We've made some changes
to The Sunday Times

Something is gravely amiss in the corridors of power. First, the French go and elect themselves a President who claims not to drink wine, which is a bit like the Scottish electing a First Minister with an allergy to haggis: peculiarly unnatural.
Now our own Government in London is proposing a crackdown on drinking at the privacy of one’s own dinner table. Specifically, middle-class wine drinkers, “those that are maybe drinking one or two bottles of wine at home each evening”.
Yes, that’s right, you with the leftover half-bottle of red in the fridge from last night (I always find it keeps so much better than way, just remember to take it out half an hour before you drink it); looking forward to finishing it off later on, were you?
Well, if this lot get their way, you won’t be able to. If you persist, you will be branded a foul drunk, an irresponsible drain on health resources, a blot on society. You might even find yourself in a labour camp (oh, sorry, haven’t they announced that yet? I’m reliably informed that it’s at committee stage).
Aside from the fact that such a directive is staggeringly hypocritical coming from an administration that introduced 24-hour drinking (it’s fine to get completely bladdered 24/7 as long as you’re contributing significantly to the health of the powerful brewery lobbies and the Exchequer), these proposals are intolerable.
Not only do they intrude on the population’s fundamental right to privacy, they are also an attempt to add a moral burden to the shoulders of the already overworked and overtaxed middle classes. These plans have nothing to do with safeguarding the nation’s health and everything to do with eroding the boundaries between public and private life.
Worse, they are another example of the pernicious new Puritanism that is slowly squeezing the life and soul out of Britain. Ye gods, as my grandmother used to say, almost all the middle classes have left is their glass of wine in the evening. That bottle of organic Pech-Latt (£6.49 from Ocado, very reasonable and actually extremely drinkable) is the equivalent of the 19th-century factory worker’s shot of gin. Because let’s face it, this Government is doing its best to make our lives about as miserable as any pox-raddled Hogarthian whore’s. Utter the word “middle class” in Whitehall and watch their greedy little pimps’ eyes light up with pound signs. Behold the British middle-classes – a docile, law-abiding army of tax slaves. Hurrah, let’s blow it all on some more social workers in Newcastle.
Here they come, edict after edict, each one (surprise, surprise), requiring a considerable financial outlay. Car seats for 11-year-olds? That’ll be £50, please; ID cards? Better start saving up now. Home information packs? Goodness only knows, but you can be sure that someone will be made to pay, and it will almost certainly be the middle-class taxpayer, since the law now applies only to dwellings with four bedrooms or more. And now they have the audacity to come into our heavily mortgaged homes and tell us how much we can drink.
Naturally, there are always going to be those who drink too much, in all walks of life. Everyone knows the apocryphal story of the middle-class mum turning up for the school run too sozzled from the night before to park her 4x4 straight. But only a fool would formulate policy on that basis. Most people are perfectly capable of enjoying a glass of two of wine in the evenings without setting fire to their hair, beating up their children or ending up with liver failure before the age of 50.
This Government doesn’t give a fig about the civil liberties of those people. It finds it preferable (and easier, since it requires a far coarser brush) to set all rules and standards according to the lowest common denominator. It did it only two weeks ago, with the new guidelines on drinking during pregnancy. Just because some women drink too much when pregnant, now the rest of us have to be subject to a ban. Great: more disapproving glares in restaurants.
And it runs throughout society: we now live in a country where grannies teaching Sunday school crèches are subject to Criminal Records Bureau checks. Soon there will be locks on our bins because this nanny state cannot trust us with our own rubbish.
Meanwhile, in areas where a ban might actually be a good idea, such as properly curtailing junk food advertising, it has mysteriously sticky feet. Wouldn’t want to upset those lobbies, now, would we?
I have always faintly admired the older generation’s ability to drink two preprandial Martinis and still hold a coherent conversation during lunch. As I stare an increasingly drab future in the face, their efforts now seem almost heroic. Up until now, I have always been a moderate drinker. From now on, however, I shall be making a more concerted effort.
As the Beastie Boys so elegantly put it: you’ve got to fight for your right to party. The battle is upon us. Ladies and gentlemen, the time has come to raise up your glasses in protest. Pass the corkscrew, please.
The good, the bad – and the effects of a lunchtime tipple
Effects on the body: about 90 to 98 per cent of alcohol is broken down by six enzymes, known collectively as alcohol dehydrogenase. These are present in small amounts in our stomachs and in larger amounts in our livers. Very small amounts of alcohol are lost in our urine about 40 minutes after we start drinking, and tiny amounts exit our bodies in sweat and tears. Women have less dehydrogenase than men, which is partly why they feel the effects of alcohol more rapidly. Women also have more fat and less water in their bodies, so alcohol is less diluted in their systems.
It is thought that, on average, a healthy person can metabolise just under a unit of alcohol an hour, though this varies depending on sex, size, ethnic group and whether you are taking medication. A big man who drinks every day may make more alcohol dehydrogenase, as the production of these enzymes can be induced the more that he drinks. He may be able to clear three units an hour. Small women who drink infrequently could take two hours to metabolise one unit. Many East Asian people have impaired production of alcohol dehydrogenase and process alcohol more slowly. Certain drugs interfere with these enzymes; aspirin is one (worth noting if you are taking aspirin on a plane to help to thin your blood), as well as certain medications for stomach ulcers.
Chronic drinkers who exceed the daily safe upper limits are likely to be severely taxing the alcohol-breaking enzymes in the liver. When this happens fats tend to accumulate in the small blood vessels around liver cells, which then begin to die, a process which, among other changes to liver cells, leads to cirrhosis, a potentially fatal disease. Excess alcohol can also lead to higher incidences of oesophageal cancer – 75 per cent of people with this cancer have been identified as heavy drinkers (those who usually drink six units or more a day). People who imbibe more than four units have a ninefold increase in the risk of mouth cancer, a figure that rises if you smoke.
Lunchtime drinking: we make fewer alcohol-breaking enzymes during the day, so having a drink at lunchtime has more effect than at 8pm, when production is at its peak. Research suggests that when you are tired one drink can act like two. Premenstrual hormonal changes have a similar effect. The enzymes break down the alcohol into acetaldehyde, which is more toxic than alcohol itself. This is eventually converted into fats, carbon dioxide and water.
Beneficial effects: moderate drinkers, regardless of the source of the alcohol, have a lower risk of cardiovascular disease. Certainly resveratrol, a super-nutrient found in the skin of grapes, appears to have strong antioxidant effects in our bodies. Studies indicate that it may help to stop “bad” LDL cholesterol and blood platelets from clumping together, reducing the risk of furred arteries and so the risk of heart disease and stroke. Pinot noir grapes have especially high levels of resveratrol, and grapes grown in areas that provide warmth and moisture, such as Chilean valleys, Bordeaux and Burgundy in France, have some of the best levels of this antioxidant. Other super-nutrients in wine also have antioxidant effects, helping to improve levels of “good” HDL cholesterol and relaxing blood vessels by increasing the local release of nitric oxide, which lowers blood pressure.
Unit trust – calculate exactly how much you drink
Curled up at home after a hard day’s work, chatting to family, reading a book or zoned-out in front of the TV, many of us indulge in a relaxing slosh or two of wine. But are you imbibing more than the Government says you should? You could be.
In recent years wines have become much stronger and standard measures larger. Even if you stick to a single glass of wine, you could easily be drinking more than the recommended daily amount – three to four units for men, two to three for women. A single unit of alcohol, as defined by the Government, is 125ml (4fl oz) of a wine that is 8 per cent alcohol by volume (ABV). This measure was devised in the late 1980s, when many of the most popuar wines were only around 8 per cent alcohol. Nowadays, though, it’s difficult to find wine with an ABV of less than 12 per cent and it is not uncommon for the ABV to hit 15 per cent.
So it’s up to us to figure out how many units we are consuming. You can do this using an equation: units drunk equals ABV multiplied by the volume of wine in millilitres divided by 1,000. However, given the vogue for outsized wine glasses, it’s important to monitor exactly how much wine is being poured.
You might be an unwitting binge drinker. The official figure for binge drinking is only six units for women, or two large glasses of wine, and eight for men. The average UK adult binge drinks 28 times a year, while an Italian does so just eight times a year and a Spaniard 14 times a year. And it’s not just about how much we drink – it’s also the way we drink. In Italy 51 per cent of people drink alcohol only when they are eating. In the UK, just 7 per cent of people drink when only they are eating. Drinking with food slows down the rate at which alcohol is absorbed, which lessens its effects and reduces drunkenness.
— AMANDA URSELL
Wine always feels like a treat, not an essential
Miranda, 36, a GP from Hertfordshire. Married with two children:
I drink at least one glass of wine a night, usually more, but I always wait until 6pm before I have my first drink. A typical week goes as follows: Monday: a Hendrick’s gin with cucumber – delicious – followed by a glass of wine with dinner. Tuesday to Thursday: pretty much the same. Friday: I would still have the gin, but would also have two to three glasses of wine with dinner. Weekends: quite often I don’t drink as we are doing things with the children, but if I were to go out for dinner I might drink half a bottle of wine.
My husband doesn’t drink, and I never drink at lunch unless there is a special occasion. I keep a vague note of what I am drinking and never go over 21 units a week.
I think it is just as possible to be a middle-class alcoholic and in denial about it as it is for anyone else. It’s just that if you are middle class, people don’t expect you to have a problem with alcohol. I know women who need a glass of wine to survive the day. I’m not like that. Wine always feels like a treat, rather than an essential.
I look forward to my first drink
Timothy, 47, a lawyer from London. Married with three children:
I have a drink every day. I can’t remember the last time I did not have a drink. It was probably the day I went into hospital for a minor operation about two years ago. This is roughly what I drank last week. Monday: a pint of lager after work with colleagues. A can of Stella when I got home. Tuesday: two cans of Stella at home. Wednesday: pint of lager in a bar, shared two bottles of red wine with two friends over dinner. Thursday: a glass of white wine at lunch, a pint of lager after work, half a can of lager at home. Friday: a glass of red wine at lunch, a predinner gin and tonic. Shared one bottle of wine with my wife over dinner in a restaurant. Saturday: a can of lager in the evening. One glass of wine with dinner. Sunday: red wine for lunch with friends. Nothing in the evening.
I am aware that written down, this looks like a lot of alcohol. But I am otherwise fit. I cycle to work every day and eat healthily. I don’t think I have an alcohol problem, but I do look forward to my first drink of the day.
I always wake with a hangover
Suzy, 32, a speech therapist in London:
My friends are always telling me that I drink a lot, although I never seem to be more drunk than they are, or indeed drunk at all. I think in part that is because I have a good constitution for alcohol, like my father. Generally, I drink every day, and often start at 5pm. If I am on my own, I will often drink half a bottle of wine while watching TV, and sometimes more – my fridge will always have a chilled bottle of white in it. If I am out with friends having a low-key dinner, I frequently have a bottle of wine on my own, and if I’m out late and at parties, I would probably drink between two and three bottles of wine. So, depending on my social schedule, my average weekly intake would range from between five to ten bottles of wine.
I always wake up with a hangover, but it goes quickly, and I enjoy the experience too much to let it stop me drinking later that day. But I’m not an alcoholic. I can easily go for weeks without wine if I’m on a health kick, and I don’t rely on it for confidence. I just find that life is a more civilised place if a glass of wine is in my hand.
Enjoy screenings of all the classic films you love, plus take advantage of two-for-one tickets
We explore leisure activities that are safe and suitable for all of the family
Times Online's new TV show helps you make the right decisions for your pet
See the best entries in this year's competition
Your brain is capable of more than you might think...
An interactive preview of the brand new For Your Eyes Only exhibition
The latest travel news plus the best hotels and gadgets for business travellers

Love Sudoku? Play our brand new interactive game: with added functionality and daily prizes

Are you irritable when you return from work? Drained of emotion? You could be suffering from boreout
Prepare for some shock and awe, petrol lovers. Despite the greens trying to wipe it out, the car is about to offer us the most exciting year ever
We've trawled the brochures and websites to find this summer’s best holidays for every taste and budget


A treasure trove of baubles, booty and stylish quests

50% off top restaurants, book online

2002/02
£59,995
The Midlands
2008/08
£169,950
Scotland
2007/57
£35,000
South East England
Great car insurance deals online
Circa £82,000 per annum
Birmingham Women's Hospital
Birmingham
To £28k
Barclaycard
Various (outside London)
£
Up to £66,000 per annum
Hertfordshire County Council
South East
To £38k
Barclaycard
Northampton/Liverpool
2 Bathrooms, Balcony and Garden
Beautiful Gardens w/ stunning Thames Views
Apts From £249,950
Mortgages, bank acc & money transfers to help you buy abroad
Explore mystical Jordan
From £1030 for 7nts 4*
to USA's Most Cosmopolitan City; San Francisco!
£POA
Book Now for Winter 08/09 and Get 10% off!
Great travel insurance deals online
It's stupid to say we have a alcohol problem in this country because wine is too readily available at a cheap price. In France, it is a fraction of the price and more readily available yet they don't have the probelms that we have. It's all about education into drinking sensibly.
B Brooks, bournemouth, UK
Britain has not an Alchohol problem but a behavioural problem! Too much is paid out in benefits to fraudsters, we now harass the middle class workers for daily drinking, while low lifes fuel not only the crime rate but exasperate it when fuelled further by over consumption of alco pops. Niether myself or any of my friends have ever started violence no matter how off the wagon we were. There is a demographic of people involved here. I know when I am out who and where the trouble makers are and avoid them. Our police force solve 25% of crimes and friends of mines have been the subject of violence when not drunk, where the perpertrator was not drunk either, simply evil. Over consumption can cause an epidemic called Idiocy in some people which has probably been on the increase with 24 hr drinking - in honesty though I once may have, I can'y say I support that.
Jonny, Belfast,
The supermarkets are complicit in this problem only in that they offload thousands of gallons of wine at less than £3 a bottle that most people in Europe would only use to run their cars on!
The problem with wine is not that it is too cheap, merely that most of it is only fit to get drunk on. A good bottle of wine costs about £8 or more (with a few exceptions) and few people that I have met drink quality wine like alchopops as it tastes too good and demands some appreciation.
People in Britain need education on how to drink - with good food - ahh another problem perhaps, or sipped whilst enjoying conversation, again very difficult against 100db of pub "entertainment system"
So please no calls for tax rises, lets get some general improvement in quality. Pubs that charge 6 times the cost price for a bottle of wine worth about £3 are basically racketeering and should be prosecuted. THe same goes for restaurants.
Richard, London,
Britain HAS an alcohol problem. Check out all the police in town centres due to people drinking too much and acting up.
Britain also HAS a drugs problem.
The social life of people in Britain RUNS on alcohol.
It's actually harder here to be seen as normal if you're a non-drinker. I challenge people blind to these facts to try and give up alcohol for a few months and see (a) how people treat them and (b) how much better they feel and how much better they look after giving up.
It's not natural to get bladdered. Not even once in your life, let alone every week!
Also us British have a disgraceful reputation abroad due to our agressive drunks and hooligans - why not have the government reign these people in a bit!?
We all get tarred with the same brush - at the moment we all look like ignorant uncontrolable pigs, why not get tarred with the govt's brush and get sober!?
louise, Brighton, uK
The country needs a sea change in attitudes towards drinking but in the meantime the goverment should act and set the tone for the attitude change. Retaillers of alchol should firstly be highly regulated, ie the likes of Tesco and the other big supermarket chains should by law be stopped from selling cheap alchol and taxes raised (even if only to pay for the extra burden on the NHS that is coming in the next few years to treat all the extra liver disease patients). The only pinta we should be getting from the grocery shop should be the white stuff that comes from cows not Smirnoff. No shilly shallying on health warnings, just like cigarettes, it should be made clear that alchol kills and destroys others lives as well as the drinkers. Advertising alchol should be curtailed just like tobacco products were. Legislation should be tightened and a 'drunk and disorderly' should not be a right of passage but seen as a criminal offence. Here endeth the lesson!
Catriona Straine-Urquhart, Edinburgh, UK
Interesting! denial, denial denial. "No problem here". What a lot of tosh!
The strength of their emotional addiction can be measured by the strength of their feeling when someone tries to stop them!
mothers ruin, Edinburgh,
I would have agreed with most of the comments here until the last couple of months. I have been preparing my body for IVF and part of that has been cutting down/out alcohol, caffeine, etc.
I also was a regular gym user, etc etc so would kid myself that my drinking was absolutely ok and that I did not have a problem. Until, that is, I stopped my nightly glass or two of wine. It was much tougher than I realised - and also my social life is much duller sober because the middle classes do actually run on alcohol. Don't kid yourselves - it's a socially acceptable drug. Try giving up for a month and see how you feel, then tell me you don't have a problem.
Jess B, London ,
This wine issue and the rising Puritanism seems to be a stealth effort to get the British to behave like Europeans who effortlessly behave in a manner which politicians seem to admire, as I do. I had an ID card in Denmark, observed sensible drinking in Spain and Italy (especially amongst the youth), felt safer and found society to be more family based. Britain needs to raise its educational standards, respect for schools and institutuions and focus on correcting behaviour in childrenrather than continually interfering with any attempt to do so. In the UK adults are now wary of and fear youth which is out of control. Bad habits start at school and on the streets but who can do anything about it without risk?
Stewart Bone, Rome, Italy
Basically, drinking is fun and being a bit drunk is also fun, and the government doesn't want us to have fun. The more the govt tries to push its tedious rules on recycling, booze and junk food, the more inclined I am to do the exact opposite.
In fact, I'm off to the pub tonight - nice big glass of chilled chablis anyone?
Vanessa, London, UK
I'm aghast at the denail this country is in around our alcohol problem, we are in complete ifnorance as to what an alcoholic is and we still beleive its the 'minority' who 'over do it occasionally'.
Wake up i'm all for civil liberties and privacy but practically half our population has anethestised themselves from life and we have a generation of people growing up who aren't going to fullfill their potential because they are too busy defending their right to a 2 for 1 offer on wine.
I'm an addicitons counsellor and non of my cleints are daily drinkers and they represent a cross section of the population, they are intesively disatisfied with their lives and abuse alcohol in order to to take the 'edge' off of their exsistance.
Is this really want you want your life to be about?
Veronica Callanan, Cambridge, UK
Good article, although with that sirname one could sense a certain bias...
Knut Akerhielm, London,
FYI, Newcastle has a middle class, too.
Paul, London,
Another article about how hard done to the British middle classes are. You are one of the most priviliged groups ever to have lived on the planet and you complain about everything.
Bob, warsaw, poland
We love you Sarah Vines for hitting several nails on the head. I drive 2000 miles a year and the traffic control terrorism one encounters on the roads is unbearable. Frequently changing speed limits, impenetrable parking restriction stipulations designed to catch out the law-abiding unwary, etc. You drive in constant fear, looking out for baffling traffic rules. And of course being photographed 300 times a day the moment one leaves the car to go about on foot.
As for taxes, a quarter of my post-tax retirement income is taken every month by an incompetent local council whose retired middle ranks enjoy pensions that I can only dream of, but am forced to fund on pain of re-possession of my property, which has suddenly become more valuable than I would wish. Yeah, move to the inner cities, get mugged and have your car vanadalised weekly and have the great life you spent 40 years preparing for. Thanks, Gordon Brown!
Tilak, London, UK
Surely the human constitution can easily handle this casual wine- and beer-drinking, for goodness sake? In earlier times it was common for most folk to drink beer or cider rather than water because fresh, clean water was hard to come by and milk was the only other alternative, again hard to come by fresh with no easy means of refrigeration. Binge-drinking is a different thing but regular intake of alcohol has always been the norm for humans historically (or for us Europeans at least). Nothing wrong with it either!
MB, Edinburgh,
I have never been moved to add a comment before. This article sums up very nicely what a small group of us, middle class and middle aged citizens, had to say over a nice sauvignon blanc at lunchtime! New Labour/ Old Puritanism. Brown's moral compass
directing us? AAAAAAAAArgh. Where to Christy?
helen, n wales ,
Children take their cue from adults. At the University the drinking culture was entrenched - I remember our rugby club being drunk as they waited to go into their annual dinner and their middle class parents would have proudly told you their tales of not remembering whom they insulted the night before. The nanny state issue is just a red hg except that it is odd that the government who sponsered 24/7 drinking should start here. It should however start with the middle classes (and first with parliament's bars) because for too long university -educated people have argued that drinking is on balance a civilising activity when in fact it is just their drug of choice with all the social problems which follow. You would hope they could find something less addictive to fill the gap at the end of a day -orange juice ,Mozart or God for example.
David Berdinner, Tring, Herts
I agree entirely with Sarah Vine's article, and am relieved and reassured to read her views and those of the others commenting on this article. I am quite astounded at the Governments attitude and latest crusade - although given its general inclination to interfere needlessly and groundlessly in all aspects of private life, I'm not sure why I am surprised. I also drink most days, generally around 1 or 2 glasses of wine with dinner, and perhaps a pre or post-dinner gin or the like. At weekends my boyfriend and I might have say 2 bottles of wine between us over the course of the night. Savouring the taste of a good wine over dinner is certainly one of life's gentle pleasures. I don't feel at all that my health suffers, as I run, am a regular gym attendee, and eat very healthily. In fact the enjoyment I take from having a glass of wine most certainly helps remove any last traces of stress from my day.
Kate Marshall, London,
Scotland's national dish isn't haggis, it's chips.
stew, bristol,
As a patriotic citizen who only wishes to help his country, which these days clearly means nothing more than reducing the cost of my life to the state, I recently increased my moderate drinking to heavy in an effort to help with the pensions crisis. Have I made the wrong choice?
Nannified, Wimborne, Dorset
I am sure that doctors believe that telling you not to drink too much is good advice, I have yet to meet one that follows it. I have an amazing capacity for alcohol being a healthy 55 year old who has imbibed to excess since I was 14 years old, I jest ye not, I am rarely sick ,still play rugby ,dive,golf and dine at some of the finest reasturants the Far East can offer regularly eating and drinking too much. Time is an illusion once gone it cannot be recaptured, live your life today , tomorrow is not yours to own, if it arrives, have a glass of wine, or better a bottle.
Timothy Walton, Bangkok, Thailand
I have read your article with great interest this morning, and was in total ageeement with you until I got to the poor overworked, damned if they do, damned if they don't social workers. What in Gods earth have social workers got to do with the ever increasing Orwellian state we find ourselves living in? I am a very middle class social work student about to qualify. Please leave us social workers out of your argument. I am fed up of the media constantly putting us down, why don't you journalists spend a day in the life of a social worker and pay witness to all the good they do?
Sue Harte, Bournemouth, Dorset
When will these abhorrent politicians leave us alone ?
Surely the big problem is the massive amount of cheap booze being swilled by our wasted youth, The wasted youth that have been failed by 10 years of Blairism and are illiterate and hopeless.
Marcus Bancroft, Sheffield, UK
This is just another way of the government banning anything that people may enjoy.
Lets have a look at the list
Drinking,
Smoking
Driving
Eating fatty foods
I think this may have something to do with the privitisation of the National Health Service. It will not be long before smokers, drinkers, fatty food eaters will all have to pay for their treatment should they require any
For god's sake get me out of here. I have had enough
Christy Conroy, Leicester, UK
Will it be ok to get absolutely smashed on beer, spirits or if it is an expensive month cocktails of meths and ginger ale? I need to know so that I can adjust my off licence order.
alan, benalmadena, spain
Once again, Thomas Jefferson's famous quote "the government that governs best, governs least" has long been lost on the politicians. In one of his last interviews before retiring, David Brinkley commented that pols did not like him and he did not like them. The job of a politician is to be re-elected. Jumping on the issues mentioned in this wonderful article highlights this over and over.
Dr. Death, Hong Kong, SAR China
Thanks for the artical 10/10
Malcolm Johnson, Falkirk,
I am not an alcoholic, really, I`m not. I can prove it. It`s just my spell checker wasn`t working. Neither are the people in the rest of the planet who don`t give a damn whether the English middle classes waste their time like this. If you don`t like what they say throw them out.
M Hunt, KL, Malaysia
The 'nanny state' strikes again, life is much more civilised with a glass or three of a good red wine
Steve Benstead, Glasgow, UK