Rod Liddle
Enter our Snapshots of Summer photography competition
It takes a certain nerve and chutzpah to invoke the messiah approvingly when Christ’s followers are relentlessly persecuted at home in Iran by, er, Mahmoud himself. Christians who have been unable to get the hell out of Ahmadinejad’s Islamist hellhole are routinely arrested, have their property confiscated and their churches closed; at least one evangelical preacher faces the death penalty for “proselytising” and “apostasy”. Ahmadinejad didn’t disclose what he thought Christ would have to say about that. Maybe he thinks he wouldn’t mind too much, all things considered.
Channel 4 presumably thought this was provocative and cutting-edge television – “edgy”, I believe, is the adjective they strive for these days. Pointing the camera at a random madman and letting him rant is thus “edgy”, although it requires nothing in the way of wit or thought on the part of the broadcaster. It is instead broadcasting of the most unchallenging nature.
I suppose that if this were 1937, Channel 4 would hand over the Christmas Day airwaves to Hitler for a burst of free propaganda (“If Christ were alive today he’d annex the Sudetenland, round up the Jews and invade Czechoslovakia. Happy Christmas.”). And when the outraged complaints flooded in, a Channel 4 executive would then defend it thus: “Hitler is the leader of a very large and politically significant nation, and it is important that the British people hear his views.” Absurd, you might think – but this is almost precisely how Dorothy Byrne, Channel 4’s head of news and current affairs, defended their Only Fools and Jihadis Christmas Special. Yes, Dot, love, it is important to hear what deranged tyrants like Mahmoud have to say – but it would be nice to ask him a question here or there, wouldn’t it?
Can you imagine, for even the briefest glimmering of a nanosecond, Channel 4 issuing a similar invitation to President George W Bush? It is unthinkable; it would not remotely occur to the executives. That said, it wouldn’t surprise me if the entire Channel 4 schedule next Christmas were handed over to President Barack Obama for a 24-hour love-in, with cameo appearances from Jesse Jackson, the relatives of Rosa Parks and so on.
Channel 4 still delivers the goods, more often than not, especially in its news and current affairs – which is why the Ahmadinejad stuff is so disappointing; a cheap shock that reveals nothing other than a dearth of imagination, an obvious political bias and a certain contempt for the viewer. The broadcaster’s bosses – Luke Johnson, who made his name flogging overpriced pizzas to the middle classes, and Andy Duncan, who made his name marketing margarine – have been pleading for more money from the public purse. But is it of value to the public? Channel 4 is indeed a peculiar and uncomfortable hybrid of the public and the private and, much like the BBC, seems utterly unsure of what a public service remit should require it to do. Too often it wishes to stretch boundaries simply for the sake of it – such as encouraging the appalling Gillian McKeith to poke around in people’s stools in You Are What You Eat. And then travelling even further around the U-bend with old Mahmoud. Edgy, huh?
+ Teachers at a school in London acted swiftly and decisively when they saw one of their colleagues, Colin Adams, being throttled by a pupil. They hurried over and, in no uncertain terms, verbally indicated that they wished the child to desist. However, the child declined to desist. Eventually another teacher helped prise the child away. Premature physical intervention was out of the question, of course. Lay a finger on a child and that’s your job gone down the Swanee. A happy outcome, though – Adams eventually trousered £250,000 in compensation for severe stress, while the excitable child was rumoured to have been sent on a taxpayer-funded holiday, presumably to improve his sense of self-esteem.
Meanwhile, teachers have been told that they should no longer make their corrections to school homework in red ink, in case it both “demoralises” the pupils and stands out too much, in an oppressive manner, on the page. They should use a pencil, instead, so that the corrections can be rubbed out. Do you suppose there is any connection between the way children are treated while in school these days and the way some behave when they have left?
What a privilege it was to settle down with a glass of port after a traditional Christmas dinner, the logs crackling and spitting in the hearth, and enjoy President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad’s message to the nation on Channel 4. Christmas isn’t really Christmas for me unless I hear the unedited, unchallenged views of a despot, psychopath, maniac or bigot. It makes me feel slightly better about myself.
All the better, too, if it is someone with the brass neck of old Mahmoud. The subtext of his uplifting message (which he delivered, Boris Johnson fashion, tieless) was: Jesus Christ, were he alive today, would smite the Jews good and proper and also kick the expansionist Yankees.
Taking us for a ride again
Tally-ho! There is no finer sight on a Boxing Day morning than right-wing people on horseback not hunting foxes. A record number of these people turned out to not hunt foxes this year, apparently. Some availed themselves of loopholes in the law that allow you to kick a fox to death, or punch it repeatedly on the snout or indeed put it up against a wall and shoot it. The hunters insist the foxes thoroughly enjoyed being devoured by hounds, thrill of the chase and all that. But then they also said that the rural community would be “decimated” by the hunting ban. Not a single job lost, to my knowledge. Wonder if they’re right about the foxes.
Of course it’s awful – it’s an advert
“Want Longer Lasting Sex?” the billboards ask. “Any at all would be welcome, even for 15 seconds,” my wife replied with a rather dark grimace as we drove through London in the rain. These new ads – presumably for a firm of divorce lawyers – have apparently outraged some Londoners who consider them offensive. Well, yes, of course – they are adverts. That’s the point. I hate them all.
In terms of magnificent offensiveness nothing, though, quite matches the billboard erected directly opposite the Maudsley psychiatric hospital in south London a while back, advertising a popular chocolate bar. It was hastily taken down.
You will remember the famous slogan for Cadbury’s Fruit & Nut, I would guess.
- At this time of the year we are usually enjoined to remember that Christmas is a time for charitable works, for feeling a spiritual warmth towards our fellow men. I always have a problem with this, being by nature bitter, mean-spirited and insular. Luckily, though, this Christmas the tables have been turned: this time we are shopping to save the world, indulging ourselves for the good of mankind; urged to spend vast amounts of money to jump-start the economy and thus help those less fortunate than ourselves – City brokers, bankers, estate agents and so on.
We should take advantage of this rare alignment between selfishness and the good of society. Remember, as you wait all night in the queue for your cut-price Nintendo Wii: it’s what Jesus would have wanted.
Rod Liddle left his post as editor of the BBC's Today programme in 2002, after a row about impartiality in an article he wrote for The Guardian. He was formerly a speechwriter for the Labour Party. As well as writing for The Sunday Times, he contributes to The Spectator and Country Life and presents current affairs documentaries on television
Win a luxury weekend to Newcastle and its neighbour Gateshead, find out more here
Risk, resilience and embracing new technology
Industry sectors news at a glance. Interactive heatmap, video and podcast
Discover the collective power of smart thinking. Submit a solution and be in with a chance to win a Flip MinoHD Camcorder
The inside track on current trends in the charity, not for profit and social enterprise sectors
Everything the Business Traveller needs to know to make a better trip
Make the most of the summer and enter our fabulous photographic competition, you could win a £5000 holiday
Corsica is an island of beauty and contrast, an ideal holiday destination
Enjoy further reading from Travel to Fashion, Business to Sport, discover more
Shortcuts to help you find sections and articles
The clever way to lease a new car is with Car leasing made simple™
2009
42,945
2008
71,450
Car Insurance
Not Specified
MI6
UK-based
£60,000
The Environment Agency
Bristol
Up to £90K
Boots
Midlands
OTE £85k
Credit Protection Association
Nationwide Opportunities
Completely London
Luxury Condo's in Manhattan with NYC views
The best new homes in Wimbledon?
Nationwide
Save up to £1,000 per couple with Elite Vacations at the five-star Constance Lemuria Resort
and do the British Isles this Summer.
Save up to 60% with Oxford Hotels and Inns
Try our inspiring luxury holidays to the Indian Subcontinent and South East Asia.
Great offers available
8 fabulous Canadian cities ...you won’t find cheaper
Contact our advertising team for advertising and sponsorship in Times Online, The Times and The Sunday Times, or place your advertisement.
Times Online Services: Dating | Jobs | Property Search | Used Cars | Holidays | Births, Marriages, Deaths | Subscriptions | E-paper
News International associated websites: Globrix Property Search | Property Finder | Milkround
Copyright 2009 Times Newspapers Ltd.
This service is provided on Times Newspapers' standard Terms and Conditions. Please read our Privacy Policy.To inquire about a licence to reproduce material from Times Online, The Times or The Sunday Times, click here.This website is published by a member of the News International Group. News International Limited, 1 Virginia St, London E98 1XY, is the holding company for the News International group and is registered in England No 81701. VAT number GB 243 8054 69.
Ayatollah Ali Khamenei is Iran's Supreme Leader so Mahmoud Ahmadinejad is NOT a 'tyrant'.
Gordon Brown can use the Royal Perogative to go to war when he wants so has something approaching such an absolute power.
Andrew, Northallerton, UK
The cows that we eat are kept in concentration camps and killed on a production line. The foxes that some people hunt, on the other hand, live free and die fighting.
Paul Giles, Brussels,
My question to Channel 4 bosses is: does president Ahmadinajad give his victims the right to free speech at all. Why haven't they asked him about the destructive role of Iran in the region from Iraq to Lebanan to Gaza?
Yasseen Al-Naeeb, Bedford, UK
The swift and appropriate solution for dealing with unpalatable broadcasts is to consult a program timetable and switch over to something you will find enjoyable. I have taken advantage of this for many years ever since the feature was invented.
Mark Forster, Richmond, North Yorkshire, UK
Another reason to turn off Channel 4. James Mason oh yes Iran has been killing lots lately but it remains little reported. Human rights abuses and torture are just routine. 14 women now face death by stoning for "adultery" which may mean of course they are victims of rape or incest. One's pregnant
Leila, Newcastle, UK
The answer to very unpalatable broadcasts by any commercial broadcaster is to make sure that the companies advertising with that broadcaster are named and the viewing public made aware of those names. A marvelous attention getter.
David Clarke.
David Clarke, SEAFORD, United Kingdom
I am white and Christian and support the right to free speech at all times and from whomsoever has anything to say. Those who think we should cherry pick whose voices may be heard have much in common not only with Hitler and Stalin but with Saddam Hussain and GWBush...!!!
Joanna Jay, Walton on Thames, UK
Can we have Mahmaoud Ahmadenijad as the Prime Minister of England please. He would save this country from disaster it is heading to
Tony, London, England
No Andrew, Israel shouldn't just ignore the rocket attacks. What they should be doing is putting a stop to the illegal occupation in Palestine. However it appears they're doing the complete opposite. So the rockets will continue to fall on both sides of the 'border'.
Max, London, UK
To preach the Christian Message,to take Christian Books into a Islamic/Muslim Country is unlawfull,so please do not write otherwise,How many Christian Churches are there in Iran? I bet not as many Mosques as we have in the UK !!
Albert Cooper, Norwich, England
By giving the leader of a murderous regime the right to free speech, we tell his own people how much better our system is. We tell their leadership that we are not afraid of them and we remind ourselves of the principles of democracy which enlighten us all.
Critics go to hell, long live free speech
Donulvi Dolam, Sydney, Australia
Channel4 think they are clever. They are certainly sensationalist and condescending. I have no problem with Ahmadinejad being on tv, but.. for a mainstream channel to broadcast his speech on an important Christian day in Britain, calling it an "Alternative Christmas Message" .. was very unsavoury.
Leon, London, UK
If you believe in these sorts of things and Christ was to come back then he'd probably be some sort of spiritually enlightened individual. I doubt he'd meddle in politics and all those armageddon scenarios are dreamt up by what can only be described as seriously deluded people.
Richard Warwick, Croydon,
If they wanted to do something really edgy they can let Nick Griffin or Robert Mugabi do the Alternative Christmas message next year .
Unlike Iran we do have free speech so Channel 4 can broadcast what it likes but I fail to see why they should be given a single penny of public money to do so.
Paul Henry, London, Britain
Christians are free to worship in Iran...as are Jews and other minorities. The main religious minoruty that faces persecution are the Bahais - so quit the rubbish about Christian persecution in Iran.
Israel today killed 200 people - lets see how much sensationalism u will put into that story...
Jawan, London, UK
I find it odd that a lot off people call him tyrant or even Compare him to Hitler. As far as I am aware Iran has more tolarance to other Religions then any other country in the region including Isreal ( ask the people of Bethlehem) and have the 2nd largest Jew community in thr Middle East.
Ali, Newport,
Not a smart move by Channel 4. I hope this hits them in the pocket - who would want to associate their brand with this?
Reading the comments, why are people so one-eyed about Israel? They've been attacked by rockets for months. Are they just supposed to ignore it?
Andrew, Sydney, Australia
'Hitler is the leader of a very large and politically significant nation, and it is important that the British people hear his views. Absurd, you might think but this is almost precisely how Dorothy Byrne, Channel 4s head of news and current affairs, defended their Only Fools and Jihadis...
james, dalry, scotland
Being half British, half Iranian, I find your lack of knowledge of Iran quite shocking. Iran has one of the oldest Christian communities in the world, along with some of Christianity's oldest churches. There's about as much truth in your assertions as there is in saying Muslims are persecuted here.
Alan Kennedy, London, UK
would Jesus approve of the way the West has ignored the plight of the Palestinians? Would he have approved of the way we go to war for oil and to destroy 'weapons of mass destruction'? I think not. I am a christian and white and my family can be traced back to Devon in the 13th C. Keep speech free!
Martyn Gaylard, Bromley,
Last I looked, it was the Israelis who killed over 200 Palestinians yesterday, many of them civilians and children. The Iranians have not been doing much killing lately. Of course neither could hope to match the record of the US and the UK in being responsible for over a million deaths in Iraq!
James Mason, Dubai, UAE
Bit of a sensationalist rant. You completely diminish your words with your attitude. I might agree with some of the things you mention, but I'm going to be flat out and say it, this is not how journalists should write.
cai, cardiff,
Rod, cheers. This is exactly the message people need to hear. The moral equivocation of Channel 4 must be wholeheartedly condemned.
Michael C, Philadelphia, PA, USA
its quite easy to hit the off switch on you're tv
mike, exeter, uk
I suppose it is a shock for non- muslims to find out that muslims also believe in christ and his second coming back to this earth. And when it comes from a chap called Ahmedinejad it is even more unpalletable ! Is believing in Christ christian / jewish monopoly.
aejaz, salford,
Thanks Rod. You are such a breath of fresh air. I posted some sarcastic comment (though far less eloquently) to a Guardian forum yesterday, which was promptly deleted by the moderator. Funny how liberalism works: freedom of speech only for those who threaten it.
Mehran, London,
I hope that corporate advertisers will realise that Channel 4 is not an appropriate vehicle for their messages if they wish us to buy their products.
P Carter, Harpenden,