AA Gill: Table Talk
Win Sky+HD for a year and a trip to Barcelona
I was in Scotland last week and thought I might surprise you all by reviewing a restaurant that isn’t in Chelsea. I found myself in Huntly, Aberdeenshire, at lunchtime. Huntly boasts a museum that is easily the most tragically pathetic in a nation that has more history than it can really cope with. A single room showed off an alderman’s dressing gown and a glass case with a complete set of chain mail sewn together out of press studs. And that was pretty much it. More a dressing-up box than an actual museum.
A local said that the finest food Huntly had to offer was at the Castle Hotel. So off we went. And . . . you know, I can’t bring myself to do it. Maybe I’ve lost my nerve. Maybe it’s the cancer of pity. But it would be like shooting kippers in a bucket. The brochure starts: “It takes a special kind of passion to seek out the rare, beautiful and extraordinary.” And it takes a rare sort of self-restraint not to wipe your bottom on the curtains of people who write about themselves with that kind of self-regard.
It was the end bit, though, that really cocked the pistol of loathing: a picture of mine hosts, him in tweed, cravat and a fulsome grin, her in fleece and cashmere, with the taut demeanour of the professionally hospitable. It was signed, “Haste ye back”, the paper motto of the English gentry in Scotland. No Scot has ever written that. Occasionally, they’ll offer, “Lang may your lum reek”, an Edwardian music-hall catch phrase that means, pointlessly, “Long may your chimney smoke.”
Ever since I hasted me back south, I’ve been considering the minefield of signing off, made so much more acute by e-mail, and I’ve come to realise that all trite expressions of insincere affection drive me to a puce distraction. “Missing you already”: no you’re not, but I wish I were. This should be used only by inept snipers. “LOL”: so much L, in fact, that you can’t even be bothered to spell it out. “Hugs’n’kisses”: anything with a connecting “n” is grounds for wiping your family name from the escutcheon of history. Smiley face: how utterly oxymoronic is smiley face? “Take care”: so you’re implying I’m a simple-minded invalid? “Keep it real”: as opposed to what? Keeping it fantastical? Mythological? Legendary? “Be careful out there”: no, you be careful, because you have no idea how many people want you dead. “Ciao”, “Auf Wiedersehen”, “A bientôt”: anything foreign is nauseating. As is Latin: “Ave!” or “Nil carborundum sodomiti” (“Don’t let the buggers grind you down”). Appeals to God — “Bless”, “Inshallah”, “Shalom” — are only ever written by the damnably apostate. There’s the cheerily Falstaffian “Keep your powder dry”, “Anchors away”, “Steady the buffs” — and the organic-hippie “Keep the faith” and “In with the anger, out with the love”, which are both what a girl I know calls “shag-busters”.
I realise that anyone who sends an e-mail with an attached cliché of even the mildest sentiment disgusts me beyond redemption — certainly beyond invitation. Which leaves us with a problem: how do you sign off? Do you just keep on and on and on writing? Shamefully, I must admit to use of the X key. I don’t mean multiple use, and never, ever, I swear, with an O. But I do do it to people I couldn’t be induced to kiss for cash. I know this is a concern that many of you will have answering suggestions for. Briefly, on an e-mail or a postcard. Cheers. Laters. AA. X
Don’t, whatever you do, try going to the Sanderson hotel for the first time. If you already know your way to Berners Street, in London’s West End, then fine, risk it. But I’ve never ventured into a one-way labyrinth of such sadistic complexity. After I had passed the same minotaur for the third time, I would have happily given up and gone home, if getting home had been any easier.
When the Sanderson opened, it was, briefly, the coolest place in London, until the circling, weeping traffic reminded everyone that they were actually north of Oxford Street. The hotel’s original restaurant was Spoon, invented by Alain Ducasse, the most absurd of all the international celebrity chefs. It was the first and most tiresome of the concept dining rooms that put the temporary into contemporary, and was all style over substance, except for one dish that has sadly been lost to London: bubble-gum-flavoured ice cream made with a particular French bubble gum. Remember the taste of Bazooka? It was a bit like that.
Anyway, Spoon has gone, and in its place is Suka, a new Malaysianish restaurant. Malay is the new Thai, as Thai was once the new Cantonese. Fusion is wandering round the Far East like a serial killer. We were walked through quite a pretty candlelit restaurant to be sat on the Siberian side of some curtains, on bar stools, at simple, refectory-style shared tables. My daughter pointed out that there was nowhere to put your feet, which is almost a disqualifying design fault.
The menu has a little concept, of course, which is that everybody orders three courses and everybody shares. The Blonde and the children had exotic cocktails sans alcohol — all tasted like the leakings from a fruit bat with prostate trouble. I’ve always thought that the alcohol in fruit cocktails is there as a consolation for having to swallow a fruit cocktail.
The starters are the best thing. They always are in eastern food. I think it’s because oriental flavours and textures are particularly intense and gratifying when you’re starving, and become less and less interesting as your hunger is sated. We liked the small squares of soft belly pork and fat spring rolls, and the duck served in what can be described only as sweet, soft panty-pads.
As we went on, it got less good. The beef rendang was just badly made and cooked in a hurry — it tasted like a stewed cowboy boot or, perhaps, a cowboy’s foot in a boot. A tranche of turbot in a butter sauce was pleasant, but unAsian. Nastiest, and most memorable, was the oyster omelette, like fried lung cookie in emphysema. Pudding — a fruit plate — was a Patpong ladyboy sex show: tasteless, underage, hard and not what it’s cracked up to be.
The bill was outrageously large — £255 for four people, with no alcohol and sitting at a shared table, which is not even within hailing distance of value. Oh, and there was the relentless numbing thud of techno-trance, according to my son.
But Suka isn’t really the point of the Sanderson. I was pleasantly astonished by the large, noisy bar. It’s a sure-thing rehearsal room for every lame pick-up line that doesn’t work on MySpace. It plainly will with these girls, who can only count up to eight, but whose bodies go right up to 16. It was a pout-practice workshop, and rather sweet. I’m glad they’ve all found each other, and that the one-way streets will stop them escaping into Soho, where they might damage the gene pool.
Chin-chin.
Suka
Rated 5/5
50 Berners Street, W1; 020 7300 1400.Lunch, noon-2.30pm. Dinner, Mon-Wed, 5.30pm-midnight, Thu-Sat, 5.30pm-12.30am, Sunday, 5.30pm-10.30pm
Ratings
5/5 All the best; 4/5 Kind regards; 3/5 Yours sincerely; 2/5 I must be going; 1/5 Over and out

AA Gill is a features writer and restaurant critic for The Sunday Times and he writes regular travel pieces for The Sunday Times Magazine, for which he has won two Glenfiddich Awards
Explore your passion for food with the delights of Thai, Indian & Chinese cooking
In our new series, Tony Hawks takes a dry, wry look at modern life - junk mail, interminable meetings and snooty sales assistants
Read the training tips and advice that helped our London Triathletes
Read our exclusive 100 Years of Fleming and Bond interactive timeline, packed with original Times articles and reviews
The latest travel news plus the best hotels and gadgets for business travellers
Shortcuts to help you find sections and articles
2007
£30,000
2006
£14,337
2008
£39,937
Great car insurance deals online
c.£75,000
GlosFirstmeansbusiness
Gloucestershire
£32,795 - £41,545
Universitry of Southampton
Southampton
£
£32,795 - £41,545
Universitry of Southampton
Southampton
Competitive Package
Npower
West Midlands
1 & 2 Bed apartments
From £249,995
Great Investment, River Views
Great Dubai Investment Opportunities
from £89,950
low-cost ownership homes in London
Las Vegas SALE!
£POA
With Ramblers Worldwide Holidays!
£POA
List your property with two leading travel websites
£POA
Great travel insurance deals online
Contact our advertising team for advertising and sponsorship in Times Online, The Times and The Sunday Times. Globrix Property Search - find property for sale and rent in the UK. Milkround Job Search - for graduate careers in the UK. Visit our classified services and find jobs, used cars, property or holidays. Use our dating service, read our births, marriages and deaths announcements, or place your advertisement.
Copyright 2008 Times Newspapers Ltd.
This service is provided on Times Newspapers' standard Terms and Conditions. Please read our Privacy Policy.To inquire about a licence to reproduce material from Times Online, The Times or The Sunday Times, click here.This website is published by a member of the News International Group. News International Limited, 1 Virginia St, London E98 1XY, is the holding company for the News International group and is registered in England No 81701. VAT number GB 243 8054 69.
Considering that Mr. Gill has a v ery over-rated opinion of himself and his concerns, he should be happy to get any sort of e-mail however signed.
Many people would be.
Pat, Ferndale, United States - Michigan
In the paper itself it was only given three stars (out of five): seems like a glitch in the online version.
Rehan, London,
Does Mr. Gill realize that by giving a 5/5 rating after such a review he has discredited his review and called into question his other reviews? I am truly puzzled.
Kim, New York, NY
Dear Mr Gill,
you may find my e-mail signing off styles useful, they are:
family and loved ones- love Ruth
coleagues and business - regards Ruth
Trevor - toodle pips
you may wish to omit the 'Ruth'
reagrds Ruth
ps Lathkill Dale is the country river walk, followed by drink in Red Lion, Birchover followed by lunch in The Driud, Birchover, (you could try the sarnie) with post lunch drink back in Red Lion again.
Ruth Davenport, Sheffield, S. Yorks
I'm sorry, the pope is infallible. A A Gill is merely impeccable and, on this occasion, wrong. 'Lang may yer lum reek.' is not pointless. Your lum (chimney) can only reek (smoke) when you can afford to put coal - or whatever - in it. Thus the wish is that you be ever prosperous. It is, or was, a realistic wish.
John Carty, Medellin, Colombia
5/5?
Daniel , Mauritius,
agree with charles, a mildly complementary final paragraph doesn't square with a largely negative review. Even in terms of Suka fulfilling its own expectations, 'As we went on, it got less good. The beef rendang was just badly made and cooked in a hurry' suggests much improvement to be had.
luke, london,
I'm sorry, 5/5 - some mistake, surely?
Andy, London,
How can you rate it 5/5 with that write-up??? It reads like an overpriced 2 at best!
Charles, charlottesville,
You can get bubble gum ice cream at Baskin Robbins in North America. They have it occasionally, and it's always been my favorite.
isabella reyes, toronto, canada
Loved your ratings, but the food sounds crap and the review, honestly, below your average.
P. D. Have you ever written on El Bulli, Ferran Adrià's restaurant? I'd love to know how you'd rate that.
Jaume Vivé, Vic, spain
I always enjoy the scathing yet suggestively piteous style of these artcles by AA Gill. And I also enjoy the flagrant disregard of anything approaching value for money at the Sanderson - anyone who goes there will know that it is one step away from them actually issuing you with a t-shirt at the door with a space where you fill in how much money you have. But then, thats the point of it. But having given a poor report of at least some of the dishes served, how has the place earned 5/5? I'll go to Chino Latino, and then the Long bar for post-prandial thanks
Alasdair MacDonald, Oxford, England
5/5? Shum mishtake shirley. I yake it the wine list wasgood at least.
Might I, in passing, concur fully with the previous message. On Sunday mornings out here in Poonah and thanks to the Internet I read the UK newspapers. One of my first stops after a glance at the main stories is your column(s) which never fails to put me in good humour for the day in case, rare fortunatley, I am not in one already.
And just for you Mister Gill... ;-)
John Murphy, Lauris, France
So you hated it, then rated it 5 out of 5?!?
I'm glad I don't live in England, so I don't ever run the chance of trying to decide where to eat based on your 'reviews'.
Funny descriptions, tho.
Michael Collins, Kelowna, British Columbia, Canada
As allways, I find it hard to control the tears of laughter , reading your reviews is a weekly high spot, , my co-workers think I am insane, as I sit laughing in front of my PC, the images conjoured whilst reading often bring me to the edge of hysteria.
Pay a visit to Montreal and puncture a few egos here!
many many thanks
Ross Cattrell
Montreal
Canada
R Cattrell, Montreal, Canada
Slate it and then give it top marks, I HAVE missed something.
Toodle pip
Ken.Wyatt, Todmorden, UK
I do not understand how you can possibly give a restaurant 5/5 when you severely criticise the food. You're not meant to be reviewing the hotel so how you can say Suka isn't really the point I don't know. I would also mention that unless the menu has changed drastically since last Tuesday, there is no duck in "panty pads" on the starter - you might be confusing it with the Suckling Pig Penang main course which is very similar to crispy duck and following with the rest of the inconsistencies of the review, this would make sense.
Kate, London,
Wonderful! I don't feel so much like a penny-pinching Philistine now. The only time I tried sushi was a M&S little quick lunch - maybe not gourmandising, but very cheap and good for a first try. Why wait in a restaurant and then sit unhappily eating stuff you may not like for loads of money? Beats me why people do it! Tried the sushi: it was tasteless. If this is what raw fish is like, I won't waste any more money. And you can keep your chili sauce, too. I can't cope with it, it makes me grab the milk bottle so I can breathe again and my stomach rebels. Yet chili is now flavour of the month ( a term first applied to ice cream, a cheap option) and I long for its demise! It has replaced tomato, which also used to upset my delicate digestion. I know what I can eat: give me the bread ( plain, no chili), rice, melon ( not watermellon - I hate it), fruit (except bananas), soup, vegitables , noodles and I can go anywhere!
Carlyle Braden, Croydon, U.K.