Nicola Woolcock
Pick up your copy of Joy Division: Closer at WHSmith today
From the football pitch to the classroom, schools have worked hard to stamp out sexism. Girls are encouraged to take up woodwork and boys to strut their stuff in the kitchen.
But there is one place where stereotypes are still calling the tune: the music room.
Macho instruments such as the trombone, drums and electric guitar are the province of boys, while girls stick to the gentler tones of the flute, harp and violin.
Now education experts are asking why. They blame gender stereotyping by both teachers and parents, peer pressure and the fear of bullying and the size and shape of instruments.
The researchers at the University of London’s Institute of Education - led by Professor Susan Hallam, a former professional musician – looked at the instrument choices of nearly half a million children. They found that the vast majority of those for harp, flute, fife, piccolo, clarinet, oboe and violin were by girls, whereas boys were far more likely to play the electric guitar, bass guitar, tuba and trombone.
They suggest setting up single-sex ensembles to bridge the divide.
However, the researchers admit that boys seem to like instruments that require physical input and are easy to learn, and girls seem to prefer gentler sounds – and instruments that are not too heavy to carry.
The report, in the International Journal of Music Education, said: “The cultural gender stereotyping of instruments inevitably has an impact on the preferences of boys and girls, leading to girls typically preferring to play smaller, higher-pitched instruments.”
A child’s choice of instrument can be heavily influenced by his or her music teacher. “Presenting instruments aurally and visually, without players, can encourage boys to select more feminine instruments, although it has little effect on girls’ choices.
“Changing the gender of the role model playing the instrument has also been shown to be effective with children aged 5 to 7. When a female is playing a ‘masculine’ instrument, more girls opt for playing it.
“Where children choose to play an instrument that is considered gender-inappropriate, they may experience bullying or loss of popularity,” the report added. “Even where there is apparently free choice, stereotypical views of masculinity and femininity still play an important part.”
The gender divide becomes more pronounced in secondary school.
“Social factors that may be important include role models, stereotypical expectations, culture, religion and parental influence,” the report said.
“Boys may prefer instruments that are struck or require high levels of physical exertion. The technical difficulty of the instrument and level of persistence required to play it may also play a part, as evidence indicates boys tend to do less practice than girls.
“However, for some children it may simply be an issue of access, cost and whether transport is available.”
The report said that music teachers should make it clear to pupils that they can learn any instrument.
Professor Hallam said: “The world would be a poorer place if James Galway had been discouraged from playing the flute and Evelyn Glennie had been told that girls shouldn’t become percussionists.”
Explore your passion for food with the delights of Thai, Indian & Chinese cooking
In our new series, Tony Hawks takes a dry, wry look at modern life - junk mail, interminable meetings and snooty sales assistants
Read the training tips and advice that helped our London Triathletes
Read our exclusive 100 Years of Fleming and Bond interactive timeline, packed with original Times articles and reviews
The latest travel news plus the best hotels and gadgets for business travellers
Shortcuts to help you find sections and articles
2007
£30,000
2006
£14,337
2008
£39,937
Great car insurance deals online
c.£75,000
GlosFirstmeansbusiness
Gloucestershire
Competitive package
Npower
Midlands
£
£32,795 - £41,545
Universitry of Southampton
Southampton
Competitive Package
Npower
West Midlands
1 & 2 Bed apartments
From £249,995
Great Investment, River Views
Great Dubai Investment Opportunities
from £89,950
low-cost ownership homes in London
Multi–Centre 9 Nights
From only £925pp
View thousands of properties online with your Vacation Rental People
£POA
List your property with two leading travel websites
£POA
Great travel insurance deals online
Contact our advertising team for advertising and sponsorship in Times Online, The Times and The Sunday Times. Globrix Property Search - find property for sale and rent in the UK. Milkround Job Search - for graduate careers in the UK. Visit our classified services and find jobs, used cars, property or holidays. Use our dating service, read our births, marriages and deaths announcements, or place your advertisement.
Copyright 2008 Times Newspapers Ltd.
This service is provided on Times Newspapers' standard Terms and Conditions. Please read our Privacy Policy.To inquire about a licence to reproduce material from Times Online, The Times or The Sunday Times, click here.This website is published by a member of the News International Group. News International Limited, 1 Virginia St, London E98 1XY, is the holding company for the News International group and is registered in England No 81701. VAT number GB 243 8054 69.
This doesn't apply in my school. I play the drums, a friend plays the guitar and two play the saxophone. However, I can't say the boys don't play instruments like the guitar and drums.
me, London, UK
Denial of opportunity because of sex should never be tolerated. But these efforts have strayed into the land of the absurd and suggest what's really going on is that some people can't stand the fact that little girls aren't little boys. UGH!
Barry Madison, Pittsburgh , USA
Girls do play the tuba.I played the tuba at school from the age of 12 to 18 and all the other 3 tuba players were girls too. The boys played trumpets and saxes.
Carol, Leighton Buzzard,
Music is an art form, and one thing that artists do is to create associations. For instance angels are always shown dressed in white to reflect their purity. They also play harps, not electric guitars, drumkits, or synthesisers.
Malcolm McLean, Bradford, UK
As a harpist myself, I will say that if girls wanted to choose a 'light' instrument, the harp would not be on the short-list! A full-size harp can weigh 90 lbs. Most harpists carry their instruments up and down stairs by themselves. The harp demands hand, eye, and foot coordination. It may sound pretty, but just remember the strength those harpists hide in their 'delicate arms.'
Alyson , Cambridge, UK
Actually I find women who can play the Violin especially attractive,can't say they would have the same attraction if they were hefting around a tuba. So no damn it, keep the girls playing elegant little instruments.That Vanessa Mae wouldn't look half as good if she enormous shoulders.
suppose next someone will expose the terrible discrepancy in the genders in regards to doors being held open.
"Shock Horror, males develop leg fatigue after standing to welcome female to table"
Our society seems to suffer differences these days rather then cherish them.
James, cambridge,
When playing at school the only other trombonists I knew were girls and now (many years later) having started playing again in an amateur orchestra in London the trombonists are all women.
Jemma, London,
Is this a joke? - Political correctness gone mad....... yet again!
C'mon Britain, get a life!
steve, white river, south africa
" a friend`s music teacher described me as a "cartoon" when he saw me playing with my trombone"
Oh dear ! Don`t teachers realise how what they say, cuts to the quick.
I wish I had a pound for every time someone tells me..incorrectly ..
" I`ve got no ear for music , my teacher told me I`m tone deaf".
It is remembered for a lifetime.
andy, peterborough, uk
Given that kids want to look cool, I can understand why no one would choose the ugly looking and sounding tuba. In my high school, the 'cool' kids play the things that make them look good and sound good - guitars, violins, clarinets, piano. You can't look cool with puffy cheeks and making a nose like a fornicating elephant.
dei, UK,
As a 9 year old girl, I insisted on playing the alto sax despite being recommended the flute.
I loved the sound, but it was too heavy for me. As a result, my dad suffered having to pick me up from school on the days I had lessons and I never really enjoyed it as much as I could because of the weight.
Jess, cardiff, wales
I played the trombone in my (girls) school marching and concert band and nobody batted an eyelid. We played whatever needed to be played to make beautiful music. But it was a real hassle having to lug a trombone to orchestra rehearsals outside school. A friend's music teacher described me as a 'cartoon' when he saw me with my trombone. I now play the flute.
SP Lee, London,
What of the poor left hander - who looks out for him (usually)/her?
john cramer, strathfield, australia