Helena Frith Powell, French mistress
Star musicians and your favourite Times writers at the Albert Hall
I was rather hoping the new French president might appoint a Brit to his cabinet. It is true that François Fillon, his prime minister, has a Welsh-born wife, speaks English, drinks tea and has even spent several days as a fly-on-the-wall observer in Downing Street to absorb Anglo-Saxon attitudes.
But why accept imitations?
Sarko has appointed a socialist as his foreign minister. Why not a Brit in charge of, say, economic competitiveness?
I’m sure there are plenty of expats here who would be up for the job. I would volunteer myself, although there are others with far more direct and bruising experience of the French paradox. On the one hand, this is a country that declares itself a beacon of competitiveness and seeks to attract foreign investment; on the other, its officials pursue ruthless vendettas against anyone who gets off their bum.
Tracy McVeigh, for example, who runs the Hôtel de Vigniamont in Pézenas, near Montpellier, would love the job of rethinking France’s policy towards small-business owners.
McVeigh and her husband, Rob, bought a run-down building in the centre of town in 2003 and converted it into a boutique hotel. Four years later, the business is a success, but McVeigh feels the government is doing everything it can to thwart them.
“It feels as if we’re being punished for doing well,” she tells me. “Hardly a day goes by without us receiving yet another piece of bureaucratic paperwork that needs either our attention, our accountant’s attention or, more often than not, another cheque to the Sécu [social security authority]. Our social charges have gone up by 65% in the past year and, of course, our tax bill has increased as well.”
So, although the couple have seen a 40% increase in business, they will actually be worse off by the end of the season than they were when they were making less money. “It is not exactly an incentive,” says McVeigh. “Sarkozy needs to provide better tax breaks and reduce social charges for small-business owners to start up an enterprise.”
Small-business owners in France generally have to pay about 40% of their gross income to the French social administrative departments, mainly the URSSAF, which controls healthcare, pensions and welfare benefits. Not surprising, then, that they find survival tricky. Two-thirds of new businesses fail during the first three years.
“Once the tax breaks given in the first two years cease to apply, life becomes impossible,” says Craig Nunn, who runs a small building company near Limoges. “Most of the people who were on the same course as me at the chamber of commerce went bust during their third year in business.”
Brits living in France have other gripes, too. Were Lauren McMullen, a sports marketing consultant, to get a job in the cabinet, she would make Sarkozy hold to the pledge, made during his campaign, to abolish inheritance tax.
McMullen and her boyfriend, Michael Groom, both in their fifties, are selling their fourbed farmhouse in southwest France, but they might rethink if inheritance tax is abolished. “France is already attractive,” she says. “Without inheritance tax, it would be irresistible. For our age group, this tax is a preoccupation. By now, we should be able to relax and enjoy life; instead, we are worrying about passing assets to our children early, to avoid 40% tax, and, if we do, whether we have enough left to live on. I know we’re not alone in this.”
The concerns of most expats are far more mundane. My friend Caroline says that first, she would pass a law to make it illegal to keep dogs locked up for hours on end, so they bark incessantly. She lives in a village near a man who keeps his two hunting dogs tied up nearly all day.
“He takes them out for an hour, but basically, the rest of the time, the poor animals are cooped up,” she says. “They bark incessantly, mainly at night or early in the morning. I’ve lost count of the number of times they’ve woken us up. I lie there listening to them at 2am, and wonder what sort of person doesn’t try to shut their dogs up at that time of night.”
Obviously, as soon as Sarko tries to implement any of the changes that will deregulate the labour market, there will be strikes. Annoyingly, these always seem to happen the one day I am on a TGV or at the airport, trying to get somewhere. My suggestion to Sarko is to employ Margaret Thatcher as a consultant on how to deal with irritating strikers. This will scare the hell out of the unions and he can threaten them by saying that, if they don’t agree to negotiations, he’ll make her deputy prime minister.
He could recruit 10,000 or so retired Brits to drive the buses and trains on national strike days, as well as retired doctors to see to patients, teachers to look after the children, and so on. We have lived here for almost seven years and have had about 10 strike days at our children’s school. Things have been quiet during the winter, but I suspect now summer has arrived, they will start up again.
While we’re on the subject of schools, were I to be offered a place in the Sarkozy cabinet, I would make school uniforms obligatory across the country, for all ages. They would be modelled on the classic Chanel tailleur: cream and black, with little skirts and jackets for the girls, trousers or shorts and cotton jumpers for the boys.
Sarko’s job will not be easy.
As well as coping with the restive French, who are unlikely to fall in line with the outrageous suggestion that they work more than 35 hours a week, he will face resistance from the many Brits who fled the British Isles to escape Thatcher. These people, most of whom have gone completely native, should be informed, rather like those Japanese who think that the second world war is still on, that Thatcher is no longer in power.
However, should they wish to remain in France, they must swear allegiance to the concept of economic reform and the free market, or they will be deported. The reason? As a French admiral remarked when asked why the English court-martialed and shot Admiral Byng: “
Pour encourager les autres.”
helena@sunday-times.co.uk, www.helenafrithpowell.com, www.hoteldevigniamont.com
To search for properties in France on propertyfinder.com click here
To find the French property that suits you on properazzi.com click here
Follow our three athletes' progress in their preparations for the London Triathlon, and pick up training tips and more
Enjoy screenings of all the classic films you love, plus take advantage of two-for-one tickets
We explore leisure activities that are safe and suitable for all of the family
Times Online's new TV show helps you make the right decisions for your pet
Read our exclusive 100 Years of Fleming and Bond interactive timeline, packed with original Times articles and reviews
The latest travel news plus the best hotels and gadgets for business travellers
Shortcuts to help you find sections and articles

Essential reading whether you're buying, selling, improving or moving
|
|
£129,500
Bentley Edinburgh
£79,850
Mercedes-Benz of Northampton
£26,995
Unit 1, Woodfield Business Unit, Kidderminster Road, Ombersley, Worcester.
Great car insurance deals online
90k + Bonus + Options
Confidential
London
£23,716 +
Highways Agency
National
£
£43,405 - £48,228 pa
Notting Hill Housing
London
£30,000 base, £100,000 OTE
Riches Consulting
London/South
with annexe accommodation and 5.25 acres
£1,100,000
Beautiful Gardens w/ stunning Thames Views
Studios £33K, 1 Beds £60K, 2 beds £79K
Mortgages, bank acc & money transfers to help you buy abroad
Explore mystical Jordan
From £1030 for 7nts 4*
to USA's Most Cosmopolitan City; San Francisco!
£POA
Book Now for Winter 08/09 and Get 10% off!
Great travel insurance deals online
Contact our advertising team for advertising and sponsorship in Times Online, The Times and The Sunday Times. Search globrix.com to buy or rent UK property. Visit our classified services and find jobs, used cars, property or holidays. Use our dating service, read our births, marriages and deaths announcements, or place your advertisement.
Copyright 2008 Times Newspapers Ltd.
This service is provided on Times Newspapers' standard Terms and Conditions. Please read our Privacy Policy.To inquire about a licence to reproduce material from Times Online, The Times or The Sunday Times, click here.This website is published by a member of the News International Group. News International Limited, 1 Virginia St, London E98 1XY, is the holding company for the News International group and is registered in England No 81701. VAT number GB 243 8054 69.
Helena - let the Brits run France? Jamais!
They can't even run their own country despite seven (or is it eight?) new laws a day since Paramount Chief Tony Kuffa Bulam achieved power.
And the corruption in Britain today? Not to mention the crime and political correctness.
By the way, I think you are gorgeous - smiling in every picture I see of you, and I am sure you speak French unlike - I am told - 90% of the Poms who live in France.
(born in England but thankfully spent half of his life away from perfidious Albion)
John Bell, Hereford, England
Dear Helena,
I really enjoyed your article and had to laugh aloud while reading it. I am neither English nor French, so I guess no one can suspect a Czech person for taking sides but I found some of your remarks truly funny. For example: don't the Brits make a business plan for more then 2 years so that they know what taxes they would be facing after the innitial 2 year period? Also, aren't they ever wondering why on the continental Europe there is no super bug, no long operation waiting lists, no post code lottery? Why is it normal to go to the theatre and to the restaurants and why you don't need to attend Eton and similar to get to a good university? Perhaps the answer is obvious: it's because of the high tax rates of which a huge sume is wasted but a big chunk goes towards making the life more comfortable. I really love the working culture in the UK and the straight business approach, but it's not a country of social equality and of equal access to an immediate medical help.
Renata Zakova, Cambridge, UK
I can only say that the Brits who want to be run by Brits, should move back to Britain. I cannot understand how people who decide to move to France for a change of life , only critizise the French way of life once in France. Due to both my husband's and my carreer, we 've lived in 8 European countries and we each time embraced the local way of life with its plus and minus points. You certainly live much happier that way!
Tattersall Monique , Aubignan, France
Just to offer some conclusion: if you look at the competitiveness of the market, as you say, I think it would be useful to consider all the factors involved as opposed to make money and not to care what happens next and who is going to fund all the nice things you are ennoying:-)
thanks, Renata
Renata Zakova, Cambridge, UK
This is my last say about H Powell's article dated 3rd of june: Mrs Powells seems like many french people to consider UK as always the most effecient, and France the most inefficient.
Let see my last experience: I am french and married to an english woman, we live in north of France, had a baby girl born 3 weeks ago, and my wife's granddad died on wednesday 30th of may. To go to the funeral we need a passport for our daughter; we contacted french and british authorities. The french autorities will do an "emergency passport", the British authorities asked us to come and stay in Paris 24H minimum...or would issue a single trip passport, so we can get in uk, but we can not come back!! Who on earth has imagined such a thing?& The death certificate is not issued yet (issued in the day here). More, french solution is free, british one cost from 86 to 118. This shows that you pay less tax on income, but every vital things is expensive in UK. So i think H Powell's vision is often reductive.
CRUNELLE, calais, France
Good afternoon, I would like to "have my say" about H.F.Powel's article published on 3rd of June. First of all I feel very sorry for Mrs Powel who must be quite miserable to live in such a country she can't stand.
Obviously, what British people must know when they decide to move to France (or another country) is that things are not necessary the same than in UK, even if people speaks english.
For instance, concerning social contributions paid by self employed peolple. They have not increased by 65%!!
It just works as following:
the first two years you pay on a "theoric profit", which is quite low. Then when profit and loss account is declared, you have to pay an adjusment. For example for the Urssaf, the adjustment concerning 2006, will be paid in October 2007 and february 2008 (a little bit quicker if you pay monthly).
Then you realise that it is not a pay as you earn system. You must keep money from 2006 profit to pay it.
CRUNELLE, calais, France
What a whingeing article! 10 strike days in 7 years is nothing. At least the French are not meek robots like the
occupants of the Anglo Saxon countries.
John, LONDON,
I would like to "have another say" about H.F.Powel's article published on 3rd of June:
There are more and more incentives to set up businesses:
-Tax exemption on profit for 5 years in certain areas (100% for 2 years, then 75% for 1 Year, then 50%, etc...)
-Social contribution exemption for unemployed people setting up a business,
-grant from assedic
and that is just a sample of the incentives.
Then when you set up a business you have to plan it properly to optimize taxes and social contributions, see that with your chartered accountant (expert comptable).Ex:if you get tax exemption, choose for a Personal income tax system (entreprise soumise à l'Impôt sur le Revenu). If you want to reduce social taxes, choose a Corporate tax system (impot société).
about inheritance tax, check with a notaire, which law applies: does it depends on where lived the deceased, or where lives his or he children, or both? This is ruled by international agreements.
François Crunelle
expert-comptable
CRUNELLE, calais, France