Richard Ford, Home Correspondent
Download 'Too Hot', an exclusive Specials track from iTunes
Ministers have been forced to concede that more than half of all jobs created since Labour came to power have gone to migrants. They were also forced to clarify again their figures on the number of foreign workers in the country.
On Monday night the Government had said that the number of foreign workers who had taken up jobs in Britain since 1997 was 1.1 million rather than 800,000.
Jacqui Smith, the Home Secretary, insisted nonetheless on BBC News’s Breakfast programme yesterday that the majority of new jobs had been filled “by British workers”.
Later, the Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) issued a clarification saying that 52 per cent of more than 2 million new jobs created since 1997 had in fact gone to migrants.
The confusion over the number of foreign citizens working in Britain then deepened after a letter from the National Statistician emerged which said that 1.5 million people born overseas were employed here.
In the letter, sent in July, Karen Dunnell said: “For the three-month period ending March 2007 there were 1.5 million overseas-born people in employment who had entered the UK in the last 10 years. This figure includes those who were children when they arrived.”
Last night the DWP gave two different explanations for the difference between the 1.1 million and 1.5 million figures.
Initially a spokesman said that the extra 400,000 foreign workers were not filling new jobs but had filled vacancies in established firms.
Two hours later the department issued a new statement which said: “The foreign nationals are not UK citizens, and they make up 1.1 million of the 1.5 million. Therefore the remaining 400,000 are UK citizens.”
Chris Grayling, the Shadow Work and Pensions Secretary, said: “This situation just gets worse. It’s clear we simply can’t trust the figures or statements put out by the Government on migrant workers in the UK”.
In her interview on Breakfast, Ms Smith apologised for the Government’s first figure – 800,000 – being incorrect. She said: “Of course it is bad that these figures are wrong and ministers have apologised for that.”
The row developed as the Government announced that curbs on low-skilled workers from Romania and Bulgaria coming to work in Britain are to be maintained for a further year.
In spite of objections by the Foreign and Commonwealth Office, ministers have decided that the restrictions imposed when both states joined the EU in January must be maintained.
The decision, details of which were disclosed in The Times on Saturday, comes as concern mounts over the scale of immigration. Polling for the two main political parties shows that immigration is one of the top issues worrying the public.
Liam Byrne, the Immigration Minister, said that the restrictions on Bulgarians and Romanians had been reviewed and the controls would remain until “at least the end of 2008”.
He added: “While initial evidence shows that there is a clear positive contribution to the economy from migration, there are some reports of pressures in other areas, including public services. The prudent balance is therefore to maintain restrictions as we monitor the effects of accession migration.”
Under the curbs, low-skilled immigrants from Romania and Bulgaria are restricted to two special programmes for seasonal agricultural labourers and the food processing industry. Only 19,750 are allowed to come to Britain under the schemes. However, the self-employed, highly skilled and those whose skills cannot be found in the existing labour market and have a work permit are allowed into Britain.
In the first six months since the two states joined the EU, 75 people have come to Britain under the Highly Skilled Migrant Programme, 1,095 have received work permits and 7,775 are self-employed.
From next April the Office for National Statistics has said that it will improve its monitoring of immigration at Manchester, Stansted and Luton airports. The International Passenger Survey came under attack last year because its figures concentrated on larger airports.

Sam Coates's blog about Westminster, politics and spin
Win a luxury weekend to Newcastle and its neighbour Gateshead, find out more here
Risk, resilience and embracing new technology
Industry sectors news at a glance. Interactive heatmap, video and podcast
Discover the power of collective thinking. Submit a solution and be in with a chance to win a Media Hub Home Entertainment System
The inside track on current trends in the charity, not for profit and social enterprise sectors
Everything the Business Traveller needs to know to make a better trip
Make the most of the summer and enter our fabulous photographic competition, you could win a £5000 holiday
Corsica is an island of beauty and contrast, an ideal holiday destination
Enjoy further reading from Travel to Fashion, Business to Sport, discover more
Shortcuts to help you find sections and articles
The clever way to lease a new car is with Car leasing made simple™
2009
per month on 36-month
Personal Contract Hire (PCH)
2008
42850
Car Insurance
£24,250 - £30,346
MI5
London
£60,000
The Environment Agency
Bristol
Up to £90K
Boots
Midlands
OTE £85k
Credit Protection Association
Nationwide Opportunities
Completely London
Luxury Condo's in Manhattan with NYC views
The best new homes in Wimbledon?
Nationwide
Fabulous Cruise And Cruise & Stay Offers Including Virgin Atlantic Flights Prices Start From Only £699pp!
Last Minute Cruise And Cruise & Stay Offers. Med From £499pp, Caribbean From £699pp!
5 star quality at a 3 star price.
8 fabulous Canadian cities ...you won’t find cheaper
Contact our advertising team for advertising and sponsorship in Times Online, The Times and The Sunday Times, or place your advertisement.
Times Online Services: Dating | Jobs | Property Search | Used Cars | Holidays | Births, Marriages, Deaths | Subscriptions | E-paper
News International associated websites: Globrix Property Search | Property Finder | Milkround
Copyright 2009 Times Newspapers Ltd.
This service is provided on Times Newspapers' standard Terms and Conditions. Please read our Privacy Policy.To inquire about a licence to reproduce material from Times Online, The Times or The Sunday Times, click here.This website is published by a member of the News International Group. News International Limited, 1 Virginia St, London E98 1XY, is the holding company for the News International group and is registered in England No 81701. VAT number GB 243 8054 69.
And remember, most of the other half was created in the public sector!
PT, Tynemouth, UK
I note that the so say "mistaken figures" always seem to be in the Governments favour. What I call it is fraud!!!
J Carpenter, Bristol,
I've got a calculator that works really well.
Perhaps the government would like to borrow it.
Mind you... It would be no use as they would fabricate the fact that they had a working calculator.
They lie about everything else.
Adrian Snood, Barnet, London
Those English people looking for work have known this for a long time. There is an issue with appalling pay which leaves the English people unable to support the system...mortgages, council tax etc. and so these minimum wage jobs have been filled with foreigners. The English cannot take them and have any kind of decent life. The only thing the poor pay affords is a room in a house with 25 others and a bit of food and heat. This is what employment at the bottom end of the job market means these days.
judy, Liverpool, england
I just cannot believe the incompetence of this government whether its the the incorrect releasing of foreign prisoners or the counting of foreign workers. If anybody made mistakes like these at their work they would be sacked and today I hear Brown saying that he will no longer accept failure when talking about education. What hypocricy.
These headless chickens deserve the fate that will surely be theirs
egor1, lagos, algarve
I graduated in 2005, and have been applying for positions since then and not just graduate positions but anything that I think might give me a chance of getting somewhere, I do have experience and worked in admin before I did my degree, the last time I was offered a position anywhere was 1997, just seems a bit strange to me that this was the time when immigrants started to come.
amanda, manchester, uk
Cue a hundred comments decrying the decline of britain and *in Al Murray's brilliantly satirical Pub Landlord's voice* the decline of the great BRITISH empire.
Close your borders. Make it more difficult for people like myself (foreign born, raised educated and probably retired) to work and live in the UK. This year I will contribute more than 20,000 pounds to the UK tax coffers. A large proportion of that will have been earned in other EU countries, however I live (provisionally) in the UK.
The attitude to foreigners in Britain sickens me and once I can convince my (english) girlfriend to leave, I intend never to darken the shores of the UK again. One less immigrant to dilute your culture.
I know a lot of other people who are of the same mindset. The attitude towards immigrants has already convinced me to strike the USA off the list of places I want to live. The UK is next.
Frank, Reading,
I teach many 18-25 unemployed Basic Skills and the Govt's one size fits all' policy doesn't work. Many school leavers are still living with their parents and have no incentive to work. They get benefit and a handout from the parents. This is the same benefit as those flat dwellers, paying council tax, electric etc. I have come to the conclusion that the majority of unemployed young people, especially those at home, are quite capable of working and there needs to be a far tougher regime for the long term young unemployed. I would suggest three months benefit, six months at a training agency, then one more month.Then nothing until after a job of say 13 weeks, when they can claim again.
Dave Brian, London,
You remember the saying, "What goes around comes around"? The United Kingdom once boasted that it "ruled the waves" with its tentacles stretched across the globe as it snatched land and wealth from the aboriginals of Australia, Africa, Asia, and the Americas. It was this capitalist exploitation of the brown people that put the terrorizing "Great" in Britain. Now that people are seeking to better their economic situations by trying to get a piece of a British pie that was baked by international ingredients, folk are getting upset and crying foul? Get over it!
(BTW, although I write from Alabama, I am a born and bred British citizen.)
Keith Augustus Burton, Harvest, Alabama
What was WW2 fought for ? was it not to defend these shores from invasion ?
Here we have a Labour goverment who have opened our doors to the world and have given away our children's future and heritage in just ten years.
Overseas workers were never ever needed on such a scale, it was always about cheap labour and undercutting wages while the fat cats got fatter and the indigenous working classes got poorer.
4,000 brits a week are leaving these shores, ten years ago it was 300, it's an exodus on a massive scale and it's an absolute disgrace.
A.Masterson, kent, UK
Blair's greatest legacy will not be seen for decades but it will creep up on the UK like the black death. The current population of the UK is 60.5 million. In just around 40 years it will be 75 million and i'm not sure that anyone can envisage the impact that this will have on a small country. But that is not the end of it, oh no! What will be the population in 2100? 120 million? or more. The UK is heading for a disaster of huge proportions and it will have been engineered by a handful of people with a political ideal and no vision for the future. The legacy of Blair to too frightening to contemplate and cannot be reversed.
The complete loss of control of immigration into the UK by this government is something which I believe will eventually end in civil war. The tragedy is that Gordon Philby, Tony Burgess and the rest of the gang will be long gone and beyond the noose.
Nigel Graham-Miller, Valencia, Spain
Suzie from Manchester's comment sums it up really: "A crummy retail job." The reason these jobs are filled is because the "foreigners" will take such jobs whilst realising that they are simply a stepping stone to earn money while they look for other things. The Eastern European girls that work in the sandwich shop near me have all got degrees but they realise that they have to start somewhere & earn money in the meantime.
At 18 years old you're not going to have any experience unless you roll your sleeves up, do something about it & take any crummy job! My first job at 17 was basically making the tea in an insurance brokers as an "assistant" & learning the job from the ground up. The idea also being that I would earn just enough to pay my keep to my mum & dad as they would not tolerate me being on the dole while living at home! I'm no longer in insurance but it's always much easier to look for any sort of job if you can show you can knuckle down to a rubbish one in the first place!!
David, London,
Am I wrong in thinking that we have a very low unemployment rate in this country - the reason we are getting people in from other countries is to fill these jobs that we can't do or don't want to do?
Under these conditions it can't be suprising that economic migrants will be taking these jobs?
Jesse, London,
We can't trust this bunch of incompetents on any issue let alone this one The Brown Bunch's days must be numbered.
Albert Fisher, kettering,
Jacqui Smith utters one thing and then the DWP are forced to issue a clarification. Proof positive this incompetent government are so deluded and out of touch with reality - OR more likely - lying to the British public.
Stuff the economy - let's have a government willing to tackle what is becoming a dangerous crisis!
Phillip Anderton, Poole, England
what ever happened to 'Great Britain', The only people who think it's great are the immigrants.It's about time something was done about this as they may certain restrictions on legal immigrants but what about the rest.Isn't it obvious that all new migrants will enter under self employment taking the work that we as british nationals rely upon to feed and cloth our own, the country has become a an open for all exile and it needs to be stamped out as the records are not showing how many british are leaving these shores. Who side is the government on? and what are you going to do about it? It is time to change the policies on immigration. If they want to come, then you come on visa's!
Rob, Enfield,
But Suzie....didnt you know that this government cares about the people of Britain ? That multiculturism works !....that it is needed ! ..............All to make Tony, European President.
I hope your Son gets the training and chances the Son of a long standing taxpaying family deserves. Or he will no doubt join the exodus. What chance does he have in buying a home ? What chance of looking forward to a career ? What chance of fairness regarding discrimination ?
Sadly hes classed by this government as nothing Suzie, he's British. This Government doesnt even care about its own troops. Im sure Red Tony was a Russian plant from his old communist days. hes done more destruction to this country than any invader since 1066.
Dave, Lincoln,
What a total joke, it is clear that the people who run our country have no idea what's going on, so how can they plan any sort of policies that will ensure this country has enough houses, jobs, services...etc. On the point of overseas workers needed to fill jobs, yes I do agree with respect to certain skilled positions, but I would also like to see a complete review of the benefit system - as without a doubt there is a percentage of people who could work but choose not too because a life on benefit is either all they know or is too easy for them.
Dave, Newton Abbot, Devon
Details of jobs taken by immigrants on the basis of ''Those whose skills cannot be found in the existing labour market' should be listed. I am quite sure that some of the many unemployed school leavers could be trained for these positions were there suitable training programmes. My 18-year old son has been looking for a job for five months and even to work in a crummy retail shop - "experience" is required. How can he gain experience when nobody will hire him because all the positions are filled by foreigners?
This government's record is appalling.
suzie, Manchester,