Giles Coren
Win a fitness package worth more than £3,000
Georges Perec, author of La Vie: Mode D’Emploi (Life: A User’s Manual), one of the few truly great, truly innovative postwar European works of fiction, once wrote a novel with no e’s in it. It was called La Disparition, it had a perfectly decent plot, a bubbly narrative character, and ran to fully 300 pages without once employing the commonest letter of all. Which was damnedly, damnedly clever. But I couldn’t finish it.
Nor could I finish Gilbert Adair’s possibly even cleverer English translation of it, A Void.
I had a bash, later, at Les Revenentes (this was back in my early twenties, when I still thought literature was the most important thing of all), in which Perec, in order, he said, to use up all the e’s he had saved by not using any in La Disparition, allowed himself only that vowel, and no other. And I tried Ian Monk’s brave English translation (The Exeter Text: Jewels, Secrets, Sex) too. And I finished neither. Indeed, I came out of them, as I had come out of the “e”-less efforts, barely able to read at all. Like when you emerge from a hard hour with The Times crossword and normal sentences no longer make sense, and for a few minutes every phrase you encounter in the real, unencrypted world (“mind the gap”, “only two schoolchildren at a time”, “five items or fewer”) seems to represent a satanic clue of some sort.
That’s the thing with lipogrammatic literature (in which the author imposes some sort of restraint or deprivation on himself, often to get the juices flowing when there is a creative blockage – a sort of creative sadomasochism): it can be incredibly impressive, but it can never have real soul. La Disparition is the best novel I have ever read which doesn’t have any e’s in it, but it isn’t nearly as good as any of the novels I have read which do.
These weird little novels came back to me last night when I was sitting in Saf, a restaurant that is not only vegan, but almost entirely raw (barely any cooking goes on, just a little blanching), and, halfway through the meal, the random (thankfully carnivorous) flopsy I had taken along for company said, “It’s all done very well, but it’s a bit like looking at a painting where the artist has only been allowed to use green and blue – the things in it still look like things, it’s just that it’s positively screaming out for some reds and yellows.”
Yup, exactly. Or some e’s. Literature is built on e’s, just as haute cuisine (to which, with its “botanical fine dining”, Saf clearly aspires) is built on meat. You can take them away and try to do it without them. And it is sort of possible. And people will no doubt clap politely. But they will not drool. Their hearts will not race. They will not weep.
I am not in any way hostile to vegetarianism or veganism. I am not one of those Shire Tory fatties who make jokes about “people who knit their own yoghurt” and chortle till they choke on their pork chop. I accept (up to a point) the neo-Malthusian projection which says that past a certain population point only non-livestock farming can sustain life on earth, and I accept totally the health benefits of a (mostly, but not entirely) vegetable diet.
I even accept that vegetarians (and even vegans) can be (although usually are not) great lovers of food. But I reserve the right to observe that, with the exception of those religiously or medically constrained to the meat-free or meat-and-dairy-free diet, they usually do not love themselves very much.
Like any food fad, vegetarianism (and veganism especially) is so often a smoke screen adopted to disguise a body-dysmorphic eating disorder. It is simply an excuse not to eat. And, indeed, Saf, which has done very well in the reviews, was positively rammed to the rafters, on a lazy Monday night in high summer, with very thin people, mostly women. (Don’t get me wrong, it’s not a complaint – better vegans than fat people.)
It’s a funky, warehousey, Shoreditchy sort of place (I saw at least two Hoxton fins, previously thought to have been extinct since 2002) with clean lines, a long, sexy bar, hard-edged, boxy tables and stools, and a restrained, rather minimalist outside space, with white walls and stripling bamboo whistling in the breeze.
The staff are kind and solicitous, and were quick to say that we should notify them of any allergies. Although I could not see anything on the menu of twiddled-up crudités to which one could possibly be allergic. Nuts, I suppose (from which Saf makes its “cheese”), and wheat, which is used only sparingly.
There was apparently only one non-vegetarian waitress (by far the healthiest-looking staff member), who, while insisting that she loved the food, suggested that we ate four starters, two mains and a couple of sides if we wanted to be full. She also said that she relished the nightly staff meal but that (unlike her vegetarian colleagues) she was usually starving hungry by the second half of her shift. Indeed, the staff here seemed an impossibly ascetic bunch – best exemplified by the wafer-thin, pale-faced young barman whom I spotted nipping outside at one point, for a crafty apple.
Giles Coren has been a columnist for The Times since 1999. He began as a feature writer before becoming restaurant critic in 2001. His reviews appear in The Times Magazine on Saturdays
Industry sectors news at a glance. Interactive heatmap, video and podcast
The inside track on current trends in the charity, not for profit and social enterprise sectors
Read our exclusive 100 Years of Fleming and Bond interactive timeline, packed with original Times articles and reviews
Everything the Business Traveller needs to know to make a better trip
Shortcuts to help you find sections and articles
05/2005
£13,500
08/2008
£109,950
2006
£10,750
Great car insurance deals online
£Excellent+ executive benefits
Torres and Partners
London
£49,229 - £62,035 pro rata
Charity Commission
London/Liverpool/Taunton
Alstom Power
Europe
Six Figure
Rolls Royce
Midlands/Europe
From £89,950
Great Investment, River Views
Special Offers now available
At the new sophisticated
Encore Las Vegas Resort!
Cruise the Islands of Hawaii - Pride of America
List your property with two leading travel websites
Great travel insurance deals online
Contact our advertising team for advertising and sponsorship in Times Online, The Times and The Sunday Times, or place your advertisement.
Times Online Services: Dating | Jobs | Property Search | Used Cars | Holidays | Births, Marriages, Deaths
News International associated websites: Globrix | Property Finder | Milkround
Copyright 2008 Times Newspapers Ltd.
This service is provided on Times Newspapers' standard Terms and Conditions. Please read our Privacy Policy.To inquire about a licence to reproduce material from Times Online, The Times or The Sunday Times, click here.This website is published by a member of the News International Group. News International Limited, 1 Virginia St, London E98 1XY, is the holding company for the News International group and is registered in England No 81701. VAT number GB 243 8054 69.
i love coren being very, very ironic. although this review smells like him, it is far less juicy that the usuall stuff. maybe the boring beetroot stuff somehow got the better of him? (note: i am a vegetarian too... just not THIS sort of ascetic freak who actually fears the lovely thing that food is
jana, prague, czech Republic
This review is stupidly bitchy and tells me nothing about the food. Vegans and veggies will be pasty if they don't get their vitamins, just as meat eaters are usually a bit smelly and greasy and red if they eat too much. I think on the whole You will find that on love and appreciate food a lot more.
CCC, London, UK
both my husband and myself have been vegan for a little over 4 years now. we love our food, love cooking, and should probably both eat a little less as we are overweight. the assumption by journalists that vegans are pasty, weak, defensive and malnourished is lazy and boring.
george, barripper, uk
Cows eat grass and hay,and are exclusively vegetarian.Thus they represent grass,etc that has been processed within their digestive systems entirely from eating a diet of no meat.Thus surely cows are not meat but merely transformed green stuff i.e. they should be accpetable to vegans?
C.Elder, Paris, France
she was usually starving hungry by the second half of her shift.
Indeed, but this is tarted-up restaurant food, designed for self-indulgence, not for fuel - I wouldn't expect it to power me through a busy shift of what is, after all, manual labour. This isn't limited to vegan food either.
Ron Graves, Birkenhead, UK
And why the focus, lately, on raw food presented as veganism? I ate a vegan diet for years, and would never have contemplated eating a raw courgette, or much else currently presented as vegan. Raw foodism does NOT mean veganism - they're different philosophies.
Ron Graves, Birkenhead, UK
Urrgh, it sounds like muck. If you want vegan stick to chips, but even they taste better fried in lard.
Brett, Manchester, UK
This review is a missed opportunity by some enterprising sub to remove a random vowel of their choice. Shakespeare Coren's reaction would have been worth it.
moviefan, London,
Vegetarians (or even better - pescetarians) can indeed be "great lovers of food", although I do agree that extreme vegetarianism (consumption of plant products only) is a rather harsh diet. However, sometimes dishes that do not include any meat/fish can be much more appetising than those that do.
YK, Abn, UK
What excellent taste in literature Mr Coren has, well according to this particular article anyway.Georges Perec really was a great writer, though admittedly some of his works are hard to get through.Nonetheless, his unique way of writing never fails to impress (Théâtre 1 is one of the best examples)
YK, Abn, UK