Giles Coren
Win a fitness package worth more than £3,000

I’ve just got back from a couple of weeks’ holiday and, boy oh boy, am I glad to be back. I swear, that was Italy’s last chance. I am not going to fall for it again. All that rubbish about lovely fresh food, charming people, casual, tumbledown restaurants in the shadow of ancient ruins, bambini frolicking between the tables, linguine cooked so al dente you could pick a padlock with it, ooh, darling the tomatoes, the tinkle of pinot grigio hitting a rustic old tumbledown tumbler, simple grilled meats, ooh, darling the mozzarella, the very pepper-grinder that gave Shelley the idea for Ozymandias, ooh darling, the zucchini flowers poached in the tears of a gryphon…
It is all rubbish. I was in Rome for a week and then in the Tuscan countryside outside Lucca – the very model of the 21st-century bourgeois holiday idyll – and almost all the Italians I encountered were cheap, tacky swindlers who couldn’t cook.
I know you’ll all write in to tell me that the best Italian food is not to be found in restaurants, and that Italians eat best at home. Well, so do I. But I have to go on holiday sometimes. You will tell me that the best places are off the beaten track, little brown places with no sign which you wouldn’t even know was a restaurant unless you were a local. Yes, well, I am not a bloody local. And I am not Marco frigging Polo either. I have to go to places with signs.
I stayed at a place called the Hotel de Russie. It was meant, according to at least two guidebooks, to be the best hotel in Rome. Ha!
I booked three months in advance and chose a “view of the garden” as opposed to a “view of the city”. But when we arrived (me and some random flopsy), they put us in a room at the end of a dark corridor, fully three days’ walk from reception, with a view only of a wall. A cellar of a room. A room so mean and dark and lifeless I think Gollum would have called in the decorators.
They had clearly seen an unfamiliar name in the book, grasped I was English (hawk, spit, flick my teeth at you), and told the chambermaid, “Clean out the broom closet, Maria, the Corens are coming.”
I said it would not do. They said it was all they had. I said that they had specifically promised me a view of the garden. They said they had not. And then I said that, if they did not give me a room with at least some natural light, I would leave. And still they said that was all they had. So I told them to call me a taxi. And so they gave me a great room on the top floor, windows on two sides and beautiful views.
Goddam, that sort of thing makes me angry: to provide rubbish as a default until the difficult people hit the roof, and let the nice ones go screw themselves. It’s how you fill the world with Michael Winners.
Next morning at breakfast, same thing. Lovely sun-dappled garden restaurant, buongiorno, buongiorno, ah, English, have a seat here at the cutlery station where the waiters stack all the old plates and the birds come and crap on your lap, after all, you’re only paying 800 quid a night (a monstrous error – when I booked I honestly thought that was for the five nights).
Breakfast was included with the room unless you had hot food (yes, I know, who in the world would expect to get a hot breakfast for only 800 quid?). So the flopsy and I ordered scrambled eggs each and two pieces of bacon. Only when I went to pay the bill at the end (at reception, surrounded by dead-eyed staff, searching over my shoulder for fat viscontis in pale jeans and sockless lizard loafers to slime up to) did I discover that eggs and bacon for two had cost me 87 euros. Seventy-five quid for two plates of bacon and eggs. And we’d done it every morning.
We sent some laundry to be done: two shirts, a pair of shorts, three pairs of pants, some socks. 220 euros. £180. At least three times the value of the clothes themselves. The pants were not even badly soiled, as this was before I knew how much the room cost.
We went to some restaurants. Couple of decent pasta dishes but otherwise, rubbish. These people not only have never heard of vegetables, but have no idea how to cook meat – it was all so overdone, so brown, so whiffy… “So dead,” grunted the flopsy, who doesn’t usually talk with her mouth full.

Giles Coren has been a columnist for The Times since 1999. He began as a feature writer before becoming restaurant critic in 2001. His reviews appear in The Times Magazine on Saturdays
Industry sectors news at a glance. Interactive heatmap, video and podcast
The inside track on current trends in the charity, not for profit and social enterprise sectors
Read our exclusive 100 Years of Fleming and Bond interactive timeline, packed with original Times articles and reviews
Everything the Business Traveller needs to know to make a better trip
Shortcuts to help you find sections and articles
05/2005
£13,500
08/2008
£109,950
2006
£10,750
Great car insurance deals online
£Excellent+ executive benefits
Torres and Partners
London
£49,229 - £62,035 pro rata
Charity Commission
London/Liverpool/Taunton
Alstom Power
Europe
Six Figure
Rolls Royce
Midlands/Europe
From £89,950
Great Investment, River Views
Special Offers now available
At the new sophisticated
Encore Las Vegas Resort!
Cruise the Islands of Hawaii - Pride of America
List your property with two leading travel websites
Great travel insurance deals online
Contact our advertising team for advertising and sponsorship in Times Online, The Times and The Sunday Times, or place your advertisement.
Times Online Services: Dating | Jobs | Property Search | Used Cars | Holidays | Births, Marriages, Deaths
News International associated websites: Globrix | Property Finder | Milkround
Copyright 2008 Times Newspapers Ltd.
This service is provided on Times Newspapers' standard Terms and Conditions. Please read our Privacy Policy.To inquire about a licence to reproduce material from Times Online, The Times or The Sunday Times, click here.This website is published by a member of the News International Group. News International Limited, 1 Virginia St, London E98 1XY, is the holding company for the News International group and is registered in England No 81701. VAT number GB 243 8054 69.
Was treated by my wife to a weekend in Rome. Was ripped off from arrival to the hotel. Then we thought we would try to find an authentic Pizzaria. No chance. In every venue when asked if it was freshly made the answer was always; "Fresh Frozen".
No Bread or butter served..Ever..
John, London, UK
Thank you Giles..I thought it was just us!
We visited Rome in June expecting fab Italian food.. even the highly recommended restaurants produced at best totally unmemorable food. We walked out of 2 restaurants after appallingly bad first courses & the most surly & impolite behaviour from the staff .
Phil , Holmfirth, UK
We had high hopes for Italy for our honeymoon in May but we were so disappointed with the food. On one occasion we resorted to buying cheese, meats and olives from the supermarket deli and making our own italian feast in the hotel room. It was much better than the rubbish offered by the natives.
Victoria Grace, Greenhithe, UK
I am reminded of my honeymoon in the Italian Lakes where the food was very mediocre. We spent the last few days in Milan which was even worse, for one meal the starter arrived after the main course and then they brought an electronic bill which didn't add up!
Steve, Scarborough,
couldn't agree more about italian food - i did not fall in love with it at all - i thought i was the only one - thank you mr coren for busting the myth.
Danuta Farah, Dubai, UAE
No deserts in Italy ? Not too surprising.
Kath, Teignmouth, England
I went to the Italian lakes a few years ago and the food was horrendous everywhere. We ended up having to go 'off-menu' and ask the best of a bad bunch to make us spaghetti olio aglio and even that was touch and go.
Always self-cater, at least you can use the markets and eat breakfast whenever.
June Avrile, London,
Very funny, but unfortunately all too true. My wife and I spent a week in Rome not long ago, and try as we might, could not find a decent meal. It was, in a word, awful, no matter the restaurant, no matter the review. Too bad the Romans can't cook food to match their great historical sites.
Richard Keatinge, Paris, France
I have not spent much time in Italy but was extremely fortunate to be invited to dinner at the new Quo Vadis last week. i couldn't have asked for a more enjoyable evening. As soon as i passed through the revolving doors I was made to very welcome and the food was beautiful. 10/10
Henry, London, England
Mr Coren, I loved this piece. Refreshingly honest (and very funny) It was so refreshing to read something that was not bowing in servile deference to a tourist board!
Jenny, Enfield,
Whilst I'm not that keen on his style I'm afraid that many of Mr Coren's points are entirely accurate. I have lived in Rome for the past ten years and have seenoutrageous price rises matched only by a decline in quality. I blame it on the low cost airlines and the resultant complacency
david pickering, rome,
Bring on the Italian food (in Italy) bashing!! So true in every respect. Only request is you mention the lack of variety in Italian cuisine - ie apart from pasta & pizza, what is there? Not a lot... And deserts? there are none. Stick to France for the most varied (& best value) food there is
Alex Popov, London, UK
Refreshing to hear that Italy is not the best thing since sliced bread. I've never been; but the italophile-type round here are so annoying, I'll take your word for it.
Cass, San Francisco,
Hilarious - I stayed a the Russie a few years ago and got, by the sound of it, EXACTLY the same room (miles away with a view of a wall, a gate and some crates of empties.) On complaining we were shown the room we SHOULD have got (tiny and not that nice.) The one with the "wall view" was a bit bigger
David, Edinburgh,
I couldn't agree more about Roman food - all mouth and trousers, no flavours and style. Very disappointing. Sorrento was worse.
Roman hotels are perhaps the most overpriced chinz palaces in Europe.
London actually gives good value for money compared with Italy - no, really.
kwev, london, uk
Giles. Unfashionable and filthy Naples is quite the opposite of what you've described in Rome. Apart from a few piratical taxi drivers and widespread graffiti (it's an Italian word), our culinary and cultural adventures were unsullied. Indeed we encountered widespread charm and consideration.
Neil Drewitt, London,
Finally, someone tells the truth about Italy.
Rod Nelson, Vancouver, Canada
I would suggest Mr. Giles Coren to avoid traveling as evidently he is not prepared to different food and different habits. Perhaps he might try to come here in the Parma area where I live where it would be impossible to find a restaurant with bad food. I also like Quo Vadis which I know since 1955
Roberto Castellano, Salsomaggiore, Italy