Giles Coren
Download 'Too Hot', an exclusive Specials track from iTunes
Leafing through The Guardian this week, I have been gripped by extracts from a new book by Polly Toynbee and David Walker, Unjust Rewards, in which the two Guardian stalwarts interview loads of rich people and discover that... they're not very nice.
Who would have thought? It's lucky we have The Guardian to get to the nub of things for us with its unique blend of snobbery, bitterness, jealousy and thwarted ambition, cobbled together with the tawdry and risible clichés its readers have thrilled to for years.
Dave and Polly begin with a trip to the 20th floor of Canary Wharf, only to find it “marbled”. Is it really, Dave? Is it, Polly? Or do you just need to write “marbled” to ram home your clunky, 1970s them-and-us dichotomy? Because two sentences later the same exact spot is suddenly “a gilded new town in the sky”. Ooh, gilded and marbled. How rich these people must be.
Polly and Dave chat for a while to some bankers and lawyers (hawk, spit) and discover that the fiends “utterly misjudged the magnitude of their privilege” and “put themselves inside a golden enclave”. Marbled, gilded, and golden. Dave and Polly are good. They should do bathrooms.
“They could scarcely deny they had money,” write Dave and Polly, as if any decent human being would. And then they tell us that they, Dave and Polly, are not so much angry as disappointed: “What we had hoped for was more awareness, some recognition that their position needed explaining and even justification.” You really hoped for that, Polly? Really, Dave? Then you're even stupider than you come across on paper.
And they get stupider. And more bitter. And more teacherly and smug. “As a group [the rich people] were less intelligent,” they crow, “less intellectually inquisitive, less knowledgeable and, despite their good schools, less broadly educated than high-flyers in other professions.” But we knew that. City lawyers and bankers have always been thick. They work inhuman hours at pointless jobs for their capitalist slave-masters and die young without really knowing their wives, their children or themselves. It's a horrible life. And they are given a lot of money to make up for it. What are you telling us, Polly? That they'd be happier living naked on a heath and eating dormice? We know that. They know that. Nobody cares. Shut up.
And then Dave and Polly write: “Their high salaries were not a sign of any obvious superiority.” Well, hell, guys, did you expect them to be? You're meant to be socialists. You really went grovelling in there, tugging your forelocks and expecting these people, on the basis of their wealth, to be in some way good or interesting? How stupid can you be? Your ideas are so thin and your politics so hackneyed and hamstrung by prejudice that you actually made me sympathise with the very rich. And I never thought anyone would be able to do that.
The next day, in my favourite paper's always-gripping education section (“Down wiv' Eton!”), there was another extract from the book, in which Dave and Polly had joined some state school kids from Brent on a trip to Oxford (I bet the kids were delighted).
The clichés here were more delicious still. Not only did the word “spires” appear twice in the same short extract, but the lawns, bless them, were “manicured”. Except they're not, Polly. They're just mown. Same as everywhere else. You don't have to be rich, or posh, or evil to mow the bloody lawn. They mow the lawn on council estates too. It's you, Polly, and you, Dave, who are trying to present Britain as a cartoonish, divided society to suit your own arrogant, dim-witted, outdated Weltanschauung.
Dave and Polly take the kids to St John's, which (no coincidence, I'm sure) is Oxford's richest college by some way: “Here was a room of their own, with their own bathroom, use of a kitchen...” Their own bathroom? I very much doubt it, even at St John's. Certainly not at Keble, next door to St John's, where I was a student. Six or eight to a bathroom at best (not all at the same time, alas). Get some perspective.
Despite Dave and Polly's best doom-mongering efforts, the kids on the trip show great enthusiasm for going to Oxford. So Dave and Polly leap in: “Did the Brent students know that over half the students at Oxford and Cambridge come from private schools? They had no idea and it shocked them.” Yeah, that's right, Polly, you step in and piddle on their dreams, why don't you. Tell them they've got no chance. It's your way, after all. (Furthermore, that statistic is another gross exaggeration as a correction in The Guardian admitted yesterday.)
It's not Oxford itself that holds back kids like this, it's sour old Trots like Toynbee.
Polly and Dave go on to contrast, with toe-curling naivety, the “kindly earnestness and bright whiteness” of the Oxford students with “the mostly black Brent kids in urban fashions with sharply razored, sculpted and combed hairstyles”, the prose dripping with that familiar and uniquely Guardian fetishising of black youth that seems to drip with middle-aged female lust for the noble savage. It's positively Victorian.
“Here on display,” wrote Dave and Polly, “was the great fissure in class, race, style, attitude, background...” No, here were children. The fissure is in your minds. In your sad, tawdry imaginations. Part of a world you need to believe in to believe you have any value left as
commentators.
“The Brent students will likely find themselves in a rust-stained concrete former polytechnic not far from home...” write Dave and Polly in tear-stained conclusion. More clichés, more fatalism. But how dare she/he condemn them like that to their doom? And how dare she/he stigmatise former polytechnics in that way? Rust-stained, for God's sake. How can these new universities hope to attract decent students, and be taken seriously in the academic world, if the bien-pensant dimwits of The Guardian opinion pages are so quick to dismiss them?

Staying with education, I see that primary schools will be weighing children and informing their parents of the results, but they will not be allowed to use the medical term “obese”, because it might cause offence. This is excellent news because the forbidding of words and the compulsion to euphemism leads to so much more ingenious ways of writing what you mean:
“Dear Mr and Mrs Wisbeech, your son, Arnold, has been weighed in the balance... and broke it.”
“Dear Mr and Mrs Funt, your daughter, Ellie, has not been weighed today, as planned, because when she took off her dress prior to mounting the scales the doctor laughed so hard he had an embolism.”
“Dear Mr Jarse, your son, Hugh, was weighed today. We are not saying he is fat, we are just saying that from next term we will be charging fees for both of him.”
“Dear Mrs Hunt, your son, Eric, was weighed today and the school doctor will be writing to you with the results just as soon as he can break free of Eric's gravitational pull.”
“Dear Mrs Hunt, your other son, Warwick, was also weighed. Tell you what, if you can guess his weight to the nearest stone, we'll forget about all those broken chairs.”
Giles Coren has been a columnist for The Times since 1999. He began as a feature writer before becoming restaurant critic in 2001. His reviews appear in The Times Magazine on Saturdays
Win a luxury weekend to Newcastle and its neighbour Gateshead, find out more here
Risk, resilience and embracing new technology
Industry sectors news at a glance. Interactive heatmap, video and podcast
Discover the power of collective thinking. Submit a solution and be in with a chance to win a Media Hub Home Entertainment System
The inside track on current trends in the charity, not for profit and social enterprise sectors
Everything the Business Traveller needs to know to make a better trip
Make the most of the summer and enter our fabulous photographic competition, you could win a £5000 holiday
Corsica is an island of beauty and contrast, an ideal holiday destination
Enjoy further reading from Travel to Fashion, Business to Sport, discover more
Shortcuts to help you find sections and articles
The clever way to lease a new car is with Car leasing made simple™
2009
per month on 36-month
Personal Contract Hire (PCH)
2008
42850
Car Insurance
£24,250 - £30,346
MI5
London
£60,000
The Environment Agency
Bristol
Up to £90K
Boots
Midlands
OTE £85k
Credit Protection Association
Nationwide Opportunities
Completely London
Luxury Condo's in Manhattan with NYC views
The best new homes in Wimbledon?
Nationwide
Fabulous Cruise And Cruise & Stay Offers Including Virgin Atlantic Flights Prices Start From Only £699pp!
Last Minute Cruise And Cruise & Stay Offers. Med From £499pp, Caribbean From £699pp!
5 star quality at a 3 star price.
8 fabulous Canadian cities ...you won’t find cheaper
Contact our advertising team for advertising and sponsorship in Times Online, The Times and The Sunday Times, or place your advertisement.
Times Online Services: Dating | Jobs | Property Search | Used Cars | Holidays | Births, Marriages, Deaths | Subscriptions | E-paper
News International associated websites: Globrix Property Search | Property Finder | Milkround
Copyright 2009 Times Newspapers Ltd.
This service is provided on Times Newspapers' standard Terms and Conditions. Please read our Privacy Policy.To inquire about a licence to reproduce material from Times Online, The Times or The Sunday Times, click here.This website is published by a member of the News International Group. News International Limited, 1 Virginia St, London E98 1XY, is the holding company for the News International group and is registered in England No 81701. VAT number GB 243 8054 69.
Wasted on food alone! More comment from Coren please.
Rufus, Putney, London
Perhaps instead of ranting and raving at someone you obviously have an irrational hatred for, you could do some research. St John's (and even Keble) offers ensuite accomodation for those that can afford it. And complaining of the use of the word "manicured"? Unnecessary ad-hominem attacks.
Nick S, Crowborough, UK
Fantastic article!
Ben, kings Lynn, uk
Mr Coren. I am a City Banker, and unlike the moany solicitors, of which there are too many, I thought this was hilarious. Good work.
J, Edinburgh,
Mr Coren, I resent you claiming lawyers and bankers are equally rich and unpleasant. I am a City solicitor, and earn a fraction of what bankers earn which does, I believe, result in me being marginally less obnoxious. Apart from that, wonderful article.
Thomas, London,
Mr Coren, I am a City solicitor and actually was oblivious to the fact that I would be happier living naked on a heath eating dormice. I must try that this Saturday.
Anna Hill, London,
You express a view just as entrenched as those you seek to criticise, especially when read in the context of a column suggesting the privately educated skip university to give the oiks a chance to catch up. Both of them are cloaked in a weird anger. Continued good luck with the restaurant reviewing.
Beth, London,
Finally an article that is music to my ears ... haaa, I think I'll read it again.
I feel that the point being highlighted throughout was one based on simple jealousy, spite, arrogant fact-lite approach on society. In fact it appears that Toynbee and her friends are the ones disempowering people.
Hardeep Singh, Farnham Common, UK
Giles, you are completely delicious! Your series with Sue P was a delight and your constant rants on any given subject are delectable. It's a pity you don't have an online blog (? do you), where I could just tap in to your witty and engaging take on the world and just listen whenever!
Elizabeth Portman-Lewis, Hereford, UK
Haha i do think Polly Toynbee is slightly biased to loathe private schools. You would have thought the bitterness of failing her 11 plus would have subsided slightly by now...
Vicky, Dorchester,
I would be more inclined to take notice of Toynbee and her ilk if they were to sell their possessions and give the money to the deserving poor rather than merely earning enormous salaries writing this risible cant.
Betty Stringer, Bungay, England
Oxford colleges have to include ensuite bathrooms in any new builds as they are now unable to secure conference bookings without them. Many colleges rely heavily on the profits they make from these conferences.
a, London,
Some time ago I wrote to you to call you something rude when you wrote a very disparaging piece about the Yang Sing in Manchester. I would now like to apologise, anyone who can write a piece that scathing about Polly Toynbee cannot possibly be what I called you. Apologies. Loved the article.
Vikki Watmough, Manchester, UK
Excellent piece.
By the way, Keble does indeed have ensuite bathrooms these days - even in the original buildings. As someone else said, better for the conference trade.
JD, Rushden, UK
For what it's worth, I entirely forgive you for the email to the subs on the basis of this brilliant piece of satire.
Oscar India, London, UK
If you'd like to see Ms. Toynbee described somewhat more earthily than in Giles' piece, visit The Devil's Kitchen blog. Oh, and check out the archive stuff, too.
JD Talwin, Preston,
Absolute genius !
Thank you Mr Coren !
A Matache, Cambridge,
The Guardianistas saw what they wanted to see. The truth is that the City - for better or worse - has generated enormous wealtth and paid its taxes to the Labour government. The result is rust stained former polytechnics. Just one reason why the nation is utterly sick of this government.
John, Bangkok, Thailand
The lawns may be manicured in Polly Toynbee land, but facts are conveniently disregarded in yours. Most Oxford colleges have some en-suite rooms these days; I had my own bathroom in my 2nd year at St. Hilda's, and friends at Merton, Worcester & St. Anne's spent at least one year in an ensuite room!
Heather Ryan, Liverpool, UK
"Marbled, gilded, and golden. Dave and Polly are good. They should do bathrooms."
Thank you for the smile Mr. Coren!
Andrew, Wales, United Kingdon
Couldn't agree more. I'm from a working class family and hope to study at Cambridge, and the universities themselves do nothing to stop state school pupils applying, it's often people in the media and teachers in state schools that come up with these silly 'facts' in an attempt to discourage you
Natalie Marshall, Sheffield, England
I wonder if Polly has ever thought of doing stand-up comedy.
Keith, Grantham,
you left out quaffing instead of drinking their wine. oh and also I never heard chinless wonders mentioned once,
Eddy, Bury St.Edmunds,
Mr. Robertson, it is not silence that Britain needs from the left. You must defeat them in elections for half a century.
George Steiner, Lachine,
Bridge of Sighs indeed. What a pity the lovely photo (in the print version) to this otherwise spot-on article shows St John's Cambridge, rather than the Oxford college of the same name referred to in the piece. But then again, John's Cambs is the infinitely the prettier ....
David Miller, Kilmacolm,
"Polly Toynbee is a joke, always has been. I never read anything she writes - Chris Wood, Camberley"
Then whether you're right or wrong, you're not really entitled to an opinion then are you?
Homer, London,
APU?
I "Googled " but am still non the wiser.
David Tomlinson, Poole, United Kingdom
Absolutely excellent piece. First-class denunciation of the damage caused by such supposedly well-meaning and concerned members of the liberal cognoscenti as Toynbee. I speak as someone from a working-class family and an industrial part of Birmingham who won a place to study at St John's,Oxford.
T.A.Bennett, Birmingham,
There's a bigger picture here. The Left must begin to realise that their ideologies produced the catastrophes of the sad twentieth century from National Socialism to all the other sorts. The Left bears a terrible burden of responsibility. It's time that we started to experience a period of silence
robertson, southampton, uk
Excellent article re Toynbee et al, punchy and honest. Could not agree more about their self defeating approach. Did not think GC had this in him. More please.
Neil Anderson, Bridgetown, Barbados
Wonderful stuff, Giles Coren (on Toynbee and Walker). You are brilliant! You made my day with this article.
Ruth Scott, Abingdon, UK
As a graduate of a one of the rusting ex polys I would like to say it is neither rusting, or out dated but an excellent educational establishment with en suit rooms! I am proud to say I graduated from APU. My father is a Fellow at Cambridge and holds APU in VERY hight esteem. Take that Toynbee!
Matilda Moore, Norwich, England
What type floor tiles does Polly have in her second home in Tuscany?
kevin atkinson, London,
Coren on Toynbee and Walker...Hooray!!!! I read a Guardian once and am still in recovery. This helps. More please. Not that more are needed, but, how about, "Mrs. Ramsbotham, We need to discuss your son's weight; pull up a couple of chairs and sit down."
J.F. Jackson, Banbury, United Kingdom
Polly Toynbee is a joke, always has been. I never read anything she writes and cannot understand why anybody does, unless, of course they are Guardianistas, who need somebody to confirm their prejudices.c
Chris Wood, Camberley, UK
I have only read Giles's restaurant reviews before and found his column intelligent and humorous. But i was surprised he didn't use the classic example of Mr and Mrs Meoff and their son Jack. Keep up the good work.
Mitchell Wilkinson, london, England
Excellent article, and inspired names of children...
John Ball, Norwich, UK
Wonderful stuff. Toynbee has hypocrisy written into her DNA. Still, with you and Littlejohn taking the mick it does provide a bit of fun now and again.
john miller, london,
Poly Toynbee is a perfect example of the Miss Havisham syndrome. Deep in self-delusion and denial.
Given her own posh lifestyle, we should perhaps add a little of the Uriah Heep syndrome to get the full rounded portrait of this poor woman?
Bill, Suzhou, China
My dad was a newsagent, I went to state school, I'm Asian, I work in the city and I earn loads of money. I do it so my parents and future children can have something close to the only kind of life Toynbee has ever known. Me explain my position? How about she explains her right to speak for the poor?
Raj Chande, London, United Kingdom
I love Giles Coren.
By the way, en suite rooms really do exist in several Oxford colleges. Easier to flog conference facilities during the vacations, for one thing. Also nice for the students (including former wards of state education).
But fancy having "the use of a kitchen"! Heavens to Polly.
John Allen, Oxford, UK
"No, here were children."
Giles Coren, I love you. Thanks for reminding me why I stopped even picking up somebody else's Guardian.
Amy Allen, London,
Polly Toynbee is Mrs Dutt Pauker from Peter Simple: she is a privately educated middle class woman who lives in a two million pound house on Hampstead with a second home in Italy ... give me a break!
Fred Smith, Scunthorpe, UK