Alan Milburn
Download 'Too Hot', an exclusive Specials track from iTunes
These are tough times for Labour. The local election results and the opinion polls tell a depressing story. The Crewe by-election defeat cannot be dismissed as normal mid-term blues. Nor can it be laid at the door of the local campaign. It is more fundamental than that. Voters are walking away from us because they fear we have failed to keep pace with them.
It is not just that the credit crunch, falling house values and rising prices are hitting hard-working families in their pockets. Or that a series of self-inflicted wounds – most damagingly over the 10p rate of tax – have taken the initiative from Labour and handed it to the Tories. After 11 years in office, time takes its toll. The issue now is whether we are prepared to capture the mood for change in the country or simply cede it to the Conservatives.
Fatalism about the inevitability of a Conservative government would be misplaced. Despite the thumping Labour took in Crewe I do not detect that voters are comfortable about placing their trust in David Cameron to govern the country. He and his party are policy-light and a long way from being ready for government.
We have a fight on our hands if we are to prevail at the next election but it is a battle we can – and must – win. I am not one of those siren voices who say that a spell in opposition would do Labour good. I remember being in opposition – and I didn’t like it. More important, nor did the people who paid the price in unemployment, recession and underfunded public services.
To win, Labour has to heed the lessons of the past year and be clear where it stands. To begin with we should show far more confidence in promoting our record. Those in Labour’s ranks who want to create distance from what we have achieved are misguided.
Adopting a new Labour approach has not just delivered unprecedented electoral success – a record three consecutive terms – but it has changed Britain for the better. What we have achieved in reducing poverty, improving services, increasing jobs and extending people’s rights is something to be proud of. If we don’t defend new Labour’s record, nobody will. New Labour won by being the party that is both against poverty and for aspiration. We introduced a national minimum wage and a windfall tax on the profits of the privatised utilities while reforming public services and cutting corporation taxes.
Now, as we heighten our drive against poverty, we must avoid giving the impression that we are no longer bothered about aspiration. Modern progressive politics means building coalitions of support that cross class and geographical boundaries. Those who seek to make it a choice of winning back either our “core” support or our “aspirational” voters are doing Labour a disservice. Victory at elections means winning both to our cause. In any case, the so-called “core” voter is often the most sharply aspirational.
There is much that the government is doing in this direction. Being told the government is on your side, however, is not enough to convince people we are. Mass migration and globalisation are increasing uncertainty. For many, community identities seem at risk. Life feels tough. People are demanding action and they are looking for clarity, but for all the blizzard of initiatives that emanate from Whitehall, Labour has yet to develop a coherent postBlair agenda.
I believe that agenda should be based on the notion of giving people greater control over their lives and a fairer share in power. The draft Queen’s speech published by Gordon Brown last month hints at this idea but it is not yet drilled through the whole gamut of government policy like a stick of rock. Tentative change will not get Labour heard. It is big, bold reforms that are now needed.
Taxes should be cut, especially for the low-paid. We should sharpen the drive to get many more people off benefit and dramatically improve help for first-time buyers to get onto the housing ladder.
Efforts to prevent and deter antisocial behaviour should be reinvigorated with a bigger role for restorative justice and community courts. Tough but fair rules should be put in place on immigration and housing and welfare allocations. Parents as well as patients should be given choice over services. People who have long-term health needs and those requiring help in old age or with childcare should be offered their own budgets so they can make the choices that are right for them. Local services, such as the police and NHS, should be directly elected. And local communities should be positively helped to run local schools, housing estates and childcare centres.
These policy priorities go well beyond the new Labour agenda of 1997. They go with the spirit of the times. In a more insecure world, where citizens are more informed, people want to exercise far greater power both in their own right and in their communities.
This is the zeitgeist. It is about empowering citizens and communities so they can realise their own aspirations to progress. It contains a redefined relationship between state and citizen in which government controls less but empowers more. Its tone is one of optimism at a time when pessimism is all too pervasive.
Empowerment can be the key that unlocks greater equity. What has changed is that Cameron wants to take that ground for the Tories. We should have the courage to take it ourselves.
In other words, we have to make the battleground for the next election more than just a fight over which party has the best credentials on the economy. Naturally, government has to take action where it can, but the economic problems Britain faces are largely global so there are risks in promising we can fix them all. In any case, the mantra of economic stability does not give us momentum.
A third-term government looking for a fourth term has to prove to people not just that it can stabilise things but that it can change them. We have to prove we have wind in our sails and a big agenda.
The willingness to change is what has made new Labour so dominant in British politics and forced even our most strident opponents into contemplating changes they once thought abhorrent. After a decade in office, the question we now have to be able to answer is: what next?
If we can do so over the next two years, victory will be achievable. However, time is pressing. Short-term policy fixes are no substitute for long-term strategic purpose.
There will always be events that buffet governments, but leadership is about steering a consistent course and being clear about both the direction of travel and the point of destination. We all have a responsibility to learn the lessons of the message voters have sent us over the past few months. They are signalling their preparedness to move on. It is time for us to catch up.
Win a luxury weekend to Newcastle and its neighbour Gateshead, find out more here
Risk, resilience and embracing new technology
Industry sectors news at a glance. Interactive heatmap, video and podcast
Discover the power of collective thinking. Submit a solution and be in with a chance to win a Media Hub Home Entertainment System
The inside track on current trends in the charity, not for profit and social enterprise sectors
Everything the Business Traveller needs to know to make a better trip
Make the most of the summer and enter our fabulous photographic competition, you could win a £5000 holiday
Corsica is an island of beauty and contrast, an ideal holiday destination
Enjoy further reading from Travel to Fashion, Business to Sport, discover more
Shortcuts to help you find sections and articles
The clever way to lease a new car is with Car leasing made simple™
2009
per month on 36-month
Personal Contract Hire (PCH)
2008
42850
Car Insurance
£24,250 - £30,346
MI5
London
£60,000
The Environment Agency
Bristol
Up to £90K
Boots
Midlands
OTE £85k
Credit Protection Association
Nationwide Opportunities
Completely London
Luxury Condo's in Manhattan with NYC views
The best new homes in Wimbledon?
Nationwide
Fabulous Cruise And Cruise & Stay Offers Including Virgin Atlantic Flights Prices Start From Only £699pp!
Last Minute Cruise And Cruise & Stay Offers. Med From £499pp, Caribbean From £699pp!
5 star quality at a 3 star price.
8 fabulous Canadian cities ...you won’t find cheaper
Contact our advertising team for advertising and sponsorship in Times Online, The Times and The Sunday Times, or place your advertisement.
Times Online Services: Dating | Jobs | Property Search | Used Cars | Holidays | Births, Marriages, Deaths | Subscriptions | E-paper
News International associated websites: Globrix Property Search | Property Finder | Milkround
Copyright 2009 Times Newspapers Ltd.
This service is provided on Times Newspapers' standard Terms and Conditions. Please read our Privacy Policy.To inquire about a licence to reproduce material from Times Online, The Times or The Sunday Times, click here.This website is published by a member of the News International Group. News International Limited, 1 Virginia St, London E98 1XY, is the holding company for the News International group and is registered in England No 81701. VAT number GB 243 8054 69.
Policy light is better than having expensive pipe drams which never work.
Peter, Brixham, Devon
I reckon that's a pretty clear message don't you Mr Millburn? If I was you I'd be getting my expenses claims in as fast as I could, because all it will take is another turn of the screw - ie another fuel tax hike - and it could be 1979 all over again, a vote of no confidence, election, goodbye.
Nobby, lincoln, England
The problem is that after taking a cool £1.3 trillion of us in stealth taxes, and presiding over a system that actually encourages "poverty" by making the production of children a career choice (e.g. Shannon Matthews' mother), we have all had enough. Oh, and the waste, the lies, the incompetence ...
Dr Pangloss, Edinburgh,
this dreadful phrase:"hard-working families"
is beginning to drive me mad
it's designed to suck up to people
peter c, devizes, wessex
Labour is policy heavy and a long way from being fit for Government.
anne, bournemouth,
Policy light is a bit better than policy heavy and taxing the public to high heaven to impliment half these useless ideals they have....
N Morgan, Stockport, UK
I usually agree with everything Milburn says put a directly elected NHS is a stupid idea. When sick you call for a doctor not an election, Plato warned of the limits of democracy, when it comes to health leave it to the experts.
Danny, Lancaster, Great Britain
Rrrright, so why not call a snap election?
John P T, Reigate,
Labour will fail because it was ruled for over a decade by a greddy, corrupt, morally bankrupt, mass murderer, war criminal 'Tory Son' who never believed in Labour and Human Rights of the individuals and this is the real face of Labour people have started to believe is. Care for the ordinary people.
A Mahajan, London, Wngland
Common Sense (CS) Policing, CS Health & Safety, CS Taxation, CS Education, CS GP Appointments, CS Speed Cameras, CS with less government how many more Tory policies does Alan Milburn need to know before they issue their election manifesto?
Brian Christley, Abergele, UK
Alan Milburn believes the Conservatives are 'policy light' does he?
Not really!
It is just something a desperate politician says. It would be like the Captain of the Titanic shouting: "Move those deckchairs faster, damn you!" as the ship slipped beneath the icy waters.
Martin, Telford, UK
They just don't get it, do they! We are heartily SICK of Brown and his taxes. Our money is spent on crackpot schemes - poured down one black hole after another - and when they need more money for another hairbrained initiative, up go taxes. Brown, in cuckooland, is fiddling while Britain burns.
Charles Lamont, Worcester,
We've had governments with "policies" for years now, and look where it's got us. Give me a government that once elected just shuts up, banks their salaries, and leaves the rest of us alone to get on with our lives. The last thing this country needs is yet more policies. We have all the laws we need.
Charlie, London,
Policy light? Well, I'd rather have someone open to new ideas and approaches, without a lot of preset policies in place, than a tired party whose policies are heavy on foolery, waste, cultural decadence, and an anything-goes approach to national identity. Labour is no longer the party of Britain.
J Cline, London,
You say the Tories are 'Policy Light' .... are you surprised?
Every time they propose a policy or initiative, Brown steals it
Alex, Buenos Aires,
Alan Milburn would say that would'nt she. Better to have no policies whatsoever than policies which have been the cause of destruction of this nation and its long suffering, ignored indigenous people. Unfortunately there are even more turbulent times ahead of us. Thank you Ms Milburn and Labour
Dr Johnson, LONDON, COUNTRY OF THE BLIND
Wel you went away once Mr Milburn, could we encourage to do so again.
Labour have failed in a monumental way.From the greatest foreign policy disaster since Suez ,a tax addicted Prime Minister who has proved an even greater failure than his deluded predecessor and incompetence on an industrial scale
robert everitt, wolverhampton,
labour are heading for thier biggest defeat at the 2010 election no matter how many u turns they make and changing leaders won,t make any difference.once they started persicuting a third of the adult population by bringing in a smoking ban then they were on the road to certain defeat.
brian rice, halifax, england
I am not surprised that the Tories are 'Policy Light'.
Every time they propose a policy Brown comes along and tries to implement it.
Sid Jacques, Durham,
Margaret Thatchers campaign slogan in the 1979 election was " Labour isn't working ". Very apt for today.
Alan Milburn lists all these things that need to be done and yet he and his party have had more than 11 years to bring some of these policies in and have not done so. Bring on the Tories
D Down, Okehampton, UK
Milburn is wrong. There are lots of Tory policies - in fact they are so good that usually when they are announced Labour adopts them shortly thereafter! (Inheritance Tax, Non Doms, the Points system for immigration). Labour is intellectually bankrupt and has a lousy leader. Bring on David Cameron.
Bruce Finch, Portsmouth,
that list of policy initiatives sounds like a Tory manifesto!
All of them were vigorously opposed by Labour for years.
If that's what he believes he should join the Tories - he won't get any support from his own side with that shopping list
Willi Dawe, Durham, England
"What has changed is that Cameron wants to take that ground for the Tories. We should have the courage to take it ourselves. "
So you want to steal the ideas of the Tories? Try to be a little more subtle about it.
Labour may be finished, but would the question is would Tories be any better?
James, Leeds, UK
As a low earner - goodbye Alan ! Rock on, the Tories !
David, Swindon, UK
What is wrong with these people? Do they think we are all as deluded as they are?
Labour is'nt working, has never worked, and is on the verge of political extinction thank God; go and get a real job Mr Milburn, as a political force, you and your party are toast.
Michael Rigby, blackburn,
UK PLC is a business and shouldn't be managed by ex postmen, ship stewards, ex journalists and unemployable ex trade union leaders. If a ship steward applied to become a chief executive of a major company do you think he would be offered a job - I think not. Labour is not fit for office.
mike lincoln, wakefield,
"... Labour has yet to develop a coherent postBlair agenda."
There was a coherent pre-Blair agenda?
Things can only get better.
John Bowman, Sarlat, France
Tories are policy-lite until manifesto time, DOH!
That's how to avoid Lab ripping off policies and using access to Gov data to rubbish others.
"No policy" is better than Labour policy.
Lab know what's best for us, tories know that we know best.
Targets, tax & social meddling. Leave us alone!
AndyG, London, Surrey
Wow! it's like reading the "were going to save you, just trust in government" nonsense we are hearing from Obama and Hillary over here in the states. People are beginning to realize government intervention isn't always the answer. Go Tories LOL
9 times out of 10 poverty is caused by one's choices
Blake, San Antonio, TX, USA
Milburn spouting the same tripe in a sad attempt to keep his job in 2010. Labour have had 11 years and delivered nothing. They lie about statistics and fleece the taxpayers. They are unaccountable for their wastage and we have had enough. It's time to pull NuLabour from the trough of public money.
Edward, London,
Alan, I'm not listening.
You can't express empathy when 1.1M lose from the 10p tax mess. Empathy is immediately;
Chopping the price of pre-pay power
Compensating 10p losers
A maximum interest rate
etc etc
and other no cost policies that'll help the poorer.
Use your majority while u can!
Ted, Cheshire,
Unfortunately when a Prime Minister lies to the electorate on a number of occasions e.g. EU referendum, nobody has been affected by the loss of the 10p rate, the election decision had nothing to do with the polls, trust is lost . Nothing the government now says or does will make any difference.
roger, swindon,
Alan,
You, and the other New Labour MPs who voted for The Identity Cards Act 2006, clearly demonstrated your unsuitability for public office because you have either:
a) Not read the Act.
b) Not understood the Act.
c) Put your political career before the interest of the people of this country.
Brian Drury, London Colney, England
What you say would ensure a conservative victory. Lower house prices plus more built will help more. Tax new cars at 30% average and cut taxes with that for the poor. Cheap shots at the sick and disabled are the reason the public thinks you dont get it,
with gold plated pension and perks.
J Thomson, Brighton, England
Levy £5 billion windfall tax on phone companies.
Authorize phone companies to grossly overcharge for mobile phone calls to allow recovery of windfall tax.
The ultimate stealth tax with collection charges borne by the utility and their customers.
Well done New Labour, very well done!
Wullie, Luss, Scotland
What Alan Milburn says will ensure a Conservative victory. First Time buyers will be helped by falling prices + 3 times the number of homes built. Tax car purchace at 30% and give to the poor. Attacks on the sick and disabled is a cheap shot at the most vunreable in society. You just dont get it.
J Thomson, Brighton, England
This article confirms for me that labour is completley out of touch and they have truly lost the plot. Milburn, your arrogance is breathtaking and I look forward to seeing you out on your ear! It is because of your contemptible party and its atrocious policies that I emmigrated to Australia.
Mitch, Melbourne, Australia
What a pile of self-congratulation !.
Judgments have to be made on the recent massive failures which will have long term consequences.
McBroon goes on like a broken record and would embarrass himself in any corporate setting.
And Millie Bland is seen as a successor?
O what joy for the Tories !!
Padraig, Perth, Australia
in your dreams
terry sullivan, morden, england
Tories policy light? He's just stolen several!
perdix, Cheshire, UK
You've had ten years and still made a mess of it, and don't start blaming "credit crunch" etc... The Britain we had had industry, had a great economy which Gordon inherited, and a some semblance of law and order. What have you left us with after ten years? High Taxes and National Wreckage. Go!
Phil A, Headley, UK
"leadership is about steering a consistent course and being clear about both the direction of travel and the point of destination".
Really? How about the withdrawal of CGT taper relief after 10 years? This lost aspirational voters trust. Self inflicted buffeting and anything but consistent.
R Harris, Horsham, UK