Tim Reid in Washington
Enter our Snapshots of Summer photography competition

The polar bear should be removed from the endangered species list because its protected status will hamper drilling for oil and gas in Alaska, the state's Republican Governor has demanded.
Sarah Palin is suing the Bush Administration over its decision last week to place the animal under the protection of the Endangered Species Act, claiming that climate models predicting the continued loss of sea ice - the main habitat of polar bears - are unreliable.
The lawsuit came as a surprise because most of the outcry after last week's decision came from environmental groups. Although pleased that the Bush Administration had singled out climate change as a reason to place an animal under the protection of the Endangered Species Act, the green lobby were dismayed about restrictions attached to the listing.
The listing came with a big caveat: that it should not be misused to harm the economy and “set backdoor climate policy”. Some environmentalists also accused the Administration of deliberately delaying the ruling to make it easier for oil companies to finalise $2.7 billion (£ 1.35 billion) in offshore oil leases in the Chukchi Sea, an area that is home to about 20 per cent of the world's polar bears. Numerous lawsuits were threatened by the green lobby.
Yet the Governor of Alaska - a state whose residents overwhelmingly support oil exploration - is arguing that the polar bear does not need added protection, and the bear populations have increased significantly over the past 30 years because of conservation. Ms Palin maintains that any commercial development in Alaska requiring federal permits or funding would have to go through a consultation process - described by Steven Daugherty, Alaska's assistant Attorney-General, as “basically a big time-and-money waster”.
He added: “We believe that the listing was unwarranted and that it is unprecedented to list a currently healthy population based on uncertain climate models.”
There are an estimated 20,000-25,000 polar bears in the Arctic, but scientists from the US Geological Survey predict that two thirds of the world's bears will disappear in the next 50 years because of a decline in the Arctic sea ice.
In a stark warning last year, scientists at the National Snow and Ice Data Centre said that the total Arctic ice cover had melted to its lowest level in modern times, and that if melting rates continued the summertime Arctic could be ice-free within 80 years.
Kassie Siegel, of the Centre for Biological Diversity, said that it was unconscionable for Ms Palin to ignore overwhelming evidence of global warming's threat to the polar bear's habitat. “Even the Bush Administration cannot deny the reality of global warming,” she said. “The Governor is aligning herself and the state of Alaska with the most discredited, fringe, extreme viewpoints by denying this. “She is either grossly misinformed or intentionally misleading, and both are unbecoming. ”
Dirk Kempthorne, the US Interior Secretary, who made the listing, said that it was based on three findings. “First, sea ice is vital to polar bear survival; second, the polar bear's habitat has dramatically melted; third, sea ice is likely to further recede in the future.”
Changing list
48 species have been removed from the endangered list since 1976
17 of these were taken off after errors in the original data
9 species have been been delisted because of extinction
Rocky mountain grey wolves were removed from the list this year after controversial reintroduction programmes increased their numbers to more than 1,500
Idaho springsnail was removed from the list last year after the Fish and Wildlife service responded to a petition from the Idaho Governor’s Office arguing that its listing in 1992 was in error
Yellowstone grizzly bear was removed from the list last year. In 1975 their numbers in the Yellowstone ecosystem dwindled and the species was in danger of total disappearance. But by 2007 there were more than 500 — no longer meeting the Endangered Species Act’s definition of threatened or endangered
Source: US Fish and Wildlife Service
Win a luxury weekend to Newcastle and its neighbour Gateshead, find out more here
Risk, resilience and embracing new technology
Industry sectors news at a glance. Interactive heatmap, video and podcast
Discover the collective power of smart thinking. Submit a solution and be in with a chance to win a Flip MinoHD Camcorder
The inside track on current trends in the charity, not for profit and social enterprise sectors
Everything the Business Traveller needs to know to make a better trip
Make the most of the summer and enter our fabulous photographic competition, you could win a £5000 holiday
Corsica is an island of beauty and contrast, an ideal holiday destination
Enjoy further reading from Travel to Fashion, Business to Sport, discover more
Shortcuts to help you find sections and articles
The clever way to lease a new car is with Car leasing made simple™
2009
42,945
2008
71,450
Car Insurance
Not Specified
MI6
UK-based
£60,000
The Environment Agency
Bristol
Up to £90K
Boots
Midlands
OTE £85k
Credit Protection Association
Nationwide Opportunities
Completely London
Luxury Condo's in Manhattan with NYC views
The best new homes in Wimbledon?
Nationwide
Save up to £1,000 per couple with Elite Vacations at the five-star Constance Lemuria Resort
and do the British Isles this Summer.
Save up to 60% with Oxford Hotels and Inns
Try our inspiring luxury holidays to the Indian Subcontinent and South East Asia.
Great offers available
8 fabulous Canadian cities ...you won’t find cheaper
Contact our advertising team for advertising and sponsorship in Times Online, The Times and The Sunday Times, or place your advertisement.
Times Online Services: Dating | Jobs | Property Search | Used Cars | Holidays | Births, Marriages, Deaths | Subscriptions | E-paper
News International associated websites: Globrix Property Search | Property Finder | Milkround
Copyright 2009 Times Newspapers Ltd.
This service is provided on Times Newspapers' standard Terms and Conditions. Please read our Privacy Policy.To inquire about a licence to reproduce material from Times Online, The Times or The Sunday Times, click here.This website is published by a member of the News International Group. News International Limited, 1 Virginia St, London E98 1XY, is the holding company for the News International group and is registered in England No 81701. VAT number GB 243 8054 69.
I no friend of Sarah Palin given the fact that I voted for her.Ever since I heard that she is paying bounty on woles she is in my little back book,which is getting bigger.I would like to see a solution which would save the bears,woles,and still get oil.I'am no friend of 40 million $ Al Gore.sinceVP
Michael Regan, PHILADELPHILA, U.S.A.
I guess I'am a bit stupid,because I don't see how drilling for in Alaska we kill off the polar bear.We need to stop putting out tons of money to countrys that don't even like us and start using our own oil.They have oil platforms in the sea that can drill in a 40 mile radius.I'am no friend of Sarah
Michael Regan, PHILADELPHILA, U.S.A.
She is not a crazy religious wak job. She will be a great vice president. However, I disagree with Sarah Palin on putting the polar bear on the endangered species list. The polar bear's habitat is practically melting. People shouldn't believe everything they hear.
Keri, Knoxville, U.S.A.
I don't care who is responsible for global warming, whether it exists or doesn't. Who could argue that pollution is bad? Isn't it a fact that cigarette smoking leads to lung problems? Is car exhaust any better? Are factories any less damaging? Let's design to have NO pollution. CRADLE TO CRADLE
glen burnie, savannah, usa
I am still amazed how people believe spin and hype without doing research. New energy sources? Why are we still using technology from the early 1900's? The gasoline engine has been outdated for decades. We need a replacement, not better fuel economy.
Brian Vaught, La Grange, GA, USA
Sarah Palin is a crazy extreme religious wak job. Her type should never be allowed in the white house. It is bad enough we had Bush for 8 years. This woman will roll back every protection and women's rights that have been hard won by women over the many years.
Jane, Savannah, GA., USA
Go for it Sarah! What really counts in this world is money and more of it! When every thing in the world is finally gone, we can stuff our mattresses with it!
Nelson, Hudson, USA
palin was brought on to solidify support among fundamentalists. she is a tool, a strategic play at its most cynical. mccain's win is a given and the addition of palins cloudy and closed 1st century worldview will be a loss to the world. we can no longer afford to indulge these regressive ideologies.
JKHuysmans, Arlington VA, USA
God is #1
He created you, all & me out there. Also the animals otherwise he wouldn't had them on the Ark with Noah & Family.
Also hate to be in your shoes when you meet our creator. Bad enough all else is going on.
Lets try to save what we can before the world falls apart.
Karen, Westciffe, USA
We can deny the fact that global warming is not caused by man. The question is can we take that risk? Palin seems to be an intellient woman but, is misguided if she thinks, she can take on congress as VP.I think she is being used by the powers in the Republican Party, Boy what a chess game.!!!!!
Lillie, richmond, USA
Not sure bout bears, and warming. But i do know that i had my first child at 16 and I raised 4 by myself & my mother is a wonderful person! Stop bashing Mrs. Palin for her kids! Does anyone know the politics of raising kids? Obviously not! Shut up until you have been in her shoes!
Robin , Munford, USA
Palin is radical and not qualified to be President but neither was George Bush. If that's the kind of leaders the idiot Republicans want to put in power so be it. George Bush couldn't even spell the word science let alone understand it. Palin can't understand it either. Obama all the way for me.
Paul S., Cary, NC, USA
I wouldn't vote for any republican anyway, but the more I read about their VP the more they disgust me........ I'm Obama all the way, more then ever. The same ol same ol party......... 8 years is enough........... Ulli
ulli clowers , Puyallup, US
I fail to see how global warming is manmade. The earth has been in extistance for billions of years and was subject to global warming and cooling long before we came on the scene. Man has only been here 100 to 200 thousand years. and The industrial revolution started in the mid 1800's
Jim, Holt, mi, USA
Since she is so well received in Alaska, I suggest she take her extremist views and take her family back there. With all her personal and family problems, it seems to me that she is needed much more there than in Washington. Sarah Palin, we can definitely do without. Obama/Biden 2008
angela, hsv, usa
Why do we even tolerate someone saying that they don't believe that global warming is man made? What happened to trusting the vast majority of scientist? Does she think God wouldn't do this to us? What about us abusing the land & animals God gave us, Sarah? Doesn't seem like she values those.
Pamela, Seattle, US
It's very frustrating to hear people like Sarah Balin tout their "let's go drill!" ideals. It's NOT just about decreasing our dependence on foreign oil. The rising cost of gas has a silver lining. We MUST invest in renewable, clean technology! Now is the time! Wake up, Palin. No bandaids!
Michele, Lakewood, CO, USA
Unless there's something in it for us, we are suddenly not religious and it's ok to allow death.
If folks believe that Valdez and could not happen again, they are mistaken. Oil companies are doing fine with the oil they have. Palin and her experience are jokes. All about the $. Stay home w/5 kids.
Germaine Kornegay, Burlington,
All animals are a part of God's Kingdom. If she is denying the Polar Bears' right to life, does this mean that Governor Sarah Palin is a Polar Bear abortionist?
John, Springfield,
I am so disgusted with these blasted Republicans and then
McPain gets Palin, another Pain ! but I hope that the
American people will wake up. We do not need the oil
on the Wildlife Refuse in Ak. There are other places. Lets
ruin the ocean. A few more spills, Whales,Dolphins will
love it.
Barbara Howard, McMinnville Oregon,
Sounds like the Republicans are running GI Joe and Barbie for President and Vice-President.
jim Louloudes, Fairfield, CT, USA
The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change reported on how global warming is really occurring. It seems no that those that don't believe in global warming are in the minority. If you really want to know why Palin wants this, check this out: http://www.commondreams.org/views02/0220-01.htm
D. St. Jean, Hooksett, NH, United States
Seems more likely to me that she's right. Bush has been against increasing our own oil production and they thought they found a way to put a halt to the U.S.'s largest producers. Think again, Bush. This lady has the smarts. I mean, if an animal really isn't endangered, why list it as such?
Marie, Sterling City, USA
Did you all forget that in the 1970s global cooling was all the rage. The one post on here regarding the volcano was dead on. We are not the only ones producing greenhouse gases. Mother Nature does so herself. Are we going to stop her?
Amanda, LaFontaine, IN, USA
And now for the truly scary part ~ Johnny Mac wants this woman to be next in line to run our country???? Riiiiiiight..... Forgive me for stating the obvious, but I think he may look back on this particular decision with a tad of regret...
Pro-life,
Pro-choice,
and I vote....
Peace~
Cherylana, Derry, USA
Sarah Palin will NEVER make it to be Vice President and i am totally Shocked anyone would want her to be the Mayor of anywhere. It just make's you wonder!
To many strike's againt you ms Palin, go take care of your children.
Nina, Deltona, America
Seems that those who claim to be pro-life are not really pro-life. They are anti-abortion, or pro-unborn-human-life, but they are not pro-life.
Laura, Cleveland, USA
OK. Sure, let's just use every bit of natural resource we've been given, forget the environment, or the wildlife. Without balance, mother nature will continue to give us more and more severe weather, and no amount of levees, or revenue from oil drilling will save us then. God bless the almighty $$
L. Jones, San Jose, CA,
It is completely egocentric idea to believe that humans have the right to use the Earth at any cost. We need to come together as a human community and decided to work with the planet, not against it . Many indigenous people have done it for centuries, it can be done.
Laine Evans, Bowling Green, USA
"kook global-warming nut jobs," yeah right. It's all one crazy conspiracy. We liberals are all banding together making up this story about global climate change so that...? So that what? What is in it for us? I think big oil and all its greedy profiteers have greater need to lie than we do.
shaina , eugene, usa
You religious zealots wave your flag pins and crosses around like they are your boyscout badges. Who wouldn't love their country and their creator? We all do. But the thoughtful individual cherishes and respects the God given creatures and resources within their nation, and all of creation.
Janet Nash, New York, USA
WHAT truly amazes me, is that the people who claim to be the MOST religious and God fearing, are the very same people who are so gluttonous (a sin) for oil and cash, that they are quite eager to systematically destroy the inhabitants of God's Eden. If you love the creator, you must love the creation
Janet Nash, New York, USA
I believe those of you who think your oil is more important than those animal's rights are inconsiderate and selfish. Along with this you are also only caring about the here and now but what about your grandchildren and great grandchildren who are going to have to live with the effects of this.
nikki, rome, USA
Anyone with half a brain knows that in spite of the supposed limitations on the listing, that the environmental extremists will treat this as the camel's nose under the tent. They will not rest until the polar bear habitat is cleared of all forms of human presence. It has happened before.
Rey Johnson, Highland, UT, USA
It really is very simple: Drilling for oil and gas doesn't require actually drilling INTO the polar bears, so I think its safe to say that the bears will be fine.They have endured mother nature and her cruelty for generations, compared to that, letting shell oil drill for oil is a cakewalk for them.
jon, Atlanta, USA
I ask if the polar bear goes, who can replace them? Sarah Palin, any US President? They cannot. Their magnificent beauty, and ability to survive in Alaska brings joy and admiration to everyone's hearts. Please be gentle with these creatures? Has Sarah Palin forgotten how precious they are?
Rita, Mulhouse, France
I am absolutely appalled by the Republican Governers demand that the polar bear should be removed from the endangered species list because it will hamper drilling for oil and gas. How utterly selfish can one be totally disregarding the right of coexistence for every living creature on this plannet
Stanley Green, Colchester,, UK
Evidence indicates a huge asteroid will hit the earth next month. That assertion is just as valid as the global warming scam. Both are made up from absolutely nothing. Quit coddling these enviro-kooks. Let's put them on a reservation in the Alaskan tundra, but away from new oil fields.
Joe, Wisconsin,
Your reporter has ignored one important part of this story: Palin's motivation and why Alaskans back oil exploitation. Around August every Alaskan gets a hefty check from the oil companies. Depending on the size of one's family and the oil revenues for the year, the bonus can run well over $1000.
Denis, Vancouver, Canada
Congress is the finest exponent of developing the Law of Unintended Consequences to its ultimate level. Re Jamie Lamb. You should feel sheepish, global warming has been cancelled due to lack of interest and education. Clue, look up the volcano in Chile this month. Check the CO2 levels released.
Desmond Taylor, Houston, USA Tx
This story has some serious omissions, among them:
<br/>
<br/> Although the ice melt up to the fall of 2007 had brought about a major retreat of Arctic ice, the reverse has occurred since then with record low temperatures, a long and severe cold winter and huge ice growth as a consequence.
Lewis, Victoria, Canada
If the ice does vanish then the cause of extinction will be bears getting shot as they try to eat Inuit children instead of seal cubs. The bears won't vanish, they will move to the next nearest food supply.
KR, Stockport,
Palin for President!
David, Minneapolis, USA
With all of the available information available on Global Warming how can Sarah Palin choose to side with the oil corporations and not the poor defenceless animal. We should be ashamed at ourselves for not doing something sooner. I feel that it's about time something was done and hope to see more.
Jamie Lamb, Victoria, BC, Canada
the bush government has finally did something correct , hopefully it will carry onward with more correct calls.
robert elliott, odessa ontario, canada
Good job Sarah Palin, standing up to the kook global-warming nut jobs!
C, Fbks, Alaska