Richard Ford, Home Correspondent
Win Sky+HD for a year and a trip to Barcelona
The deportation of a Ghanaian woman with terminal cancer was defended by the head of the immigration service yesterday, who disclosed that there were hundreds of similarly difficult cases each year.
Lin Homer said that the removal of Ama Sumani, who was in hospital in Cardiff, back to Accra was heart-rending but not exceptional.
She spoke as The Lancet described the removal of Ms Sumani as atrocious barbarism. “To stop treating patients in the knowledge that they are being sent home to die is an unacceptable breach of the duties of any health professional,” it said. “The UK has committed an atrocious barbarism. It is time for doctors’ leaders to say so, forcefully and uncompromisingly.”
Ms Sumani, 39, suffers from malignant myeloma and was receiving dialysis at a hospital in Cardiff when she was taken by immigration officers and flown back home last week because her visa had expired. She left the hospital in a wheelchair accompanied by five immigration officials before being driven to Heathrow to board a flight to Accra last Wednesday.
Keith Vaz, the chairman of the Commons Home Affairs Select Committee, said that he had spoken by telephone to Ms Sumani in her Accra hospital shortly before a hearing of the committee — at which he told Ms Homer, the chief executive of the Border and Immigration Agency: “Her health has deteriorated since she arrived in Ghana.”
Ms Homer said: “I think it is very difficult to see the circumstances in which this case stands out from the very many difficult cases we consider. These are incredibly difficult cases. There are many hundreds each year.”
She added: “We deal with many hundreds of cases where the personal circumstances reach and touch the people involved. It is one of the things that makes being a caseworker in the agency a difficult job.”
Ms Sumani came to England as a student in 2004. It is not believed that cancer had been diagnosed at that time. Her lack of English prevented her from taking up the course and she then sought work, which broke the rules of her student visa. She did not keep in touch with the immigration authorities and was taken ill a year ago.
Explore your passion for food with the delights of Thai, Indian & Chinese cooking
In our new series, Tony Hawks takes a dry, wry look at modern life - junk mail, interminable meetings and snooty sales assistants
Read the training tips and advice that helped our London Triathletes
Read our exclusive 100 Years of Fleming and Bond interactive timeline, packed with original Times articles and reviews
The latest travel news plus the best hotels and gadgets for business travellers
Shortcuts to help you find sections and articles
2007
£30,000
2006
£14,337
2008
£39,937
Great car insurance deals online
c.£75,000
GlosFirstmeansbusiness
Gloucestershire
£32,795 - £41,545
Universitry of Southampton
Southampton
£
£32,795 - £41,545
Universitry of Southampton
Southampton
Competitive Package
Npower
West Midlands
1 & 2 Bed apartments
From £249,995
Great Investment, River Views
Great Dubai Investment Opportunities
from £89,950
low-cost ownership homes in London
Las Vegas SALE!
£POA
With Ramblers Worldwide Holidays!
£POA
List your property with two leading travel websites
£POA
Great travel insurance deals online
Contact our advertising team for advertising and sponsorship in Times Online, The Times and The Sunday Times. Globrix Property Search - find property for sale and rent in the UK. Milkround Job Search - for graduate careers in the UK. Visit our classified services and find jobs, used cars, property or holidays. Use our dating service, read our births, marriages and deaths announcements, or place your advertisement.
Copyright 2008 Times Newspapers Ltd.
This service is provided on Times Newspapers' standard Terms and Conditions. Please read our Privacy Policy.To inquire about a licence to reproduce material from Times Online, The Times or The Sunday Times, click here.This website is published by a member of the News International Group. News International Limited, 1 Virginia St, London E98 1XY, is the holding company for the News International group and is registered in England No 81701. VAT number GB 243 8054 69.
While Muslims sacrifices animals for their religious believes, many people protest with anger. I saw hardly ever sympathy to this woman from British public. This is because; we live in a society of animals, dressed as human beings.
samuel brown, tanworth,
I would suggest to Christopher Hobe Morrison that
in America the healthcare is driven by insurance and there is no gurantee that the insurance would cover the cost
of any illness. I had experience in 1970s, and fortunately had some savings. The doctor's bill was outrageous, and even in those days for a vitamin B12 shot which I did not need which his nurse gave routinely for every one, he charged $60! I know a few in Ohio who became bankrupt , selling their possessions after the insurance companies refused to pay all the cost for treatment. One of my friends an IT professional lost his job, within months developed a serious health problem. He had no insurance,had to go to an Asian country to get cheaper private treatment. He wished that America had NHS. There are excellent hospitals like Memorial Sloan Kettering and some very bad hospitals and doctors. All charge tens of thousands of dollars,and one needs a fistfull of policies to cover illnesses.
Gary Smith, LONDON,
Don't worry African nations have no problem deporting or arresting people so why should European nations have a problem with it. This is why Africans go to Europe to abuse the services there and to put nothing back.
S Danks, Zurich, Switzerland
This woman did not come into Britain for treatment. She came to study. She became ill after she had been here studying. The relevant government officials have all admitted that they had violated their own guidelines when they kicked her out.
Now we have native British (white for the most part apparently) saying that because the NHS treats them poorly, it is therefore wrong that any foreigner (non-white apparently) should not be given any more than they get. The issue should be first of all, why the NHS isn't better. Second, why is medical care so bad in Africa that getting kicked out of Britain can be a death sentence. And third, why isn't anyone raising money for this woman to get her treatments. When she is dead they will all be moaning.
Christopher Hobe Morrison, Pine Bush, Ulster County, NY, USA
If Lin Homer is so concerned about the health of an illegal immigrant who has made no contribution to the NHS, I suggest she either volunteer to pay for the treatment herself, or alternatively, go to Ghana and work as a heath carer there.
Why should the taxpayer finance someone from overseas at their expense. If one case were allowed, the UK would be flooded with similar cases.
steve, white river, south africa
The "court change" is a shifting of power in favour of ordinary people that has been under a political silence but is on publicly traceable record through petitions 730/99 in the European, PE6 and PE360 in the Scottish, parliaments. Since 7 July 1999 all court or other legal decisions are "open to open ended fault finding by any party" instead of final.
This follows from my European Court of Human Rights case 41597/98. This case concerned a discrimination from 13 May 1997, yet the admissibility decision claimed the last stage of decision taken within Britain was on 4 Aug 1995. ECHR has made itself illegal, by issuing a syntactically contradictory nonsense decision that reverses the physics of time, and calling it final. Hence, the European Convention creates an ECHR removing the original's illegality, by its decisions not being final. It follows, this requires courts within the member countries to be likewise, all legal decisions in council of Europe countries are no longer final.
Maurice Frank, South Queensferry, Scotland