Charles Bremner in Paris and Thomas Catan in Madrid
Enter our Snapshots of Summer photography competition

It is the latest ruse on the roads of France: drivers are avoiding disqualification by trading licence points on the internet.
Complete strangers are taking the rap for speeding offences in return for up to €1,500 (£1,000), and police admit they are powerless to intervene. Even pensioners who have not driven for many years are getting in on the act.
The online scam is also popular in Spain and other European countries, and authorities believe it may soon be introduced in Britain. It threatens to make a mockery of a French crackdown on road safety and embarrass President Sarkozy over his promise of a “zero tolerance” on law and order.
In France a clean licence has 12 points. Points are then deducted when an offence is committed. Now motorists are “selling” their clean points for hundreds of euros each to drivers who are on the verge of disqualification.
Advertisements on the internet offer points for sale at prices ranging from €300 in the Paris region to more than €1,500 in rural areas. “I have 12 points on my licence. If you need them for work or your holidays, I can help you,” said a typical offer yesterday on the French eBay auction site. Another on a small-ad site said: “I suggest you keep your points and I’ll sell you up to six at €700 each.”
The technique is simple. In return for money, the seller provides his or her name and licence number in response to the speed camera ticket. The notice that is automatically sent to the owner of the offending vehicle includes a form for identifying another driver. Checks are extremely rare.
The black market, which the authorities admit they are unable to prevent, is an unintended consequence of stronger enforcement of the highway code and especially of an exploding number of speeding tickets since automatic radar was installed on French roads on 2003.
Some eight million points are deducted from French licences each year through the operation of 1,000 speed cameras, which were introduced by Mr Sarkozy when he was Interior Minister. An estimated 70,000 licences were cancelled last year, compared with 21,000 in 2003.
Another consequence has been a steep rise in the number of people driving while disqualified. Some experts estimate that unlicensed drivers are at the wheel of up to 8 per cent of vehicles on the road.
It has become routine in families of all classes for repeat offenders to ask friends and relatives with clean licences to lend their names. This explains an apparently steep rise in bad driving by older citizens. The rate of offences by drivers over 65 jumped 38 per cent from 2003-05, when the speed cameras began to bite.
Substituting another driver for a speeding ticket carries a €1,500 fine. Sellers can also be prosecuted for “complicity in false accusation”. The Government of Dominique de Villepin, the last Prime Minister, ordered a €20 million effort to find ways of combating points fraud, but the process has so far reached no conclusion.
Officials acknowledge that the state is swamped with the administration of automatic fines. The Interior Ministry said that it carries out spot checks. “For example, suspicion will be raised if an 84-year-old grandmother is snapped at 200 kph (160mph) at five on a Sunday morning near a nightclub,” he told le Parisien newspaper.
Jean-Baptise Iosca, a lawyer who specialises in motoring cases, said that the borrowing and buying of license points now touched every social class. “I have clients coming to see me after losing not only all their own points but also 12 from their grandmother and all their grandfather’s,” he said.
The illegal market is fuelled by a widespread belief that there is something immoral and unFrench about the enforcement of the 15-year-old points system with speed cameras.
Polls show many believe that les radars have been installed as an unfair ploy to make money for the state. Dozens of installations on motorways and major roads have been vandalised. Eighty per cent of offences are for under 20 km/h excess speed, yet each eats two points from the licence. The loss of all 12 triggers a six-month suspension plus the obligation to retake the driving test.
Some points sellers argue that they are performing a social service, saving the licences of people who depend on their vehicles for their living.
“When you are on the road all day for your work, it is impossible to avoid being caught,” said Pierre-Yves, a 45-year-old businessman from Nantes who sells points at €700 each.
“I don’t have a bad conscience,” he told le Parisien. “I only offer my services to people with small excesses of speed. And I always ask to see a copy of the ticket. I would never sell my points to a road hog.”
French officials were unable to estimate the scale of points fiddling. Across the border in Spain, the Autopista.es online motoring site, estimates the black market in points there is worth €30 million a month.
One internet user in Spain listed his grandmother’s licence points for €250 each, plus the cost of any traffic fines. “I have persuaded the poor woman to renew her licence, with the sole objective of having more points,” he said. “At the moment, I am going to use them, but if anyone is interested we could reach an agreement.”
Elena Extxegoyen, a Spanish MP, said that families were trading points among themselves while foreigners, who do not lose points on their licenses, were offering to take responsibility for speeding tickets for a fee.
Rules of the road
— Speed limits in France vary according to the experience of the driver. If your licence is less than two years old, the dual carriageway maximum speed of 110km/h (68mph) is reduced to 100km/h
— If you exceed the limit by less than 20km/h (12mph) the minimum fine is €68 (£46) and 1 point
— A fine of £60 and 3 points is the minimum penalty in Britain
— Speed cameras caught 4.2 million drivers in France in 2005, compared with fewer than than 2 million in Britain
— There are an estimated 1,000 speed cameras in France, and about 3,200 in Britain
Sources: english.controleradar.org ; www.iam.org ; www.viamichelin.co.uk ; www.speed-trap.co.uk ; www.direct.gov.uk ; www.dft.gov.uk
Win a luxury weekend to Newcastle and its neighbour Gateshead, find out more here
Risk, resilience and embracing new technology
Industry sectors news at a glance. Interactive heatmap, video and podcast
Discover the collective power of smart thinking. Submit a solution and be in with a chance to win a Flip MinoHD Camcorder
The inside track on current trends in the charity, not for profit and social enterprise sectors
Everything the Business Traveller needs to know to make a better trip
Make the most of the summer and enter our fabulous photographic competition, you could win a £5000 holiday
Corsica is an island of beauty and contrast, an ideal holiday destination
Enjoy further reading from Travel to Fashion, Business to Sport, discover more



The clever way to lease a new car is with Car leasing made simple™
2009
42,945
2008
71,450
Car Insurance
Not Specified
MI6
UK-based
£60,000
The Environment Agency
Bristol
Up to £90K
Boots
Midlands
OTE £85k
Credit Protection Association
Nationwide Opportunities
Completely London
Luxury Condo's in Manhattan with NYC views
The best new homes in Wimbledon?
Nationwide
Save up to £1,000 per couple with Elite Vacations at the five-star Constance Lemuria Resort
and do the British Isles this Summer.
Save up to 60% with Oxford Hotels and Inns
Try our inspiring luxury holidays to the Indian Subcontinent and South East Asia.
Great offers available
8 fabulous Canadian cities ...you won’t find cheaper
Contact our advertising team for advertising and sponsorship in Times Online, The Times and The Sunday Times, or place your advertisement.
Times Online Services: Dating | Jobs | Property Search | Used Cars | Holidays | Births, Marriages, Deaths | Subscriptions | E-paper
News International associated websites: Globrix Property Search | Property Finder | Milkround
Copyright 2009 Times Newspapers Ltd.
This service is provided on Times Newspapers' standard Terms and Conditions. Please read our Privacy Policy.To inquire about a licence to reproduce material from Times Online, The Times or The Sunday Times, click here.This website is published by a member of the News International Group. News International Limited, 1 Virginia St, London E98 1XY, is the holding company for the News International group and is registered in England No 81701. VAT number GB 243 8054 69.
There's an upside to being able to sell points. It means that carefull drivers are being rewarded.
Malcolm, Wirral, UK
200km/h does not equate to 160mph. When are you guys going to get into Metric (SI)? Hubble telescope ring a distant bell?
Andrew Milner, Yokohama, Kanagawa
Victory to the French people: I never thought I'd say that!
George below highlights how part of the system works very well: Grab a headline and point a finger. 3000 deaths a year? And how many are CAUSED by speeding George? And how many of those are caused by people who care little about enforcement George? You need more police on the roads, not more cameras.
Statistics don't help you see, you might as well say 3000 deaths related to 'people going out of their home', possibly 3000 deaths related to people eating breakfast that day? How about 'more than 50% of people killed on our roads wore trousers?' More people die in hospital than in McDonalds?
Avoid the headlines and look at the reality!
paul, Milton Keynes,
Wondeful - Le systeme D in action.
The French have always known how to deal with bureaucracy.
Neill, London, UK
France had a death rate on its roads roughly double that of the UK. Enforcement of both speed limits and drink-drive laws has substantially reduced the death and injury toll. Nowhere does anyone comment on these savings and its just about the driver's convenience to continue driving. I sometimes think that drivers and the media think that death and injury on the roads are "inevitable" or "unavoidable". Try asking those who have been bereaved - that will reveal the true impact. There is no such thing as a perfect driver, but at least we can try and comply with the law.
Peter, London , UK
This serves to illustrate the immorality of carbon trading, which is exactly the same process in a different context.
Mike Poulsen, Reading, Berkshire
The 'right' speed limit is arbitrary and depends on a number of factors, not some magic number printed on a pole. Draconian enforcement measures may appeal to politicians and statisticians but the vast majority of road users will drive according to common sense. The few that don't will probably ignore any measures taken against them. To penalise drivers for minor infringments is counter productive in a number of ways and to hear some of the comments from the 'serves-them-right' lobby makes me wonder whether they have a personal axe to grind. Tolerance is not a feature of the Lilliputian mind.
John Wade, Camberley, Surrey, UK.,
âFor example, suspicion will be raised if an 84-year-old grandmother is snapped at 200 kph (160mph) at five on a Sunday morning near a nightclub,â he told le Parisien newspaper."
Forgive my curiosity Messrs Bremner and Catan, but since when has 200kph equated to 160mph??
Sam, sussex, uk
this is the differance between the French and the British. We allow the goverment to shaft us and when a Dad takes his sons points here we jail them both for 3 months yet release "real" criminals early to make room. In France they fight back on things that are seen as unfair. Road safety is not just about speed it is about skilled driving for the conditions. Many of those who have bought into the speed kills mantra that supports cameras are the worst drivers out there. One who was an advocate I met had such bad eysight yet wore no spectacles having no legal requirement to have them checked.
Speeding is not seen as a serious matter, which it may bein some cases, as the goverment have allowed it to be turned into a multi million pound business with many benefiting and yet the death rate has not fallen. goverment figures report less than a third of accidents are speed related, yet 90% of roadsafety is based on speed. go figure that one
Spaximus, bristol, s glos
According to the UK police speeding, as in driving at speeds over the posted speed limit, only account for a very small percentage of accidents. Inattention is the biggest cause of accidents. So why do all the authorities focus on speed? It's a joke and the joke and the points are on you!
shane, Poole,
âWhen you are on the road all day for your work, it is impossible to avoid being caught,â... it's not 'impossible'. In fact it's quite simple. Stay within the speed limit and you won't be caught. Hopefully the government here will soon introduce average speed monitoring across the UK road network, particularly motorways where almost everyone currently breaks the speed limit of 70mph. The driving skills of the majority of British motorists leaves a lot to be desired. Not surprising when in Britain the latest ruse is to pay someone else to sit the driving test for you (around 900000 have done so thus far, I believe). Makes a mockery of British law and order!!
John Dixon, London, UK
What exactly is so hard about driving in accordance with the legal speed limit? I really don't get this at all. If you cannot manage it, are you competent to drive?
3000 dead on the roads every year, many of them children, and we let this go on?
George Johnson, London, England
It used to be that the Police followed you for a quarter mile to make sure you're speeding before you got a ticket but these days they cant be bothered and other more dangerous traffic offences are not even spotted. An offence it may be to speed but its well known the UK cameras are purely a tax collection system so I fully support the business acumen of these internet points traders. If I were still living in the UK paying the sort of council taxes you pay there, I'm certain my wife and I would supplement our pension with an extra income of at least 6 points each every two years. With three times the incidence of cameras over there, an extra annual income of about 1000 pound between us is virtually guaranteed.
Mike, Alicante, Spain