Yasmin Hai
Win VIP tickets
When my friend Nazia started flirting with Islam, I felt betrayed. Over the years, we had been clubbing together and got up to all sorts of mischief. Now she was abandoning me.
I wasn’t bothered that she’d started praying five times a day or by her obsessive consultation of the Koran. But when she started denigrating western culture, I felt that she’d betrayed me, herself and our entire Asian community.
I’d grown up in suburban Wembley in a strongly Asian area. My father, who had come to Britain from Pakistan as a political refugee in 1964, was ambitious for his family. So he encouraged my younger brother and sister and me to adopt the ways of the English.
We were banned, for example, from speaking Urdu to our mother: she could speak to us in our mother tongue, but we had to answer in English. Nor were we encouraged to practise Islam. In fact, my father bought me The Book of Common Prayer so I wouldn’t feel excluded during school assemblies.
Most of my friends were brought up in similar culturally ambiguous households. So when my friend Nazia started using racist terminology, stereotyping white people as cultureless drunks who don’t know how to look after their children, I was furious.
We had both gone to university; but while I flourished at Manchester and threw myself into the club scene, she was finding the normal excesses of university life unsettling. It was then that she started to feel that she would never be able to participate fully in English life. After graduating, she agreed to an arranged marriage - her way of reconnecting with the Asian community. But when the marriage failed, the community ostracised her.
This rejection was devastating. At that point, she started to take an interest in the more politicised version of Islam that had begun to filter through in the early 1990s.
Becoming a strict Muslim was her way of exacting revenge on the community that had deserted her when she needed it most.
She wasn’t the only one I knew to take that path. For so many of my Asian friends, radical Islam was not so much a matter of being anti-West as a way of wresting back some form of identity. In the early 1990s many of them had thrown themselves into the club and drug scene. Most, though, eventually started to suffer from a creeping form of cultural guilt.
Becoming a committed Muslim was a way of being born again, of wiping the slate clean. You could use your new identity to define yourself against the western way of life - and against your parents.
As many of us weren’t fluent in our mother tongue, and often discouraged from talking about our problems, we hadn’t ever had a meaningful dialogue with our parents. My own relationship with my mother suffered immeasurably as a result of this.
What it also meant was that my friends’ parents didn’t see the dangers when their westernised children started listening to the new radicalised imams who talked thrillingly about western excesses such as drugs, alcoholism and sexual promiscuity.
Most, in fact, were merely relieved that their child hadn’t gone off the rails. The truth is, most of my parents’ generation wouldn’t recognise a radical if he were standing in the front room with them - purely because they have not had the same cultural experience as their children.
At the heart of the disillusionment that many of my friends felt was not knowing how they fitted into British society. I wasn’t immune, either. At 19, I found myself becoming increasingly drawn to Islam. I was struck, when I visited Pakistan, by the confidence of the people, who seemed comfortable in their own skins in a way that my friends and I were not.
Here, the chasm that now exists between Asian generations has created a generation of vulnerable young people seeking direction and a sense of belonging. And that makes them more likely to turn to a fundamentalist ideology that professes to offer answers.
In my own case, I can date the start of my confusion back to the death of my father when I was 17. Suddenly, my traditionally Asian mother was alone, barely able to communicate with the children she found it hard to recognise as her own. Many of my friends’ fathers died at about the same time, either from heart disease or diabetes - two of the biggest killers of Asian men - leaving behind a whole community of mothers who didn’t understand their children.
We would discuss our feeling of emptiness. Some started going to religious meetings and found that “modern” Islam was helping them to make some sense of their lives. In my case, I started wearing traditional Asian clothes for the first time in my life.
Of my 10 closest Asian friends, half of them became born-again Muslims. However, for most of us, this focus on the new Islam was only a passing phase.
Those who are still committed Islamic radicals are now keeping their own children segregated from the mainstream. I wonder how they will react, in turn, when they grow up, living in the shadow of 9/11, only knowing an England where they’re a frightening “other”.
In my own case, I realised eventually that I didn’t have to force my life into a narrative that had been imposed on it by either British - or radical Islamic - conventional wisdoms. There was nothing wrong with being me.
Yasmin Hai, who was talking to Jessica Jonzen, is the author of The Making of Mr Hai’s Daughter, published by Virago at £14.99
Win a luxury weekend to Newcastle and its neighbour Gateshead, find out more here
Risk, resilience and embracing new technology
Industry sectors news at a glance. Interactive heatmap, video and podcast
Discover the power of collective thinking. Submit a solution and be in with a chance to win a Media Hub Home Entertainment System
The inside track on current trends in the charity, not for profit and social enterprise sectors
Everything the Business Traveller needs to know to make a better trip
Make the most of the summer and enter our fabulous photographic competition, you could win a £5000 holiday
Corsica is an island of beauty and contrast, an ideal holiday destination
Enjoy further reading from Travel to Fashion, Business to Sport, discover more
Shortcuts to help you find sections and articles
The clever way to lease a new car is with Car leasing made simple™
2009
per month on 36-month
Personal Contract Hire (PCH)
2008
42850
Car Insurance
£23,093 - £56,211
The Office for National Statistics
Newport, South Wales
£60,000
The Environment Agency
Bristol
Up to £90K
Boots
Midlands
OTE £85k
Credit Protection Association
Nationwide Opportunities
Completely London
Luxury Condo's in Manhattan with NYC views
The best new homes in Wimbledon?
Nationwide
Fabulous Cruise And Cruise & Stay Offers Including Virgin Atlantic Flights Prices Start From Only £699pp!
Last Minute Cruise And Cruise & Stay Offers. Med From £499pp, Caribbean From £699pp!
5 star quality at a 3 star price.
8 fabulous Canadian cities ...you won’t find cheaper
Contact our advertising team for advertising and sponsorship in Times Online, The Times and The Sunday Times, or place your advertisement.
Times Online Services: Dating | Jobs | Property Search | Used Cars | Holidays | Births, Marriages, Deaths | Subscriptions | E-paper
News International associated websites: Globrix Property Search | Property Finder | Milkround
Copyright 2009 Times Newspapers Ltd.
This service is provided on Times Newspapers' standard Terms and Conditions. Please read our Privacy Policy.To inquire about a licence to reproduce material from Times Online, The Times or The Sunday Times, click here.This website is published by a member of the News International Group. News International Limited, 1 Virginia St, London E98 1XY, is the holding company for the News International group and is registered in England No 81701. VAT number GB 243 8054 69.
M. Sayeed from Halifax might get a shock were he to actually try life in a Muslim majority country. A tour of the Raki houses in Istanbul might show him as much degradation as the club scene in the UK. And his display of virtue might not help him in Eastern Iran, where to be muslim is mandatory.
Dectora, London, UK
Very perceptive article. Much more in depth than Yasmin Alibhai Brown crudely offering racism as a key to the 8 young muslim men on trial for terrorism.
This looks at the complexities which IS life. At alienation and cultural differences on several levels. Inter-generational (which exist in many societies), loaded onto parental language and cultural barriers and the stark isolation that brings. On top of that mothers being left stranded and widows in middle age through patterns of ill health.
There are no worthwhile short-cuts to self identity. Racism exists as a bad thing in some cultures in one form or another. Social exclusion exists in many countries too. Certainly in the subcontinent you can be held back and excluded from opportunity on several levels of social acceptability due to caste, status, power, financial clout and other divisive taboos. Each society practices its own form of social exclusion. Finding a way through yr life is always going to be hard graft
JT
Jenna, Oxford, UK
So just because your friend chose a different path to you it makes your choice a superior one to hers? Obviously, anyone anywhere at all who chooses to base their values on Islam is automatically making the wrong choice, right? Maybe your friend turned her back on the things your hold as valuable, and you think this reflects badly on you, so you react by denegrading her choice? The tone of your book, and writings, is to say that there is no place for people who base their life on Islamic values here in the UK. Aspects of western life that a Muslim living in the UK might find none too edifying are pretty much the same as those that are perplexing the minds of many a western thinker - over sexed club scene, ASBO, youth violence, drink culture, breakdown of families, respect for elders, general lack of mutual and self respect. I guess the difference is that a Muslim in the west might tend to see individual problems as symptomatic of a wider value system - pretty much the same as westerne
M Saeed, Halifax, W Yorks
I respect your views they are by no means representative of all practising Muslims in the country.
My mother is born and bought up in Britain (her parents are Pakistani) and my dad was born and bred in Pakistan - I had no problems communicating with either one of my parents and they are both alive today.
My parents never emphasised religion however overall we did have values which were more traditionally inclined.
About 2 years ago I became a practising Muslim because after much study into it I found that it was the way of life for me.
I feel very Scottish AND I feel a strong sense of being Muslim and a part of the Ummah.
These are NOT mutually exclusive and I believe both go hand in hand very well.
I'm currently still at university studying a professional degree and have NEVER gone into excesses either way.
The point I am trying to make is that it is possible to HAVE and LOVE both - your country and Islam.
B, Glasgow, Scotland
"At the heart of the disillusionment that many of my friends felt was not knowing how they fitted into British society. I wasnât immune, either. At 19, I found myself becoming increasingly drawn to Islam. I was struck, when I visited Pakistan, by the confidence of the people, who seemed comfortable in their own skins in a way that my friends and I were not."
Perhaps you and your friends would be happier living permanently in Pakistan?
JB, Saskatoon, Canada
Good article. When i came to GB in 60s, I wanted to learn the British ways. Slowly, I came to the conclusion that religion is not important in one's life. My grown up son has no faith and I am not unhappy about it. We want to live in the west, nobody wants to live in Islamic countries, even those preaching radical Islam. Most cannot mix with host communities, because of halal food not offered. You invite a non Muslim, offer him halal food and when you go visit him expect that he cooks also halal. So you see, we want the others to conform to us; we do not or cannot change our ways.
SharifL, nidder, Germany
I recommend Eckhart Tolle The Power of Now and A New Earth as the answer for all regardless of our origins to gain, regain a sense of self and purpose.
Larry Watson, Kingswood, UK
This is what the British people have known for 40yrs. The Irish are renown for singing about being away from home (even when they are still in Ireland !!).
In small numbers cultures can be absorbed and individuals can be "integrated" (my mum's Irish but since we didn't grow up in an Irish ghetto I'm English - I support england in an anglo/irish footy match!) but en masse it's a different story. Enoch Powell said exactly that but he was castigated.
Multiculturalism has been a disaster as it's the opposite of the above
The only answer is to reduce the numbers.
john, manchester, UK
As I suspected, the heart of this darkness is with imported imams - the government has been craven in failing to vet and filter these fanatical hate mongers; they have preyed on ordinary Muslim families.
Fati, Dalston, London
What do you recommend White Britons do to compensate for their alienation in this awful society ?
Bradford, Bradford, England
Doesn't this underline the fact that immigration is a cultural as well as an economic phenomenon - something which applies to the host community as well as the immigrant one? And that the cultural aspects of immigration should be at least taken into the equation before arguing that large scale immigration is an unmittigated good?
Anne, London,
this rings true with my experience. I am from the middle east and I definitley found the arabs who grew up in the US or UK tend to be more religious or traditional than me and my friends who actually grew up in the middle east in arabic schools in cairo, beirut, jeddah or kuwait. There is something about needing to belong in a society that is so different from your own heritage that makes a person more ademant and protective of their own culture. It's the need for a sense of identity. In fact I found myself avoiding some of the arabs here in the US becuase I found them to be too traditional, even though being far away from home and speaking the same language would have made my life easier! it's all very strange.
Samia, washington,
Well written article!
Tung, Heidelberg, Germany