David Lister, Scotland Correspondent
Download 'Too Hot', an exclusive Specials track from iTunes
A Roman Catholic teenager has brought a landmark legal action against a council for sending her to live with Protestant foster parents.
The young woman, identified only as “AR”, is seeking damages of £70,000 from Highland council for housing her with two sets of Protestant foster parents after she was taken into care aged 8.
Now 18, she has been granted legal aid to mount a case against the council and was yesterday given the go-ahead for it to be heard in the Court of Session in Edinburgh, Scot-land’s supreme civil court.
In a written ruling after a brief hearing last Friday, Judge Lord Uist appeared to admit yesterday that the case was unprecedented, saying that it involved “novel and difficult questions of law”.
He added: “I think that the only appropriate forum for this action is the Court of Session. Indeed, I think that [its] unusual nature qualified it for the Court of Session more than many personal injury actions, some of very low value, which are customarily raised here.” If successful, the action would extend dramatically the boundaries of human rights legislation in Britain and could trigger a host of similar cases.
Legal papers were served on Highland council this year, while documents lodged before the court yesterday said only that the council had failed to accommodate the girl’s religious needs.
According to the papers, the council failed to ensure that she could follow “her religious persuasion throughout the period she was looked after and accommodated”.
The girl moved from the South of England to Alness in the Highlands with her mother, stepfather and brother, but in May 1997 was taken into care, according to the papers. She remained in care for most of the next nine years.
In addition to being housed with Protestant foster parents, the teenager alleges that she was sent to schools which did not provide lessons suitable for her learning disabilities.
She also claims that the council breached the European Convention on Human Rights by preventing her from having contact with her natural mother an alleged breach of the right to family life. The young woman claims that she suffered anxiety, depression and educational impairment and was so affected by the experience that she is still being treated by doctors. She also says that she finds it hard to get a job and has suffered loss of earnings as a result.
No date has been set for further hearings, and it is thought that the case is unlikely to go to court before the end of the year.
A spokesman for Highland Council said last night that it would strongly resist the claim. He said: “We will robustly defend this action, although at the moment it would be inappropriate for us to comment further because of the ongoing proceedings.”
Win a luxury weekend to Newcastle and its neighbour Gateshead, find out more here
Risk, resilience and embracing new technology
Industry sectors news at a glance. Interactive heatmap, video and podcast
Discover the power of collective thinking. Submit a solution and be in with a chance to win a Media Hub Home Entertainment System
The inside track on current trends in the charity, not for profit and social enterprise sectors
Everything the Business Traveller needs to know to make a better trip
Make the most of the summer and enter our fabulous photographic competition, you could win a £5000 holiday
Corsica is an island of beauty and contrast, an ideal holiday destination
Enjoy further reading from Travel to Fashion, Business to Sport, discover more
Shortcuts to help you find sections and articles
The clever way to lease a new car is with Car leasing made simple™
2009
per month on 36-month
Personal Contract Hire (PCH)
2008
42850
Car Insurance
£24,250 - £30,346
MI5
London
£60,000
The Environment Agency
Bristol
Up to £90K
Boots
Midlands
OTE £85k
Credit Protection Association
Nationwide Opportunities
Completely London
Luxury Condo's in Manhattan with NYC views
The best new homes in Wimbledon?
Nationwide
Fabulous Cruise And Cruise & Stay Offers Including Virgin Atlantic Flights Prices Start From Only £699pp!
Last Minute Cruise And Cruise & Stay Offers. Med From £499pp, Caribbean From £699pp!
5 star quality at a 3 star price.
8 fabulous Canadian cities ...you won’t find cheaper
Contact our advertising team for advertising and sponsorship in Times Online, The Times and The Sunday Times, or place your advertisement.
Times Online Services: Dating | Jobs | Property Search | Used Cars | Holidays | Births, Marriages, Deaths | Subscriptions | E-paper
News International associated websites: Globrix Property Search | Property Finder | Milkround
Copyright 2009 Times Newspapers Ltd.
This service is provided on Times Newspapers' standard Terms and Conditions. Please read our Privacy Policy.To inquire about a licence to reproduce material from Times Online, The Times or The Sunday Times, click here.This website is published by a member of the News International Group. News International Limited, 1 Virginia St, London E98 1XY, is the holding company for the News International group and is registered in England No 81701. VAT number GB 243 8054 69.
Why are all your correspondants on the defensive.Surely even protestant foster parents could have cared for the child´s Catholic needs!
When we look after a child its the whole child including the spiriual needs that need looking after.The Council concerned could have found a Catholic Family to have fostered her.Perhaps they had ulterior motives for not finding a Catholic Family.
Not all children who are taken away from their parents have been taken away justly.Your correspondents must be careful.Many mistakes have been made and will continue to be made.
Some children have been removed from their parents for reasons which beggar belief.
However we still must protect the most volnuable children.But how do you do that if they cannot even follow God in the way they have been brought up?NOTHING IS MORE IMPORTANT THAN LOVING GOD FIRST ABOVE ALL OTHER THINGS.
Myke & Dr.Miriam Rosenthal-English, Füssen, Deutschland
This is not a ridiculous girl. I know great Protestants but nothing compares with the fullness of the Catholic Faith. We need nothing less to help us with life's challenges.
Father Bryan Storey , Tintagel, UK
Obviously a very ungrateful young woman, who doesn't think much of the care of her foster parents. I wonder did she ask to be taken to her beloved RC church? and as to meeting her birth mother....obviously the authorities had good reason for not allowing this young lady from seeing her. I know of two young RC children brought up in a Protestant home...they were taken to their Church and to their RC School without any trouble but this case really 'takes the biscuit'.
William, Londonderry, Northern Ireland
My cousin's recently started fostering and I think she's doing a fantastic job. It's such a hard thing to do and something foster parent's aren't rewarded enough for. Caring for any child is touch, but one that isn't your own who most likely has behavioural/psychological problems is a whole other basket. To any foster parents out there, keep doing your best; Good on you!
This girl should step back and take a good look at herself!
S. K. , London,
My mother was a foster parent for 16 years specializing in medically fragile infants (we also took older kids). While the county always tried to ensure that children be placed in a foster home of the same ethnicity, it was felt to be more important that he be placed with people whose skills matched his needs.
This backfired occasionally (I am brought to mind of a little boy who called my mother a dirty word because his own mother had taught him to call white women by that word), but on the whole I believe it to have been the best method.
What prevented this little girl from attending church on her own? If she is old enough to make the distinction between sects and has the interest in attending church, then she could have attended alone, or found an elder to assist in her religious upbringing.
As for the prevention of contact with her mother, I can give several examples detailing when it was *not* in the child's best interest to see its mother, no matter the child's own feelings.
Sarah Ruth Paltiel, Concord, Calif., US
Sounds like an ambulance chasing lawyer has seen a way to make a quick buck through this woman. I can't see how we can win in this country. If children aren't taken away from unfit parents we're sued. If they're taken into care and their "religious" and "other" requirements aren't met then we're sued. Oh and if they're not fostered at all we're sued as well.
This woman is completely ungrateful and selfish. She can blame her lack of achievement on everyone and everything, but the reality is that only she is to blame. I really feel for her foster parents who tried to care for her. Actually I feel for foster parents everywhere. This case has put me completely off ever becoming a foster parent.
Stephanie, London, England
This is rediculous. She should be grateful that she got placed in a family home with people who cared for her. My mother had to live in a Childrens home back in the 50's.
A, London,
I feel sorry for her foster family. I do not agree that the action is appropriate. Does this mean that mixing ethnicity when placing children will be an arguable ground? For differing political views? For vegetarians being placed with meat eating families?
Katie Palmer, London,