Nicole can't act. And Hugh does not do it for me. Would have loved Cate Bllanchett and a trim Russel Crow (like he was in Gladiator) for the two roles.

Ingrid, Queensland, Australia

I think this is way off! Myself and many of my girlfriends love Nicole Kidman. She is beautiful and a wonderful actress!!!! The movie was fantastic and worth the wait....infact I am going to see it again this weekend with another batch of friends!

June, Detroit, USA

Kidman's expressions are limited to a gaping mouth and blank stares. Her attempts at accents are embarrassing. And the comment that men flock to see her. Pssh! I don't know a single male who will watch a "Kidman" flick. Melanie is not jealous, she speaks the truth! Way to go.

Donna, Kansas City, USA

I loved Austrailia, we need more feel good movies! This one made me feel good, and no movie has done that in years!!

Diann, Folsom,

Who cares what she gets paid, or whether she's any good at her job. She is able to get more than 426 comments, which is more than most topics in the timesonline. She must be doing something right! If the hyper-critical saddos get uptight then they dont have to go watch the film do they.......crikey!

woody, Aberystwyth, UK

saw Australia last evening. out of curiosity Melanie, who would you have play that role, if not Nicole? AND...name three good (in your eyes) female actors who might have been considered?

noel, guelph, canada

It's become evident Nicole is the most over-paid actress, as her high salaries aren't justified by how poorly she draws in audiences. So it's interesting to read the comments about why this is.

I thought she was stunning in "Moulin Rouge". But I've had mixed feelings about her other roles.

Felice, Salt Lake City, USA

Baz goes back to Shakespeare in his next project "Taming of the Shrew". Directing Melanie Reid in her West End debut. Cant wait to review that one.

Rumpole, Singapore, Singapore

Yes i saw Australia last night and i too thought it was our times gone with the wind,it was fantastic,nicole was fantastic!

emily, anchorage,

Nicole Kidman is my all-time favorite actress. Its tragic that some believe that beautiful woman are not talented. seems that some have gotten carried away with the amazing beauty and have not seen the real talent. may be you should take second look forgetting the fact that they are beautiful.

Brenda, Singapore, Singapore

if shes in it, i wont be going.

Anne, melbourne, Australia

I just got back from the theater - Saw Australia - Nicole Kidman was SENSATIONAL - the film was wonderful. It is today's Gone with the Wind!! I was fearful because it was a long film, but it did not drag of even have any slow parts!! Superb!!

Judy, Raleigh, USA

She was brilliant in The Hours as Virginia Wolff.

lula, London,

JEALOUS, JEALOUS, JEALOUS

You people need to get a life and stop wishing yours was as successful as hers!!!!

lisa, melbourne, australia

Thank God someone has finally said what I've been thinking for years - Nicole Kidman makes Jennifer Lopez look like an accomplished actress.

Thanks Melanie - you've made my day!

Alison , Sydney, Australia

I'm not really sure you can call it acting when a cold emotionally distant woman plays a cold emotionally distant woman. Although sometimes she does stretch (?) is a scary, manipulative cold emotionally distant woman.
How many of us really believe she hasn't had plastic surgery?!

grace, sydney, australia

I'm sorry, but where is this all coming from? Kidman is talented and she has created a highly respected image of herself. I think she does great in all her films. Also, Keira Knightley and Gwyneth Paltrow are amazing and highly entertaining. Critics are harsh and sometime annoying

Trisha, San Jose, USA

Nicole Kidman has lovely blue eyes and in The Others I thought her rather good - or maybe it was just a good movie anyhow. Otherwise she's given the same performance so many times it really is a waste of time going to see her.

jacqueline rokotnitz , Tel Aviv, Israel

Hooray, very well put! My sentiments exactly. I cannot understand how people cannot see through all the hoopla about Nic. I think the kiss of death happened to her a long time ago when she married Tom Cruise, who cannot seem to reach me either. They are one of a kind.

mia, Sydney, Australia

Maybe you should've actually watched the film before writing this? Besides failing to mention Nicole's performance in Australia or, well, anything about the actual film at all, you also made sweeping generalities about "female cinemagoers" which are, quite frankly, false. I though Nic was great. =)

Alex, Melbourne, Australia

thank you Melanie Reid, at last someone was game enough to say what I certainly feel about Nicole Kidman .....I will not be seeing Australia as i find her acting shallow, uninspiring and downright embarrasing

olya Parrama, carlingford, australia

I'm female, I'm educated, I'm a proud Australian & I think Nicole is a great actor. She was especially brilliant in Moulin Rouge & I love her in so many other movies. Gwynneth & Keira have also made great contributions to the film industry. They are slim, beautiful & can act! Jealous perhaps?

Libby Stark, San Antonio, USA

Dear Melanie

Too bad you haven't seen the movie. My husband, friend and I went to see it last night. Those two do not like Nicole Kidman. They came out of the movie last night absolutely pleased with her acting. Nicole has grown as an actress and this one is one of her best.

Barbara, Gold Coast, Australia

She is perfect for this GENRE, its a Baz film-she acts quite well for a strong woman who is passive just like an actress in the b n' w 1950's films, looking perfect (the type of genre Baz went for). Women may not like her because they don't like sexism?? Sure Baz could have got Sandra Bullock!??

Karen, QLD, Aust

Nicole was great in her earlier roles displaying depth,emotional range and connecting with the audience. I think she was much better in her Australian films like Dead Calm and the teleseries Bangkok Hilton. She could get you to care about her characters then, but not her Hollywood roles

Tom, Adelaide, Australia

Nicole Kidman has an amazing talent. I think your words are unkind and a bit harsh. I'm looking forward to this movie.

Jen, , USA

Dear Melanie...Thank you, at last someone has dared touch the seemingly untouchable. My sentiments exactly re Nicole . As far as her face goes we could all look like that if we had her money. What happened to her red curly hair and huge amount of freckles!!! I refuse to go to see "Australia"

Dana Grant, Brisbane, Australia

Nicole Kidman burst into our cinema's and lives in a big way with 'Days of Thunder' and worked her way from there. During that time there have been movies that have not worked and some that have been great. We need to focus on the movie as a whole not belittle the actress due to personal flaws.

Kell, Newcastle, Australia

The current trend to rip through Nicole kidman is disgraceful. Her countless international accolades are testament to the fact that she can act, and that her appeal is broad (not simply for her acting ability). And who cares if she uses botox? Name me an actor/actress at her level who hasn’t?

mike, melbourne, australia

All I learned from this article was that Ms Reid dislikes Nicole Kidman . I have seen the movie, and loved it. It's a very theatrical Baz Lurhmann epic, as expected, and the audience in my cinema reacted very positively. Perhaps MS Reid hated the fact that Nicole made the English look stupid.

Julie, Brisbane, Australia

You are definitely out of touch with most women. I am a typical movie goer, upper middle class, 37yr old mom of 2, I have enjoyed most of her films. They are entertaining, which is the whole point of these movies. Your unfounded criticism is just wrong.

Lisa, Whittier, USA

Will everyone please note that Melanie does not speak for 'all women'. I am female and think Nicole Kidman was great in Birth and Moulin Rouge. Keira Knightly is also a good actess. Someone criticised Keira's pout. What is the point of that? That is like criticising the shape of her ear!

Marie, Harrogate, UK

I agree totallly with Melanie. Nicole with her botoxed forehead lip filler disaster and gummy tooth makeover cannot act. When you see her all you see is Nicole trying to act. She miscues all the time and has this ridiculous glazed over look throughout the movie.

ally, Brisbane, Australia

I just think that if the film is a love story about an English woman and a good Aussie bloke, then Baz should have cast an English actress, there are many who would have played the role brilliantly. It would have added an honesty to the film and heightened the romance.

Viv, Melbourne, Australia

I've seen Nicole Kidman in a couple of movies - she was good in "Dogville" but so-so in the Batman movie. The problem is she accepts or gets cast in movie roles that don't play to her strengths. She needs a good director like a Hitchcock perhaps. But not Baz Luhrmann.

Jen, Sydney, Australia

Quote: ....but cannot act to save their lives: Gwyneth Paltrow, Keira Knightley...."

Keira Knightley cannot act? Are you kidding me?

And Gwyneth deservedly won an Oscar...
I agree that Nicole is not the most talented of them all, but to drag down to perfectly good actresses down with her?

Bo Miller, St Die, France, France

I like her, i've liked all the movies i've seen her in, and she dosn't turn all women of........

Emmy, Loughborough, england

What about The Hours - that was a great movie....(and Dead Calm)

Carol, Houston, USA

She actually worked perfectly in The Portrait of a Lady, she was the perfect Henry James woman, which is not a compliment.

William, Washington, DC, USA

Well, perhaps it's the fault of the recent Australian School of acting. Judy Davis can certainly act, but because she is no longer 35, no one will cast her. Where are the up and comers? Is there no stage work in Australia to teach young actors?

Bonnie, Greenville, SC, USA

I really like her and don't understand where the bashing is coming from.

Liana, San Juan, Puerto Rico

Ms. Kidman is by no means my favorite actor, however cold mountain rocked and I thought he was absolutely perfect for that part. I think it must be difficult to be so tall and have such red hair although lovely it must be hard to place her. I think in the right atmosphere Nicole could prove us wrong

virginia, Phoenix, USA

I've seen a lot of Nicci Kidman's films and I haven't see one that I haven't likedher in. She's fanatastic AND talented.

Scott, Dundee, UK

Isn't it funny if a man said he can't stand any actor no one would ever say to him he is just jealous.
Not everyone can like all the same things or people, it's just human nature to have different tastes.
Can't say I care either way about Ms. Kidman.

Brenda, Longbow Lake, Canada

I completely disagree with this article. Nicole Kidman gave an excellent performance in Cold Mountain.. and is a really good actress. Where do people get the time to criticize every little waking moment and every little thing? Man.. wish I had your job. Well, actually, I complain enough already :)

Karen, Greenville, USA

Nicole Kidman is a great actress. She's hardly "vapid." And this is coming from a woman.

Holly Ross, Worthington, OH, U.S.A.

Agreed! I've given Nicole Kidman the benefit of the doubt in many of her movies but time and time again, I've been disappointed. I don't think she's bad. I just don't think she's all that special. I'd add Julia Roberts to that list of high-grossing, popular, but bad actors. She's also overrated.

Brian, New York City, USA

Apparently you never saw "The Hours."

Paul, Los Angeles, USA

I've always thought that she would play a wonderful role as Mary Queen of Scots in any epic .

Steve Evans, Kalkara, Malta

Hugh Jackman could star opposite Ernest Borgnine and I'd be there. I like Nicole, I see her as extremely shy though and a bit cold in her demeanor, so I see the writer's point -- but yeah, Hugh Jackman in stubble, ask me I care who else is in it?

Kristin , California, United States

The Hours and Moulin rouge, otherwise...pffft! I agree there's not much to her, but she doesn't deserve that kind of abuse.
This article could have been written with just a WEE bit more tact, I'd have more respect for it even if I do agree for the most part.

Teri, Edmonton, Canada

My wife wanted to see the movie, right up until she saw Nicole Kidman was starring in it. Immediately, she said "I will NOT see that movie. She's terrible."

Say what you will, Melanie is on to something.

Earnest, Whitehouse, OH, USA

I kind of like her, I recently watched Fur. I thought she was pretty good. As for Australia, I'm getting closer but if they could get the Island to float around I'm sure more would visit and how's about a free ticket?

Lee Owen, Bucharest, Romania

I loved her in Cold Mountain, Far and Away and Practical Magic.

Seems you just don't like her.

debbie, linthicum heights,

Nicole Kidman is a lovely person on and off screen. I have had several chances to meet her around Nashville and she exhibits poise, grace, and beauty. All actors have good and bad movies. The biting comments seem a little harsh. Maybe I care more about the real Nicole than the onscreen persona.

Robin, nashville, USA

It is all a bit catty, isn't it? I wouldn't rate Kidman as talented but she can be competent. I thought The Others worked perfectly for her and Practical Magic was a charmer, but there are others that are awful and not just because she's in them: Moulin Rouge, Far & Away, Golden Compass. Shudder!

Ed, Cardiff,

I'm a woman, and I like Nicole Kidman. In fact, I'm planning to go and watch Australia just because she's in it.

Olivia, Leeds,

I agree completely .... completely.

William, New York, NY, USA

i love her movies.... i love the way she is in her private life.....not selling the pictures of her newborn, never kiss the brother, no tattoos, never steal the husband.

Karin , Mexico,, Mexico

I really do not find time to watch movies anymore. Does this cloud my judgement on Australia? What a pitiful debate this is!

Alex, London,

While I am not a “movie critic” it is after watching “Eyes Wide Shut” that it became glaringly apparent that Kidman is a superior actor-actress to her ex. Beyond that I agree with Reid that she is part of a larger group of female performers who seem to be remember more for “scenes than roles” That said a multitude of male counterparts could be just as readily listed (Tom should be considered as such).

Stan, Auburn,Al.,

On The Money.

Australia: The Movie: Mediocre

NicKid; Bland

Plot: Trivial.

Summary: No amount of flowing robes will fix this mess.

Tom Storm, Upper Coomera, Australia

Spot on! You forgot to add Julia Roberts & Madonna in the bad acting group...Nicole was once gorgeous (I actually thought she was smok'n hot), but too much plastic surgery/botox....

Bud, Chicago,

The men will see it because of Nicole, and the women will see it because of PEOPLE's sexyist man of the year - Hugh.

jim, Chicago, USA

I think the way you criticize Nicole Kidman's act is not fair and not objective. I am a woman and she doesn't turn me off at all.I was not very fan off her till I saw "Moulin Rouge".We were 5 women and we all enjoyed it and since then I saw few other of her movies that I too enjoyed.

Asli, Virigina Beach, USA

my husband loathes kidman. he is an artist and an astute judge of character. i don't like her. she was foisted upon us one night, in 'to die for', which neither of us warmed to - and now she has become merely a near-absolute-zero caricature of herself.

holly von hundeshagen, north america,

You obviously didn't see the movie where her and Sandra Bullock are witches. Sorry dear, I think you are jealous cause she is cute.

Craig, Nashville,

Nicole I find oddly enough is a better comedic actress, namely To Die for and her and Steve Carrell were the only good things about Bewitched. Now Will Ferrel is the epitomy of 1 dimensional. Other than maybe Malice and being naked in Dead calm she hasn't impressed me. Brain surgeon in DoT??? C'mon.

mike, Port St. Lucie, Florida, USA

Thank you - I really thought I was just jealous, but now I know I'm not alone in being totally underwhelmed by Kidman & Co. I once forgot her name for 3 weeks and I thought it was early onset Alzeimer's. My brain obviously recognised it wasn't worth the effort.

Sheila Spencer, Burnham-on-Crouch,

I notice the writer left out her Oscar-nominated performance in Moulin Rouge. Sounds like she has another axe to grind with her about something. She's hasn't been bad in the films I've seen.

K Huntley, Hartford, USA

I don't care what you say. She was flawless in "To Die For" Remember the scene where she danced for the spellbound kid as he sat in the car? The oddness in her eyes? And how about in "Birthday Girl" when she pushed the sex book across to the guy who purchased the mail order bride? She CAN act..

Joe G., Cocoa Beach, USA

Cate Blanchet? Yes! Rose Byrne? Even more yes! Nicole? Bland looks, even though I liked movies like The Others and Bankok Hilton

Jordi, Montreal, Canada

Thank you for this article it affirms me.
Last movie in which she turned me on was BMX Bandits...but I was a young teen then. Since then, I sould have been predisposed to being her biggest fan, but I could never find the spark. Was good in the movie with Pullmann & Baldwin, but since then zilch..

robert walter, Troy, USA

I will see this movie because Nicole kidman is in it. She is an accomplished actress who brings a compelling presence to the screen. It's amazing to see such a small country consistently produce world class talent in the Arts.

Lynne, Hollis, USA

Women don't like Nicole Kidman?! Speak for yourself only, please. I've followed Nicole Kidman's career for years and have enjoyed all of her films. Even when her movies are not entirely successful (Fur, Dogville, etc.) they are interesting and often brave. She has a LOT of female fans!

Maria, Miami, Florida, USA

Agreed, wholeheartedly. Just last night, a girlfriend and I turned to each other during the previews at another movie, and said "I hate Nicole Kidman" spontaneously, and at the same time. i would not see this movie, just because of her dull wooden face...the idea that she could inspire passion..ha!

rhonda, kingston,

Her worst acting ever was in the Batman movie with Val Kilmer..

There's a scene where she's jumping around the furniture. She's supposed to look frightened but her mouth is hanging open. That's all she does, Come to think of it, her mouth is always open in all her movies.
Worst. Actress. Ever.

Caroline, Austin, Texas, USA

I can't comment either way. I've never seen anything she has been in.

Susan, Sagamore Hills, USA

Nicole is great, she can captivate an audience and I will see her movie!

Veronica, Norwalk, USA

On behalf of all Australians, I apologise for this parade of stereotypes and cliches. Please punish the producers for their hubris - Don't waste your time and money. Seriously, this is more embarrassing than the Ashes loss a couple of years ago.

Todd, Adelaide,

I have said this for many years. Actually, Cold Mountain was the movie that made me realize that whenever I see Renee Zellweger in a movie, I see the character. Whenever I see Nicole Kidman in a movie, I see Nicole Kidman playing a character. She's definitely overrated.

Keith, VA, USA

Melanie Reid you left Nicole Kidman of to lightly. i have never seen a movie of hers that was good. well this may just get her back to acting school

sam newman, far cue, Australia

Most actors belonging to the Hollywood machine aren't great actors. They have a presence that sells movies, whether through marketing or hype or whatever. People are told what they are going to like or dislike.

tony, wondai, Australia

Nicole is a totally amazing actress. She captured my heart from the moment I saw her. Her acting skills are exquisite. The world is filled with mean hearted people who seem to exist to try to destroy whatever they can not be themselves. Moulin Rouge was a magnificent film for both men and women.

Elizabeth Walton , Los Angeles, USA

Agree!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

cvc, columbus , usa

Thank you, thank you, thank you. Finally someone has acknowledged the elephant in the room. Nicole Kidman cannot act and the thought of nearly two hours of watching her immobile face - I'd rather have bamboo put under my fingernails.

Linda Wilkins, Sydney, Australia

"...just because she's pretty and we're jealous. "

Yeah I would say that pretty much covers it.

But then I'm male! I might be biased :) I enjoy watching her in movies.

Eric, Idaho, USA

Yes! Finally someone has the nerve to print the truth about Kidman. Because with good acting the process should be invisible, Kidman is not an actor. I am still annoyed that Bewitched, my favorite childhood TV show, was ruined by as a movie in part by her.

Theo, Las Vegas, USA

Congratulations on a brave review! Finally someone who doesn't suck up to the stars who are not worth it! Why should Mrs Kidman be off-limits to bad reviews?
I do admit that her performance in The Hours was Oscar-worthy(albeit for the supporting actress category), overall she isn't a great actress.

Rebecca, NY,

Australia had a lesser known actress by the name of Claudia Black who has an expressive face, mobile features and an interesting, striking look. and she has a voice like an old school movie star of the 1940s.

Kidman has always left me a bit cold. No gravitas.

Blanchett would' ve been fantastic.

Marie, Chicago, USA

No one will ever be as bad as Kiera Knightly, unless it was Natalie Portman. But let's do a comparison. Kidman and McEwan in Moulin Rouge. Sure she's pretty (and with the makeup, wigs and surgical intervention one would hope so), but unlike McEwan she never makes a connection with the audience.

Richard , Sydney,

Rose, I'm going to have to dispute. L. di Caprio, though once an on-screen fairy, has utterly redeemed himself with outstanding performances in Blood Diamond, The Aviator, The Departed to name a few, from which he has risen to become a great of his time.

James, Sy,

might be onto something re: Kidman (guys are always the last to know) and i've always found Paltrow underwhelming. but i really liked Keira Knightly in "Pride & Prejudice" and her performance in the first "Pirates of the Caribbean" was absolutely fantastic. you're way off base there, Mel.

paul, pittsburgh, usa

Just saw the poster for this 'epic' in the NYC subway: Jackman and Kidman.
The first thing that came to my mind re: this female 'lead' was:
please, EAT SOMETHING!.
The thought of this malnourished, pencil-necked, thin-blooded waif of a woman conquering Australia is ridiculous.

jamoke, Queens, US

Nicole Kidman is so hot the projectionists in movie theaters have to use asbestos gloves to change the reels.

I'd stand in line for a week just to watch her read a telephone book.

tom mann, washington dc, usa

They should have gone with Kate Bekinsale! :-D

Jimbo, Phoenix, USA!!!

Nicole won an Oscar for The Hours! How many of you are thin and beautiful like Nicole? I cried my way through Cold Mountain, because of Nicole. She is like an English Doll that we girls, received in Christmas past. She withstood a very difficult divorce. Give her a break. Australia tomorrow!!!

Patty DeBorn, Grand Junction CO, USA

This article is just sour grapes. While I'll agree that Ms. Kidman should lay off the Botox, her performances in Moulin Rouge, The Hours, and Dogville are nothing to scoff at. Before you throw such brutal stones, ask yourself if you are capable of the like. I am a woman and I adore her.

Vanessa , NYC, USA

Nicole was absolutely brilliant in Dogville. Up there with the greats. Kidman has no pulling power? You must be kidding.

David , Brussels, Belgium

Wow. For a woman, you know nothing about the thoughts of other women. Jealousy is NOT the same as envy... and who wouldn't envy Nicole Kidman's beauty, intelligence, and life?
As women, we should celebrate her success as a fellow woman! I, for one, like that she makes no political statements.

Kim, NY, USA

Even Keira Knightly?
I think you have some major prejudice over the 3 actress you mentioned.

Cheri, Malvern,

I think Nicole is a good, if not brilliant, actress. She made Moulin Rouge and is undeniably gorgeous. On the other hand, Julia Roberts' mouth is too irritating for words. and Keira Knightly never stops pouting long enough to act!

Louise, Bristol, UK

I don't like Kidman's acting much at all, but she was rather good in 'Birth.' It was a tough role, and she pulled it off - even with an American accent.

June, Leatherhead, UK

I am one of the men in the audience who agrees with you. Kidman has never even made my B list and for all the reasons you state, plus a few more. I wouldn't date a woman who liked her, and if I allow an actress to become an on-screen "cipher for my desires" I wouldn't let Nicole Kidman be her.

Frank, Boston, USA

I am an American male. I have thought of Nicole as a GREAT actress for most of her career. I have always admired the fact that she was a wonderful actress AND beutiful, not a common thing in Hollywood. Keira is also a very good actress, Paltrow is touch and go, overated. Why so bitter?

Sean, N. Kingstown, USA

By Golly, if a movie critic hates it so much, It's one I just have to see!

Tom, Mobile, Al

Tom Klouzal, Mobile, alabama, united States

Oh Dear Melanie, are you just the teensiest bit JEALOUS? Nicole Kidman may not be the greatest actress ever to have drawn breath, but she is one of the best around today. I'd rather you didn't judge her on my behalf. "We" women don't all agree with you.

Wendy, London,

this is a personal attack on nicold kidman. tis woman is one of the most respected and well known actors of our time. every actors have a different style of acting. she is fantastic in every film she does, just because she doesn;t bounce around and her acting isn;t so technical like meryl streep

peter, sydney, australia

trust me in eyes wide shut nobody was looking at her face.

Bill Jackson, Ortonville, USA

Totally agree with this article. Kidman is vapid, vacuous, and useless. Thanks, Melanie Reid, for expressing what millions of men think also.

Carlton West, Atlanta, USA

She's a perfect example of a beautiful woman with absolutely no sex appeal. Though Lucy Lawless isn't from Australia, she probably would have been a better choice since she can act.

sailordave, Lafayette, LA, USA

What about the most boring, bland, can't act acress of all time?Cameron Diaz!.

But the boys are guilty too. Anyone really think Keanu Reeves is a good actor?

Will, London,

Any chance of a film review?

Mark Buckley, Manchester, UK

I thought she was brilliant in "Moulin Rouge" and "The Others".....two opposites in genre. Moulin Rouge = an epic love story with awesome singing, The Others = an incredibly creepy film with a huge twist.

If an actress like her can pull of such extremes with style and panache, she can't be bad!

Kirsty Anna, Spean Bridge, SCOTLAND

Sorry, Melanie. As a woman, please don't speak for me. I will pay to see a film with Nicole Kidman.

annabelle, Sag Harbor, New York

goodness, what has she done to you?
not say good-morning?

dd, Buenos Aires, Argentina

Obviously haven't seen Dogville or The Hours. Too busy going to big blockbusters...

Francesca, London, UK

a film about australia...YAWWWN!

Graham, Towcester,

Nicole is lovely, I have enjoyed her movies, including BMX Bandits! I can't wait to see Australia and cannot believe all the negative whining that has erupted with this movies release! Melanie, you may be one of those people who require several viewings before you understand what you are watching?

sharyn, Grantville, Australia

Is someone jealous?! Are you a ginger who hant managed to work her pale skin/red hair combo! Yes she is fragile looking, but how does that distract from her acting??! I found her brilliant in To Die For & Moulin Rouge & loads others...of course she has off movies, dont they all.

Kat, Leeds,

Saw her on Letterman today. Creepy. As a man, I don't know what the excitement is about. There are so many more beautiful and talented actresses. But which Australian actresses would they substitute?

Niels, alice springs, australia

Just saw Australia and it was the best.
I believe a true australian would be able to love that movie and so will everyone else in the world.
Our country is beautiful and this movie cannot of been made better.
If you haven't seen it, don't listen to these reviews, go see it on your own terms.

Hannah, Mackay, Australia

I tend to agree-to a point. However, she was outstanding in 'To Die For' and the makeup was something to behold-she never looked that good. As for 'The Hours', I could never stay away during that film.

JohnT, Washington, DC, US

Geesh...Melanie,
Did she steal your husband?
Do you have PMS?
Or just green?
Kidman is a superb actress. Moulin Rouge was amazing as are so many of her other films. One of a very few actresses who pull men and women into the theatre.

Mary, Chicago , USA

I agree with most of the writer's comments. However, I thought you were a little harsh. I enjoyed Nicole in To Die For, Moulin Rouge, The Others, and The Hours. As a Southern American, I thought she and Jude Law made Cold Mountain completely unwatchable. I'm looking forward to seeing Austraia.

JFM, Foster City, CA, United States

Well, I don't think she is cute.

And Far and Away is not only her best flick, but the best flick ever!!!

Okay, but for the love of God, give her some credit for Days of Thunder.

Peter, New York,

You've got to be joking me. I'm a woman and she's my favorite actress. This is absolutely silly. I loved Practical Magic, Moulin Rouge, The Others, Loved her in Cold Mountain, and loved Bewitched. She was great in Far and Away.

Melanie, Maybe this is YOUR opinion but not mine.

someone, Houston, USA

i am not a fan, but i have to admit. i liked her in Dogville.

stan, tokyo, japan

I love Nicole, she is a briliant and versatile actress. She makes me want to see a movie.

Alex, London, United Kingdom

Loved her in Moulin Rouge and hope to see Australia....mostly because of her.

Maryl B, Kirkland,WA, USA

I enjoyed her in Bewitched!

Marc, Oklahoma City, usa

kidman a bad actress? i think we can confidently agree that at least 80% of 'hollywood' fits this description. these people are way way way over-rated. it's ridiculous that i'm even spending 30 seconds engaging in this conversation.

hansoloz, minneapolis, USA

Agreed, Nicole is overated and most of us Aussie women can't stand how she's gone down the very un-Australian route of too much plastic surgery and botox... Cate or Naomi Watts would have been much better choices, but Baz seemed determined to put Nic in it...

Jem, Adelaide, Australia

Nicole Kidman is a GREAT actress! I love every movie she has been in. (eyes wide shut, not so much. Tom had to strut his stuff in that one). Looking forward to seeing Austrailia. Hey, stop dishing Nicole, whomever does; greeneyed jealousy. Keep making great movies, will see every one!

Wendy McDonald, Braselton, usa

Nicole Kidman has her share of dudds, but she's pretty decent actress. I don't think she's done anything to warrant this kind of vindictive slash job.
I loved her in 'The Others'...she has me on the edge of my seat every time I watch it.

dina little, massapequa, ny, USA

Way what you will, Kidman is one of the most beautiful women alive, to ridcule her like you did, I would hate to think
what kind of personality you must be. You might not like her for
this role. But stiff she is not! She is one of our most enduring Stars!!!!!!!!

Judy, Metropolis il, United States

Right on the money love, and you could add that Jackaman character to the list of hopeless actors. What a ham!

Dave , Nambour, Australia

I guess Kate Winslet would have been a better choice. Oh thats right, she has lost every time she has been nominated for an Oscar. Criticism from a talentless country should be taken with a grain of salt.

Simon, Sydney, Australia

When you look at successful actors, De Niro, Hanks or the lesser known but equally talented Seymour Hoffman, it's plain to see that looks are not all that important. Where are the female equivalents of Steve Buscemi? Less than 7/10 on the attractiveness scale doesn't cut it if your female. Why?

Louisa, Dundee, United Kingdom

First, she's a red-head. Second, who could be good in "Eyes Wide Shut?" Third, she was pretty good in "Dead Calm." She ain't the best but she's no worse than the Kris Kristoffersons (great songwriter, lousy actor), Megan what's-her-name ("America's Sweetheart" or so says her publicist) etc....

Abu Nudnik, Toronto,

This type of clever hatchet job makes for dramatic movie reviews, but has no bearing in the reality of acting or film. This reviewer either has no understanding of the trade or is purposely trying to generate a following of like-minded, ignorant sociopaths.

Robert, New York, USA

I feel the same way about Russell Crowe.

Paul Neri, Canberra, Australia

Hey! What's wrong with Paltrow? She was great in "The Royal Tennenbaums." Hilarious, in fact.

Abu Nudnik, Toronto,

I agree with Lisa - Naomi Watts would have been the better choice.

I will never ever pay too watch Nicole Kidman, Katie Holmes or Jennifer Aniston in a film; they are boring & act the same in every single film.

Sarah Tartaglia, Brisbane, Australia

Agree 100% - and the same goes for S. Johannsen, L. di Caprio, J. Law and all the other pretty-but-totally-wooden actors around. All are targetted at the producers' favourite moviegoing 15-25 demographic - who surely must get as fed up with Barbie and Ken playing the lead roles as everyone else is?

Rose , Salwa, Kuwait

Give Nicole a break! Tall poppies anyone? The failure of some (not all of the movies she has been in are NOT her fault, I for one enjoy her work and she did win an Oscar, wasn't that voted by other women?

Mark, Sydney, Australia

Never did like her, in Bangkok Hilton, was superb, however once hooked up with Cruise it was like she didn't have to try and act anymore.

MCG, NSW, Australia

This not over yet? Reid may yet win the Silver Sandbag award over this. But why do readers fault Kidman for lack of speech clarity? Are there any actors who do not mumble and grunt their way through lines? Nobody enunctiates anymore. Well, okay, Jack Nicholson.

JvO, Sarnia, Canada

A bit harsh, but I generally feel the same way. Cate Blanchett and Abbie Cornish are probably the best aussie actresses, but they would've had projects lined up already. I think Claire Van Der Boom from Rush and Jessica Marais from Rafters will be the next big things.

Hayden, Melbourne, Australia

I'm afraid I have to agree. The most overpaid and over rated "actress" in the history of film.
She looks to me as though she's in a perpetual trance.
What they were thinking of to pick her for this film is beyond all understanding. Banking on her name to pull the crowds I imagine.

Ray, sydney,

Yeah! I'm not alone. I have believed this for years. Nicole Kidman cannot act. I have not seen the movie Australia and do not intend to. Fake accents make my skin crawl. Why didn't they use an English actress. It didn't need to be someone famous they could have discovered a brilliant new talent.

Abbey, Byron Bay, Australia

Yep, that just about covers it. More celebrity than artist, but that's nothing new.

Japers, Melbourne, Australia

This IS acting. A role in whichever movie Nicole's been cast. You are watching the fruit of someone's imagination, not Nicole herself. Give her a break. Are we Aussie girls all supposed to look like Amazons? Why is she chosen for any role? She CAN act!! Prod/Directors choose her because she's good.

Di, Queensland, Australia

Wow, all these experts.
It just comes down to who you do and don't like.
I guess there's no pleasing everyone.
If she's as bad as everyone claims her to be,why does she
continue to get all the leading rolls?
I think she's a wonderful Aussie, a great actress and I can't
wait to see the movie.

Anne, Kempsey, Australia

Nicole Kidman is boring and can't act her way out of a paper bag. The same is not true of Gwyneth Paltrow, who has much more warmth on screen. Keira Knightley can't act either, but she is beautiful enough to make it work.

Ben F., Westport, New York

Finally someone who isn't afraid to speak the truth in the face of the publicity mega machine that is Kidman!

She genuinely can't act. Unfair she is paid so much for delivering so little.

Lesser known Aussie actressess who are brilliant and real deserve their chance to shine

Jennifer, Gold Coast, Australia

Couldn't agree more!!!! Since she first appeared on Australian screens in a trashy teenage 80's movie called "BMX Bandits", many of us have shared your views, & I've yet to see one performance of hers that could make me think she is anything but a third rate soapy star....

Scott Hartley, Sydney, Australia

They should've considered two other Aussie actresses who are both beautiful and talented in their craft.....Cate Blanchett & Naomi Watts!!!

Lisa McDowell, Darwin, Australia

Exactly the sort of review we Australians have come to expect from English journalists about anything - film, sport, ballet, take your pick.

Rosemary, Sydney,

I'm not a Kidman fan, but ouch! That was mean. I was pained just reading it.

Nick, Florida, USA

If Nicole is miscast, then I suppose we must assume so is Hugh Jackman...I mean..a film entitled "Australia"without Russell Crowe? Or Guy Pearce? Or Cate Blanchette? Or Naomi Watts? Or Simon Baker? Or...and the list goes on! There will always be differing opinions about casting ...!

NL Harwood, Denver, USA

Your bashing Eyes Wide Shut --one of the best films of the last ten years-- basically nullifies your entire piece. I stopped reading right there. Thanks for trying!

Justin, Los Angeles, CA

My first instinct to this article was outrage but when you really think about it, she's actually right to some degree.
There are lots of fantastic Australian women that could have done the part beautifully. Naomi Watts comes to mind as she really was born in England and hasn't been frozen by Btox

frances Cardamone, Melbourne, Australia

Kidman was fine in Dead Calm, The Peacemaker, The Others and The Hours, really don't know why you are getting so upset.
Julia Roberts on the other hand....that mouth ....I can't watch.

swedgwick, London, UK

Finally the truth about this woman.. I Never thought I would live to see the day but I am so glad I did.

patrice, chicago, usa

People need to give Nicole Kidman a break, how can you people be so cruel, It had to have been difficult for her to go threw what she has been going threw, especially her time in Los Angelas with Mr. Crusie. Anyways, give her a break, bashing is so 20th century...

Fabian Starr, Charlotte, USA

Thank you !! I thought I was the only one who believed that Nicole Kidman couldn't act her way out of a paper bag. I would love to see a great Australian movie but Nicole Kidman leaves me cold. We needed someone who could portray emotions with depth and feeling.

Annie, Brisbane, Australia

I believe nicole is a good and versatile actor , and a beautiful women. I loved her in Moulin Rouge. Zoe, you wish that men would think of you as they think of nicole!!!! If they did you would be the star .

nelson, srasota,

well what has she got?
just about every director wants her in his movies and so does the big time actors who want to play opposite

neale

dusty, brisbane qld , australia

I'm a woman and I've don't dislike Nicole Kidman at all. You however sound awfully sour.

Ingrid, London, Uk

I watched her on Letterman last night... What a trainwreck!

Thom, Fresno, USA

Nicole is playing a regal British woman. I think swanning around like a lost porcelin doll is rather accurate way to depict a posh Londoner.

Nathan, Sydney, Australia

Well, Im male and I have no desire to see her. Either for her acting skills or her beauty. I have not enjoyed any movie that she has been in and never was attracted to her looks in any way. So lets hope that Hugh Jackman can carry her and the movie.

Troy, Goshen, USA

Please do not speak for me, I am a female cinemagoer (and a film student and feminist) and I like Nicole Kidman. She's hardly the 'kiss of death', apart from being a good actress she sells tickets! Do you actually have anything to say useful to say about the film or just a personal tirade on Kidman?

Claire, Belfast,

Hey, us men don't see anything in her either! We always thought it was women who thought she was great. The empress has no clothes.

Luke, Melbourne,

Finally, someone has gone on the record regarding her lack of talent. Despite playing every type of role, Ms Kidman has shown that she cannot act. Her numerous mediocre and lousy performances make "To Die For" and "The Hours" mere anomolies. We should not be subjected to her lack of talent.

Jill, paris, france

Finally, someone who shares my opinions on Nicole Kidman. She is definately so overated as an actor and yes you are right again, I am Australian and I won't be going to see the movie because she is in it. Cate Blanchette should have been cast.

Gerrie, Brisbane, Australia

Don't worry. Men think she's a shambles as well.

Phil, Mount Isa, Australia

I loved Nicole Kidman in Bewitched. She was wonderful. I completely fell in love with her. She was so sweet and inocent. It has to be hard to be famous. I like what she said That She will only go where her Husban can go. I aggree. I only take my wife where she feels welcome.

Dave, San Jose,Ca, USA

well the difference is. anne hathaway is pretty but she's not striking like nicole kidman, they have very different looks. Also , men don't really find nicole kidman attractive, it generally is the women who think she is. i haven't met any men who find her attractive.

Zoe, Manchester,

they could have cast Naomi Watts (also an Australian) in that role, or as someone else posted on this forum, Charlize Theron.

Dana Garner, Sacramento , US

Kidman was exceptioanl in 'The Hours' though, I can't believe the author of this article didn't even mention that movie. I also liked her in 'Eyes Wide Shut'.

Dana Garner, Sacramento , US

Kiera Knightley - good grief! Couldn't act her way out of a paper bag. Her Elizabeth Bennet was a joke - turned P&P into a comedy. Well, perhaps I'm being too hard on the girl; she could fit in well with Abbott and Costello, if they were still around. But certainly nothing dramac

NMR, Richmond,

Kidman, like all of our "big" actors are soulless, politically correct beings. They have been brought down by isolation money and fame. They are so disconnected from normal people, they can no longer select and star in movies that are appealing to large audiences of normal people. Sad

Sara, Houston, USA

Agree with the author. Kidman is just pure pain to watch.
She saps the life out of every take. Ditto Keira Knightly and Gwyneth Paltrow. I love the way Knightly looks and admire Gwyneth for her style but they are women without spirit or gravatas or sex appeal. They miss the X factor.

pcollier, London, England

Don't prefer her, definitely not in my top 50 of actresses, but I think your article is harsh and unnecessary.

Bill, Philly, USA

Thank you, thank you, thank you! I feel exactly the same as the author...as does every woman I know. This woman is HORRIBLE. I can say, I have NEVER seen her movies in the theatre and I never will.

Jennifer Cunningham, San Francisco, USA

I completely agree with this commentary. I loved Moulin Rouge - mostly for the songs and Ewan MacGregor, and Nicole sang pretty well, but otherwise she pops me out of the movie every time. She just doesn't get into the roles in myopinion. Add Julia Roberts to the list, too.

chole' tiscornia, Murrieta, USA

I thought Kidman was good in "The Others", but it's true, she whispers and I can't hear her. The actress that drives me nuts is Renee Zellweger. Her constipated look is maddening.

elise, Gator Country FL, USA

Cat fight!

J. Alejandro, Hudsonville, MI, USA

What about Julia Roberts, she the worst ever. She can stop a movie dead in it's tracks.

john, Springfield, USA

They should have cast Charlize Theron for this movie. She is in a class of her own; not only stunningly beautiful, but a superb actress too. Yes, I agree Nicole Kidman is completely over rated. She just doesn't have 'it'.

Gina, NYC, USA

Gus Van Sant was the only reason she did well in To Die For.
He went on to direct Good Will Hunting and Finding Forrester, now Milk. I can't think of anything she's done, oh, wait a minute. I did see a an ad for Golden Compass when it opened.

Katherine Meade, Nashville, USA

In the much-reviled THE INVASION, she channelled the spirit of 60s/70s actress Sandy Dennis (Whose Afraid of Virginia Woolf?) while adding stunning beauty to the equation.

Let her play real grown-ups, not naive paper-dolls, and we'll see what she can really do.

James M, Doha,

It's not fair to criticize her for Eyes Wide Shut. No one could shine in a film that horrible.

Mark J, Kansas City , USA

I think you are wrong. I'm a woman and I love her movies. I will go see this movie because she is in it. I think she's graceful and beautiful.

Elaine, Albuquerque, USA

Has this reporter even seen The Hours! Nicole is amazing in that film!

Em, London,

In order to act, your face has to move. Kidman's face doesn't move anymore. Like Joan Allen in The Bourne Ultimatum. I used to love her but when I saw her in the latest Bourne movie I was so disappointed! She is a good actress, unlike Kidman, but she can't act with a face that can't move.

Diane, NYC, USA

I agree with the author, but not her point of view. Nocole Kidman is a terrible actress, just terrible. No argument. But to say that she gets a pass because directors are male, is ridiculous. Tom Cruise, is in film after film and he's the absolute worst terrible actor of all time. Explain that!

Derek , San Jose, CA, USA

MEOW!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Melanie get rejected, did she?

wallyamn, morris, usa

OK - you don't like Nicole Kidman. But nothing in this article says you saw the movie you are trashing wholesale. Don't convict the entire movie on 'guilt by association' of one cast member.

DMorrow, Annapolis, USA

I won't be so harsh as to say that she cannot act. But I think she can only play certain roles, like the frozen snow queen type. For some reason casting directors haven't realized that and have stuck her into every movie and expect a blockbuster hit. And we are getting sick of seeing her.

Gigi, bloomsfield, USA

I can't stand Kidman. She whispers her lines - I'm turning up the volume every time she's in a movie. She's terrible. And she's not all that great to look at either. What a sappy excuse for an actress. Zombie on prozac.

Kat, Everett, USA

Let's see how it does.But I saw a clip of it wih that gorgeous hunk, Hugh Jackman (is that his name?) and it was LUDICROUS!! All I could think was "GAWWWD-awful".
As for Kidman, it's not just that she can't act, it's that something cold and calculating in her eyes and the way she pinches her mouth

elizabeth schumann, Paris, France

Don't just say that women hate her...I'm a man and I can't stand Nicole Kidman, and for all of the same reasons you listed...#1 being she CAN'T act!!

Wes, Plano, TX,

Nicole Kidmanhas made the mistake so many 40ish ACTORS HAVE--bOTOX. I saw her on Oprah and it was frightening--her upper lipnever moved. Unfortuantely, when she is on screen now, you are so distracted by how she has mutilated herself that you can't focus on her performance.

Ann K. burke, Boynton Beach, US

What a ridiculous statement that the women of the world will turn as one on "one of their own". Talk of living in an enlightened age when columnists will claim that women work as one great, bullying clique,

Gordon Saunder, Oxford, England

This does sound a little personal like you'd had a few too many glasses of red before you wrote this.

She is out there, giving it a go and as a fellow Australian, I will be supporting the movie and going to watch it.

D Judge, Brisbane, Australia

Those who have no talent, criticize. Lady, get a life. You do not speak for all women. I am one and as it happens, couldn't disagree with you more on the appeal of Ms. Kidman. I'd far rather see one her movies than read another column by you. Good luck and try to get some help for that anger thing.

Laura, Auckland, New Zealand

Not true. Kidman starred in some very good movies such as Far and Away. And she was terrific in Birthday Girl while the movie itself was bad.

Anton, New York, USA

This is exactly how I feel about Kidman! Hit the nail on the head! She is a horrible actress. She never seems "real" in any role I've seen her in. She is absolutely the main reason I'm not interested in seeing Australia.

L Van, Maryland, USA

What ? because she hasn't kissed Madonna or endorsed gay marriage suddenly she can't act? She is a woman of a thousand faces and as a producer /writer I would have her in my film or script in a hearbeat.

Michael Angelo Meyer, Mainstreet , USA

Cold Mountain as well as Nicole Kidman were excellent! Thanks for your opinion but I disagree.

Tim, Atchison, USA

For everyone claiming that Ms. Reid is jealous, do you honestly think any woman would be that jealous of an immobile face? We could buy one of those if we really wanted.
She can't act. Gwyneth Paltrow can't act. Keira Knightley can't act. Amen to Melanie Reid.

Michele, Vancouver, Canada

Something tells me that if Kidman were to publically get an abortion and bash Gov Palin, Reid would give her five stars. We are seeing liberal women writers show their sick side more and more as they attack normal, family loving women..if they are pretty..that is key.

Mary, columbus, usa

I thought Kidman was fantastic in "Moulin Rouge".

Daniel, Sterling, USA

I have enjoyed many of Nicole Kidman's movies. I thought she was great , and I will probably see her movies in the future.

shawnee, Austin, USA

This is why I prefer old movies.

Ingrid Bergman and Bette Davis weren't just 'stars', they captivate with their talent.

Mary Catherine, Elmhurst, US

You're absolutely right-Nicole Kidman cannot act her way out of wet paper bag. I never saw the fascination with her besides her obvious charms-looks, but as you mentioned, her performances come off rather vacuous and not compelling.

Joseph, phoenix, USA

She's a decent actress and one of the most beautiful women I've scene. I think there's a lot of jealousy out there... you are special too. ;-P

Joe, Seattle, US of A

I agree with the writer regarding Gwyneth Paltrow and Keira Knightly. Paltrow, especially, is bland at best. She seems to think a smirk is all she needs in order to emote onscreen. I love Nicole Kidman, though, if only because she dresses so beautifully. Loved "Moulin Rouge," too.

Madeleine, New York, USA

Thank you for finally expressing what everyone I know has been saying for years--Nicole Kidman cannot act! Australia looks like it could be a great movie...assuming it had different leading lady.

By the by, isn't Naomi Watts Australian? Couldn't she had done this film?

Alora, Brighton,

I'm a woman and Nicole Kidman is one of my favorite actresses. I thought Moulin Rouge, Cold Mountain, The Others, etc were all great movies! Moulin Rouge is actually one of my favorites. When I saw she was going to be in this movie I actually made a personal note to go see it as soon as it comes out

Alison, , USA

did you not see Moulin Rouge? She was amazing! You can't deny that.

Mike Kim, DC, USA

I think you hit the nail on the head with this article. Nicole Kidman is so annoying.

Laura, Jacksonville,

This woman is overrated! She marries Tom Cruise, she becomes more successful. She divorces Tom Cruise, and suddenly she wins an oscar for wearing a fake nose in THE HOURS. She is drop dead gorgeous, and has looked really good when she has done full frontal nudity , but that's about it.

Thom, Tampa, USA

how can you write this article and not address The Hours i.e. the movie nicole kidman won *best actress* for???

erik mitchell, bronxville, usa

I can't wait to see Australia. What a stupid statement to say women movie goers won't see it because Kidman is in it. I am a woman and never considered NOT seeing it because of Kidman. I'm looking forward to it!

Stacey, huntington beach, USA

I think if Nicole would stop with the breathy baby voiced interviews, she could be taken more seriously. She seems way to self concious and into coming off as a great beauty rather than a great actor. And could someone please convince her to stop with the botox?

sandy, SAN FRANCISCO, USA

The only thing I thought she was compelling in and owned was the rooftop perfume commercial.

Nenajo, Oglesby, USA

I'm a woman and I think Nicole Kidman is just gorgeous. But I've always like the pale look (garish crispy tans don't really do it for me). I loved The Others, Moulin Rouge and several other Kidman movies, so I'm really not sure what you're talking about. You can't really generalize.

Rachael, Houston,

I'm actually going to see the movie BECAUSE Nicole Kidman is in it. That and I love Baz Luhrmann's stuff. And while I don't particularly like to look at them, I think GP and KN aren't bad either. I really don't understand the bitter and vitriolic tone of this article.

Dannie, Dowagiac, USA

Nicole Kidman is an actress of rare beauty whose only crime is being in possession of a limited acting range (the botox doesn't help...) Ms Kidman is exceptionally good at portraying naked fear/ terror (which is unfortunate when used in a comedy like The Stepford Wives). Poor casting is to blame!

Chris Clark, Nottingham,

I rather like her. I thought she was good in DEAD CALM and TO DIE FOR (as you mentioned). I thought THE OTHERS was also good.

Fuji, Winston, US

Her acting is terrible that is correct. She can't act! She is classy although not beautiful, she has a grace about her that is refeshing...I agree with the article.If it is starring Nicole Kidman then I don't go...boring!

Kelley McElroy, Black Diamond, USA

What an embarrassment to Australian and world cinema... she's about as interesting and warm as a box of frozen peas.
Perhaps, with a few acting lessons, she might one day learn to do a convincing Aussie accent...

Jess, London,

I'm afraid that you're right. She was on The Late Show with David Letterman last night and the interview seemed awkward. Letterman wanted to talk about her husband, her children, and things other than the movie. She seemed lost and just wanted to stick to a script.

Colin, Hampton, USA

So glad someone else is saying the things I've always said about Paltrow, Knightley and Kidman. Saying it's jealousy or something stupid like that doesn't fly since there are many beautiful actresses that women admire and love to watch. If we're paying for a movie we want someone who can act.

Anne, Lindon, USA

I have a suggestion. Pay no attention to the critics. If you like the actors, go see the movie. If you don't like the actors, don't watch the movie or TV show. Most of the movie critics are totaly useless and have never done anything worthwhile on their own.

Jack, Bogalusa, US

I agree with Melanie Reid -- Nicole Kidman is horrible as an actress. I will not pay money to see any movie she stars in.

Christine, San Diego, USA

I disagree (and I'm female). She can act, although she doesn't always do it. She was good in The Hours, To Die For and The Others, to name a few. You're the one stuck on her porcelain face. I hope, as she ages (and lets herself age), and can move into character roles, she proves you wrong.

Laura, Atlanta, USA

That prosthetic nose was the real Oscar winner.

Jess, London,

I agree with Reid's assessment of Kidman, and the comparison of Kidman with Paltrow. In fact, I think Gwenyth Paltrow is even worse. That woman couldn't act her way out of a cardboard box. However, I actually think Keira Knightly is a decent actress. Not amazing or transforming, but good.

Katherine, Fairfax, USA

Don't care much for Tom Cruise. Typical in-your-face-five-foot-four-wannabe-six-foot-two-persona. So go figure. 'Course I like Nikki. Aside from that, there's an kind of an ethereal air about her. Maybe her bat-like features, who knows...

JvO, Sarnia, Canada

Gwyneth Paltrow, Keira Knightley ? These actresses do not emote like the old generations but the grating emoting of the older generation of actresses too often brought the storyline to a stop and almost killed Hollywood in the 1970's until a mechanical shark and a bunch of rubber aliens rescued it.

Gregory Franke, Groton, CT, United States

She is completely awful!
In Eyes Wide Shut she was unbelievably bad.
The scene where se tried to act stoned, she came off as being special needs. Terrible 'actress', just terrible.

Michael, Chiacgo, USA

Meow. What a catty review.

I think Nicole Kidman is a wonderful actress. Far superior to her over-rated ex-husband.

Becky , Concord, USA

On the other hand, I thought she was quite effective
in the supernatural thriller "The Others."

Buckley, Silver Spring, USA

So well said. I have always fel there was somethingabout her that just didn't wrok, and this artical has pinned it down. Love Austrilia, but I will not see the movie.

STEVE, DALLAS, U.S.A.

So how come Gwyneth won the Oscar if she can't act?

Chip, columbia, usa

You're spot on! Since Dead Calm, Kidman's acting skills AND sex appeal have disappeared. In that time, I've seen Days of Thunder and Bewitched. Both are rubbish. There are plenty of Aussie actresses that can out-act Kidman ... Rachel Griffiths, Mirando Otto, Toni Collette and Naomi Watts

Mike, Denver, CO, USA

Wow, angry much (not to mention catty and shallow?)? I love Nicole Kidman. I think she has a lot of depth, and almost always enjoy the films she choses to be part of.

Michelle, Chicago, USA

She's just one of those "muhh" actors really. I don't think good or bad of her "skill" (if you want to call acting that). I wouldn't rush out to see a film she's in, nor would I avoid it.

Personally though, I thought she was good in BMX Bandits and Bankok Hilton. Now I'm showing my age!

Tori, London,

Melanie Reid,
Your evaluation of all these actors is utterly prejudice.. I believe you speak for yourself. Have you attempt acting before? I wish to see you try on any of these actors’s “skin” and see how you do!

Oh, for your next review check out “Bollywood” female actors …
bad, bad acting!

Sonia, Toronto, Canada

I think this writer is ead on!. I cant stand Kidman and will not see her movies ,Ill give her a 5 or 6 on attraction but her acting is stiff and contrived!

greg, mount clemens, usa

Keira Knightley is the most overrated actress at the moment directors really need to wake up.

Amy, London,

Completely, completely agree.

PS. No one actually drinks Foster's in Australia. In fact the first time I saw it in a pub was in London.

Susan, London, UK

The reason Kidman cannot convey emotion is because her face no longer allows for it, after all that hideous plastic surgery. She once was pretty, and she would have matured into a gorgeous lady, had it not been for the addiction to plastic surgery.

Bob Hunter, Denver, USA

134 comments; come on guys, get a life

David, Nottingham, UK

I've never really associated many Hollywood actors or actresses with acting.

Michael, Ankara, Turkey

Finally, someone who has read my mind. I have always felt this about her, Julia Roberts, and Meryl Streep. Really no emotion in their acting. If they are in the movie, I usually do not see it. All overrated for sure. I am tired of the model-type actresses we are getting today.

Jean, Cary, NC, USA

I always thought it was the other way around- that men tolerated Kidman but it was the women who inexplicably loved her.

You're right, she's terrible! I still have nightmares about having to watch Moulin Rouge again.

But let's face it, most mainstream actors/musicians/artists are awful these days

steve, Oklahoma City,

I have not seen this movie but Kidman is a very talented and expresive actress who has apparently roiled the hackles of this critic. Personal, mean spirited attacks are fine in a blog but for this publication to elevate Ms. Reids scathing atack as reporting is sad.....

brian cole, vallejo, United States

Sour grapes..what a bunch of vitriolic blather. Miss Reid is most likely a typical angry feminist who despises any woman who exhibits classic feminine qualities. May I remind you that you are a journalist not an artist, and the artists of film (woman included) have rewarded her with numerous awards

David, Wichita, USA

Oh dear, oh dear... Bad day, Melanie? Oh, and I'm glad someone (Cathy, Switzerland) mentioned "The Others." Rather well executed by Kidman. Can I throw you a towel, Melanie?

JvO, Sarnia, Canada

Women actors don't need to be ugly and angry to have talent. Considering those 'types' have invaded practically every other corner of the entertainment industry, it's refreshing to see a classical, 'classy' feme fatale.

JoeLiberty, Houston, USA

Which women did you refer to? I'm a woman and I will purposely GO to a movie if Nicole is in it. But then I'm not jealous of powerful women like Hillary either, so Nicole being beautiful and nice doesn't make me insecure. She is a class act....deal with it.

Beth, Los Angeles, USA

Nicole Kidman isn't the most talented actres - but she is certainly not as bad as you portray her to be. And Gwyneth Paltrow and Keira Knightly happen to be fantastic at what they do.

Marley, Chicago, US

I can't believe someone is actually admitting this. She completely ruined Cold Mountain. Not only was her acting bad, but her accent was horrendous. Kiera Knightley and Gwyneth Paltrow are both the same way! I'm shocked that it's being said in print.

Lindsey, missouri, usa

She was excellent in "The Hours." But otherwise agree.

A, Teddington, UK

I think Melanie has put her finger on it. I always felt there was an emptiness in Nicole's acting. She did a good job in Practical Magic...but then she played a pretty air-head...type casting. And she was opposite Sandra Bullock who can save any movie. Nicole seems to be overdosing on Riddlin.

Phocus, Prescott, AZ, USA

What a stupid nasty article. I want those 30 seconds of my life back. I agree with Karen from New Orleans, Julia Roberts is the most overrated and overpaid actress on the planet. As for Kiera? Yuck..how do ppl see past the teeth, chin and annoying acting? I like Nicole, she has grace and style.

Bill Terkel, LA, USA

Kidman is an amazing and accomplished actor. I think this article is completely off base!

Lance Friedman, chicago, usa

I 100% agree with this article...I have never been able to stand Kidman...she can't act and really is the most over-hyped actress. Cate Blanchett and Naomi Watts are both far far superior actresses (and better looking).

Pusca, Christchurch, New zealand

Perhaps jeaolosy played a large part in this review?

I happen to think Nicole Kidman is a wonderful actress. Her role in Cold Mountain was captivating. It's one of my favorite movies. Sure, she's been in some bad movies...who hasn't? But blame the script or the director, not the actor.

Ray, New Hampshire, USA

"...she's pretty and we're (your) jealous..." thats really the reason you don't like her. By the way, the theme of "Eyes Wide Shut" was the lack of intellectual and sexual heat between Cruise and Kidman and Cruise's search for it. So based on your observation I would say she did a good job.

Steve, Jacksonville,

Melanie Reid, quite obviously, haven't seen Dodville where Kidman was sensational besides many other films.

As an actress and a director I can tell you that her acting is superb and well regarded in the industry.

Jane K, London, UK

You want news? Today, actors don't act because they don't know how, the same is true for directors, writers and producers. So, you ask, how come they make all this money? Here's the answer everyone...because the vast majority of you are culturally illiterate, that's why.

Edward, Chicago, USA

Moulin Rouge was the worst movie that will ever be made. How was it possible to make a movie set in a French whore house with lingeried women in every scene that every straight guy hated?

DigitalBob, The States,

I like her and the movies she is in. What a nasty article you write about her. Perhaps she has rebuffed you in the not so distant past? You appear jealous and bitter. I'm a female and think her movies are very good. Dead Calm, one of her first, was quite a thriller!

Kyra, Somewhere, USA

It's not only women who find Ms. Kidman uninteresting. The world has an enormous surplus of skinny blondes.

Honeysuckle Weeks can act rings around the lot of them. If she's not a big star in 10 years, it's either because she doesn't want it or moviegoers have poor judgement.

Scott Palmer, Indianapolis, USA

I think Nicole Kidman had red blood flowing in her veins back in the day when she had curly red hair and freckles. She was really good in Dead Calm, and her early Australian movies were pretty good. But now she is so self-conscious of her beauty, so wooden cold and waxen...souless.

Milly Orbit, Singapore, Singapore

I am a women who loves Nicole Kidman as an actress, however, I won't be seeing this movie because it looks boring.

Quinn, redding,

FINALLY someone says it! SHE CAN'T ACT and she does not have that "it" factor that a superstar must have. Go back and watch Practical Magic. When she's on the screen with Sandra Bullock, your eyes go to Bullock...that's the difference between an actress and a STAR!

Hildy, Laughlin, NV, USA

She's not that bad - it's not like she's Julia Roberts or *gag* Renee Zellweger.

Erin, Independence, MO

i'm an american female & like nicole kidman.

lee, usa,

Poor Nicole - she seems to rile lots of folk, however no-one has mentioned Dogville in which she was chillingly excellent and The Interpreter another good role.

jo , Whitstable, United kingdom

She chooses harsh and bad movies yes.. but she is a good actress and is acting out the part in her manner. IF you aren't pleased just submit a name that you think would have improved that film instead of just being anxiously worried that she didn't send you off to the moon with romantic awe.

gumball, Pearland, texas USA

I guess most of you are too young to remember Billy Bathgate because she was pretty good in relation to a damn good cast.
(D. Hoffman, B. Willis, Stanley Tucci) I read one comment that said she does not do the "Slutty thing". Not sure what that means as she has done full frontal several times

Barry, New York City, USA

The truth at last! Couldn't agree more.

cath, cairns, australia

I don't hate Kidman either...I am a woman, pretty discerning too I would say. Perhaps Elle Macpherson was the other option...I like Kidman and don't think she is particularly beautiful... Her Irish nose brings her down to earth for me but she is graceful. You are too harsh.

maddison, london, england

I have to agree a little.
Nicole Kidman used to be lovely - see Far and Away, To Die For. She was full of charm and vivacity. Now she seems to have not only morphed her acting into a cold, sharp facade, but also her looks.
Perhaps Rose Byrne or Cate Blanchet would have been better choices?

Allison, Wellington, New Zealand

I agree aside from the male-bashing. I've always said Kidman acts like the lobotimized. But I don't think it was men driving Moulin Rouge or other Bar Lurman box office. Women need to take some accountability for the Kidman phenomenon. It's your fault.

Steve, New York, USA

Kidman was incredible in "The Hours" as Virginia Wolfe.

Lily, Canada,

AMEN sister, AMEN!

L U, Houston, USA

Are you kidding? Moulin Rouge and To Die For were superb! Moulin Rouge is one my top 10 favourite movies of all time and certainly top 5 musicals. She is such a part of that - you take her away - I don't think so. She is SOOOO much better then anything I've seen Tom Cruise do

Donald D, London, Canada

Outstanding - I couldn't have said it better myself!

Julia, Hammersmith,

When will film makers learn that when we pay to see a movie we want someone on screen with acting ablility, Kidman can't act. She looks good on the red carpet but thats it. She would do better working car shows standing in front of a new car and waving at people as they passed by.

Dennis, Decatur, US

I'm a woman, guess I didn't get the memo about hating Nicole Kidman. For some reason that I can't explain I like her very much. Maybe I like her because she managed to survive a marriage to Tom Cruise and resisted Scientology and came out of all of that with her integrity in tact.

Kelly, Indiana, USA

She got where she is by marrying Tom Cruise.....and, her
eyes are always PINK.............she's not pretty, she's fake.

kit hogan, seattle, usa

I can't disagree more. She mesmerizes me, captivates me, and if I were a banker, well, she's money in the bank as far as I'm concern. She is a rare beauty, one of the most beautiful women in the world, and an actress in the league of the femme fatale.

Thaddeus, San Diego, USA

I always considered her underrated and under appreciated. She is one of the true beauties of the screen - like from the 30's and 40's. She is a subtle actresses - and like Marylin Monroe has the same insecurity - she thinks she can't act - but can. She is pure class - which is a rarity in Hollywood.

Will, Florida, USA

I have always thought she couldn't act-nor was very pretty. I always assumed her career was fueled by the success of Tom Cruise. Now she is leaching on another "celebrity" whose name escapes me and isn't worth looking up in Google.

Kaz, St. Louis, USA

I couldn't agree more about Gwyneth Paltrow's acting abilities.
In "A Perfect Murder," with Michael Douglas, I kept waiting for her to show some emotion. It was painful. I could have done a better job.

sari, new york city,

Wrong. Julia Roberts is the worst! Most over-rated actress. I still have nightmares thinking about them "giving" her an academy award.

Karen, New Orleans, LA

I love Nicole Kidman - and I don't know of anyone that is put off by her being in a film.
That crown goes to Keira Knightley.

Andrea, London,

Hear hear! Thank you Melanie Reid for pointing out how unbelievably overrated Kidman is. (And for all that Botox she isn't even attractive.)

Omar, Cleveland, OH, USA

I think thats rubbish! Nicole Kidman is fantastic - i loved Moulin Rouge and am really looking forward another film with her & Baz. I find it is men who don't 'get' Nicole because she does not do the whole slutty thing, she just looks icily beautiful! Real dignity too over split w/ Tom.

Victoria, London, UK

Following on the Pike/Blanchett comparison, perhaps pastiness emphasises doe-eyed wonder? - think 'Far and Away' and even 'Days of Thunder' where she was the most tepid feisty red-hed concievable...

E. Dellert, London,

While we're at it let's add Scarlet Johanson, Katie Holmes, Jessica Alba, Jessica Biel, Paris Hilton and Emma Scot Tomson to the list of flawless female actors who pout and scream very beautifully, but cannot act to save their lives.

Marita, London, UK

What a great review,basically voicing opinions I have had for years.I myself cannot abide Kidman,my four-year-old could perform with more style and content, than this wet lettuce.

Estella E, Leeds, England

As a guy, understand exactly what you mean. Attractive but no depth, but there is a lack in good female actresses in general at the moment - Knightley is terrible (and over hyped as being attractive). The likes of Blanchett or someone like Rosamund Pike may have been better.

Andy, London,

I'm a woman, you are spot on here. Her acting pretending to be serious really irritate me and put me off big time. I don't like her at all when she's doing any serious actings. On the other hand she does quite well for i.e. Practical Magic or other witch role, which she naturally fits in perfectly!

Amelia Dawn, London, UK

I'm woman, read a bit of her diary to hello mag. She kept diary while filming, she's so vague, sickeningly romantic oh, what can I say? She put me off. I'm surprised Chanel's still airing that No.5 CM this year. She doesn't appeal to the majority of women, she's completely gone off with botoxed face

Jane Watson, London,

as an actor, i am absolutely amazed at this article. what a bunch of bull! when you look at the poor movies kidman has been in, it is not the fault of HER not being good, but rather the direction, screenplay, etc. hate her all you want, but the woman can act. and very damn well!

jamie , brooklyn, USA

Please don't speak for me or group me with "the worlds female cinemagoers" (is that even a word?) either, as I beg to differ with your opinion. I think Nicole is a great actress and have enjoyed every film I've seen her in.

trixie, Sooke , Canada

I definitely think Nicole Kidman is an overrated actor, and her excessive use of botox has stunted her facial capacity to display emotion. There are few movies which I can sit through with her blank looks and whispy voice.
However I must say she was brilliant in the movie Birth.

Lara, Sydney,

Interesting you ignore such key Kidman performances. The Hours? Moulin Rouge? Fur? Hell, even Stepford Wives. Theres a chance her performance is not top notch, but you arent talking about the possibility of it being Baz's shortcommings as a director. Each actor has some roles that arent up to par.

Cecilia, Guaynabo, Puerto Rico

I agree with the new female "actresses" that just beautiful faces, but to say that we woman hate Nicole Kidman is a tad presumptuous. Actually, after her divorce from the now tyrannical Tom Cruise, I would say we women rather like her. Her problem is is that she whispers every line in every film.

Poppy, London, England

Nicole Kidman is one of my favorite actresses, don't speak for me! My husband and adult son enjoy some movies she's in, but she's never a draw for them. I always look forward to her movies because I tend to think that I'm going to like the story--she's usually in such wonderful storied (?)movies.

Lori, San Francisco,

Couldn't agree with this writeup more. As an Aussie woman myself, I died a little bit on the inside when I heard Baz was casting Kidman in this role. She jumped the shark a long time ago. The woman couldn't act her way out of a paper bag. She's far too self concious on screen.

Ana, sydney, australia

if she is such a great film actress why do all of her recent films keep bombing at the theatre and dvd?

jamie, melbourne,

That's rubbish, I think she is a good actress and she would not put me off seeing the film at all. She was great in the Hours and I've enjoyed several of her other films. She is watchable as is Gweneth Paltrow. In fact this is the first time I heard such critcism and it seems pretty unsubstantiated.

Lavina, London, UK

To Melanie Reid...

Why is Nicole Kidman bad in Australia? Did you even see the film? If you didn't, then that's a pretty shoddy editorial on your part.

Dead Calm, The Hours, Moulin Rouge!, Margot at the Wedding, are all great performances, to name a few.

Sounds like you are jealous much.

Lia Beachy, Los Angeles, CA, Unites States

After reading the beginning of this article, and after reading about how women hate Nicole Kidman, I looked to see who the author of this glorious piece of journalism was. A woman. Surpirse! More female-bashing by a fellow female. How boring.

Nicole, San Diego, USA

What about "The Hours"? Are you saying she can't act, because if you've seen that movie then you know she can. Why do you hate someone you don't even know that much? I don't get people these days.

A Woman who likes Nicole, Santa Barbara, CA

She is better than an actress.
For me , used to sublime old french movies ,starring Delphine Seyrig and Emmanuelle Riva in Alain Resnais 's movies Hiroshima mon amour and l'annee derniere a Marienbad , Nicole Kidman is part of the same magical brightness as these fabulous actresses.

francoise, london,

I'm not a fan of her looks, but, after seeing her in the Hours, she gained enormous respect from me for her acting. I thoroughly enjoyed every aspect of Cold Mountain, including her performance in it.
I can do without sex scenes in films though, so, Australia, I may pass on that.

filmaker, Los Angeles, Los Angeles

I was just going to mention The Hours. You can't deny she is an actress when you watch that movie, she does an amazing job. Why does everyone feel that they need to put down celebrities that they don't even know? What a hateful article.

A Woman who likes Nicole, Santa Barbara, CA

It's about time someone caught up with "Our Nic". Well said and well overdue.

Katie, Hong Kong,

Kidman has been around for years and there is a reason why. What passes for "acting" in today's Hollywood is pathetic. Check out "The Others" and tell me who you think could have played that part to perfection.

Cathy, Switzerland,

I disagree- she does pose in the way Knightley does. But to me it's not bad acting. It's old school Hollywood acting. Which I adore and find refreshing to see. Sometimes Im not interested in seeing a raw, real performance, but a lil' Garbo/Dietrich glam. Noone does period like her and Keira.

juan, toronto, canada

I don't think it's true that all women hate Nicole and are turned off by a film that stars her. Personally I think she's an amazing actress (esp in moulin rouge) and very beautiful in an elegant way. Be kind!

Sonia H, London,

The only thing this article is wrong about is that men can't stand her either. I, like most of my male friends, think she's utterly bland and sexless. I always assumed she was one of those women that women find attractive, but apparently not. Apart from the 76 posters, who likes her?

Norton , Beijing, China

I completely agree, she wasnt bad in Moulin Rouge but generally shes not a great actress, & she is not beautiful, she is too pale, too blond, too thin and she has a huge forehead. people may say im just jealous but she is the last celebrity I would want to look like! she WAS hot when she was younger

kate, saitama, japan

Erm.... The Hours? Dogville? Nicole Kidman is amazing and has an Oscar to prove it, end of.

Bradley Morris, Darlington, UK

Nicole is pretty samey... she was appalling in Batman forever, Eyes Wide Shut... In a lot of her films she is ok but she just 'is' Nicole Kidman as opposed to convincing you that she is the character she is playing.Keira Knightley is definitely worse. She just pouts around with her stupid accent...

Jane Monks, Reading, UK

How nasty.

How very accurate.

It's not just women who have noticed. I place Glenn Close in there too, I can't bear to look at her.

David, St Albans, UK

Nicole behaves like a woman who has never had an orgasm. She would be better known as the "ice queen" and im not just talking about her acting. She is boredom personified!

Robert, Sydney, Australia

I agree with the reviewer. Kidman gives the same frozen perfomance in all her films. She ruined Cold Mountain, partly because she was too old to play the ingenue but also because she was just too cold and unsympathetic to make you care about her character. Her success is a mystery.

mike scott, NY, USA

Ginger, too thin and not very good looking. I don't know any blokes who can stand her either.

Alex Evans, Sydney, Australia

As an Australian and a woman I have to agree wholeheartedly with your statement Ms Kidman cannot act. She can't. The movie would have been a winner with talent such as Cate Blanchette or even a bloody star of Neighbours might have done better.....

K Kirda, sydney, Australia

Nicole seems to polarise opinion more than most.

Personally I think her performances in films like Dogville,The Others , The Hours , To Die For and Dead Calm were all outstanding .

Maybe glamorous blondes are fated to be under-rated on the screen as well as in real life.

Tony, Jeddah,

of course she cant act but then 99% of women cant.Acting requires a deep knowledge of real life and suffering to be at its best whereas the modern females lifestyle is one of total self-indulgence,decadence and vacuity.

rob, colchester, uk

Forget about Nicole Kidman.
The posters promoting the "epic movie Australia " forgot to put TASMANIA on the map depicting the country.

Sheila Mary Beamish, Kingston, Australia

Kidman's portrayal of Virginia Woolf was a absolute insult to all VW fans. She has never lit up the screen and is as inanimate as a store mannequin. I have to agree that she is the most overrated actress on the planet.

robina Jaffray, Canberra, Australia

Nicole is a pretty good actress. A seasoned pro. Not a lot of range, not great, but the camera loves her. And that is why she keeps working.
I must say in her defense, she has worked with some real clod, mannequin actors. Jackman, Cruise, how would you like to drag those guys through a scene?

kb, kansas city, usa

Miaow! And I'm not just saying that because I won't hear a word said against the goddess who is Keira Knightley...

Stephen, Glasgow,

Excuse me but Keira Knightley is a powerful actress, my fav in fact, I adore her work.

wanda, folsom, usa

Well said! It's about time people recognised that being able to act seems to be a secondary skill for an A lister. And while we're on the subject it's not just female actors - John Malkovich and Nicolas Cage spring to mind!

Andy, London, UK

You are forgetting "Dogville", which is her best film up to date, despite (or maybe because of) the obvious contrast between her hollywood glamour and the disturbed world of director Lars von Trier. Only the fact that she was brave enough to take on that role makes me like her. I'm a woman.

Maria, Lyon, France

There is one comment in here that, for me, hits it right on the money:
"What a brilliant opportunity this was for Australia to introduce a bright, young star to the screen"

Iain, Thurso,

you forgot to mention the correlation between frozen-gaze and botox.

Piers Little, London, UK

This article is definitely too harsh. While I don't like her in everything, I've liked her in plenty of things. Moulin Rouge is one of the best movies I've seen and she was fantastic in it.

Leslie, Benicia, CA, USA

She was great in Moulin Rouge, I love that film!

Moona, London, UK

I like her, too. I found this review overly harsh. I have liked all of her movies. I think she's a fine actress. And by the way, I'm a woman.

Leigh Anne, Houston,

have u see the hours?????amazing.
she can act she is beauitful and most of all people dp admire her.
for some reason i would think u might be envious

Brendan O'Donnell, tipperary, ireland

As a woman I have been a fan of Nicole Kidman for years. Moulin Rouge was superb. She is far from being emotionless in films. Retract the claws kitty cat......

Bella, philadelphia, usa

What a crazy review.

The only valid point is that her skin is flawless and like porcelain and maybe a little hard for ANY individual to aspire to.

This sounds like a review a bitter and cold hearted person in my view.

Greg, Melbourne, Australia

You want to talk about talentless female actors? Why don't you mention the real ones like Jessica Alba who keep getting roles after roles just because she is hot? Yet you go after Nicole, Gwyneth and Keira who are not all that bad. They may not be the best, but this is some serious exaggeration.

Julie, Los Angeles,

I can NOT DISAGREE more! Have a look at her in the hours by Stephen Daldry. A masterpiece in every aspect. I am getting so sick of those reviewers who think they know something about acting or directing by just sitting behind her desk. This review is just far too subjective in my opinion!

Pip, London, UK

Sadly the only reason I am not going to see Australia is because of Nicole Kidman. I could not think of anything more painful than setting through an epic with her in it. I don't hate her, I just think she is boring, dull, and nothing about her appeals to me. I'd rather watch paint dry.

karen , Byron Bay, australia

SO TRUE! Why wasn't Cate Blanchet cast for the part???

claire, seattle, u.s.

You are a bad judge of good acting ----Nicole Kidman is a great and beautiful actress

Lisa, new york city, usa

Glad someone is saying this out loud; I would have loved Australia with Naomi Watts starring...

Jo, Vancouver,

Nail on the head! I'm a Brit now living in Australia and yesterday there was a quick show of hands in the school playground to see who wanted to go see this film. Every single person said they would like to if it were not for the fact that not one of us could stand watching Nicole Kidman for 3 hours

DD, Canberra, Australia

I am an avid film-goer and an actress, and I love Nicole Kidman. She was fantastic in Cold Mountain (a movie I resisted seeing due to all the hype) and to judge Eyes Wide Shut on her performance is ludicrous - she was the only thing worth watching in that film. Can't wait to see Australia!

Roxanne , Toronto, Canada

I think Nicole is a wooden actress. Very stilted Not convincing at all, and I have tried to watch her movies. She looks hard, even when she smiles her eyes have no emotion.

and I'm not joining the Nicole bashing bandwagon, just making observations.

tony, kingaroy, australia

People read Perez Hilton for scathing, pathetic commentary on celebrities. Grow up.

Carla, London, UK

Wow...I could not disagree more. If Nicole's guilty of anything it's accepting these types of porcelain doll roles. (Though I can hardly blame her: Say no to a romantic lead with Hugh or Ewan? Riiight.) She's always been intensely believeable to me and I totally enjoy seeing her onscreen.

Marie, California,, U.S.

I'm woman and I completely agree with everything in this review! I was looking forward to this film, until I heard Kidman was cast. She's just brings nothining to the table. Watching her lips inflate and deflate in the press is enough, I don't want to sit through two hours of her Botox forehead.

Jane, Vancouver, Canada

I am inclined to agree with you about Kidman. She was horrid in "Eyes.." Just because she manages to say her lines and not bump into the furniture that does not make her worth all the money she commands. She didn't even play a convincing pregnant woman in real life.

Sherry, San Francisco, USA

I'm a woman. I love Nicole Kidman. I'm not sure what your problem with her is, but I'm so excited to see this film because I think she is a great actress!! Moulin Rouge is one of my favorite movies ever.

nicole, muncie,

As an up and coming Australian Aboriginal Actress i cant wait to show the world what real Australian talent is...Nicole your days are numbered...

Sandy, Melbourne, Australia

I agree. I think Kidman is vastly overrated as an actress, and,
also overrated as a 'Beauty'. Like another great 'beauty', Catherine Deneuve, when you look into the eyes - there's nothing there. I loved Deneuve, and I'd like to love Kidman ( I have nothing against her), but where's the talent?

Carle Wilson, Brevard, NC,

Im a woman, have been all my life (haha), and i really like her...Moulin Rouge is one of my all time fav movies and this director is also one of my favs..I WILL, go see it!

scarlett, clifton, usa

What on earth did Nicole Kidman ever do to you?? This is the most bizzare review I've ever read. You depict her in a way that doesn't come close to being true. As if you have some kind of grudge against her. Strange.

Betsy Swetnam, Fishers, USA

Don't speak for everybody, Im a woman and I love Nicole Kidman, I would watch almost anything with her in it because I think she's a fantastic actress.

Don't generalize, if you don't like her that's fine, but don't say we all hate her or find her overrated because that's just not true.

Kathia, Miami,

Kidman and botox do not miss, but she is still a great talent (albiet one with out the ability to move her face). There is a fear in Kidman that radiates to her pictures and this is a weakness. The girl needs lots of therapy, sure, but she can still act

Caroline, Felton, USA

Hey, I'm a woman and I don't hate Nicole. In fact, I do like her performance in many films. So... am I sick? is there somethng wrong with me? Of course not!

I think it's terrible the way you speak for all us "the world's female cinemagoers".

Raquel, Mexico city, Mexico

um, how about the Hours. I think Nicole Kidman is a wonderful actress. Actually, I think she is one of the best. She is always absorbing herself into the role. Unlike actors like, Tom Cruise, Kidman becomes the character she is portraying rather than having the character become her.

Rebecca, Washington, D.C., USA

I don't care what you have to say about Nicole Kidman, she was spectacular in Moulin Rouge. The girl can sing as well as act.

Jen, San Diego, California

Kidman can be hit and miss, and her excessive botox isn't helping lately. But you wldly exaggerate this to 'no talent', so the piece does come off as a vendetta. You can be jealous without wishing to be someone - jealous and resentful that person gets attention for being nothing special.

Christine, Brisbane, Australia

This article is full of horrible generalisations that are unfair to both sexes. Plenty of women like Nicole. And there are men who think she's overrated. You say it's not jealousy, but don't argue so convincingly. Instead you invoke the convenient idea that women are more innately perceptive.

Christine, Brisbane, Australia

She should change her name to Kidwoman.

Baz is the hype MACHINE!

Sean Ho, Brisbane, Australia

Look I dont know about Nicole bashing! but why why do we have to have the same old sorry storyline. Now if I had the money to buy the rights and make a film there is only one writer Peter Carey and his fabulous book 'Ilywhacker' now there is a script to make a great creative australian story.

Catherine, Sydney, Australia

Look I dont know about Nicole bashing! but why why do we have to same old sorry storyline. Now if I had the money to buy the rights and make a film there is only one writer Peter Carey and his fabulous book 'Ilywhacker' now there is a script to make a great creative australian story.

Catherine, Sydney, Australia

For too many years myself and most of my friends have battered our heads against the wall (and cinema doors) wondering how Nicole Kidman manages to land these roles. She can not act, full stop. Daily details of her boring life splashed across various media is the epicentre of depravity.

Craigie B, Sydney, Australia

'Surely Aussie women are meant to be tough outdoor healthy-looking Sheilas??'

Like Cate Blanchett? Or Rose Byrne? Or Kylie?

90% of Australians now live in cities. And avoid adding to the world's highest rate of skin cancer. Weathered outback shelias aren't common.

Nicole - great in The Others

Sian, Melbourne, Australia

i have wondered for years how she still gets offered roles. I simply cant understand it. Did anyone watch the Stepford wives?

i agree she looks like a porcelain doll, but one that has been covered in a lacquer to stop it falling apart....

only women would argue she is attractive.

david k, Brisbane, Australia

Nicole Kidman is one of a very small number of amazing female actors on this planet, Cait Blanchett being another. For a country with such a small population, Australia punches well above her weight when presenting our talented folk to the world. If I find a cure for cynicism, I will let you know.

Helen, Melbourne, Australia

That reads exactly like what it claims not to be."I hate you, you're pretty, and you must pay". Nicole has made some clangers, but she was good in Moulin Rouge, The Others, The Hours. As for Cold Mount, well she was stuck with the truly awful Jude Law. Bet Meg isn't offended by his lack of talent.

Mdc, Toronto, Canada

There's plenty of Aussies that are embarassed about this movie... not just Kidman. It's made to a US formula for people that subscribe to the shallow jingoistic vision of Oz where everyone says crikey a lot... in the same way that everyone in England wears bowler hats and swings an umbrella. Ugh

Peter, Melbourne, Australia

At last! Someone finally said it! Nicole Kidman is a very average actress, with all the emotional range you'd expect from someone who's singlehandly keeping the Botox business afloat. Most people I know would like to see "Australia" - if only Cate Blanchett had the lead role.

Katrina, Melbourne,

Nicole gets paid way too much to play the same stepford wife - and geez wasn't that woeful - over and over. Melanie, Thanks for articulating what so many think about Nicole on screen.

Kevi, Sydney , Australia

She destroys every film she is in irrespective of the supporting cast. The remade Stepford Wives bombed, Dead Calm was rubbish, Bewitched - an insult to the memory of Elizabeth Montgomery and I could go on. Every film she is in flops.

Anna, Sydney, Australia

In my humble female opinion, Keira Knightley is a far, far worse offender than Nicole. To all those male directors (and they are still largely male, did someone say glass ceiling?): put your tongues back in, do your reputations a favour, and wake up to the fact that POUTING DOES NOT EQUAL ACTING!!

Abi, Toronto, Canada

Go Melanie! Totally agree. Nicole is the most insipid actress and why on earth Baz cast her is a mystery - I certainly won't be rushing out to see this one.

LJ, Sydney, Australia

Whilst I am not a big fan of Kidman, I do think she does shine in certain roles. I have yet to see Australia so I can't comment, however the work she did earlier in her career in Australia was magnificent: Bangkok Hilton, Dead Calm, Vietnam, Emerald City and dare I mention it, BMX Bandits.

shaygb, Eatons Hill, Australia

What a brilliant opportunity this was for Australia to introduce a bright, young star to the screen... all but let down by Baz-L and his myopia.

Don't blame Nic, blame him!

P.S Yes, she's rubbish.

David, Melbourne, Australia

Nicole's brittleness, her fragility, delicate beauty, refinement, remoteness are all part of her mystique. She's elusive, ethereal, unattainable.

Dillon, Sydney, Australia

I know its "Un-Australian" of me but I think she's been awful and over acts in everything I've seen her in. I wonder if anyone would have ever heard of her if she hadn't been Mrs Cruise. That was a smart career move by Nicole, but then again neither of them can act

Tim, Sydney, Australia

Couldn't agree more. It is a complete mystery how this actress can be in such demand from directors/producers. I would really like to read an article or thesis attempting to explain this. Nicole Kidman is obviously very clever and very focussed but how did she manage to get this far? A puzzle!

Cate, Sydney, Australia

Jeez, I must be a moron, I actually like Nicole. Jeez double moron, I actually like the movies she's been in. It sure beats attending road traffic accidents and finding murder victims. Escapism at is best. Thanks Nicole.

helen, ballarat, australia

i wonder if all you judgemental, hard nose critics do your job as well as nicole kidman does?

tri, St.Kilda,

Completely agree. My dislike turned to loathing when I made the mistake of seeing that stupid film - To Die For. I just don't understand how she still gets paid so much for delivering so little. Hopefully this stupid movie will finally wake people up.

Rob, Cairns, Australia

Winner of 3 Golden Globes, 1 BAFTA 1 Oscar, 1 BSFC, 1 Critics Choice Award, 2 Empire Awards, 2 Logies, 2 ALFS..
Need I go on about how wrong you are!
P.S. I am a female cinemagoer and I'm Australian!
P.P.S Melanie get out of the village & stop talking to the cows!

Joanna, London, England

Nicole Kidman always seems to be playing the same character, it's like she can't step out of herself. Sometimes it suits the role, often it shows a limited range. I don't like her voice, it's often breathy and wheezy without conviction. Visible cosmetic surgery (pumped lips) is a nono for actors.

Barbara Fischer, Melbourne, Australia

Agree totally. The most annoying woman on film. Maybe if she backed off on all the botox, her face would give the appearance of some emotion. A terrrible, terrible actress who should step aside and let some real talent take the leading roles.

Simone, Melbourne , Australia

Finally someone to write it as it is. Nicole Kidman cannot act, and never has. I agree no emotion. A face that is stuck frozen all the time. I watched her on Oprah last night, again straight out of the freezer onto your screen.

And she knows she cant act

actress ABSOLUTELY NOt!

Joycey, Brisbane , Australia

I cannot agree with coments about Russell Crowe's acting ability.Whatever one thinks of him as a celebrity, his acting as Geoff Wygan in "The Insider" was channeling, pure mastery.

Simon V, Sydney, Australia

isn't it funny (and how this writer predicted) that men on this blogger are sticking up for Nicole and the women aren't. well I'm a pretty honest fella with good taste and have to agree with Melanie. Nicole is a bore and hardly rates in anything (that said, I will have to see "to die for" now!)

Laids, Adelaide, South Australia

Ms Reid

I speak for the silent majority of Australians; living in and outside of the great southern land. Your analysis is correct.

Ms Kidman is miscast in this role as she has been in many others.

There is no comparison between Ms Kidman and our greatest Actress Cate Blanchett.

Bart, New York, USA

I both agree & disagree with the reviewer. Nicole Kidman can do great work given the right material & direction - "The Hours", "Birth", "To Die For". Her choice of material is often unfortunate, particularly in regard to commercial ventures & I don't like Baz Luhrmann's direction - hammy & cliched.

Patrick, Melbourne, Australia

Being of Australian heritage I have 2 say I completely disagree with this verbal abusive attack on Nicole.Nicole is very talented & nobody else would hv played the roles she played better.She has won the hearts of millions of people all around the world especially us Aussies,especially us Aborigines

Lee, Ballina, Australia

Spot on Melanie! How Nicole Kidman came to be considered "an actor" is one of the greatest mysteries of modern times. She has always lacked facial expression, so her "acting style" only spans the range of exaggerated breathing -- she puffs, she gasps; she pants; she heaves . . .

Marnie, Sydney, Australia

I have been saying this for years and got the reaction from me of "oh but she's beautiful". She seems to shriek in every movie - i couldn't stand Moulin Rouge. And her face does not move at all - she cannot act.

Emma, Canberra, australia

Totally Agree I was so shocked to see her terrible acting in Cold Mount.. don't want to watch Australia cuz she's in it!Doesn't she get the ice maiden thing won't work!No person can call themselves an actor if they only know how to give a convincing performance because a directer gets it out

Annie, Sydney, Australia

Yes - I'm Australian and I agree. At work all the women said the same thing, she can't act, she's sexless and cold.
Mostly she puts on this teenager facade; the giggling and naive persona when she is a 40 year old women.
But male directors seem obsessed with her.
Cate Blanchett instead!

Marie, Mindarie, Australia

2 major generalisations there Melanie. (1) That All woman of the world loathe Nicole Kidman (you shouldnt consider asking your old gal pals what they think as being relevant research), & (2) That Nicole Kidman can't act. Eyes wide shut, The others, The Hours, Bangkok Hilton, Dead Calm, To Die For...

mike, melbourne, australia

Pretty brutal, but, unfortunately for Nicole, there's more than just a modicum of truth to the writer's take on her acting. Nicole, whilst pretty to look at -- with an almost-ethereal persona -- is very one-dimensional. Over the years, her acting roles have devolved into type.

Merv , Auckland, New Zealand

It's not just women and Australians aren't immune. She hasn't been in a good movie since BMX Bandits

Nick, Canberra, Australia

I completely agree with Melanie. I can't think of one movie that I've enjoyed watching her in. Her Oscar for The Hours was unfathomable. She just moons about and talks in an affected little girl voice. I can't stand watching either her or Russell Crowe and I'm Australian!

Amanda, Sydney, Australia

I agree with Melanie; Kidman looks wonderful in perfume adverts, but I just can't like her. No, it's not jealousy; Anne Hathaway also looks wonderful in perfume adverts, and I liked her in The Devil Wears Prada and Becoming Jane and she was excellent in Brokeback Mountain

Lucy, London,

I confess I would like to be tall, slim and rich.
But I bet if Nicole Kidman were honest she would say she would like to be able to do more than simper or let out the odd high pitched squeak in her attempts to "act". Surely Aussie women are meant to be tough outdoor healthy-looking Sheilas??

Laura, London,

Agree about Paltrow and Knightley. Unfair to Kidman. She CAN act. See her performance as a Russian mail-bride. Quite brilliant, especially the moment in the airline queue when she shows her husband how to pretend he's Russian. Also, "Eyes Wide Shut" IS a masterpiece, and largely thanks to her.

JF, Canterbury, UK

Nicole Kidman turns off other women?? Kidman is one of the ONLY actresses that I am interested in seeing on screen and one of the only actresses that deserves the credit she is given. She is in the Meryl Streep league as far as I'm concerned and continually sets the bar for other A-listers.

Gillian, New York,

Completely agree. I can't think of one great movie (Moulin Rouge was BORING) that she has been in and yet she rates so highly as a 'star'.

On the looks issue I would like to quote another reader who said: "she has the pulling power of a no beer, vegetarian BBQ".

It's a mystery.

Tom, Edo, Japan

Good for you Melanie. You have stated what many feel about Kidman. She can't act. She can't talk without using that ridiculous Marilyn Monroe breathy voice. It's beyond annoying. She either has the stone-faced expression or the shocked, big-eyed look. And no, I'm not jealous of her..get over it!

Emily, USA,

Sorry, Melanie, but you sound really jealous of Nicole. You may not think she can act, but Nicole has something about her that's eye catching and mystique. She can act as well as any of the other leading ladies of today.

Gail, Carrollton, USA

Oh yes, you're absolutely, completely, totally jelaous of Nicole Kidman.

jule, rome,