Camilla Cavendish
Download 'Too Hot', an exclusive Specials track from iTunes
It's not insane to be paranoid. That is the comforting message I took from the speech given this week by Sir Ken Macdonald, the Director of Public Prosecutions, who warned the Government not to abuse its “enormous powers of access to information”. In a direct hit on the Home Secretary's desire to record on an Orwellian database every e-mail, phone call and website visited, he said that “freedom's back is broken” if ministers give in to the pressures of a State that is insatiable.
I say comforting, because I frequently feel that I am living in a looking-glass world, where what Sir Ken calls the “paraphernalia of paranoia” makes reality feel like a spoof. Take a parochial example. Several readers sent me an article from the Lincolnshire Echo that claimed Lincoln City Council was training its plumbers and electricians to spot child abuse. I contacted some nice people at the council last week, apologising for wasting their time on what, I said, was probably overexcited gossip. But it turned out to be true. These perfectly sane people are indeed training their 820 staff to “recognise when a child may be in a harmful situation”. They believe that the Children's Act 2004 requires all employees to “safeguard and promote the welfare of children and young people when discharging the council's functions, eg, throughout their daily work or work that has been subcontracted out”. Staff will be trained, and required to “report to relevant agencies” what they see.
So the bloke who used to fix your washing machine on the estate, who would surely have called the police if he had seen a starving and beaten child, will become a subcontractor “accredited” by the local Safeguarding Children's Board. He will report any child wearing long sleeves in summer (one sign of possible abuse that trainers teach people to look out for, in case the sleeves conceal a bruise).
What, you might ask, is wrong with that? In a world where, the NSPCC never misses the chance to tell us, children suffer and no adult can be trusted? What is wrong is that this kind of well-meaning, covering- our-back kind of exercise will generate “information”. On which someone will feel he or she must act. The “information” may stay on file despite all attempts by the innocent family to rub it out. Meanwhile, the piles of paper on the desks of harassed social workers will grow higher. And people who never asked to be social workers will have been co-opted as informants against the taxpayers who pay their salaries.
I was once an advocate of joined-up government, because I wanted efficiency. But too often joined-up government seems to mean joined-up fascism. In June, a select committee of MPs heard some astonishing evidence from respected campaign groups. One, Parents Against Injustice, gave instances where people whose children were being taken into care had not been allowed to challenge the allegations against them. The Association for Improvements in the Maternity Services (Aims), said that midwives were being turned into “health police”. Jean Robinson, of Aims, said that she had seen case after case where health visitors and midwives were not supporting postnatally depressed mothers but reporting them to police and social workers, whose interventions largely made things worse.
In my investigations into child protection I have repeatedly come across doctors and psychiatrists who are expected to report suspicions of child abuse to non-medical authorities. One result of this “information-sharing”, it seems to me, is that the age-old principle of patient confidentiality is routinely broken - without a murmur from the medical profession.
I recently went to meet Mrs Robinson, in Oxford. She is one of the sanest, most reasonable people you could meet. She has lectured on medical ethics and sat on the General Medical Council. Yet like Sir Ken Macdonald, she uses strong language. Because that is the only way accurately to describe a State that has lost its sense of proportion.
The problem is not the Government's desire to build up a picture, so much as how that picture can be distorted. I have spoken to a number of families who say that it has taken years to get papers that the local authority holds about them, despite freedom of information and Data Protection Act requests. Mrs Robinson says that she has “never had a single case where social services provided all the information that a parent was entitled to within the time limit”.
The bitter irony is that none of this makes anyone safer. The Government is building a Children's Database that will contain the personal details of every child. Apart from the vulnerabilities involved in giving so many bureaucrats access to that database, it will also make the haystack gigantic. The real needles will be even harder to find.
The same problems beset the terrorist issue. The Government has been unable to point to a single case where 42-day detention, or increased surveillance powers, would have made us safer. Police officers can already get information on most suspects' phone calls and e-mails from network providers. The suspicion is that the Government wants to hold that data centrally only to mount fishing expeditions, looking for patterns of behaviour.
“We should take very great care to imagine the world we are creating before we build it,” Sir Ken said. “We might end up living with something we can't bear.” Even if Jacqui Smith drops her plans to make Big Brother everyone's Facebook friend, we have built something unbearable: built-in suspicion of citizens by the people paid to serve them.
We must not allow the Britain that we know, built on centuries of freedom, to be whittled out of existence by the sharing of “information” that is created by the State, controlled by the State, and that turns perfectly decent people into informers. You think I'm paranoid. But maybe I'm sane, too.
Camilla Cavendish has been a McKinsey management consultant, an aid worker, and CEO of a not-for-profit company. She is now a leader writer and columnist on The Times
Win a luxury weekend to Newcastle and its neighbour Gateshead, find out more here
Risk, resilience and embracing new technology
Industry sectors news at a glance. Interactive heatmap, video and podcast
Discover the power of collective thinking. Submit a solution and be in with a chance to win a Media Hub Home Entertainment System
The inside track on current trends in the charity, not for profit and social enterprise sectors
Everything the Business Traveller needs to know to make a better trip
Make the most of the summer and enter our fabulous photographic competition, you could win a £5000 holiday
Corsica is an island of beauty and contrast, an ideal holiday destination
Enjoy further reading from Travel to Fashion, Business to Sport, discover more
Shortcuts to help you find sections and articles
The clever way to lease a new car is with Car leasing made simple™
2009
per month on 36-month
Personal Contract Hire (PCH)
2008
42850
Car Insurance
£24,250 - £30,346
MI5
London
£60,000
The Environment Agency
Bristol
Up to £90K
Boots
Midlands
OTE £85k
Credit Protection Association
Nationwide Opportunities
Completely London
Luxury Condo's in Manhattan with NYC views
The best new homes in Wimbledon?
Nationwide
Fabulous Cruise And Cruise & Stay Offers Including Virgin Atlantic Flights Prices Start From Only £699pp!
Last Minute Cruise And Cruise & Stay Offers. Med From £499pp, Caribbean From £699pp!
5 star quality at a 3 star price.
8 fabulous Canadian cities ...you won’t find cheaper
Contact our advertising team for advertising and sponsorship in Times Online, The Times and The Sunday Times, or place your advertisement.
Times Online Services: Dating | Jobs | Property Search | Used Cars | Holidays | Births, Marriages, Deaths | Subscriptions | E-paper
News International associated websites: Globrix Property Search | Property Finder | Milkround
Copyright 2009 Times Newspapers Ltd.
This service is provided on Times Newspapers' standard Terms and Conditions. Please read our Privacy Policy.To inquire about a licence to reproduce material from Times Online, The Times or The Sunday Times, click here.This website is published by a member of the News International Group. News International Limited, 1 Virginia St, London E98 1XY, is the holding company for the News International group and is registered in England No 81701. VAT number GB 243 8054 69.
To paraphrase Terry in Auckland, 'The nanny state and the "war on terror' are joining forces to destroy one thousand years of [formerly Great Britain.] Great article."
Another nail in the coffin.
Dennis, Portland OR, The American Colonies
The singling out of groups (as per nazis) has already begun. Smokers, (using a perfectly legal product) are now legitimately demonised. Drinkers and the overweight are not far behind. The fightback HAS begun with organisations such as forces.org and freedom to choose. Visit these sites for info.
A Lovell, Hereford, England
"Oh brave new world"
N.Smith, Hartfield, England
Try watching the movie Zeitgeist (www.zeitgeistmovie.com). Banks collapsing, Government takeovers - it really is coming true.
RW, Madrid, Spain
Agreed, this is an excellent piece. It is frightening what the "intellectualists" at the top will come up with when they start applying the neurolinguistic programming of Sudoku and Crosswords over society!
Worrying. You are not a person. You are owned...
S, ox, UK
Don't be fooled, Tom Paine. Although the French don't have as many CCTV cameras and their surveillance is quieter, they have other faults just as noxious such as corruption at the highest level, government and business run by the old school network and a crippling reliance on image.
Jenny, London, England
Your reference to George Orwell gave me the willies. 1984 is being realised. Big Brother. On the underground do not make eye contact. I have been made to feel paranoid about smiling at a child in the UK so sad. With all our problems back home in SA we still smile at people.
Gary Margot, Durban, South Africa
Nick from Bristol, are you refering to Tony Blair or Eric Arthur Blair?
Gary Margot, Durban, South Africa
So now you've pointed out the problem, what should we do? Go march outside parliament? Cant do that, it's against the law. Write to our MP, no point, they write back telling you where to stick your vote. What can we do?
Arthur, Newcastle,
You would never believe it!!!!!
Whilst reading post very interesting article I received an email at work from head office. Titled "NEW WHISTLE BLOWING POLICY" To cut the story short it encourages staff to grass up fellow colleagues. This plague is spreading a lot faster than you realise. AARGH!!!
Si, Surrey, uk
We know all this. What we want to know is - how to oppose it and make them stop. Voting does not seem to work. The databases/snitches are there so they can stop you before you can do anything they have to take notice of. I think I`ve just heard a knock at the door!!!!!
Jim, Herts,
This article is too late! We have already passed several scary laws.
We seem, as a nation, to be mildly concerned about ID cards for instance but I bet we'll blithely elect the party that introduces them and charges us for the invasion of our own privacy.
Violet, Gloucester,
I agree with most others that the state is becoming ever more intrusive and authoritarian, but how do we fight it? Where is the organised oppostion? If they start singling out groups or individuals for special treatment (as per Nazism), will we raise a murmur?
Ged , Paris,
An excellent piece. Having already introduced "Double Speak" and "Double Think", this is the final step to New Labour's 1984. The enquiries and "lessons learned" when a child "falls through the net" continue unabated. What happened to Blair's talk of "masters and servants" when they were elected?
Nick, Bristol, UK
Definitely the real danger of our times - and one that is not being addressed - at all.
Michael, Ankara, Turkey
When the winds howl, rains pour and the environmental chickens come home to roost with their economic sisters, the Island of Britain will be as a life raft to many nations across the channel. Mass surveillance will be a damned but necessary evil. Perhaps that's how paranoid we should be.
Rowg, London, UK
Having left the UK 3 years ago I look back with increasing horror at what is happening. The nanny state and the "war on terror" are joining forces to destroy one thousand years of history. Great article.
Terry Nolan, Auckland, New Zealand
The most dangerous issue of our time (alongside wars, terrorism and financial woes), yet I'll bet it won't figure at next election time as it lies, by definition, below the radar. What is more, the Tories probably espouse it (as does Europe) and won't do much to change it even if made to promise to
Nick, Athens,
One simple lesson from history is that things change when enough people take a stand. Labour couldn't get elected in the '80s so they infiltrated non-elected organisations. When they finally fooled enough people to get elected, they had us in a vice.
MarkChina, Beijing,
I think the phrase 'You're not paranoid if they really are watching you' ironically describes the governments behaviour.
Phil, Surrey, UK
such a true article. that old word from school "snitching " crops to mind so many times recently. if a country has a psychology then ours is currently paranoid with touches of OCD. in its pursuit of safety its making people obsess over things they would never think about and making everyone victims
James, London, UK
It is as though the government is introducing the instruments of totalitarianism via the back door. We are an ever-shorter step away from becoming a dictatorship, and the political apathy and social fragmentation of society is allowing this to happen, or am I too paranoid?
Ben Garside, Loughborough, UK
I recently watched a DVD film titled "Other Peoples lives" it's about the Stasi in East Germany,if you want to know where all of this surveilance is heading I suggest you watch it.Several Labour ministers had communist sympathies in their past life this film shows where it is coming from.
R.Rowan, Sandown, England
I think it can be summed up in a few words: Welcome to Napoleonic Law, guilty until proven innocent.
Thomas, Alicante, Spain
its the nu labour and the health stasi that is paranoid thinking that us once freemen of england are conspiring against them so have to be kept under the watchful eye of the nanny state its not terroists they should be worried about but the voters who have had enough and will VOTE EM OUT in 2010
brian rice, halifax, england
in our part of the world, which has seen most deadly encounters with terror, warnings that you are being watched, appeared on every road. The Orwellian dictum of Big Brother is watching you, seems to be said for our age, how true was he!
Manzoor, Peshawar, Pakistan
Of all the alarm bells to ring, the government's own chief prosecutor has turned into the champion of human rights. As for the LCC case, a database of suspicion and innuendo is the basis of all the secret policing in history.
You're right. It's not paranoia if they really are out to get you!
KR, Stockport,
It's funny how we constantly hear about the breakdown of society.
Benefit fraud hotline, people being paid to snitch on your expired tax disc, accountants to report suspicious activities of clients, a childrens database. SNITCH.
No wonder society is broken. People cant trust eachother anymore
Christophe Sir, london, UK
"The Government is building a Children's Database that will contain the personal details of every child"
Children become adults and after a few generations we are all controlled from cradle to grave.
Andrew, Cape Town,
One of the corrollories of this increasing information gathering is including public servants in the process, and those public servants are increasingly officious, stonewalling any reasonable discourse with the public that pays their wages; all on the basis that they have a "duty to act".
Franco, Blackburn,
Tom,
You very nearly got it right, We British are rapidly becoming suspects of the Crown.
Nigel Stanworth, Bingley, UK
We need to get together and show the clowns (government, "intelligence services"-an oxymoron if ever there was one) who delude themselves that they can do what they like that we can(drum roll) waste their time-a campaign of pointless phone calls and reporting ourselves. Watch the database collapse.
pete, wolverhampton, UK
The mathematicians will tell you that large databases inevitably contain many errors and that, the longer a database is maintained, the more corrupt it becomes. In the case of child abuse, most of the 'information' is unverifiable opinion and supposition, making things much worse.
Frank Upton, Solihull,
In the early days of the Nazi administration in Germany, the state gave to the police powers to enter and search any private premises or homes without a legal warrant. Its response to criticism was: 'if you have nothing to hide, you have nothing to fear'. Now, we hear the same from ministers here.
Bruce, Apt, France
Has anyone seen the "we are watching you" posters that are now on bus stops aimed at benefit fraudsters? They look alot like something out of 1984.
Ben Bower, Doncaster, UK
The End of Democracy. Only this time it's not an exaggeration. Western Europe and North America are in decline. Are we witnessing (in more ways than one) the ascent of Eastern and Southern Europe, China, South America, India. Perhaps demoracy and free speech will survive in these countries?
Roger Bingham, Bergen , Norway
If they really can afford to embark on such a wasteful project (this is government IT, remember), then the Treasury can afford to send in the dogs and relieve the department of a swollen purse.
Ought to help pay for the odd bank or two.
D Murphy, Skipton,
If you have nothing to hide, you have nothing to fear. Oh yeah, you have even more to fear than most. Databases contain at least 10% inaccuracies, you are on 10 or more databases. There is no mechanism to check and definitely no mechanism to correct inaccuracies.
Mike Sedgwick, Eastleigh, UK
I America we have Democrats speaking out against the phone companies "sharing" imformation with the government. Yet they vote in favor of it. Governments are acting to protect themselves from the people they are supposed to be representing.
Something is afoot in the World!
michael horning, sant fe, USA
just remember east germany. they had an organisation called the STASI. it collected info on everything and everybody was an informer. it bankrupted the state and destroyed trust and privacy. why can't we learn from history?
Ian, Brisbane,
Are these powers that government and government agencies have taken upon themselves to enforce resulting in the breaching of privacy laws.
If they are not , are the existing privacy laws adequate?
Tony Atkins, Cairns, Australia
Excellent article, no adult can be trusted should = no man can be trusted. Demonisation of men = minimal man boy relationships = more teacher assaults, police in schools, young people stabbed on a regular basis, unhappiest kids in Europe. More articles needed to break this a dangerous mindset.
Brian Hill, Edinburgh,
Relationships between parents and school / health professionals only work when the information shared isn't stored on an insecure database and shared with 330,000 civil servants and child protection professionals. You think I'm going to take a kid who's just fallen downstairs to casualty? No way!
Michael, Liverpool,
Camilla, you are one of the sanest people on the planet and wide awake too.
It is the poor sheep, who need to wake up to reality.
Lilith Barrett, London, UK
The French are citizens. We British are subjects of the Crown.
Vive la Republique!
Tom Paine, Huddersfield, UK