Jane Shilling
Win luxury hampers plus Waitrose vouchers & guidebooks
“Consumer gloom as spending power fails,” said the front-page headline in Tuesday's Times. To which I can only say, tell me about it. Here, in no particular order, is a list of things I can't afford to do, this week, this month, this year.
I can't afford to have the car serviced; I can't afford to take the cat to the vet after his latest skirmish with the feline bully who thinks our garden is his territory. I can't afford to fix the rotten back door, even though it fell off a while ago and now maintains a tenuous attachment to its frame. Nor have I the means to staunch the leak that means when it's raining outside, it rains indoors as well. I can't even think about replacing the roof, in which there is a perceptible dip. I can't afford to get my cataracts treated privately, even though my GP briskly assured me that this was the only way to get them dealt with in the foreseeable future. I can't afford a holiday this year, and I certainly can't afford that treasured female ritual of a shopping expedition for a new spring wardrobe.
When I say I “can't afford” these things it is, of course, a relative sort of not being able to afford. Financially speaking, March is a particularly cruel month, with January's tax bill and February's VAT and accountant's bills falling like blows of fate, one after another. And although the current account is worse than empty, I do have a credit card with the usual vast credit limit and a modest outstanding balance. I dare say that the vet, the garage, the travel agent, the clothes shops and possibly even the builder and eye hospital would be happy to accept my flexible friend.
What's more, having bought a small, cheap house a long time ago, and steadily overpaid on the mortgage, I have a comparatively modest outstanding balance there, too. Even in the midst of the credit crunch I suppose I might find a lender willing to release some of the equity in my decrepit but much-more- valuable-than-when-I-bought-it house. And then I could bung on a new roof and a solid back door, no problem. So what's stopping me? Why am I sitting here in my ancient jeans and Oxfam jumper, peering at the computer screen through a cataract fog, typing away to the merry plink of raindrops into a bucket and planning to pin down the cat as soon as I've finished and bathe his wounds with salt water, when I could sort out my ramshackle life with a phone call or two to the mortgage broker? Because I'm frightened, that's why.
In Wednesday's Budget speech the Chancellor used the reassuring word “stability” 23 times. But stability is exactly what I don't feel I have. This time last year it struck me that, having been accustomed for years to finding a small surplus in my account at the end of the month I was now barely breaking even. With the help of a financial adviser I reviewed my budget. The results were chilling. So I began a regime of economies. Like many of the respondents to the Times Online poll, reported on Tuesday, I stopped eating out and buying books or clothes, except in sales or charity shops, began scrutinising the cost of my food, replacing Elizabeth David's French Country Cooking with Susan Campbell's Poor Cook.
A year later it is clear that these gestures - the elimination from our spending of all frivolity, the stern crushing of any extravagant impulse - are nothing like enough. Not only do I not feel a sense of stability, I feel as though financial freefall is a heartbeat away, with the fact that we are not enormously in debt our only fragile safety net. Which is why I hesitate to borrow to get the cat or the roof fixed; and also why I have belatedly realised that things aren't going to get better, and that I have to embark on a radical rethink of my relationship with money.
A headline in another of the week's papers reads, “Treasury wants to take the shame out of bankruptcy”, which struck me as odd because, although I hope I'm not on the verge of bankruptcy, I have a certain sense of shame about my situation. When I bought my first flat, in my late twenties, my parents gave me the deposit. It seems unlikely that I'll be able to do the same for my son - more likely he will begin his working life with the equivalent of that deposit in student debt and no prospect of buying a place of his own until I do the decent thing and leave him what remains of my estate (after inheritance tax).
To which you might say (as Ed Balls either did or didn't during the Budget debate, depending on whom you believe): “So what?” That's what social mobility is all about: the feeble going to the wall while the vigorous rise to take their place. If that is how it works, I can hardly complain, though I'm not proud to be the generation that undoes the remarkable achievement of my foundling grandfather, who dragged himself from destitution into the middle class by sheer hard work and determination.
But I wonder what will happen now that the erstwhile middle class is subsisting on a regime of tight belts, leaky roofs, old cars and no holidays. To some of us the adjustment, after the initial shock, is not without its charm: I've always liked growing things and making do; never really enjoyed going on holiday; can, now I've readjusted my expectations, still live a life of modest happiness within the constraints of my dramatically reduced spending power. But if there is a whole class of people out there who share my experience (and the Times Online poll suggests there is), what will happen to the gap in the economy that our money used to fill? While I wait for my clever colleagues on the Comment pages to answer that question, I am consoling myself with an ancient copy of World of Interiors, in which a young man of no means but exquisite sensibility invited the magazine to photograph his lovely home - a squat in a tumble-down North London stables where visitors navigated the ruined floor and leaky roof to sit on rickety reclaimed chairs among a riot of ravishing objets trouvés. I may be on the way down, but I'm going there in style.
Haute cuisine versus kitchen Cabinet
Eleven years ago, provoked by a picture of the Blair Babes clustered around
the new Prime Minister, I wrote an article lamenting their ghastly clothes.
It caused a flurry of condemnation - not of the dowdies, but of me, for
being so frivolous as to think it mattered what a female MP wore. I was
reminded of that piece this week by two contrasting gatherings. In France,
female Ministers attended an official dinner at the Élysée palace. Their
British counterparts, meanwhile, were photographed on their way to a Cabinet
meeting. The French politicians are women of a certain age, with medium good
looks and figures. The Brits ditto - though Yvette Cooper, Caroline Flint
and Ruth Kelly are younger than their French colleagues. But what a
difference of presentation: the French well groomed, beautifully dressed,
feminine without being unsuitably provocative (unlike the President's
ex-model wife, in a nasty one-shouldered purple frock). The Brits, on the
other hand, look a mess: Yvette Cooper in a crumpled suit with unsuitable
knee boots; Caroline Flint in a dire, split skirt and low-cut waistcoat;
Ruth Kelly apparently wearing an outfit borrowed from someone twice her size
and age. To me, elegance is a matter of self-control. When I look at Rachida
Dati, or Condoleezza Rice, their exquisite grooming seems part of the
seriousness with which they are tackling their important jobs. How odd that
in Britain, with our vibrant fashion industry, female MPs should consider
turnout a matter of no importance.
Fare trade
A survey by Tesco finds that traditional British dishes are being replaced by
foreign cuisine. Sherry trifle and coronation chicken, it is claimed, might
disappear from our dining tables by 2021. To which the only possible
reaction from anyone who has ever tasted either of these repulsive
confections has to be - as late as that?

Jane Shilling's column appears in the paper every Friday. She lives in Greenwich and recently published a memoir The Fox in the Cupboard
Read the training tips and advice that helped our London Triathletes
Times Online's new TV show helps you make the right decisions for your pet
Read our exclusive 100 Years of Fleming and Bond interactive timeline, packed with original Times articles and reviews
The latest travel news plus the best hotels and gadgets for business travellers
Shortcuts to help you find sections and articles


Why good girls pay good money for bad-girl baubles

Search The Times Births, Marriages & Deaths
2007
£47,995
2008
£42,945
06/2006
£40,850
Great car insurance deals online
£33,000
Macmillan Cancer Support
Central/South West
£50k
NHS
Nationwide
£
£30k OTE
Meltwater News
Nationwide
circa £70k
Central Office of Information
London
5% below developer pre-launch price!
Luxury Appts, beautiful gardens w/ Thames views
Great Homes Available on a shared Ownership Basis
Great Investment, River Views
Visit the ‘entertainment capital of the world’
at great sale prices!
Christmas Cruises
From only £995pp
APTs East Coast now from only
£2425pp.
Great travel insurance deals online
Contact our advertising team for advertising and sponsorship in Times Online, The Times and The Sunday Times. Globrix Property Search - find property for sale and rent in the UK. Visit our classified services and find jobs, used cars, property or holidays. Use our dating service, read our births, marriages and deaths announcements, or place your advertisement.
Copyright 2008 Times Newspapers Ltd.
This service is provided on Times Newspapers' standard Terms and Conditions. Please read our Privacy Policy.To inquire about a licence to reproduce material from Times Online, The Times or The Sunday Times, click here.This website is published by a member of the News International Group. News International Limited, 1 Virginia St, London E98 1XY, is the holding company for the News International group and is registered in England No 81701. VAT number GB 243 8054 69.
Dear Jane,
As always you have soundly hit the nail on the head for all of your readers including one that reads your column from far away in Dallas, Texas thanks to an email friend in Leeds who forwards it.
Fear! This is what we are all feeling at the moment regardless of our current financial situations. If the economy, like Humpty Dumpty, falls off the wall, we are all in trouble.
Yes, we can tighten our belts now and control our consumption of the unnecessary, but underneath the gloomy financial reports we hear today, may lie even gloomier reports.
What will we tighten then?
The best antidote to fear is hope. And I do hope by some miracle that the economy will improve both here and there and that you will be able to get your leaky roof fixed, your cataracts removed, and your cat to the vet.
And perhaps then we can all loosen our belts a little and drink a little wine.
Laura Mohsene, Richardson (Dallas), Texas USA
To the editor:
I'm surprised that no-one has mentioned Jane's cataracts. It is deeply shocking to hear of someone in their forties in danger of losing their sight from this affliction.
Jane, being a writer, is also in danger of losing her livelihood. I suppose it is too much to hope that The Times will put her on the payroll and give her private health insurance. But she is a lovely writer, worth hanging on to.
To Jane:
I have followed your progress with affection over the years, and know that you are a single working mother with a horse and a child in private school. Any one of these three conditions is inimical to personal wealth. I should sell the horse, and use the money to fix the roof and the cataracts. When your son has done his GCSE's, I should get him into a State Sixth Form (State Schools function better after the masses leave at 16).
Use the money to build up some funds for your retirement. Otherwise you face a very bleak future.
All the best.
Jane Saunte, Cambridgeshire, UK
You clearly have no clue how to make sherry trifle.
Billy Barnett, HK,
Jane always writes beautifully, and is so right that it is the little things that bring contentment. I have ME, but so long as I can walk round my garden and look forward to a glass of good red in the evening, I am content!
Sheila, Letchworth Garden City,
Grow up Jane and take your cat to the vet.Why should an innocent animal suffer from your pathetic attack of financial panic?
You obviously have a huge amount of equity in your house and it makes no sense at all not to get the roof fixed as it is just going to create bigger bills in the future.
Count your blessings and stop whingeing.
Charles Masraff, Yerevan , Armenia
I don't want to worry Jane , but in the present credit crisis banks are looking carefully at how we use our flexible friends.
It may be a case of 'use it or lose it!'
At least she should get the cat some attention , that is a priority, and sack the accountant, his fees would pay the vet's.
I
pat hodgson, coventry, warwickshire.
Redcliffe: re Poor Cook (Campbell & Conran). I bought my copy new for 60p in 1972. Seems it's now a collector's item! So I doubt if Jane has just paid £70 for hers.
Marion, Newmarket, UK
So just how did my grandparents raise 5 children between 1904 and 1924 then? Him a farm labourer. Sorry but you must try harder!
David Vinter, Louth. Lincs., UK.
It's a national hobby to buy something one cannot afford thus putting oneself into a misery for many years and then start complaining that exactly this (speculative) activity has driven the prices up, that one cannot do anything in life but pay for that house, its insurance, fees, renovations, local plumber who drives a Porsche or a carpenter... Do you really think that life should start at 60 when the house is paid off? Obviously, there is no financial possibility for it to start earlier as one lives to work and to pay off the house rather than works to live! The question is whether this house would make you happier when looking back at your life you realise that you only lived to pay it off? Or maybe a 3-4-times cheaper flat in southern France would do it for your late years (which you can actually rent off your pension), but meanwhile you would be able to do scuba diving or Himalayas climbing or whatever else you might need money for?
Oleg, London, UK
Well, Jane, I've been reading your column for some time now and from that have gleaned a few things about your life style that might explain where the money goes. The horse, for instance. The private school fees. The organic food from farmers' markets. The clothes that may not seem all that extravagant to you but do to someone like me who buys from charity shops as a matter of course (I'm not complaining - there's far more satisfaction to me in putting together what i consider a nice outfit at a cost of £20 or less than hitting the High Street and doing it easily but expensively). Will those suggestions do for starters?
Jenny Latimer, Dundee,
Eat simple food like vegetables and rice, skip holidays, don't use TV or buy newspapers (use the internet cafe), don't drink or smoke, don't buy books, wear cheap clothes, don't have more than two pairs of shoes, and you ought to be fine.
Westerners are too extravagant. It will do you good to cut back.
Ganpat Ram , London , UK
Its an Ill Wind that Blows. Reminds me of the 1970s when Sunny Jim Callaghan and Dennis Healy were 'In charge'. Then they had to go cap-in-hand to the IMF for bail-out loans after another Labour Party's Fiscal incompetence.
Another round of Pension Fund raids on financial institutions and banks. Maybe we will all be forced to buy 'Citizenship Bonds' to 'prove' our right to abode in Blighty. Of course it will be us middle-classes who will be hammered. Pa Broon and his Marxists PC Cronies hate anything to do with Middle-Britain, and that includes Scotland, Wales, N Ireland and of course - England. More is to be taken, so hang onto your Wallets and Purses!
B Clarke, Chelmsford, Essex UK
I think you need to try my mother's sherry trifle . . . it is the gold medallist of the trifle Olympics. Especially when made with unpasteurised cream.
CFG, WGC,
If Jane Shilling is registered for VAT, she's presumably earning more than £64,000. What does she do with it all? Does she realise the vast majority of her readers will be living on less than half that? It makes strange reading to hear of the 'struggles' of someone who by most standards is very well off. I must admit my sympathy is rather limited.
Marion, Newmarket, UK
For heaven's sake Jane, why should female MPs be judged on how 'well-groomed' they are? Grooming is for animals; maybe intelligent grown women have other priorities. I note that when we have scruffy male MPs, such as Ken Clarke or Boris Johnson, people go 'aaah' and make out they're eccentric and clever and maverick. But women...? Why must female columnists buy into the bitchiness and the value system?
Lyn, Birmingham,
Female MPs haven't quite grasped the concept of 'Yes it DOES matter what I look like' if not to themselves, then at least to others. Being well-dressed and groomed brings with it extra respect and admiration. You are taken more seriously because you look the part.
If men feel more powerful in a tailored suit from Jermyn Street, why should women in power feel any different.
Frumpy and dowdy on the outside = frumpy and dowdy on the inside. They might have a brain but they are obviously stricken with the curse of the British woman - lack of self-confidence.
Sarah Hague, Montpellier, France
Why?
Two words...
Labour
Government
(I apologise to those who think "Labour Government" is an oxymoron.)
John Bowman, Sarlat, France
The reason you feel strapped, Jane, is that the world that you have taken for granted is coming to an end - cheap food and fuel and so on. On top of that, someone has to pay for the increasing costs of the popluation living longer and wating more and more.
People that never fended for themselves - relying on parents state, partners etc - tend to be the first to suffer when things get tight. Adults reliant on their own means tend to have better protection mechanisms and perhaps, say, never had a car at all, let alone an "old" one.
Your reality is probably that you could never afford the house or the car. Your good fortune to come of age in the 80s in one of the rich Western countries that thought they could take from the world forerver (and the help of bank of mum and dad) duped you into thinking you could.
Vicky, Germany,
The "poor" cook, in paperback, is selling for £70 on Amazon. Something doesn't add up.
Redcliffe, London,
Get an allotmant. Your already-praiseworthy BMI will go down even further, and you'll rediscover what things ought to taste like. Your bank balance will improve hugely.
ben foster, penley,