Bronwen Maddox, Chief Foreign Commentator
Pick up your copy of Joy Division: Closer at WHSmith today
Yesterday, for the first time, Britain said that Robert Mugabe had no right to call himself the President of Zimbabwe and that the world should try to get him out. Strong words, although tailing off into euphemism about exactly how other countries should do that.
The weakness in this call for sanctions - which is not at this point, ministers made clear, a call to arms - is Zimbabwe’s nervous but immobile neighbours. The task is to persuade them, as they sit watching the rising tally of deaths, the hunger, the inflation of more than a million per cent, that even if humanity won’t prompt them to act, self-interest now should.
“This Government, this status quo, is not something we can accept or live with,” Lord Malloch-Brown, Foreign Minister for Africa, said. “We do not recognise the Mugabe Government as the legitimate representative of the people of Zimbabwe,” David Miliband, Foreign Secretary, later told the House of Commons.
Unambiguous, finally, and free of the fear of seeming like a colonial power, which has kept Britain too reticent for too long. The turning point, Lord Malloch-Brown said, was Sunday’s rally, where the opposition Movement for Democratic Change persuaded a judge to overturn a ban, only to find itself confronting thugs with clubs from the ruling Zanu (PF) party.
But now that Britain has said that it wants an end to the Mugabe regime, what can it actually do? Not much on its own, although Lord Malloch-Brown said it might now look at forcing the few British companies that still did business there to cut all ties. In answer to a question about whether Britain might strip Mugabe of his knighthood, he said drily, “I can’t imagine anyone in this room, including this minister, thinks he should keep it. But for the mangy old British lion to rise to its full height and say, this is outrageous, you’ve lost your knighthood . . .” - it would not, he concluded, match the gravity of the offence. “We don’t want it to be Zimbabwe versus Britain, it’s Zimbabwe versus the world,” he said.
What should the world do? More sanctions, and more targeting of those in the regime, including perhaps their foreign assets and children’s education. But not, he argued, blocking remittances or cutting off electricity, because these would hurt the poorest.
This makes sense. But it is vague about how this might dislodge a leader who has said he will consent to be removed only by God. The intention appears to be to prompt some within Zimbabwe to overthrow Mugabe. The risk is not just of a worse bloodbath, but that some of those most equipped to do that, including army generals, are not those who might rush to form the kind of “democratic government representative of all the people” that Britain wants. All that other countries can do is to offer lavish rewards to a new government that resembles that ideal.
A risky plan, then, but better at this point than military action (Miliband, with a stutter, brushed away a Commons question about whether Britain would send in the SAS). But a flurry of meetings this week will test whether there is any real support from other countries. “We are at one end of the spectrum,” Lord Malloch-Brown said, describing Britain’s efforts to urge a tougher stand. “But the spectrum is moving towards us.”
Slowly, though. The most important signal will come from the African Union (AU), egregiously indulgent so far, which has one of its regular meetings later this week. There were signs during the Zimbabwe election campaign, Lord Malloch-Brown said, of interest by some AU members in a role for international peacekeepers. For the AU, this would be a radical and welcome step forward. He also claimed to see signs that South Africa was moving in a tougher direction. We’ll see. If it were not for the world’s reverence for Nelson Mandela, now celebrating his 90th birthday, and its deep respect for South Africa’s own journey to democracy, there might have been much louder opposition to President Mbeki’s determined evasion of the Mugabe problem - comparable, say, to the criticism of China for support of the Sudanese Government.
The United Nations Security Council could be hugely important but is not yet close to the necessary pitch. Yesterday’s meeting was always going to consider Zimbabwe, but only to take stock of humanitarian help. Miliband warned the Commons about Britain’s struggles, unsuccessful so far, even to get Zimbabwe made a standing item on the agenda. The council, and the meeting of foreign ministers of the G8 later this week, will test China’s willingness - so far absent - to join a united front.
This might be a rare time where the EU moves first, although only because members have least at stake. Last week they signalled support for tougher measures, although they did not name them.
Britain is right that this conflict is between Zimbabwe and the world. It is to the world’s discredit - and South Africa’s, above all - that it has so far ducked the battle.
Explore your passion for food with the delights of Thai, Indian & Chinese cooking
In our new series, Tony Hawks takes a dry, wry look at modern life - junk mail, interminable meetings and snooty sales assistants
Read the training tips and advice that helped our London Triathletes
Read our exclusive 100 Years of Fleming and Bond interactive timeline, packed with original Times articles and reviews
The latest travel news plus the best hotels and gadgets for business travellers
Shortcuts to help you find sections and articles
2007
£30,000
2006
£14,337
2008
£39,937
Great car insurance deals online
c.£75,000
GlosFirstmeansbusiness
Gloucestershire
Competitive package
Npower
Midlands
£
£32,795 - £41,545
Universitry of Southampton
Southampton
Competitive Package
Npower
West Midlands
1 & 2 Bed apartments
From £249,995
Great Investment, River Views
Great Dubai Investment Opportunities
from £89,950
low-cost ownership homes in London
Multi–Centre 9 Nights
From only £925pp
View thousands of properties online with your Vacation Rental People
£POA
List your property with two leading travel websites
£POA
Great travel insurance deals online
Contact our advertising team for advertising and sponsorship in Times Online, The Times and The Sunday Times. Globrix Property Search - find property for sale and rent in the UK. Milkround Job Search - for graduate careers in the UK. Visit our classified services and find jobs, used cars, property or holidays. Use our dating service, read our births, marriages and deaths announcements, or place your advertisement.
Copyright 2008 Times Newspapers Ltd.
This service is provided on Times Newspapers' standard Terms and Conditions. Please read our Privacy Policy.To inquire about a licence to reproduce material from Times Online, The Times or The Sunday Times, click here.This website is published by a member of the News International Group. News International Limited, 1 Virginia St, London E98 1XY, is the holding company for the News International group and is registered in England No 81701. VAT number GB 243 8054 69.
Mark, leeds, uk
You have a point there. Mr.Mugabe was awarded before by the West and now condemn as everything evil also by the West. Hate blinds and hate refuses to understand. Yes, why not speak to him? He is 84 and having ruled for 28 years he is wise and capable.
Lim , Johor Bahru, Malaysia
Mark, Leeds. UK
Mugabe is a hero for putting the welfare of blacks first? for some reason, I was thinking that the matabele were black . Remember those, yes the 20,000 of them massacred by the 5th brigade after Mugabe came to power, back in the 70s. I assume this is the "welfare" you mean?
John, Knutsford, UK
Roger Ndaba , St Albans, UK
Whether you are white or Zim. I agree with you. Sir Bob will still be in power. Mr.Morgan has failed. The MDC has failed and should be dissolved. A new Zim democratic party totally free from "western influence and support" maybe more
acceptable to all Zims.
2506
Lim , Johor Bahru, Malaysia
Robert Mugabe has continuously failed humanity and Africa. The inability of Southern Africa, outside of Zambia and Botswana to 'care for our brothers' - condemns us all as accessories to human shame.
Our South African role was correctly much maligned - there was a crisis in Zimbabwe !!
Nick, Sandton, South Africa
For anyone to say that Mugabe is misunderstood has not been reading the headlines. Mugabe has been forcibly clear on his intentions and beliefs.
Anyone who lives where even small towns have more than one supermarket filled with world foods can not understand the welfare of ordinary black Zimbabweans
Kevin, Lusaka, Zambia
Mark, Leeds....Thabo Mbeki has been trying to engage Mugabe for years and got nowhere. If he, a friend, cannot change Mugabe's ways then what hope have his opponents got? Mugabe inherited a working and functional country with agriculture and industry and has destroyed it completely. He should go.
David Ashton, Bathurst, Australia
Next week this time Sir Bob will still be in power, the reason - the utter ineptitude of Tsvangirai. It 's time the trade unionist admitted he is out of his depth. After ten years surely his "democratic" principles must compel him to acknowledge his failure and make way for somebodyelse.
Roger Ndaba , St Albans, UK
Comments on these forums shows alot of patronizing to africans. If people believe that all of africa is corrupt, ignorant and backward,it reflects the inbuilt racism and negativity which they have toward africa. Leave africa alone to sort it own problems.
jesee itotian, newcastle, uk
This man Mugabe, and his cronies, are uncomfortably reminiscent of another dictator in recent history, Sadam Husein and the Baath regime. It is truly sad that such inhumanity is rewarded with worldwide inaction. Enough is enough, remove him forcibly!
Michael, Norfolk, USA
Mugabe is misunderstood, why not engage him into dialogue, its the west who have isolated him. no matter how devil you might label him the man deserves credit on most of the things he did for the ordinary zimbabwean. you hate him for putting the welfare of blacks ahead of yours. mugabe is a hero
mark, leeds, uk
Why is Mugabe a target now while leaders like Meles Zenawi of Ethiopia the \buthcher of Addis who reigns over the death and starvation of millions of fellow human beings every year for the last twenty years? Or you are focusing on Mugabe now because you would not be able to grow your tobacoos ? Why?
Ewnetu, Winnepeg, Canada
Which world? You must be referring to the white world as Asia and Africa do not seem to share your perverted views. What is happening on Zimbabwe shows there is real danger ahead! Now I am beginning to think our foolish leaders embracing another colonial master in China might be right after all!
Ezhi Opfu, London, UK
Any plan thqat does not involve the rest of Africa is almost doomed to failure. Fortunately, the rest of Africa appears to be awakening slowly to the damage Mugabe (and perhaps more so Mbeki) are doing to Africa's image. Africa SHOULD sort this out, but a bit of carrot and stick would not go amiss.
David Ashton, Bathurst, Australia