Nicola Woolcock
Pick up your copy of Joy Division: Closer at WHSmith today
Children are turning away from schoolwork because they see education as unhelpful to their ambition to become rich and famous as reality TV stars, a teaching union claims today.
Their role models include David and Victoria Beckham and WAGs – wives and girlfriends of highly paid footballers – according to the Association of Teachers and Lecturers.
It has put forward a motion for its annual conference this weekend saying that members are “appalled at the extent of the decline in this country into the cult of celebrity, which is perverting children’s aspirations and expectations”. It adds: “This compounds the subsequent sense of failure, alienation and low self-esteem when celebrity status is not achieved.”
The union asked 300 teachers about whom their pupils modelled themselves on. More than half said David Beckham. Victoria Beckham, the former Spice Girl and self-professed fashion expert, was a role model for almost a third of girls.
Almost two thirds of teachers said children they taught aspired to be sports stars or pop singers. Many said their pupils sought to be famous with no discernible talent. A third of teachers said that Paris Hilton, the heiress and gossip-column fixture, was a favourite role model.
Julie Gilligan, a primary school teacher in Salford, said that she had seen and heard pupils emulating the behaviour and language of footballers and pop stars in the playground and in school, “including disturbingly age-inappropriate acts by young girls in school talent shows”.
Another member, Elizabeth Farrar, who teaches in a primary school near Scunthorpe, North Lincolnshire, said: “Too many of the pupils believe that academic success is unnecessary, because they will be able to access fame and fortune quite easily through a reality TV show.”
Robert Sanders, a junior school teacher in Bath, said: “One girl said that she wished to be a WAG.”
Mary Bousted, the general secretary of the association, said: “We are not surprised about infiltration of celebrity culture in schools – it reflects the current media obsession with celebrity and the effect of celebrity culture on society as a whole. Celebrities can have a positive effect on pupils. They can raise pupils’ aspirations and ambitions for the future.
“However, we are deeply concerned that many pupils believe celebrity status is available to everyone. They do not understand the hard work it takes to achieve such status and do not think it is important to be actively engaged in schoolwork as education is not needed for a celebrity status.”
Explore your passion for food with the delights of Thai, Indian & Chinese cooking
In our new series, Tony Hawks takes a dry, wry look at modern life - junk mail, interminable meetings and snooty sales assistants
Read the training tips and advice that helped our London Triathletes
Read our exclusive 100 Years of Fleming and Bond interactive timeline, packed with original Times articles and reviews
The latest travel news plus the best hotels and gadgets for business travellers
Shortcuts to help you find sections and articles
2007
£30,000
2006
£14,337
2008
£39,937
Great car insurance deals online
c.£75,000
GlosFirstmeansbusiness
Gloucestershire
Competitive package
Npower
Midlands
£
£32,795 - £41,545
Universitry of Southampton
Southampton
Competitive Package
Npower
West Midlands
1 & 2 Bed apartments
From £249,995
Great Investment, River Views
Great Dubai Investment Opportunities
from £89,950
low-cost ownership homes in London
Multi–Centre 9 Nights
From only £925pp
View thousands of properties online with your Vacation Rental People
£POA
List your property with two leading travel websites
£POA
Great travel insurance deals online
Contact our advertising team for advertising and sponsorship in Times Online, The Times and The Sunday Times. Globrix Property Search - find property for sale and rent in the UK. Milkround Job Search - for graduate careers in the UK. Visit our classified services and find jobs, used cars, property or holidays. Use our dating service, read our births, marriages and deaths announcements, or place your advertisement.
Copyright 2008 Times Newspapers Ltd.
This service is provided on Times Newspapers' standard Terms and Conditions. Please read our Privacy Policy.To inquire about a licence to reproduce material from Times Online, The Times or The Sunday Times, click here.This website is published by a member of the News International Group. News International Limited, 1 Virginia St, London E98 1XY, is the holding company for the News International group and is registered in England No 81701. VAT number GB 243 8054 69.
Lauren from Edinburgh. My point was that many jobs have been devalued (look at nursing for one) leading to kids believing that fame and fortune is the only worthwhile occupation. Also, kids ARE informed and they do know what is going on in this country - if they weren't aware of the media how would they even know what a WAG or who Paris Hilton is. As for "blaming immigration for everything", in my opinion mass unchecked immigration is (albeit one of many factors) contributing to low pay and thus the devaluation of jobs. Decrying anyone who dares to have a negative opinion of immigration won't change that.
Emma, Southampton,
You can't judge them for wanting to be famous, at some time in most people's lives, that's what you want to be.
But you shouldn't just ignore education because of it. There's no guaranteeing anything
Amy, Richmond,
ERm, below this story about the overvalued status of celebrities you have a story about a City Academy sponsor who is famous...as a celebrity on something called Dragon's Den! Black pots and kettles anyone?
nick, Wembley, UK
Breaking News....Kids want to be famous when they are older!!!....... Come on, I wanted to be in the Thunderbirds when I was younger, surely that's a bigger story than this? Thunderbirds beat WAGs any day
James, Surrey, UK
Our Country, and our Culture, has been deliberately dismantled by three decades of politicians with hidden agendas, its time for the People to get serious with them and start voting them out, no more 'safe' seats !
Clive Burghard, LANCING, ENGLAND
Girls wanting to be WAGS? Was it for this that the Suffragettes chained themselves to railings, and for this that Simone de Beauvoir dedicated her life??
JF, Canterbury, UK
Your children are not your children.
They are the sons and daughters of Life's longing for itself.
They come through you but not from you,
And though they are with you yet they belong not to you.
You may give them your love but not your thoughts,
For they have their own thoughts.
You may house their bodies but not their souls,
For their souls dwell in the house of tomorrow,
which you cannot visit, not even in your dreams....
Kahlil Gibran, Bsharri, Lebanon
Most kids are doing what they always did, which is some will study and some wont. northing has really changed in the last 40 years or so. When I was a kid I wanted to be a rock star, so I joined a band, we played, did a few gigs and then grew up and went our separate ways. I studied, got o levels, a levels and a degree and became a wage slave like everyone else. The same will happen with todays lot.
Neil Murphy, cromer,
"What a startling revelation."
The problem is not that they dream about it, but that they think it's their right. They're still dreaming about it when they're 16, by which time they should have grown out of such fantasies.
starling, stockport,
Well since the rest of my generation are going to be day dremaing for the rest of their lives I don't think I'll find it too hard to take over the world.
Meera, Reading, UK
Emma from Southampton, I really don't think these pre-teen children are considering the rate of immigration into the country when telling their teachers what they want to be whenthey grow up, lol!
Some people really will try and blame immigration for everything.
Lauren, Edinburgh, UK
So young kids dream of being pop stars, footballers and millionaire heiresses (the modern cultural equivalent of the 'princess' fantasy).
What a startling revelation.
Giles, London,
I have a good idea, let's have lots of award shows like the oscars, sports 'personality' of the year and the brits for a bunch of people that are already idolised, just in case they start to think that they're not well enough paid and get no 'job' satisfaction.
Seriously though do they not get enough attention?
Richard, Cambridge,
Where are the parents? Where are the heroes in the near environment of these children? Who has the guts to restrict the time children spend on TV and computering? Who offers them a solid foundation and roots them in a living tradition that points them to the values of a lifestyle that centres around the Ten Commandments?
Mrs Irene Fadaee Outan, mother and teacher, Heerlen, The Netherlands,
In aggregate, the ambitions of children should be an accurate reflection of the underlying values of the society in which they have grown up. When I was a child, most young boys aspired to social respect as firemen, policemen, doctors or other "normal" jobs. That children now admire overpaid celebrity status says less about the children than about the adults and social environment around them. In other words, don't blame the kids for the outcome of decades of very bad decisions and foolish priorities taken by adults.
Martin Baldwin-Edwards, Athens, Greece
Of course there are many pupils who see academic success as unnecessary to obtain fame and fortune, but there are also many pupils who are unlikely to achieve academic success in the first place who hope for fame and fortune.
Yesterday this newspaper contained an article about £200 million being made availabe to over 600 poorly performing schools. For many children at these schools what hope is there of academic success?
Des, Edinburgh,
Am i mistaken, or wasn't there a report out not that long ago saying that WAGS should be looked up to because the majority of them have very ggod school grades and degrees?
Anna, cheltenham, Gloucestershire
Very good Ben. Just because you work in a call centre, doesn't mean your childhood was spent daydreaming about angry callers and a fancy headset.
Most childhood aspirations are healthy and normal. It's the majority of society being fascinated by celebrities who are simply famous for being famous, which is then stoked by the media that is not healthy.
By all means aspire to be famous for doing something; actor, scientist, adventurer, writer, comic, even model. But famous because you're erm famous. No.
Karl (aspiring Lotto winner and Big Brother contestant)
Karl, UK, UK
"Many said their pupils sought to be famous with no discernible talent."
But why should we wonder? They are obviously the product of the ' something for nothing' culture, promoted by succesive governments since the sixties, with the heartfelt encouragement from most teaching unions.
Marin, London,
One of the flaws made evident within this arguement is the fact that adults (teachers, union representatives etc) seem to be inflicting their values onto todays children. However as students ourselves we do not condone Paris Hilton being a role model for future generations. From the age of 9 we are catagorised into the things that we are and are not good at: for those of us who are not good at the conventional subjects, are there really provisions to support them? In reference to Paris Hilton:'The Role Model of the 21st Century' children need to realise what being an heiress means. It is something that you are born into and does not neccessarily mean that you have what it takes to be successful. Children should learn that their natural talent is what if anything makes you famous. Instead of teaching kids that fame equals success and recognition throughout the world we should be teaching them that humility and compassion are the neccessary characterisitcs to get through life.
Julia Goolia, Leighton Buzzard, England
What else is there to aspire to? You are right Ben, we are left with little option but to aim for the alien world that is 'fame'. Kids are more obsessed with the actual grading of their work rather than how much they believed they have actually learnt. Let them be popstars for goodness sake..
Leave Britney Alone!
x
Lukey, Walsall, England
I weep for the future!
Ben, if you actually look around, there are other jobs to be had other than just call centres. What exactly did you think: "Oh no, I haven't made my fortune pratting about on some god-awful 'reality' TV programme so my life is over and the only job left is working in a call centre" - was that it?!
Seriously, other kinds of jobs are available and if you want them, YOU need to find them - they're not going to come looking for you! There is more to life than call centres and fame and fortune, and it's certainly not a case of you have the choice to do one or the other!
It's fine to have aspirations to be rich and famous, a lot of people want that, but you need a contingency plan. And if that means working hard at school, then so be it. Kids need to understand that their fortune is not going to be handed to them on a plate. The media needs to become more responsible for this trash tv as it is the media who have the highest influence on our children these days.
Dan, Kent, UK
This has always been the case. During my teen years I wanted to be a guitarist in a death metal band. One day that dream was shattered and I lost faith in everything. I believed in nothing else. So I then went to law school.
Chris, London, England
I say let them. Let them go and be failures, that way, they'll have a valuable lesson to tell their children about the dangers of being a colossal moron.
Joshua Yau, Frodsham, Cheshire
Didn't we all want to be famous - I was going to be a pop star (can't sing) and a model (too small) and I was going to marry a rich famous pop star (the equivalent of being a WAG).
Isn't it nice for our kids to have dreams while they are still young enough to believe dreams can come true!
April, Chester, Cheshire
Doesn't every kid want to be a popstar at some point?
I know I did, and I've grown up to be a teacher of all things!
I think there are a lot of reasons that education is no longer valued in the way it was, most of them cutural, but it is a bit flippant to attribute it to the Beckhams and Big Brother.
Jo, Sussex, UK
Not all of us work in call centres! I enjoy my job and earn very good money doing so (I'm not a celebrity). The media needs to stop obsessing so much about over-night 'celebrity-ism' there's more to life than that rubbish.
James Clarke, Brighton,
So kids want to grow up to be famous footballers or pop stars. Is that really news to anyone?
That this should come as a revelation to teachers says more about the sorry state of the educational system in this country than the fact that the kids, on this evidence, are the same hopeless dreamers they ever were.
xwoof, Margate,
I have a good degree from a good university in engineering and all it has enabled me to do is work hard for mediocre remuneration.
Matthew
Matthew, Oxford,
I thought pupils had parents who could set them straight .. But maybe they're just as daft ...
n monrad, amsterdam,
I fail to see the obsession with the Beckhams!! Children should be informed of more options than being Rich or Poor and then maybe we would hear of some real aspirations!
Grow up
Amy, Bourne, England, United Kingdom
Rather than complain about the poor role models supplied by TV, perhaps the teaching profession should be engaging with the media to suggest better role model ideas. I recall well the soap opera Brookside had a character who studied for her accountancy exams and let the life of a young woman with life choices. The inherently moral messages underlying many soap story lines would be an excellent way of exploring life choices.
Yvonne, Newcastle,
Girls have always wanted to marry millionaires and they always will. Millionaires, on the other hand, don't usually put academic achievement at the top of the list when choosing a partner.
The girls are being more realistic than they're getting credit for.
Albert Lampwick, UK,
What a shock. Since the influx of immigrants to this country, British workers have been denounced as lazy with no work ethic (in reality we can't afford to work for peanuts). No wonder kids can't be bothered with proper jobs when they are condemned before they even start.
Emma, Southampton,
There's nothing wrong with having David Beckham as a role model. His dedication and work ethic are exemplary. Stories of him staying behind for hours after training working on his game are now legendary.
David, London,
What...ever
Jade, London,
We have nothing else to aim for in this country.
It's either that or a call centre. Given the alternative I think these kids ambitions are pretty healthy and normal.
Signed Ben, from a grim call centre in the north west.
Ben Rosenthal, Manchester, Lancashire