AA Gill: Table talk
Download 'Too Hot', an exclusive Specials track from iTunes

We’ve got mice. We’ve got mice on the inside. A mouse on the outside is a friend of David Attenborough, an infinitely miraculous and fascinating link in a complex and breathtaking ecosystem. A mouse on the inside is home herpes. We’ve got a mouse on the inside. A mouse is a stylistic invention, a literary conceit. You can write “a mouse”, you can say “a mouse”, you can imagine a mouse – you can imagine a mouse playing the ukulele or driving a small train, wearing a monocle – but in the real world, there is no such thing as a mouse. There are only mice. You might notice a mouse going about his busy business on the carpet, but it is only the tip of the miceberg.
And where you find mice, you also find Rentokil. I don’t know which is worse: mouse, or Stanley from Rentokil. “Hi, I’m Stanley from Rentokil,” he said. He said it on the outside. On the inside, he was saying: “Hi, I’m Dirty Harry. Make my day, furry bitch.” Nobody leaves school and says to the careers person (a teacher too fat and stupid to teach gym): “Thank you for the 14 years of full-time education – I’m off to join Rentokil.” But plenty of kids leave school at eight knowing that they want to be the Men in Black. They naturally slip into pest control as the closest legal alternative to whacking extraterrestrials.
So, Stanley Die Hard cased the house, sucked his teeth in the manner of an Acton Tommy Lee Jones and told the Blonde she was living on a midden of hairy pestilence, that the kitchen was the Petri dish of a new Black Death, that mouse urine contained all the ingredients for the pustular, bloody, vomiting end of life as we know it, but not to worry. He could sort it. For the price of a term’s school fees or a short skiing holiday in Gstaad, he would do it all without unsightly, embarrassing or smelly corpses. He said we should block their holes with wire wool. I can see that would be effective, but isn’t it fiddly and rather cruel?
“Not their holes; their other holes.” Other holes?
“Yes, the holes they use.” Use for what?
“Ignore him,” said the Blonde.
“There is this new solution we have,” Stanley said silkily. “It works with state-of-the-art techno-stuff. You don’t need to worry your pretty little heads. The problem steps inside the box, and a measured dose of gas is administered – silent, efficient, keen. And we take them away.”
I’m sorry. Run that past me again. You’re going to put a dozen Hornby Dublo gas chambers in my house?
“Well, technically, they’re . . .” Technically, they’re Mauschwitz.
It was too creepy. Confronted by this Cruella de Vil played by Ralph Fiennes, I found my inner Mouskar Schindler and decided to kill them the painful, old-fashioned, screaming, democratic way. Then the Blonde discovered the sticky paper.
Once in a generation, an invention comes that is so brilliant, so farsighted, so utterly right, it changes the world and makes you believe that the future will be a sunny, happy and civilised place. Sticky-backed mouse mats are pure genius. You peel off the paper and lay them like solitaire aces around the house and garden, and, in the morning, there are mice, glued in comically balletic positions. But you have to get there before the dog. If you don’t, you have mouse stuck to mat stuck to jack russell face. It’s like the Tar Baby – both funny and disgusting. Then you just pop them in the bin, except, of course, you can’t dump a live mouse embossed on cardboard into the recycle bin bag. The Blonde said: “Best to fold them in half and hit them hard with a frying pan.” Sometimes it’s useful having a South African round the house.
Stanley left us with a small dilemma: through the letter box, he shouted, “You’ve two sorts of mice: town mice and field mice.” Oh, no, not field mice! Town mice are a pest infestation; country mice are a fairy story. I blame unrestricted immigration. They’re obviously economic migrants, imported to the town to be sex slaves and waiters. The Blonde says she thinks we’ve got Polish mice as well. There are droppings under the sink, and they’ve started grouting the tiles.
St Peter’s Square is one of those surprisingly expansive corners of the suburban city that squats between the motorway west and Chiswick High Road. It is a showy moment of aspirational Victorian villa life plopped among the terraces, the skilled tradesmen’s cottages. But it isn’t anything like as surprising as the Carpenter’s Arms, on the corner, a lost pub of the type that is now useful only as a spivvy conversion to studio flats. It’s a long, plain room with a bit of a courtyard out the back, and doesn’t make any effort to be anything other than a down-on-its-luck backstreet boozer. Philippa, who lives round the corner, said we should try the food. The menu is English, in the current genre of robust and enthusiastic use of interesting ingredients and cheaper cuts. The starters include leek and potato soup with oysters, sauté of smoked eel, chanterelle and jerusalem artichokes, steamed razor clams with parsley, garlic and cream, quail with grapes and braised bacon, chicory and mustard. For main courses, you can have a hot salt-beef sandwich with beetroot and pickles, a proper poacher’s pie, bream with octopus and butternut squash, bits of beef, a Tamworth pork chop or duck-fat oven chips with roast garlic and foie-gras mayonnaise. Altogether, that’s a pretty good spread for a pub. It’s not pretentious or weird, it’s not got a concept, it’s just bloody brilliant.
I’ve eaten here twice. The first time, I had a mutton soup that left me speechless with admiration; each time, every dish has been faultless. The room is plain, quiet and relaxed. The grub is served by a pretty, quiet and relaxed waitress who knows what’s what. It comes on plates that are round and white, with cutlery that does what it’s told. And it comes without ta-ra, falderal or soliloquy. It’s honest, accomplished and confident, full of its own flavour, and as well made as a grandfather clock. I could now go on to sauce each dish with metaphor and simile, I could garnish it all with alliteration and allegory, serve it up to you on napery of verbiage, but I shan’t. Simply and truly, this is a kitchen that wholly succeeds in doing what it sets out to do, in a room that is gently hospitable, without assumption or pretension. It is as fine and joyous a lunch as you will find the length and breadth of Britain this week.
91 Black Lion Lane, W6; 0871 703 2881.
Lunch, Mon-Fri, noon-3pm, Sat, Sun, 12.30pm-4pm; dinner, Mon-Sat, 7pm-10pm
(Sun 9.30pm)
5 stars: Mighty Mouse; 4 stars: Squeaky clean; 3 stars: Cheesy; 2 stars: Mousy; 1 star: Taking the Mickey
AA Gill is a features writer and restaurant critic for The Sunday Times and he writes regular travel pieces for The Sunday Times Magazine, for which he has won two Glenfiddich Awards
Win a luxury weekend to Newcastle and its neighbour Gateshead, find out more here
Risk, resilience and embracing new technology
Industry sectors news at a glance. Interactive heatmap, video and podcast
Discover the power of collective thinking. Submit a solution and be in with a chance to win a Media Hub Home Entertainment System
The inside track on current trends in the charity, not for profit and social enterprise sectors
Everything the Business Traveller needs to know to make a better trip
Make the most of the summer and enter our fabulous photographic competition, you could win a £5000 holiday
Corsica is an island of beauty and contrast, an ideal holiday destination
Enjoy further reading from Travel to Fashion, Business to Sport, discover more
Shortcuts to help you find sections and articles
The clever way to lease a new car is with Car leasing made simple™
2009
per month on 36-month
Personal Contract Hire (PCH)
2008
42850
Car Insurance
£24,250 - £30,346
MI5
London
£60,000
The Environment Agency
Bristol
Up to £90K
Boots
Midlands
OTE £85k
Credit Protection Association
Nationwide Opportunities
Completely London
Luxury Condo's in Manhattan with NYC views
The best new homes in Wimbledon?
Nationwide
Fabulous Cruise And Cruise & Stay Offers Including Virgin Atlantic Flights Prices Start From Only £699pp!
Last Minute Cruise And Cruise & Stay Offers. Med From £499pp, Caribbean From £699pp!
5 star quality at a 3 star price.
8 fabulous Canadian cities ...you won’t find cheaper
Contact our advertising team for advertising and sponsorship in Times Online, The Times and The Sunday Times, or place your advertisement.
Times Online Services: Dating | Jobs | Property Search | Used Cars | Holidays | Births, Marriages, Deaths | Subscriptions | E-paper
News International associated websites: Globrix Property Search | Property Finder | Milkround
Copyright 2009 Times Newspapers Ltd.
This service is provided on Times Newspapers' standard Terms and Conditions. Please read our Privacy Policy.To inquire about a licence to reproduce material from Times Online, The Times or The Sunday Times, click here.This website is published by a member of the News International Group. News International Limited, 1 Virginia St, London E98 1XY, is the holding company for the News International group and is registered in England No 81701. VAT number GB 243 8054 69.
The crab on toast was inedible - far too salty, insipid, no taste of fresh crab (I bet is was bought pre-dressed) and as dry as, well, dry toast. One of our party refused to pay for it.
The mains were slightly below bog standard.
We went there on Gill's recommendation.He obviously doesn't have a clue what he's on about.
Sean Wallace, London,
Rotwacher.... I challenge you to write in such an eloquent fashion... perhaps you should apply for Gill's job and see how you fare
Drew Rogers, London,
I'm glad it got its old name back anyhow. It used to be a French theme pub called Le St Pierre. Like drinking in a pop-up model of the inside of the head of a particularly irritatingly francophile section of the English upper middle classes. I speak French, I've lived there, but I don't want a French theme pub, merci. Le St Pierre est dead, long live the Carpenters.
Chris, London,
I'm a Londoner, born and bled. This is unquestionably the best 'pub' (?) grub in town. Forget the facy restaurants that spend more on showing their taste in decor rather than their in cuisine. The Carpenter looks like it spent £2.50 on its decor but its food is worth ten time that per bite.
SS, London, UK
Visited on 4/11/07. The Amstel draught beer was as flat as a pancake and the table hadn't been wiped clean. JK.
JK, london,
What total rubbish. The Carpenter's Arms is exactly what Gill said it was, simple but excellent. There are certailnly no "overdone presenations". Go and be horrible to a restaurant that deserves it. By the by, if you have an issue with something you should tell staff of the establishment while you're there not rant about it online.
Tony, London,
i am just coming back from the carpenter's arms and i had a wonderfull meal. three starters on my own.
my wife and my two sons loved it, even if one normaly eat chips and chips only.
slow service but friendly. i will certainly go again and again and again.
i am a chef myself voted twice pub chef of the year and going next week for the final (third year) and i am glad the chef of the carpenters arms is not on the finalist list or i would maybe stay home.
claude, london,
Having read A A Gills recent review of the Carpenters Arms, I ventured there with a couple of friends for lunch today. Unfortunately it was without fail one of the worst gastro pub experience from every point of view other then where it is located and the lovely garden. The food was less then acceptable with overdone presentations, it took about half an hour for each course to be served, the staff were nowhere near as learned as indicated by Gill. It simply was a disaster.
I can only assume that he was recognised on his visit or the pub has since its write up exceeded all his expectations and can actually not cope with it. The waitress told me they are booked up for the next three weeks. If it continues as it is now, it'll be gone very soon as I have not seen too many happy customers today. I suggest Gill goes back there disguised and reviews it again as soon as possible, if he wants to retain his credibility as a serious food critic. I'll doubt I'll accept his future recommendations
E Wirtenberger, London ,
The pub sounds fantastic, but the sticky mice mats are horrible and cruel. Don't use them. If they aren't checked the animals suffer and die.
Karen Ralph, Calgary, Alberta, Canada
Well said Tom.
jilly, London,
The menu isn't large at all Ian, it's relatively tight and well written. Of course the food is cooked on the premises. A chef who has the craft to write as interesting menu as that would not consider re-heating. Learn the trade before making ill informed comments.
tom , leicester,
I cannot now park, Mr Gill...
They're nice folk and have worked hard for this - well done you for helping them - they're my local. The food is yummy and has no agenda. I do not drink but boozers purr at the wine and even CAMRA Nazis guzzle whatever strange beer of the shires gets served.
This is now, thank God, a truly decent pub - and I still cannot find any spot to park despite knowing the place well...nor can I get a table, also thanks to you.
Geordie, London W6,
Isn't that a large menu for "an unpretentious pub"? Or isn't it all cooked on the premises. The food in my local "The Lamb and Flag" at Welney,Cambs is ? I will back it against Gill's local
ian skidmore, march, cambs
720 words on his rodent infestation (well, I assume that's what it was. I always elide the first bit of a Gill review since he just goes off on whatever riff occurs to him at the time) and just 400 on the restaurant. In other words, just as dull and soporific as all his other "reviews".
Rotwatcher, CHELTENHAM,
An amusing article, which, delightfully, ended with a wonderful restaurant review. I'm sure that the beer is important to you mym but I'd be more interested in the wine list.
Before the back biting starts, may I say, "Welcome back A.A. Gill".
Marc, St. Barthelemy,
Good point mym! What about the beer!
Geoff, Birmingham, UK
And what about the beer?
mym, London,
Where do I buy the sticky-back mouse mats for my French mice?
Dot Wilcock, Windsor, Berkshire