Dominic Kennedy
Win Sky+HD for a year and a trip to Barcelona
When Scientology officially opened its spectacular new British church in the Square Mile, the movement was given an unusually warm embrace by the Establishment. Ian Luder, an Alderman of the Corporation of London and a magistrate, lauded the organisation’s anti-drugs efforts. “The work which you do in this area is greatly to be welcomed,” he said, “and I wish you growing success.”
It was a satisfying moment for a group that yearns for respectability and is striving to transform its image from that of a shadowy cult to a mainstream religion.
The new building, opened last November in Queen Victoria Street near St Paul’s Cathedral, is part of a global expansion, with fresh sites in New York, Johannesburg, Madrid and Berlin. In Britain, Scientology has built up a small fortune in property, while its influence grows through businesses, charities and educational offshoots promoting its philosophies.
Its wealth in the UK has been estimated at £18 million, based on the Companies House records for its main corporate body – but it now values its property portfolio as nearly twice that alone.
Scientology draws a distinction between its churches and what it calls secular bodies promoting the beliefs of the movement’s founder, the late science fiction writer L. Ron Hubbard.
However, when all is added together, The Times calculates that the value of the pro-Hubbard empire in Britain today is £57 million, with an annual turnover and income of £17 million. Not bad for an organisation that had only 1,781 adherents in England and Wales in the last census. How did this happen?
Scientology has old roots in Britain. From 1959 to 1967, Hubbard lived at Saint Hill Manor, an 18th-century pile set amid gardens, woods and lakes at East Grinstead. It developed an unusual set of practices, which leave it open to accusations that it exists as a money-making enterprise, targeting a combination of vulnerable addicts and the rich and famous.
Scientology is probably unique in that it keeps its sacred texts secret until, typically, devotees have paid enough money to learn what they say. “The goal is to make your way up the Bridge of Total Freedom,” Monique Yingling, an American tax lawyer who advises Scientology, told The Times.
The Bridge can be reached either through “auditing”, a practice reminiscent of one-to-one counselling, or by coursework, where several individuals may study under a supervisor at once. Auditing is the more expensive route.
Some anti-Scientology campaigners claim that the cost of completing all the courses can set an individual back $380,000 (£190,000). When The Times put this figure to Bob Keenan, director of the umbrella L Ron Hubbard Foundation, he adopted an ironic tone and said: “I wish.” He accepted, though, that the price of the “Premier Auditor Training Saint Hill Special Briefing Course Package” could be $33,932. “That’s the largest course that can be done,” Mr Keenan said.
Scientology has a singular structure. The Religious Technology Centre, chaired in America by David Miscavige, the de facto leader of the movement, claims ownership of the trademarks of scientology. Trademark law is used to enforce hierarchical power. Any church falling out of line with the centre can be stripped, through the courts, of permission to practise. Heretical offshoots or imitators may be stopped in their tracks. All Scientology’s texts are said to have been written by Hubbard. Since the full knowledge of the faith is reserved for those who complete the course, there can be no official confirmation to outsiders of what they ultimately believe. According to popular culture, Scientology teaches that 75 million years ago the intergalactic tyrant Xenu brought millions of space aliens to earth.
Hubbard’s writings are controlled by the California-based Church of Spiritual Technology. This uses copyright law to police access to the holy books, charging royalty fees to organisations, even churches. New technologies are used to ensure that the writings are kept “in forms that can withstand natural catastrophes”.
If this all looks rather businesslike, the World Institute of Scientology Enterprises formally promotes the application of Hubbard’s teachings to the workplace. It licenses the application of Hubbard’s methods in business.
Saint Hill remains at the heart of British scientology. It is the country’s highest-ranked church, while East Grinstead is home to a hub of ventures related to Scientology. Land Registry documents still show a conveyance bearing the name of “Lafayette Ron Hubbard” dated August 1959. The present owner of Saint Hill is the Church of Scientology Religious Education College Incorporated (Cosreci). Although this is Britain’s principal Scientology entity, it is based in Adelaide because South Australia, unlike Britain, recognises the movement as a religion for charity law.
Scientology says its most recent valuations show that its British religious properties are worth a total of £32 million. This may be pessimistic. The Times has been told by a property expert that its new church in the City of London has increased by a further £6 million to £18 million since that last valuation was done.
A copy of the latest Cosreci accounts filed at Companies House shows an annual income of £10 million and nonproperty assets of £10.8 million including £6.7 million cash. The main Hubbard-influenced charity is Narconon, which claims to provide therapy and education against drug abuse. It has an annual income of £520,000. The Greenfields School, which promotes Hubbard’s teachings for pupils aged 1 to 19, has £2.4 million assets and an annual turnover of £1 million.
A string of businesses can be linked to Hubbardism through prominent Scientology-related directors, solicitors and accountants, while another novel institution in scientology is the “celebrity centre”. While the likes of Tom Cruise and John Travolta may be expected to pop into the Hollywood centre, British scientology has attracted a more modest calibre of celebrity. Trustees of Narconon include the Polish cellist Baroness Soujata de Varis and Michael “Woody” Woodmansey, who played drums in David Bowie’s 1970s concept band, the Spiders from Mars.
Hubbard’s empire
Scientology
Religion
— Church of Scientology Religious Education College nonproperty assets
£10.8m; income £10.3m
— Nesta Investments assets £1m
— Church of Scientology Mission of Bournemouth assets £125,000
— SOR Services (UK) Assets £54,000; turnover £25,000
— New Era Publications UK assets £40,000; turnover £79,000
— Total religion: assets £11.9m; income/turnover £10.4m
Charities
— Narconon Trust assets £29,000; income £519,000
— Citizens’ Commission on Human Rights: assets £4,000; turnover £43,000
— Criminon United Kingdom assets £3,000; income £14,000
— Total charity: assets £36,000; turnover/income £537,000
Businesses
— G & G Food Supplies: assets £2m; turnover £4.6m
— Centrepoint Ltd: assets £2m
— Weald Property Investments assets £1.8m
— G&G Nutrition: assets £44,000
— Naturecheer: turnover £40,000
— Wellmore Int’l: assets £8,000
— Human Detoxification Services International: assets £5,000
— Organic Nutrition: assets £3,000
— Total business: assets £5.8m; turnover £4.6m
Property
— Saint Hill Manor and Castle, East Grinstead, £7.5m
— Bullards, East Grinstead, £1m
— Walsh Manor, Crowborough, £1.5m
— Queen Victoria St, London, £18m
— Tottenham Court Road £2.5m
— Two Manchester properties £5m
— Tyne & Wear £1.5m
— Plymouth £1m
— Edinburgh £360,000
— Total property: £38m
Education
— Greenfields Educational Trust assets £2m; turnover £1.4m
— Hubbard College of Administr’n assets £2,000; turnover £19,000
—Total education: assets £2m; turnover £1.4m
Explore your passion for food with the delights of Thai, Indian & Chinese cooking
In our new series, Tony Hawks takes a dry, wry look at modern life - junk mail, interminable meetings and snooty sales assistants
Read the training tips and advice that helped our London Triathletes
Read our exclusive 100 Years of Fleming and Bond interactive timeline, packed with original Times articles and reviews
The latest travel news plus the best hotels and gadgets for business travellers
Shortcuts to help you find sections and articles
2007
£30,000
2006
£14,337
2008
£39,937
Great car insurance deals online
c.£75,000
GlosFirstmeansbusiness
Gloucestershire
£32,795 - £41,545
Universitry of Southampton
Southampton
£
£32,795 - £41,545
Universitry of Southampton
Southampton
Competitive Package
Npower
West Midlands
1 & 2 Bed apartments
From £249,995
Great Investment, River Views
Great Dubai Investment Opportunities
from £89,950
low-cost ownership homes in London
Las Vegas SALE!
£POA
With Ramblers Worldwide Holidays!
£POA
List your property with two leading travel websites
£POA
Great travel insurance deals online
Contact our advertising team for advertising and sponsorship in Times Online, The Times and The Sunday Times. Globrix Property Search - find property for sale and rent in the UK. Milkround Job Search - for graduate careers in the UK. Visit our classified services and find jobs, used cars, property or holidays. Use our dating service, read our births, marriages and deaths announcements, or place your advertisement.
Copyright 2008 Times Newspapers Ltd.
This service is provided on Times Newspapers' standard Terms and Conditions. Please read our Privacy Policy.To inquire about a licence to reproduce material from Times Online, The Times or The Sunday Times, click here.This website is published by a member of the News International Group. News International Limited, 1 Virginia St, London E98 1XY, is the holding company for the News International group and is registered in England No 81701. VAT number GB 243 8054 69.
Scientology was expelled from the UK during the early 1970's but clearly readmitted subsequently.
Clearly the strength in these 'religions' are their financial empires. A reform would be to prevent any organsation claiming to be a religion from owning any property in any form. Why should a religion need property? Then we would see how long this nonsense would last.
Alan, Torbay, UK
A young girl is persecuted by her school officials for wearing a religious chastity ring, yet Scientology cult members are welcomed with open arms and loudly praised by an Alderman of the Corporation of London.
After this, what could possible make Britain look any more stupid?? And I thought that we in the States had our priorities completely backwards. I guess we're going to have to hand it to you Brits on this one. Comparatively, one school's actions and one alderman makes America look pretty much normal.
Scott, Durham, NC, USA
There's a wealth if information out there about this cult. Read as much as you can and see it for what it is.
A real faker, out for financial gain and control of the individual. Members have no credibility and deserve the contempt and riducle they receive.
M.J.Dorset, Sussex,
Even in this day and age, people will believe anything. These scams make money by exploiting the uneducated and gullible. Says heaps about the education systems we have in place, doesn't it?
If you're willing to believe in and financially support the great bearded one in the sky, then you might as well believe in Xenu.
They are both bogus.
Michieux, Melbourne, Australia
If the Mormons can gain respectability, then I suppose that this crew probably has some hope of someday being accepted as a real religion. Probably take a few generations. But possible. Sadly enough...
Ben Hoff, NJ, USA
wonderful article, make a report of this kind of stuffs is the best thing a newspaper can do, cause too much people believe in this fake churches, who're only a money's machine...the times should always be THE THUNDERER, as it doesn't happen quite soon....
valentina , milan, italy
I've been a Scientologist parishioner for approx 11 years now and I've never been put under any duress to donate. Churches need money to grow and survive like anyone else so whats the big deal?
The courses and Auditing must be done in conjunction with each other not alternatively.
If you join staff and help out you get your services for free to a certain point called "clear"
If you join the administrative "Sea Org" that runs the religion keeps the technology from being watered down and rendered useless; you get the whole lot paid for.
Its a non profit organization. All spare cash goes to building more and humanitarian operations throughout the world.
This is the truth. Panorama wouldn't tell you this for reasons best known to its then presenter and editor.
People who have left have done so because they have committed some crime small or large against the church. This is often why people leave a group or relationship. Its because we all know deep down when we've cheated and so "blow"
mike stryk, Chichester, Sussex
And did you know that it's the members 'donations', extracted under what borders on spiritual duress, that pay for these buildings. The properties are of course bought by the 'Church' using members money with the result of the buildings costing the Church itself practically nothing.
And if any of these members say or do anything that offends the Church in any way, the member is expelled, his past contributions over many years totally ignored. If he/she goes to the media or tries to speak out they are harassed and destroyed. The Church prepared a file on Travolta when he became unhappy with the new Church management back in the 80's. If you investigate Misgavage and Co. you will find they took control of the Church in the 80's and booted out many of the people who were trained by .
The Church is expanding for a reason across the globe and their members are paying. I should know, I left recently.
Jack Lord, Bedford,
Celebrities paying a fortune to learn secrets dreamed up by a science-fiction writer? More proof that they're as stupid as they look.
Paul, Johannesburg, South Africa
How can anyone be stupid enough to join this con?
As you can see, I didn't watch that Panorama investigation :>
starling, Lancaster,
Scientology. Respect? Notice the period separating these words. That is because the two words simply cannot appear in the same sentance formed in the English language.
Scientology is the Rodney Dangerfield of "religions." "I get no respect, no respect I tell 'ya." No kidding.
Try "CULT" on for size. It's a more accurate description of Scientology. It is simply orginzed to fleece the gulible as are all cults. Pay me and I'll show you my secret documents. Who in their right mind buys into that silliness? And if Tom Cruise is your religion's spokesman, that should tell you something right there; can you spell i-d-i-o-t??
Thomas, Atlanta, GA, USA
After watching BBC's Panorama investigation into Scientology I am too afraid to comment.
Andrew, Bath, UK
Thank you for a most informative article. Untangling the byzantine structure of the Church of Scientology is not an easy task!
A scan through the businesses you list reveals where the Church thinks the money is: selling quack medicine and unproven pseudoscience to the gullible.
On only one point would I quibble. Scientology heretics are thriving with a steady stream of disillusioned members leaving the Church, and there is no way they can be stopped from practicing Scientology despite 'Scientologist' being a Trade Mark any more than the Catholic Church could stop Protestants by burning a few martyrs.
hartley patterson, High Wycombe, Bucks
Just another cult that will ruin peoples lives.
dave B , york, n yorks
Why does any religion get aid? You don't need cash to worship a god, so it is just greed. The Vatican is teeming with wealth, plus real estate in one of the world's major cities. All other major religions have huge wealth too.
Ben, York,