Karen Bartlett
Win Sky+HD for a year and a trip to Barcelona

The room is dark. Giant oversized pencils hang from the ceiling. It's a crazy upside-down world full of crayons that are 3ft long, Lego bricks bigger than loaves of bread and huge geometry sets. Then there is the light. Demi Moore is on stage with two candles. She spreads the flame from one candle to another: “About ten years ago I was in an enviable position. I was making $12 million a movie. I was at the top of my career. I stepped away from all that to spend time with my children. Now I make $125,000 for a movie, but do I have less?”
Well, obviously she does have less - “but there is no accounting for spending that time with my children”. It is all about finding your light and sharing it. At this point more people emerge from the darkness with candles. “I share this light in peace,” says one, as each person leaves a candle at a table.
This is not a strange childhood dream; it's the Greenwich Village studio space that belongs to the designer Donna Karan and is bustling with a New York-LA nexus of fashion and fame. Karan, Moore and her actor husband, Ashton Kutcher, are present for this high-powered fundraiser. Madonna is a co-chair. They are all friends, tied together originally by the red string of Kabbalah, the controversial religious group that has now given birth to the focus of the evening, Spirituality for Kids. SFK is a global youth programme that is already working within British schools as part of the curriculum and plans to expand. Its purpose, it claims, is to encourage children to recognise their own goodness, see the light and have more spiritual powers.
Kabbalah opponents have been surprised and outraged to learn that SFK is now running classes in six schools in London, with more on a waiting list.
“I heard it was their intent, but I hadn't realised that they had infiltrated British schools. I believe they work using mind manipulation,” says Rabbi Yitzchak Schochet, of Mill Hill Synagogue, London. He points to reports four years ago in The Times that former members of the London Kabbalah Centre had been subjected to emotional manipulation and financial pressure. Such allegations prompted the Chief Rabbi, Sir Jonathan Sacks, to issue the following statement: “In light of the issues which have been brought to our attention relating to the Kabbalah Centre in the UK we wish it to be known that this organisation does not fall within the remit of the Chief Rabbinate or any other authority in the UK recognised by us.”
Critics believe the modern-day Kabbalah movement has hijacked a traditional form of Jewish mysticism and promoted it for financial gain using high-profile celebrities, most prominently Madonna. While traditional Kabbalah is practised only by male Hassidic scholars over the age of 40, celebrity Kabbalah spawned a T-shirt saying: “I scanned the Zohar with Ashton.” When David Beckham, Winona Ryder and, briefly, Britney Spears, were spotted with a red Kabbalah string tied to their wrists the group was dubbed “Hollywood's hottest cult”.
“That it is not supported by any main religious group in the world, what does that tell you?” Rabbi Schochet asks. “I'd like to tell Madonna: I won't meddle in your songs if you stop meddling in my Judaic traditions.”
Karen Berg is the founder of Spirituality for Kids. She is also the co-director of the Kabbalah Centre based in LA, and wife of the Kabbalah guru Philip Berg. She frowns and affects astonishment that anyone would question the connection.
She has just introduced the SFK fundraiser with an emotional speech about herself: a little girl, neglected by her parents, forced to make her own way in the world. Berg now has a Beverly Hills mansion, but still speaks with the Brooklyn twang of someone who has gone from nothing to considerable fame. The Kabbalah website says that she has an “unquenchable thirst for spiritual knowledge”. So much so that she was once attacked by a “bat-wielding religious zealot” for taking traditional Jewish teachings and turning them into popular books with titles such as God Wears Lipstick.
The UK branch of SFK is based at the Kabbalah Centre, Central London, and many SFK teachers and helpers - as well as the higher echelons - are practising members. Most of the terms central to SFK, such as sharing the light, stopping reactive behaviour and “The Opponent”, are also found in Kabbalah. But SFK maintains that it is based on fundamental spiritual principles and is non-religious. It is not, it maintains, Kabbalah for Kids.
Heath Grant, the executive director of SFK, does not worry about the concerns of Kabbalah critics. “I don't even think about that. I just do my thing.”
Later Grant will accompany Karan to the Mayor of New York's office to discuss a city-wide SFK schools programme. First, he will visit an SFK class in an elementary school in Far Rockaway, in Queens. The school has mesh on the windows and a police officer at the entrance. Most of the children who attend are from the nearby public housing projects.
“OK guys, the spiritual detective searches for clues within himself,” says Daniel, the SFK teacher for a class of eight-year-olds, as he turns to a page in the SFK handbook. There is a picture of Sherlock Holmes searching for the “good seeds” and “bad seeds” that children plant. “It's time for the spiritual detective glasses,” Daniel says, producing a pair of joke-shop frames with a large nose and eyebrows. Kiena, a girl with plastic flowers in her hair, puts on the glasses. What clues to her spiritual state will she reveal today? “I felt angry because my sister woke me and I yelled at her,” she says
“Thank you for your honesty,” Daniel tells her. Another girl follows her to the front. She relates an issue about a pencil-throwing incident. “And what did you do?” Daniel prompts. “I scratched his face, threw him on the ground and hit him,” she replies. “Thank you for your honesty,” Daniel repeats.
Much of the SFK programme is based on the principle of cause and effect: if you do good things, good things will come to you; if you do bad things, bad things will come to you. Daniel speaks with childlike enthusiasm and simplicity. When the children are called on to think about their plans for the future, he asks his adult assistant, Jackie, where she sees herself in a year's time. “I'm an SFK facilitator. In a year's time I want to be an SFK teacher,” Jackie beams. “Awesome,” Daniel says.
One of the most important tenets of SFK is teaching children to identify two different voices. “The Good Guy”, who SFK tells them is their own authentic voice, and “The Opponent”, who leads them astray.
Kutcher likes to illustrates this with a story about his romance with Moore. “I was 25, I was in New York City. I had a hit movie. Then I met a woman. I just beat Prince William to be the most eligible bachelor in the world - I could do a lot of damage. But then I heard another voice saying ‘This could be real'. But The Opponent did not give up. The voice said “You can't be faithful to this woman. You can't support this woman. She has three kids. But then another voice said, ‘Follow that woman'.” He breaks down and points at Moore: “I followed her here, I would follow her to the end of the world.”
Most of the children spend their hour-long SFK lesson engaged and enthusiastic. “It's fun,” says Dyshawna, who is on her third level of SFK teaching.
The room is decorated with SFK posters. The first has rays of light pouring through a keyhole: there's unseen power in everything, it indicates. The second poster claims that this unseen power makes us be the best we can be and stops us being scared and lonely. Paper plates with sun-like rays hang from the ceiling. They have been made by the children and the principles of SFK are printed on each one: Stop your reactive behaviour. Ask your Good Guy to guide you. Share and make room for all life's blessings.
Critics of SFK believe the lessons it gives demonstrate that the programme is at best silly and at worst sinister - although it appears to have support from parts of the education community and evidence of academic success. A recent study by the Rand Corporation, a research institute, found that children taking SFK classes in Florida showed improvement in areas of leadership, communication and study skills. In the five years since it was founded SFK is now working in the US, UK, Malawi, Israel and Latin America. Karen Berg would like to see SFK expand into every school, with teachers being taught SFK to incorporate it into the curriculum. Supporters insist that the SFK programme, which primarily teaches 6 to 12-year-olds in a ten-week block with two eight-week follow ups, has a transforming effect on children's lives.
At the SFK fundraiser in New York, Moore and Kutcher encourage everyone to be children for the night. One activity involves saying hurtful things while tearing up a paper heart. The task of trying to reconstruct it with glue demonstrates that broken hearts are hard to mend. The next day it's the children's turn. At a special “funday” they arrive to eat popcorn, play with SFK dominoes and act out the Good Guy and The Opponent with finger puppets. Most parents seem unaware of a link between SFK and Kabbalah and none expresses concern.
“It's just basic good behaviour,” one mother shrugs. Christy Turlington, the model, turns up with her daughter. One of Jerry Seinfeld's children correctly identifies the task that proves that life is more fun when it's difficult and challenging. In a chaotic afternoon it's no wonder that sometimes even SFK volunteers listen to the voice of The Opponent; when Karan bustles past wearing a green T-shirt covered in graffitiand big baseball cap, one mutters: “She looks like a lettuce.”
Karan does not hold back: “I want to be clear. SFK is not Kabbalah, it's for every child in the world to have the tools for life.” She does practise Kabbalah, adding that she has seen it help her friends, including Moore and Madonna. “It's not a religion, it's a science. It's the science of connection.”
Sonja Nuttall, Karan's co-founder at their charitable foundation Urban Zen, is sitting in on the discussion and appears irritated. “It's incredible that we have to defend SFK and talk about Kabbalah when all we are trying to do is teach children that they have innate goodness and help them to figure out the rules of life.”
But today the focus is on the whole child. “It's a hard sell,” Moore says, wearing her own over-sized orange T-shirt and baseball cap in the Tolerance and Unity area. “Anything to do with the word spirituality has connotations for people,” she says. Moore has been to Rikers Island prison to meet the teenage boys taking the SFK programme. She hopes to return in a few weeks to see their progress.
Despite such enticements, in the UK at least, there are serious doubts. “SFK approached us to work with them in schools,” says Camila Batmanghelidjh, of Kids Company, a children's charity in South London. “We turned them down. It didn't feel right. I don't believe in doing it their way.”
Spiritual development has been part of the school curriculum since the Education Act of 1944, but Batmanghelidjh believes that although young people need emotional support and love, spirituality is something they should be left to find in their own time. Kids Company has worked with vulnerable children for many years. “It takes a long time for these children to trust you - you have to prove that you are a constant in their lives.”
But one of her key workers, Christina Enright, points out that there is a gap in the market. “Schools have removed religious education to be more inclusive, but they've lost something important - morality and community. The Government is trying to balance that with personal and social development and citizenship, but it's so poorly organised it's not meeting anyone's needs.”
The headmistress of a North London primary school, which is now in its second year of SFK teaching, agrees. “SFK approached me and since we started the programme it has had a significant effect on some of our children's lives. A lot of them have behavioural problems and SFK has helped them to become more active in making decisions.”
There is a more conventional programme favoured by other state schools that also aims to teach children about moral and emotional development called Personal Health, Social and Citizen Education (PHSCE) but, she claims, it is more time-consuming and difficult to implement. “SFK didn't talk about Kabbalah when they came to see me originally, but a few of our parents spotted the connection and came to talk to us about it. They were worried about terms such as ‘the light' and thought it sounded a bit like a cult. Two parents took their children out of the class.” Despite this the school has decided not to discuss the issue with parents beforehand.
Today's SFK class is “The Art of Problem Solving”. It is stage three of the SFK programme and attempts to make children think about their problems through great artists. Monet, we learn, was bored, but by adding light to his work he changed his world. Children can add light to their days by caring about other people and sharing. “Some of our children have horrible lives,” says Greg, the class teacher. “I'm not sure about all this business of ‘the light'. All I know is that this has helped these children. It's about common decency and teaching them how to behave. Frankly, its better than nothing.”
But some people who have encountered Kabbalah do not agree. “I'd question the integrity of any school that hasn't properly researched the work of the Kabbalah Centre,” says Rabbi Schochet. “It might make the children feel good, but so would drugs and alcohol - it is not necessarily good for them. The schools and the Government are going to have a lot to answer for when the implications of SFK is understood.”
Michael Berg, director of SFK, says: “SFK is the Kabbalah Centre's children's charity and it shares the same co-founder, Karen Berg, who has dedicated her life to bring spirituality to the world. Many of the volunteers and donors of SFK come from the Kabbalah Centre. One of the major principles of Kabbalah is to share and give back, as seen with Donna Karan who is a student of the Kabbalah Centre and who also gives back through her work with SFK.”
He also pointed out that all money going to the SFK stays within the organisation and that it operates as a separate charity.
Created In The Image Of God, A Foundation Course In The Kabbalah Buy the book
Explore your passion for food with the delights of Thai, Indian & Chinese cooking
In our new series, Tony Hawks takes a dry, wry look at modern life - junk mail, interminable meetings and snooty sales assistants
Read the training tips and advice that helped our London Triathletes
Read our exclusive 100 Years of Fleming and Bond interactive timeline, packed with original Times articles and reviews
The latest travel news plus the best hotels and gadgets for business travellers
Shortcuts to help you find sections and articles
2007
£30,000
2006
£14,337
2008
£39,937
Great car insurance deals online
c.£75,000
GlosFirstmeansbusiness
Gloucestershire
£32,795 - £41,545
Universitry of Southampton
Southampton
£
£32,795 - £41,545
Universitry of Southampton
Southampton
Competitive Package
Npower
West Midlands
1 & 2 Bed apartments
From £249,995
Great Investment, River Views
Great Dubai Investment Opportunities
from £89,950
low-cost ownership homes in London
Las Vegas SALE!
£POA
With Ramblers Worldwide Holidays!
£POA
List your property with two leading travel websites
£POA
Great travel insurance deals online
Contact our advertising team for advertising and sponsorship in Times Online, The Times and The Sunday Times. Globrix Property Search - find property for sale and rent in the UK. Milkround Job Search - for graduate careers in the UK. Visit our classified services and find jobs, used cars, property or holidays. Use our dating service, read our births, marriages and deaths announcements, or place your advertisement.
Copyright 2008 Times Newspapers Ltd.
This service is provided on Times Newspapers' standard Terms and Conditions. Please read our Privacy Policy.To inquire about a licence to reproduce material from Times Online, The Times or The Sunday Times, click here.This website is published by a member of the News International Group. News International Limited, 1 Virginia St, London E98 1XY, is the holding company for the News International group and is registered in England No 81701. VAT number GB 243 8054 69.
Kids are intelligent and more capable than we give them credit for. They are forced to learn about this unjust world at an early age and need guidence. Kids must learn understand unjust situations in life with out justifying thru "reciprocal behavior." Why don't we teach them about Job instead?
Bernice, New York, USA
During SFK lessons, students learn resiliency and more , I watched my students become stronger,stop themselves from taking drugs, from slitting their wrists, ..SFK taught them practical skills to enable this!They are the walking examples! It ought to be part of the PSHE Curriculum in all UK schools!
RRS, London, UK
Through SFK I've seen the most uncontrollable kids in a class become the most helpful, contributing, and enthusiastic. I've heard the hardest kids bragging in the next lesson about the good things they did at the weekend - unheard of when I was a kid in East London.
Kevin White, London, UK
i have seen the SFK programme and many others with similar goals for children, and I will say the SFK programme has the most tangible positive effect in childrens lives I have seen.
ann, nyc,
SFK is one of the most amazing programs I have ever encountered and the children I have met that are recipients of the knowledge are forever changed for the positive! Why is everyone so quick to judge??????
Stephen, NYC, USA
KABBALAH, IS NOT A CULT!!!!!!! It is the basic of all religions .It is HEBRAIC of course, Learn and see for yourself,let me see AVRAHAM, MOSES,JOSHUA And all our great hebrew ancestors were EXPERT on KABBALAH. Here is a small Example. The Word KABBALAH Mean To Receive The Light Of The Creator.
MICHEL KESLACY, Sterling Heights, mi, USA
So don´t stabbings, more kids & teenagers in sheer emotional, psychological,social, economic and familiar agony
have any links?those who criticize, have you given any better solutons or ever witnessed these youngsters struggle every day of their lifes? think of consequences think! Jose, London
Jose, London, UK
Jan Jansen is right. This is a gross violation of the 1944 Education Act, which stipulates that Christianity is the official religion in state schools. The Act has not been repealed.
Edmund Burke, Kingston upon Thames, England
In the 1960's Madalyn O'Hair (atheist) sucessfully banned God from U.S. schools. Before this event schools produced (for the most part) Godly children, less out of wedlock pregnancies, much less crime etc. Eliminating God left a huge hole to fill and occult Kabbalah is one thing filling it. Sad!
J. Warre , Crossville, u.s.a.
I have seen and experienced Spirituality for Kids, and the comments that it is either a cult or dangerous are completely ridiculous. It is simply a great set of lessons about Lifeskills which are sadly lacking elsewhere in the school curriculum. Religeon is not even mentioned, and it is woinderful.
neil davidson, london,
Recruit in the cradle, cash in the future! Shameful, disgusting! Let's get rid off these soul rippers from the schools. How did they get there in the first place? Was our minister fast asleep?
Lauren, London, uk
Why criticise a unique educational project which teaches the young how to love and be positive in todays world of violence,drugs and crime? Rabbi Shochet (no expert on Kabbalah)would be true to his calling if he would stop his old vendetta based on ignorance and and learn about love and tolerance
Norman, London,
whatever sfk's motives are...reading what the headmistress had to say.. it seems to have brought some positive changes in children...could be a good thing?
charles, London, uk
There's one verse in the New Testament "it is easier for a camel to pass through the eye of a needle than for a rich man to enter heaven" that may be a kabbalistic formula. Two Hebrew letters are metioned (gimel and qof). However that's the only hint that Jesus might have practised kabbalah.
Malcolm McLean, Bradford, UK
'Four blind men described an elephant. To the first it felt like a tree, to the second a long hose. The third thought it was soft like a purse, and the last thought it more like a house. All were correct. Such are the paths to God.'
Sufi Mystic
Chris, London,
What a fantastic program!! I would send my kids in an instant - something that teaches children values, and how to make better choice in this difficult world we live in should be encouraged. I called up and found out when the next course was!! i suggest you all do the same before slandering it.
Val, London, uk
Lets see, a gibberish cult that span off from Judaism taking the world by storm...mmmmm..When did that last happen?
Eric Skelton, Cardiff, Wales
I do not believe that doing good and having good things happen to you is anti Christian. And am I mistaken or did Jesus not practice Kabalah?
UKautosOnline.co.uk
Cass, Daytona, USA
Obviously the christian way has worked, look at the number of violent crimes commited by children in the UK and US recently. Giving the children positive re-enforcement is better than the alternative ie; Rap music, television and movies. I say give it a chance and see what happens.
John, Phoenix, AZ, USA
One Way - Jesus!!
Sorry to Kaballah, Islam, Buddhism, Hinduism etc. It is the way of the Judeo-Christian faith or none at all!!
Watch for the signs of the times - we are in the last days!
Watch for Israel to attack Iran.
Watch for the "Dome of the Rock" to disappear from the Temple Mount!!
Alastair, Perth, Australia
The UK is a Christian country, the Head of State is the Queen. She is also"Supreme Governor" of the Anglican Church. Kabbalah is based upon Jewish mysticism so there is no place for it in the UK state education system
Jan
Jan Jansen, Amsterdam, Netherlands
I am a facilator for SFK for almost 1 year - and I have witnessed first hand the transformation it brings to the kids and teens -- every aspect of the teachings is all positive -- i would encourage all those doubters to come to our classes and experience the program first hand --
Linda, New York, USA
I've read that the founder of this 'movement' is a fraudster with no 'authentic' religious background.. As to Ashkenasi jewish kabbalistic practise - well Hasidim spring to mind - and even the Misnagdim will study Kabbalah when certain criteria have been met. This is about money for this group.
Austin, London, England
It's no different to Bikram and his so called Bikram Yoga.
Is turning up the heat,walking around in a pair of speedos and doing just 26 asanas out of a total of 8,400,000 really Yoga?I don't think so but hey bring something to the USA and you have got yourself a brand and then it seems a fortune.
James Currie, London , U.K
That's nice, now I'm a multi-millionaire I can afford to work for a bit less. Gosh, makes me feel a whole lot better.
David Leslie, Perth, Scotland
Kabbalah means 'received wisdom'. Jung considered it to be the 'Yoga of the West', or a path of union with God that fitted with the Western type. It shows the hidden mechanisms of creation, the necessity of pure love and intention, and is in acccord with all other worldwide mystery religions.
Chris, London,
Children today are exposed to daily doses of knife crime. Many live in broken homes. Many others just get the drip feed of negativity that is the modern media. SFK teaches them simple techniques to default to their good instincts, and be aware of reactive behaviour. Seems like a good thing to me.
Mark , London, UK
It cracks me up when famous people claim they walk away from Hollywood when everyone knows that their latest movies had failed miserably and they are usually forced to "step away" from the limelight.
Shani, Chiba-Ken, Japan
Regardless of some of the misinformed comments here, Kaballah in itself is harmless and indeed helpful when practised by authentic Sephardim (Ashkenazi Jews historically have not dabbled in the mysticism. This money-making high-profile version peddled by the Kaballah Centre should be watched closely
David S, London, UK
Like Scientology, Kabbalah is an absolute cult.
Anything involving this kind of mumbo-jumbo is fundamentally bad, evil even, because it leads those entrapped in it to avoid using their intellect.
And where is the prescribed prominent disclaimer that the whole show is "for entertainment only"?
Rosemary, Germany,
What religion isn't mind manipulation? "Give me your children till they're seven, and you can have them for the rest of your life". The Jesuits say. All faith-teachers ought by law have to begin their lessons with the statement "This may not be true".
Kevin Straw, Leicester,
I believe they work using mind manipulation, says Rabbi Yitzchak Schochet
Errr... pot, kettle and black are three words that come to mind!
louise, guadalajara, mexico
If it is teaching basic moral values and life/self-awareness skills, then I do not see the problem. Although sadly the principle of cause and effect does not always benefit us - kids also need to be taught that life, sometime, is simply not fair. A bitter pill to swallow, but swallow it we must.
Ella, London,
Sounds like a cheap version of Scientology. The basic principles of positive thinking and positive reciprocal behaviour are beneficial, but the concept of a Good Guy and an Opponent is simpilistic. We should want to do good, not just because it benefits us. It's too focused on the self
Ez Mayo, Oxford,
As someone from a mixed background who has followed an eclectic spiritual path, why do I feel uneasy about this? I think the celeb funded Kabbalah-lite movement is superficial and minimally understood by its adherents. I'm not sure how immensely successful people cooing about letting light into their lives and going with the flow has anything real to say to most people. Especially as none of them appears to drink or has gotten obese by the fizzy drinks that some of them are paid vast sums to promote.
Yes, kids will love something glossy with lots of visuals which gets them out of lessons for a couple of hours. Just a passing fad.
Isadora, London,
Where before we brought up children within the Judeo-Christian moral framework via daily chapel/assembly, we now have a multicultural morass of religious views and traditions thrown at them bereft of any core guiding set of values. Cults like Kabbalah & SFK just step into this moral vacuum.
Simon, London, UK
Another cult. Great, just what we need. Stupid people being lead by exploitive people. Follow the money.
Instead of "In god we trust", how about trying "In reason and observation we trust". What is it with people like Moore who abandon what is real for something fictional
GK Lott, Austin, USA
The road to hell is paved with good intentions. Diluted extract of occultism is never going to be the beginning of a solution to inner city deprivation, poverty and crime. Only a Holywood star would be capable of thinking this applied distortion of reality could be a solution!
John Nutt, Wellington, UK
I guess if it's led by celebs then children will follow. The adult supporters look a deal more plausible than any politician or policeman. If such self enquiry and pause for thought keeps children away from bad behaviour then that can only be a good thing even though skeptics may mock and chortle.
Boris, Belgravia, London
Why don't people make a fuss when their kids are taught Christianity? Ok, religion does have it's flaws, if it's helping kids be better people in life rather than mis-behaving, why not? I'm Asian, I was taught Christian religion, I now know about all religions. I'm not brainwashed.
Seetal Udeshi, London, UK,
It sounds like a good thing to me.
Too many people are narrow minded and don't like anything that differs from what they think is normal. It's these people that need to learn from this type of outfit the most.
Michael, Bracknell, England
Sorry, I also forgot to mention that I found my own path and way to think about life. But I think it's nice that kids get some help in making the right decisions. I mean, if it is a way of brainwashing then obviously it's a bad thing. But teaching kids to do good I'm all for I say!
Seetal Udeshi, London, UK,