Peta Bee
Download 'Too Hot', an exclusive Specials track from iTunes
Life is a dirty word. No matter how you live yours, you are exposed to filth daily. According to microbiologists, your home is riddled with dangerous bugs, as is your workplace.
Once you start digging for dirt, it’s hard to stop. Here are some findings from the most recent research. Swimming pools harbour faecal and urine contaminants; take a dip and you might pick up the Citrobacter freundii bacteria, an agent of infections such as pneumonia. The hot tub is another bubbling broth of bacteria, and has been linked to deaths from Legionnaire’s disease and pneumonia. Gyms are dripping with other people’s stale sweat and bacteria: Staphylococcus epidermis, which causes skin infections, streptococcal infections, and candida, a yeast infection, to name but a few. Germs, we are told, loiter in the most unlikely places; the herpes virus and those listed above can be a risk if the sweat of an infected person gets on to light switches, door handles, escalator handrails and any other frequently touched surfaces. Cold and flu viruses are also easily transmitted through touch. Some germs, such as enterococcus, survive for just 40 minutes, but most can linger menacingly for anything from 24 hours (Staphylococcus aureus, salmonella) to two to three weeks (rotavirus, hepatitis A and clostridium).
Charles Gerba, a professor of environmental sciences at the University of Arizona and an expert in the study of nasty bacteria that lurk in our lifestyles, found, for instance, that one of the most germ-ridden items in public spaces is the ground-floor button on a lift. But germs are not just spread by obvious means such as touch. They are insidious, creeping into every nook and cranny of our daily existence. Another of Gerba’s findings revealed how 30 per cent of women’s handbags contain 100 million particles of faecal matter per square inch on their surface, probably from being placed on the floors of public toilets. Kitchens and the implements they house are other prime breeding grounds. Surveys by the Hygiene Council (HC), a panel of the world’s leading microbiologists and virologists, indicate that 85 per cent of public toilets were cleaner than the average kitchen worktop in a British home.
Professor Hugh Pennington, an infection expert at the University of Aberdeen, would “like to get rid of washing-up bowls altogether; they are a menace”. Bathtubs often contain faecal particles “as people sit in them with dirty bottoms and don’t clean them afterwards”. Office desks are crawling with germs, as are the mobile phones used by 55 million Britons every day. Microbiologists say that the constant handling of a mobile combined with the heat generated from its battery allow bugs such as Staphylococcus aureus, which can cause everything from pimples to pneumonia, to spread like wildfire.
The list of warnings about public and private cleanliness – or lack of it – and its effect on our health seems endless. But does it really matter so much, or are scientists overreacting, triggering environmental paranoia in a society already burdened with one health worry too many? Professor John Oxford, a virologist at St Bartholemew’s and the Royal London Hospital, thinks not. “Experts are genuinely concerned about the spread of infection and disease through a lack of hygiene in this country as in others,” he says. “Exposure to dangerous germs is much more common than people think. Every day people come into contact with microorganisms in food, and faecal and oral contaminants spread through a lack of personal hygiene. Many microbes are using the opportunity to spread as never before.”
One person in five will suffer from diarrhoea this year and many more will get colds, flu and other viruses that have been transmitted through everyday germs and grime. It is easy to blame environmental health services and inefficient public health systems, but much of the problem lies with our own habits. We stroke pets, change nappies and sneeze without performing the most basic but effective bug-fighting practice: washing our hands. Hands are the primary carriers of pathogens such as salmonella and E coli. In theory, says Oxford (who is also the HC’s chairman), washing hands well, and often, could prevent the spread of everything from colds to MRSA.
What concerns experts is that complacency about hand cleanliness is increasingly responsible for the spread of illness in developed countries. It is known that viruses can survive on human hands for several hours and can be transmitted by direct contact. In October the HC is setting official hand-washing guidelines, urging people to wash their hands five to six times a day and more frequently if someone in the household or workplace has an infection.
On the flipside is the growing number of people who have become so fearful of the messages about poor hygiene that they develop obsessions about cleanliness. Kevin Gournay, a professor of psychiatry at the Institute of Psychiatry at Kings College London, says that obsessive compulsive disorder (OCD) affects 2 per cent of the population to the degree that it has become a significant handicap in their lives, and many more who find it disruptive. Of those, a “significant number” are obsessed with germs and dirt.
“There are varying degrees of OCD, from people putting tissue on toilet seats before using them or washing coins that they fear may have been contaminated to those who carry out rituals such as washing their hands 50 times a day,” Gournay says. “In extreme cases they have irrational fears such as concerns that they might catch Aids from microscopic spots of blood, even though they aren’t having sexual intercourse.” What all sufferers probably have in common, he says, is a biological propensity for OCD. “But the culture and environment we live in, where we are constantly told that things are too dirty and that we need to use antiseptics, chemical cleaning agents and wipes to r e m a i n s p o t l e s s , serves to exacerbate this propensity. It might start with someone washing his hands but never feeling clean enough.
“So he washes his hands, then uses a cleansing wipe. Then that becomes insufficient, and the problem gets out of control.” Stress and anxiety make it worse. Treatment for severe cases of OCD involves cognitive behaviour therapy and antidepressant drugs. “These people have to be exposed to gradually increasing amounts of dirt and grime until they become less anxious about it. It can take time.”
There are, of course, theories that we can be too clean, that all the antibacterial cleaning products we use are dulling our immune systems to the point where they no longer know how to fight bacteria. Many experts blame increasingly sterile environments for the increase in serious allergies, which have risen by more than 25 per cent in the past four years, according to reports based on Department of Health data obtained from GPs’ surgeries. Some 12.2 million people in England have had allergies such as eczema, asthma and hayfever diagnosed. Yet children who grow up on farms or have several older siblings – each of whom brings home germs a n d grime – are said to be considerably less at risk.
Even conditions such as diabetes have been linked to a lack of exposure to germs during childhood. At Scripps Research Institute, in California, scientists proposed that coming into contact with too few bacteria during childhood meant that the immune system was understimulated, creating a condition, lymphopenia, in which there is a reduction in the number of the body’s T-cells. People with type 1 diabetes, rheumatoid arthritis and lupus are known to have low levels of such cells, and the Scripps team suggested that “priming” the body with germs might reduce the chance of someone becoming ill later in life. Other studies suggest that there are enough T-cells, but they are not equipped to fight infection because they haven’t “met” enough germs.
However, Oxford dismisses the extreme cleanliness hypothesis as “scientific tosh”. “Nowhere is too clean and it is misleading to suggest that to the public,” he says. “People are getting ill because they are exposed to an ever-increasing number of germs.”
The issue of cross-infection, spreading viruses via unwashed hands, is high on the Government’s agenda as it realises that it is vital in the prevention of flu epidemics. Still, Oxford says, we should not become “too obsessive” about cleanliness. “People should target their hygiene habits, focusing on their hands, the kitchen and bathroom. That could be the best thing you do for your health.”

Offices
Professor Charles Gerba, of the University of Arizona, has uncovered some dirty secrets of the average workplace. Phones, PC keyboards and mice all harbour germs. “Desks are really bacteria cafeterias,” says Gerba, “capable of supporting ten million microbes. The average office contains around 20,961 per square inch compared with 49 in a toilet bowl.” He found that teachers had the grubbiest desks, lawyers the cleanest.
Gerba discovered that levels on keyboards peaked at 3,295 per square inch after lunch had been eaten at the desk: “If not cleaned, the keyboards could support millions of bacteria, which could cause illness such as gastrointestinal upsets.”
Computer mice harboured 1,676 particles per square inch, and both mobile and landline handsets could be health hazards because of the bacteria they contain. Microbiologists at Manchester Metropolitan University say that 26,000 microbes are crawling on every square inch of the average handset. Bugs found on phones include staphylococcus, which can cause pneumonia.
Toilets
Toilet bowls in people’s homes are usually so clean that “you could eat your dinner out of them”, says Professor John Oxford, a virologist at St Bartholemew’s and the Royal London Hospital.
But public conveniences are a different story. A study conducted by the University of Arizona found that the most common microorganisms associated with outbreaks stemming from public toilets included shigella, salmonella, norovirus and hepatitis A virus. Bacteria and viruses are ejected and dispersed into the air when a toilet is flushed; these germ-filled droplets land on all surfaces, contaminating the environment.
Researchers found that 64 per cent of the time the floor in front of the toilet in a public convenience was contaminated with faecal bacteria. For sinks the figure was 61 per cent of the time; for the top of the toilet, 20 per cent; and for the toilet handle 6 per cent.
Women’s toilets were significantly more contaminated than men’s, with the middle cubicle usually the most contaminated of all. Airport toilets were the germiest of all.
Gyms
Dr Derren Ready, a clinical scientist in microbiology at University College Hospital in London, analysed swabs taken from an unnamed London gym and found dangerously high levels of bacteria. “One site harboured 132 million bugs in an area the size of a 2p coin, while the average count was 16 million,” he says. On the bench-press headrest and dumbbells he found plenty of Staphylococcus epidermis, which causes skin infections. Sweaty residue on gym equipment used in quick succession, such as weights and exercise bikes, could also harbour streptococcal infections and candida. The sauna was the most bug-ridden place, with high levels of Citrobacter freundii, which can cause pneumonia, and blood and urinary-tract infections.
“It usually lives in the gut and its presence indicates faecal contamination,” Dr Ready says. He suspects that the high bacteria count could stem from the wooden benches in saunas and steam rooms; these have “lots of crevices, which are ideal gaps in which bacteria can colonise”.
Swimming pools
A recent survey by Which? tested 80 pools in Majorca and Corfu and found that most were laced with sweat, urine, mucus, saliva, hair, faecal matter and dead skin. Other studies have shown that outbreaks of cryptosporidium, which can cause vomiting and diarrhoea, may be linked to pools, while acanthamoeba causes painful inflammation of the eye. And the overuse of chemicals such as chlorine can irritate eyes and skin.
Win a luxury weekend to Newcastle and its neighbour Gateshead, find out more here
Risk, resilience and embracing new technology
Industry sectors news at a glance. Interactive heatmap, video and podcast
Discover the power of collective thinking. Submit a solution and be in with a chance to win a Media Hub Home Entertainment System
The inside track on current trends in the charity, not for profit and social enterprise sectors
Everything the Business Traveller needs to know to make a better trip
Make the most of the summer and enter our fabulous photographic competition, you could win a £5000 holiday
Corsica is an island of beauty and contrast, an ideal holiday destination
Enjoy further reading from Travel to Fashion, Business to Sport, discover more




Shortcuts to help you find sections and articles
The clever way to lease a new car is with Car leasing made simple™
2009
per month on 36-month
Personal Contract Hire (PCH)
2008
42850
Car Insurance
£24,250 - £30,346
MI5
London
£60,000
The Environment Agency
Bristol
Up to £90K
Boots
Midlands
OTE £85k
Credit Protection Association
Nationwide Opportunities
Completely London
Luxury Condo's in Manhattan with NYC views
The best new homes in Wimbledon?
Nationwide
Fabulous Cruise And Cruise & Stay Offers Including Virgin Atlantic Flights Prices Start From Only £699pp!
Last Minute Cruise And Cruise & Stay Offers. Med From £499pp, Caribbean From £699pp!
5 star quality at a 3 star price.
8 fabulous Canadian cities ...you won’t find cheaper
Contact our advertising team for advertising and sponsorship in Times Online, The Times and The Sunday Times, or place your advertisement.
Times Online Services: Dating | Jobs | Property Search | Used Cars | Holidays | Births, Marriages, Deaths | Subscriptions | E-paper
News International associated websites: Globrix Property Search | Property Finder | Milkround
Copyright 2009 Times Newspapers Ltd.
This service is provided on Times Newspapers' standard Terms and Conditions. Please read our Privacy Policy.To inquire about a licence to reproduce material from Times Online, The Times or The Sunday Times, click here.This website is published by a member of the News International Group. News International Limited, 1 Virginia St, London E98 1XY, is the holding company for the News International group and is registered in England No 81701. VAT number GB 243 8054 69.
You will not believe how annoyed this article has got me! I have OCD because of articles such as this 1 and spend a hell of a lot of time washing hands, showering and panicking 'incase' I contaminated this and that and incase I will get ill or others will. Reading this has only reinforced those thoughts and will only make me more paranoid of germs.
Rationally thinking though - if it was so bad people would be ill EVERY SINGLE DAY, because of touching mobile phones etc. which are health hazards supposedly. People do get ill but it is just natural we cannot live in a germ free bubble. But we do need to be careful ie. washing hands, not touching dirty things, but articles that instill fear that we are all dirty just help make suseptable people like me get OCD and fear germs.
DAN C, South Wales, UK
Lots of people keep their toothbrush in the damp atmosphere of a bathroom. Would you keep your cutlery or food in a room with a WC? Of course not. But health experts don't seem to think it matters, e.g. see the above article.
Carey, Chengdu, China
There are huge numbers of people who say "so why aren't we all ill then?" and state how healthy they are despite their low hygiene. Generally, they are wrong. I know people always saying how they aren't that fussed by hygiene and how they never get ill. But they do, lots. Some are lucky and have good imune systems so are healthy despite poor hygiene, but most just forget how often they are ill.
I am very hygiene concious and have had far fewer colds and illnesses as a result.
What people forget is that it's not just about you. Not washing hands, poor hygiene and most of all going out when ill spreads your germs to others - you make others ill with your germs. For people with poor immune systems or bad chests, you are spreading misery, putting lives at risk and indeed killing people. Every year thousands die of flu and illnesses spread needlessly. Please keep your germs to yourself.
So to answer why aren't we all ill or dying, a lot sadly are. Keep hygiene up, stay home if ill!
David, Ashford,
I would say more people are getting ill as a result of reading fear based articles like this one than actually getting ill from living.
Kursla, Northern Ireland,
I agree with Alex from Leeds. I have started travelling to work on the Tube and have had more coughs and colds in the last 5 months than ever before. I have been more and more interested in the causes and possible preventions and hand hygiene keeps arising. I have started using Quash, a hand saitiser when I travel on the tube. Totally recommend it!!
Nicky Clifford , London,
Dear Tina,
One is not "forced" to take a shower before entering a swimming pool in Germany . A sign indicates that you should do this. And what a good idea it is. I thought it was common practice everywhere but apparently not. Yes, it is shame that the wearing of a bathing cap is no longer promoted.
Brooks, Munich, Germany
I always wash after I visit the loo. Surprising how many people in the UK have terrible personal hygeine. I've noticed an increasing number of women, after drinking or eating messy food, casually wiping their mouthes with the back of their hands and then wiping the hands against their pants/skirts.
Just because we can 'live with it' doesn't mean we shouldn't practice good hygeine.
John, London, UK
I have witnessed individuals evacuating their nasal cavties (without a tissue) in the communal showers and the hot tub at my local JJB Gym.
Perhaps that explains the heavy chlorinated water they use.
Anon, Widnes, Cheshire
This article chimes with me. I recently began to get the local train to work again, and noticed strangely that I started getting really sore spots around my chin. It didn't take me too long to realise that the spots were caused by me touching bars and seats on the train and then touching my chin at my desk. As soon as I started washing my hands as soon as I got into work, the spots disappeared.
What this says about public transport, I don't want to consider.
Alex Greenwood, Leeds,
My observations in rather too many public toilets is that about 80% of people "wash" their hands, but of those, 80% don't use soap. They just rinse them and walk out - which is vastly worse than not washing them at all, since wet hands transmit hugely more bacteria than dry ones. Use the soap - please!
ASNS, Suffolk, UK
There is a solution to these problems based on photocatalyst coatings. Moisture in the air is transformed into hydrogen peroxide at a microscopic level. Used extensively in the Far East but quite a new technology in the UK
CHRIS GUMMER, droitwich, worcester
I'm always amazed when going to the public toilets by the number of women who don't wash their hands afterwards.
"So why aren't we all dead or dying then?" asked Phil.
Not dying, but catching the flu or skin diseases. I think I'm pretty clean myself, but I hate going to the gym or the public swimming pool because I often come back with a skin problem.
Laure, Paris,
It's interesting how much more cleanliness-consious people are in Muslim countries - where for example toilets are made with a little spray that washes your behind (Istanbul airport) and in many, if not most restaurants you pass handwashing facilities on the way in. People then always dry their hands not with the towel provided, but with their own, beautifully ironed, hanky.
We can learn something there.
Beate, Vilnius,
Oxford calls it "scientific tosh" - then what are his own arguments?
Undoubtedly he throws the jam away when it has passed it's sell-by date.
I do not obsessively wash my hands - not even every time I go to the toilet; I do not wash everything directly after use; I do have a dishcloth and the milk does reside in the door of the fridge.
And I am very rarely ill.
Undoubtedly Oxford would put that down to luck....
Timothy Bolton, Schalbruch, Germany
Do we need some more research funding boys? Stop justifying your worthless jobs. If what you said were true we´d all be dying or ill as it is a shocking 1 in 5 might have to get some additional toilet paper in....
I really wish so called experts would just stop with the apocolyptic nonsense. Get a proper job boys.
Rob, Lima, Peru
Oh come on, sort it out! We have a thing called an imune system which has had thousands of years to develop itself to counter most of the nasty bacterias out there. If the above article were 'true', why don't most of us end up very ill all of the time!
ewan, sherborne,
In Great Britain, people immerge dirty dishes in soapy water, then put them to dry without rinsing them in running water at all, or even worse, they wipe them with a dry towel and put them away.
Foreigners who discover this "tradition" are horrified at the obvious spreading of germs that occurs daily.
Millions of Britons have been abroad and saw people cleaning the dishes in clean running water, but still ignore hygene, so when they eat their next meal, they are literally eating millions of germs and cleaning chemicals. I am quite surprised that even on the washing up liquid there are no rinsing instructions. Surely we are not supposed to drink washing up liquid?
F. Sidney, Norwich, England
One simple thing one could do with regard to swimming pools is force people to take a shower before they go swimming. This is what is done in Germany.
I wear a swimming cap to make things easier when I swim, but I wish they would make it compulsory for all people again.
Tina, Duesseldorf, Germany
if it was re-iterated to children over and over again that washing their hands after going to the loo or blowing their nose was a good idea so that they 'don't spread bugs' to everyone else then countless infections and consequent antibiotics courses could be avoided. Out of all the children who come to our house I can't actually remember any of them washing their hands after being to the bathroom. This includes all age ranges. If it was endlessly enforced at school (since it is unlikely to happen at home) maybe it would become a habit that if you don't do it feels odd (like not having a seatbelt on).
louise, tunbridge wells, east sussex
It's amazing how we ever survive, isn't it? There's nothing in the above list that can't be beaten with a decent diet, enough sleep and the right levels of activity and rest.
Paolo Bagarino, Roma, Italy
I used to work in a leisure centre and the cleaning standards were atrocious. The floor underneath the sauna benches was a pinky-orange colour with the sweat and fat people had perspired, the rubber sealant on the pool decks had corroded after 3 years from the mould that had set in and all the grout in the showers and even some shower tiles had an orange tint to them that required strong acids to burn off.
The only time a deep clean was authorised was when somebody would threaten senior management with bringing in the HSE, the rest of the time it was deemed acceptable.
I think it comes down to the centre, my old workplace was a council run facility with a very tight budget so all the cleaning of wetside facilities was carried out by lifeguards mostly aged 16-24 who will generally say they're above cleaning and know all the tricks for making a job look done when it isn't.
Chris, Cheltenham, UK
So why aren't we all dead or dying then? Clearly special precautions are necessary in hospitals and the like or for those unfortunate enough to have a compromised immune system. However, in my house nobody gets diarrhoea and vomiting and we are rarely ill in general. I imagine this is not unconnected with the absence of anti-bacterial sprays and wipes and with no more that a sensible attitude to bacterial hazards. Work surfaces are washed with hot soapy water, raw and cooked meat kept apart and so on. Toilets are cleaned with eco-friendly solutions and the baths are cleaned as and when.
Stop worrying and enjoy life! You'll stay a lot healthier.
Phil Batten, Haslemere,
difficult to practice good hygiene when must public toilets in shopping centres, hospitals and airports are absolutely filthy in Britain!
jb100, radlett, herts