Win VIP tickets
The belated admission by police in Goa that Scarlett Keeling, the 15-year-old British girl found dead on a beach last month, may have been murdered is as shocking in revealing local corruption as it is damaging to one of India's most popular tourist destinations. The police asserted initially that the girl had drowned after taking drugs. After a second autopsy, the arrest for rape of a suspect was challenged by her mother. The police are now attempting to delay matters further by ordering extra medical examinations to prove the girl's age. They are also seeking to deflect criticism of their work by blaming the mother for negligence, amid accusations of a cover-up, media reports of corruption and the mysterious disappearance of a man who claimed to have witnessed what happened.
The sordid affair has shone an unwelcome spotlight on the hinterland of this small state that has grown rich on a $465 million tourist industry, accounting for 15 per cent of its economy. The availability of drugs, the lack of proper regulation and the influx of predominantly young Western tourists - 60 per cent of them British - have attracted the unscrupulous and the opportunists hoping to profit from the tourists' naivety. Criminal elements appear to have formed a cosy relationship with the police. A blind eye has been turned too often to what has been happening near the golden beaches. Goa has got rich on a louche image. It now looks a lot less carefree than the tourist posters proclaim.
The problem for Goa is the same as the difficulty faced by other tourist destinations “discovered” by the young and the adventurous and trading on their fashionable, hippy associations. Ibiza, Bali, The Gambia and parts of Thailand are all places where the prevailing hedonism attracts a large number of free-spending tourists but runs counter to the more conservative views and mores of the host country. Entrepreneurs who have invested in the bars, clubs, pools and hotels that bring in the tourists are keen to encourage a lively reputation in the West. That same reputation, however, can cause resentment, disdain and confusion to the very people working in these resorts. A clash of assumptions can have dangerous consequences.
Such clashes have been increasing in Goa as the tourist numbers rise. The Indian media have reported 27 deaths of foreigners already this year, though police said many were from natural causes. The state government now needs to take an urgent look at regulation, the safety of women tourists, the rise in crime, availability of drugs and the impact, beyond the financial bonanza, of tourism on Goa's values and way of life.
There are other aspects of this tragedy that are disturbing, however, and have little to do with India. The question many must ask is why a 15-year-old, who had never been abroad before, was left in the company of strangers by a mother who then travelled with other school-age daughters to another state. It is not only tourist authorities who must exercise responsibility. But those going on holiday must also understand the dangers of what can happen when the law, especially on drugs, is not enforced. Countries such as India, and local authorities such as Goa, cannot afford to build their tourist image on a dubious reputation for laxity and permissiveness. It puts tourists at risk - and also the entire industry.
Win a luxury weekend to Newcastle and its neighbour Gateshead, find out more here
Risk, resilience and embracing new technology
Industry sectors news at a glance. Interactive heatmap, video and podcast
Discover the power of collective thinking. Submit a solution and be in with a chance to win a Media Hub Home Entertainment System
The inside track on current trends in the charity, not for profit and social enterprise sectors
Everything the Business Traveller needs to know to make a better trip
Make the most of the summer and enter our fabulous photographic competition, you could win a £5000 holiday
Corsica is an island of beauty and contrast, an ideal holiday destination
Enjoy further reading from Travel to Fashion, Business to Sport, discover more
Shortcuts to help you find sections and articles
The clever way to lease a new car is with Car leasing made simple™
2009
per month on 36-month
Personal Contract Hire (PCH)
2008
42850
Car Insurance
£23,093 - £56,211
The Office for National Statistics
Newport, South Wales
£60,000
The Environment Agency
Bristol
Up to £90K
Boots
Midlands
OTE £85k
Credit Protection Association
Nationwide Opportunities
Completely London
Luxury Condo's in Manhattan with NYC views
The best new homes in Wimbledon?
Nationwide
Fabulous Cruise And Cruise & Stay Offers Including Virgin Atlantic Flights Prices Start From Only £699pp!
Last Minute Cruise And Cruise & Stay Offers. Med From £499pp, Caribbean From £699pp!
5 star quality at a 3 star price.
8 fabulous Canadian cities ...you won’t find cheaper
Contact our advertising team for advertising and sponsorship in Times Online, The Times and The Sunday Times, or place your advertisement.
Times Online Services: Dating | Jobs | Property Search | Used Cars | Holidays | Births, Marriages, Deaths | Subscriptions | E-paper
News International associated websites: Globrix Property Search | Property Finder | Milkround
Copyright 2009 Times Newspapers Ltd.
This service is provided on Times Newspapers' standard Terms and Conditions. Please read our Privacy Policy.To inquire about a licence to reproduce material from Times Online, The Times or The Sunday Times, click here.This website is published by a member of the News International Group. News International Limited, 1 Virginia St, London E98 1XY, is the holding company for the News International group and is registered in England No 81701. VAT number GB 243 8054 69.
firstly, id like to say i come from the region where scarlett was from, and i have been out to goa three times to patnem + palolem beach ( she went to anjuna + baga) and i have never had any problems over there. it was really bac luck what happened to her... goa is fine.
dani, barnstaple, UK
I met and played pool with Scarlett and her brother Merlin in early December at Curlie's shack. She and her best friend (?) were really nice and polite, so I was really disturbed when I heard about what happened to her two weeks ago.
I'm not sure I agree with the title of this article and the way Goa is being singled out. As Tony A. from Toronto points out, murders happen everywhere. And I don't think Goans are overly "conservative" or unable to adapt to Western tourists. Goa has been a tourist destination since before India got its independence from Britain.
Smaran, Poona, India
As one will note from some of the comments above, Goa is not the only culprit to be blamed for this tragic loss of life. My heart felt sympathy goes out to Scarlet's mum. But she (Mum)too is responsible, to a certain degree, for her daughter's murder. What in heaven's name was she thinking when she decided to leave her 15 years old "baby" to be "baby sat" by a complete 25 years old stranger man. "Goodness gracious me" again, what was the woman thinking? I am not implying that the 25years old man murdered the poor girl. In some parts of the world as in North America the mother would be charged and most probably covicted for child neglect. The other point i wish to make is murders occur all over the world. Not too long ago an innocent young Goan sailor was murdered in England by a group of delinquent youths for no apparent reason. The poor chap got off the cargo ship to do a bit of site seeing. That cost his wife and child his life.
Tony A., Toronto, Canada
I think this is good article because it doesn't just focus on the corrupt Goan police, it also discusses the responsibilities tourists must take when traveling abroad. I was in Goa a couple of years ago and found most locals to be very good people. Though I was only there about a week, I heard many of them complain bitterly about the corrupt police as well as the "non-Goans" (out of staters) who come in to profit from the riff-raff. However, due to the type of tourism the state attracts, I would probably never visit there again. Most of the younger tourists were stoned most of the time and walked around half-naked as if they were in the safety of their own back yard. The behavior of most of the tourists was so contrary to the locals' culture that I felt uneasy throughout my entire visit there as well as a little embarassed. If you are looking to meet other interesting travelers, Goa is definitely not the place.
Richan, New York, NY
What a ridiculous article. How such an article has spawned from over a tourist's (supposed) murder is beyond me. I'm sure Indians (amongst other nationalities) have been murdered in Britain - Indian's aren't on TV or writing belittling articles pitying the serious underlying societal problems in Britain with tones of forewarning and danger. I'm also fairly sure other foreigners have been murdered in India but its funny how the media in other countries don't seem to have many articles warning their fellow countrymen of the dangers of being on holiday in India? This article being a fairly clear example of why no-one seems to take British people seriously anywhere in the world anymore.
Sarah Quinlan, Munich, Germany
Having spent a year travelling in Asia and recently arriving in Thailand, i see the attitudes. Have the "travellers" dont come here to take any notice of the culture and attitude of the Thais, they just want to lead a crazy life and tough if people dont like it.
Generally in the world you need to go looking for trouble if you want to get in it, so if you hang out with a druggy crowd, something will go wrong. If you are sensible, you can appreciate everything these countries and the overwhelmingly friendly locals have to offer with ever feeling threatened.
Matthew, Pracuap Khiri Khan, Thailand
Yes Goa is becoming a dangerous place. But economics tells us if there is no demand there is no point in there being a supply. If there is no consumers for the drugs there will be no sellers/pushers of the same.
You should see the type of foreign tourists we get now a days. They have no regard for our laws and customs. They walk into our churches with practically nothing. I am a witness to the fact that an obese brit with no underwear wearing only a see though kimono walked into our holiest churches the basilica de bom Jesu and none of the guides had the decency to tell her otherwise. I challenge this tourist and all the other Brits like her to please walk into the Vatican City with just a V Cut Blouse
I hope the Keeling tragedy will force the tourists, Indian and foreign to take care in the future and try their best not to go against their better judgements. Please know our police here are worthless and can only harass the meek.
Sherwyn Dlima, Mapusa, Goa India
Yeah its true. Dont say Goa is unsafe for tourist, but its other way round, it is unsafe for us Goans. These tourist has spoilt the golden beaches of Goa. The tourism dept. should make it a point to protect these beautiful beaches and land of GOa.
SS, Kuwait, Kuwait
Basically the mother was forced to let the teen stay behind because she kicked up such a fuss......but how on earth can a mother leave a 15year old immature daughter in the custody of young men and move on to another state apparently on holoday ..unbelievable ..if the kid kicked up such a row they should have packed their bags and left for home ....
However the attempted cover up by the Goa police is unpardonable ...if they want the tourist trade to flourish , each and every single crime should be out in the open and the toursits should also be aware of the attitude of the locals , conflicting with that of their own ..
Bhat, Kerala, India
I'm writing this to show how some foreign tourists behave in Goa.
In February 2004, I and my German (girl)friend visited Calangute beach (in Goa) for a swim. We saw that many of the older foreign women were topless and the beach patrolmen dressed in blue were gawping at the younger girls romping in the waters.
A native boy clearly below 16 years of age was pinching a topless woman of about 35 lying on a reclining chair at her sides and she was giggling. My German friend was apalled. A few minutes later, the woman disappeared with the boy into one of the many temporary cabins behind the reclining chairs.
As it was none of our business to watch, we returned to the souvenir shops.
If foreign tourists in Goa would like to be intimate with local natives, clearly, there are risks involved and the police normally does not interfere and should not be blamed.
SM Hussain, Hyderabad, India
There are good times and unfortunately some bad. This is an incident.
Very good article you have wrote.
Good job.
quishor
quishor, macau,
Goa is like any other tourist destination. There are good times and unfortunately some bad. This does not necessarily mean to say that Goa is dangerous (as your headline seem to suggest or imply). Every place in the world is dangerous when criminals are out there. That doesn't mean everyone is a criminal. It could have happened in London, Paris, Madrid, New York literally anywhere. What parents have to be conscious of is to make sure that their kid(s) are safe and everyone in the family is having a good time. Holidays doesn't mean parents can loose their responsibility or hive it off to someone else leave alone people you knew only for weeks. Drugs & crime go hand in hand & problems facing the society in the UK & the number of crimes being committed here is far worse than what happens elsewhere around the world albeit few other countries. This incident does not mean Goa is unsafe but what it has exposed is the shortcomings of the local police force and this is what should address.
Tim, London, Britain