 per cent having a mother who contentedly breastfed eight children, in turn, for the first two years of their lives; 12 per cent being a rock-hard, ice-cool feminist warrior queen, like Sarah Connor in Terminator 2, but wearing a purple, white and green hat; and 81 per cent wanting the crying, screaming baby to just shuuuuuut uuuuuup before we set off all the fire alarms in Boots.
To be honest, I brought a geeky aesthetic to the process, in that I often pretended my breast milk was a killer laser beam. Once I'd built up a sufficienthead of pressure, I'd jet my milk lasers across the room, “taking out” objects/people while making the “zzsswhoompf” light-sabre sound from Star Wars. Perhaps we could get more women into breastfeeding from that angle, encouraging them to use lactation for the purposes of pugilism. That way, until public breastfeeding is made legal, at least they could pick off disapproving art gallery security staff, one by one, with their mummy-guns.
*Hahaha. I've just noticed that; that's quite clever.
Industry sectors news at a glance. Interactive heatmap, video and podcast
The inside track on current trends in the charity, not for profit and social enterprise sectors
Read our exclusive 100 Years of Fleming and Bond interactive timeline, packed with original Times articles and reviews
Everything the Business Traveller needs to know to make a better trip
Shortcuts to help you find sections and articles
05/2005
£13,500
08/2008
£109,950
2006
£10,750
Great car insurance deals online
£Excellent+ executive benefits
Torres and Partners
London
£49,229 - £62,035 pro rata
Charity Commission
London/Liverpool/Taunton
Alstom Power
Europe
Six Figure
Rolls Royce
Midlands/Europe
From £89,950
Great Investment, River Views
Special Offers now available
At the new sophisticated
Encore Las Vegas Resort!
Cruise the Islands of Hawaii - Pride of America
List your property with two leading travel websites
Great travel insurance deals online
Contact our advertising team for advertising and sponsorship in Times Online, The Times and The Sunday Times, or place your advertisement.
Times Online Services: Dating | Jobs | Property Search | Used Cars | Holidays | Births, Marriages, Deaths
News International associated websites: Globrix | Property Finder | Milkround
Copyright 2008 Times Newspapers Ltd.
This service is provided on Times Newspapers' standard Terms and Conditions. Please read our Privacy Policy.To inquire about a licence to reproduce material from Times Online, The Times or The Sunday Times, click here.This website is published by a member of the News International Group. News International Limited, 1 Virginia St, London E98 1XY, is the holding company for the News International group and is registered in England No 81701. VAT number GB 243 8054 69.
The Star Wars angle is quality - sign me up in a couple of years!
Pucci, London, UK
Well, my breasts are ready and primed, and I will shoot to drown so just say the word.
Unfortunately, this proposed new law is so ridiculous, that those of us interested in feeding hungry babies where and when they are hungry, think it should be junked. Downing St needs to steal the Scots' law.
Morgan Gallagher, Bedford, England
Re:using them as guns : my sister squirted me (whilst feeding her son,I hasten to add) in church, during prayers, a couple of weeks ago. I assumed it was accidental. Not so sure now.....
Jessica, wrexham,
I live in Scotland and have never been asked to leave anywhere told to stop breastfeeding or even so much as a disapproving glance though its nice to know that you have a bit of legal comeback should anyone try to give you aggro.
suzie, Glasgow, Scotland
No, just the arrogance of people who think they're always right, and a skin like a rhinoceros.
Hilary, Telford, UK
Loved the column yesterday. Glad to see I'm not the only person who breatfed partly because they were just too lazy to faff around with bottles.
There is a petition on the Downing Street website if anyone wants to sign up in favour of the proposed legislation:
http://petitions.pm.gov.uk/breastfedright/
Sharon Marazzi, Ipswich,
As a breastfeeding mum of a 2 year old I have never had a problem because I arrange my clothing to be discrete. This is a good thing because the proposed legislation will not apply once a child is 12 months old.
Rachel Prosser, Bradford,
I was once kicked out of Tesco's for BF. But the worst were the disapproving looks from some "ordinary people" when I fed my baby in public. As for being "discreet", who dreamt up the idea that BFing mums are secretly yearning to expose themselves in public? It's a miracle anyone in the UK BFs.
Cam, Canterbury, UK
Well done Caitlin I haven't laughed so much in ages. Never realised that I was a serial criminal.
Please,comments people, lighten up! She's not critisising you personaly but the law and the stupid people who want to inforce it.
Cal, St albans, uk
The current situation is silly but there is a half-way house - breast feeding mothers need to be discreet and modest. No wonder successful breast feeding is so low in this country - it's actually rather difficult and then to be made to feel uncomfortable outside the home makes it even worse
Maria, London, Uk
Breastfeeding 2 babies in central London was easypeasy, once I got over my acute embarrassment of inexperience. The only time I was told I was not allowed to breastfeed, was when I was discovered, in a personal 'makeup booth' in the ladies in Harrods. Needless to say I've never been back.
Anna, Seattle, USA
Maybe I live in a really cool place, but I've not once felt uncomfortable breast-feeding in public. I was even complimented in Tesco's coffee shop last week by an old woman: "Lovely to see someone breast-feeding!" and, to my baby, "Best breakfast you'll ever have!"
Alex C, Cockermouth,
I love Caitlin Moran but just a point of information; in my experience the vast majority of bottle feeding mothers don't do it because its easier, they do it because for whatever reason breast feeding didn't work out. I hate cleaning bottles and long to have/had the convenience of BF.
Eve, Smethwick,
Thanks for sharing your daydreams about shooting people down with your jets of milk/laser beams. I wonder if this is quite a common fantasy... I invented an alter-ego called "Lactating Woman", who had pretty much the same characteristics, and, sadly, never saw the light of day as a comic strip heroi
fifi, Edinburgh, Mid Lothian
Hmm. Not much going on in Downing Street, then, that they can spare time to legislate for this sort of trivia?
James, Hatfield,
I'm sick of these people who feel that every single area in life should be open to them and their wailing offspring.
Moni, Sheffield, South Yorks
This is ludicrous, especially when we have the NHS trying to hammer home the message that breast is best for all new mums, often making those who can't do it feel very guilty. We will never encourage more women to do it whilst society continues to make mothers feel uncomfortable to feed in public
sarah Blanks, kenilworth, UK
I'm so glad to live in Germany where you can whap out your mams anywhere you like. A German friend of mine has mastered the art of walking and breast feeding - baby in sling, breast out and off you go!
Gaby Pinkner, Cologne, Germany
The idea that a mother might be breaking the law by breastfeeding her baby is ludicrous. The proposed legislation needs to drop the age limit since the healthy breastfeeding relationship spans some years and not just a few months.
barbara , Ilkley, uk
I doubt whether anyone breastfeeding discreetly was ever in much danger of fetching up at the cop shop, Caitlin. An exhibitionist letting it all hang out to provoke an emotional reaction or make a political point might legitimately be regarded as breaching order or decency laws.
Janet Davis, Sydney, Australia