The man, the films, those blondes. Free DVD collection starting this Sunday
MORE than 80% of the jobs created in the past 10 years have gone to foreigners - many more than the government admitted last week - according to statistics presented by the Treasury to parliament.
They also show that in the past five years the number of foreigners in work in Britain has risen by nearly 1m, while employment among the UK-born population has dropped by almost 500,000.
The figures are a further embarrassment for the government, which last week was forced to admit it had seriously underestimated the number of migrant workers in Britain.
“They are in a state of complete confusion over the figures for migrant workers,” said Chris Grayling, the Conservative shadow work and pensions secretary. “Another day brings another completely different set of statistics. They are floundering and nobody has any idea what is going on.”
Peter Hain, the work and pensions secretary, announced last week that previous estimates showing that migrants accounted for 800,000 out of 2.7m jobs created in Britain over the past 10 years were wrong, and that the true figure was 1.1m out of 2.1m. The share of jobs going to foreigners was thus 52%, rather than under 30% as originally estimated.
Gordon Brown was infuriated by the mix-up over the data, which has undermined government claims that immigration is a big benefit to Britain and provided David Cameron with a platform on which to attack the government’s record. Downing Street aides said the prime minister was irritated by what they described as a “cockup”.
But the new figures, given by the Treasury in a written Commons answer last month, suggest the picture is even worse. Alistair Darling, the chancellor, was asked for estimates of the number of migrant workers in Britain since 1997.
In a written response, Angela Eagle, a junior Treasury minister, published a letter from Karen Dunnell, the National Statistician and head of the Office for National Statistics (ONS).
In it she said the number of foreign-born workers in Britain rose from 1.904m in mid1997 to 3.269m in the middle of this year, an increase of 1.365m. Over the same period, there was a rise in working-age employment among UK-born people from 23.638m to 23.948m, a rise of just 310,000. The ONS figures thus show that 81% of jobs went to people born abroad. Since 2002 the number of foreigners working in Britain has climbed by 964,000 while UK-born employment has dropped by 478,000.
“The government’s welfare to work programme is proving to be an abject failure,” said Grayling. “UK employment has barely increased over the past 10 years and it is now falling.”
Read the training tips and advice that helped our London Triathletes
Times Online's new TV show helps you make the right decisions for your pet
Read our exclusive 100 Years of Fleming and Bond interactive timeline, packed with original Times articles and reviews
The latest travel news plus the best hotels and gadgets for business travellers
Shortcuts to help you find sections and articles


A treasure trove of baubles, booty and stylish quests


Our Credit Clinic has free help and advice

Overseas contacts and local business information
2007
£47,700
2007
£41,899
2008
£41,445
Great car insurance deals online
£25,510 – 32,000
Transport for London
London
£50k
NHS
Nationwide
£
£90,000 + PRP
Essex County Council
Essex
100K
Confidential
London
5% below developer pre-launch price!
Luxury Appts, beautiful gardens w/ Thames views
Great Investment, River Views
By Funway – Thailand
from £589pp
Christmas Cruises
From only £995pp
APTs East Coast now from only
£2425pp.
Great travel insurance deals online
Contact our advertising team for advertising and sponsorship in Times Online, The Times and The Sunday Times. Globrix Property Search - find property for sale and rent in the UK. Visit our classified services and find jobs, used cars, property or holidays. Use our dating service, read our births, marriages and deaths announcements, or place your advertisement.
Copyright 2008 Times Newspapers Ltd.
This service is provided on Times Newspapers' standard Terms and Conditions. Please read our Privacy Policy.To inquire about a licence to reproduce material from Times Online, The Times or The Sunday Times, click here.This website is published by a member of the News International Group. News International Limited, 1 Virginia St, London E98 1XY, is the holding company for the News International group and is registered in England No 81701. VAT number GB 243 8054 69.
This is fine for the ruling elite of this country. Migrants come to the uk and take jobs at rates of pay locals cant afford to work for because of being taxed out of by successive governments. Profit for business owners tax, while tax payers cover tax credits . They (migrants) live in crowded conditions, profit to private landlords, benefits paid by tax payers. Overcrowding helps liberal do gooders bemoan the cruel treatment of migrants. Councils take migrants onto Housing waiting lists, make offers of accommodation because, large families typified by Somalians escaping persecution, many coming from Holland and Norway, (state benefits paid for set periods), or Polish migrants working, but living five to a room, always attract the most points on the waiting lists. Locals who dont have families with 16 kids, would fear being savaged for it if they did, try and get by squashed up with mom, dad, brother, sis and 2 kids of own in a run down council flat or house if they are lucky.
Steve, West Midlands, UK
One thing is for certain, there is no one left in this country that has one shred of care or decency for the indigineous working classes of this island, be they black or even white. The failure of those who control this country to invest is there for us all to see. They need to undercut their own to run their inefficient businesses because they, the ruling classes, are too lazy, too ignorant and too incompenent to make effective use of the resources of this country, and esp its people, who they just want to abuse. The so called ruling classes are the real parasites here. How many of them could run a german or a french business. None! Would a german run firm want any of them? NO!
They remove any bits of culture that working class people relate to, but the same rules arent applied to Glyndbourne, the Henley Reggata or Royal Ascot. They wouldnt use restaurants were the staff can't and dont want to speak english. It always has been and always will be, one rule for them, one for us!!
Steve, West Midlands, UK
dear sir what a great courage you have by speaking the truth!!
i am from gibraltar born and bred lived here since 1972
cant express my sadness to watch what is happening to
britain,
wishing lots of successs in the near future
from a truly sad british person
mr.g.r.walton
g.r.walton, portchester fareham ,
The BNP have been saying all this for years, they understand exactly the problems facing our society today and have solutions for all our futures.
Paul, Nottingham, England
Your sins will find you out and New Labours misdemeanors are coming in spade fulls now. There is literally nothing that any Labour minister says that can be trusted to be even near to the truth when it comes to statistics and figures and whether its deliberate lies or pure incompetence it's difficult to judge. To cover up lies for ten years is a pretty impressive achievement and with a superb orator like Blair at the helm Labour got away with murder. Now with that soggy fist of Browns at the helm he looks a laughing stock bereft of any substance with the stuffing knocked out of him. All of this trouble in the government is self inflicted and has been stored up for a long time. Labour is now a lame duck government as its spending all its time on the ropes trying to deflect the current blows that it can't see where the next one is coming from. Keep it up Brown and you'll wish you'd called an early election !
Mike, Alicante, Spain
I had a visceral hatred of this government before - Smoking ban on health grounds rather than revealing a hatred of smokers - no referendum for fears of loosing - no election ditto. They do not believe in freedom but in controlling peoples lives and telling them what they can do. Could someone suggest a new level of hatred for me. beyond visceral
Trevor Hogg, Brighton and Hove, England
It's actually a good deal worse than you thought: The figures don't cater for the truly vast number of skilled-up Britons who have left for good. It's a bit weird how the British are condemned by their own would-be employers as rubbish, but have absolutely no difficulty persuading Australian, American, New Zealand, Irish or Dutch employers of our suitability. I make a point of working for non-British companies as a way of punishing the Brits for denouncing me and my compatriots as trash. I wish them the best with the foreigners, who will surely show them no more loyalty than I am prepared to.
Kit , Melbourne, Australia
He's only stating a fact.Most peaple in the street think he's only stating the obvious.Why should he resign,he said the truth.
harry sykes, ellesmere port, cheshire
I don't believe the British people are inately lazy. The problem lies with a welfare and tax system that acts as a discincentive to work, and a very poor education system. How else can we have eight million economically active people out of work and yet require milions of migrants? After 10 years in power and tens of bilions of pounds of extra spending, the fault surely lies with this incompetent government.
anthony beachey, lymington, hants, UK
As somebody who hires for the catering industry, I'd just like to point out that I don't need need to know what government statististics say.
All I need to know is that Eastern Europeans work like Spartans for the agreed wage, whereas English lads are as likely to turn up stoned or hungover as they are to turn up at all.
I hate the way the papers are always whining on about immigrants. If it wasn't for immigrants, whose labour do you think would keep this economy going, and whose taxes do you think would pay for our NHS/Pensions/Police ?
Bob, Liverpool, UK
These indigenous workers who lack a "work ethic" are the descendants of folk who built the Lancaster, the Spitfire, the Hurricane, the Queen Mary and the Queen Elizabeth etc and invented radar and the jet engine etc. Over the last 50years something has gone seriously wrong with British industry. Blaming the British working man is totally unjust, the faults lie with succesive govts and management. But who winds up on the scrapheap? Poor old Joe Bloggs.
M Young, London, UK
It's tantamount to treason - the fat cats need a constant flow of cheap labour to service their candy floss economy and supply supermarkets with "cheap" throwaway food whilst the native British people are cast onto the scrap heap. But the fault must rest partly with the mass of the British working classes who have taken their eye off the ball and content themselves with TV, sport, junk food etc. whilst the articulate middle classes abdicate their responsibilities and flee from the inner cities and keep thei heads down. A political solution cannot rest with the old Establishment blessed parties........
Dr Stuart Russell, Grantham, UK
How many of the Governments statistics are right and how many are wrong?
We urgently need statistics on this - so we know whether to believe the statistics or not!
But will the statistics on the statistics be right?? etc ad nauseum....
Richard Garland, Greater Manchester, UK
It's a bit like the inflation figures really isn't it?
Saving for emigration, Manchester, UK
This is just the latest failure by this incompetent government, who it appears cannot be trusted on anything. Why should anybody believe what they say now or indeed in any future manifesto. They mislead the public when promising a referendum on the EU treaty, Brown could not even bring himself to tell the truth as to the reason he did not call an election, and now it appears they cannot even add up .Doesn't anybody check such figures before they are released ?
It has become clear that Brown's only 'vision' was to get into no10 and he seems to be far more concerned with what the Conservatives are doing than running the country. Indeed the only ideas he has come up with he stole from the tories, the government appears to be wallowing about like a rudderless ship. Brown's reputation is in tatters and it is embarrassing to watch him at PMQs. His big political tent ,after this latest fiasco, appears to be just full of clowns.
Tony and Cherie must find his demise highly amusing.
micah, lagos, algarve
The recent cross-Departmental report on the Economic and Fiscal Impact of Migration for the House of Lords quotes a survey among memers of the Institute of Directors according to which 3/4 of them supported the view that migrant workers made a significant positive contribution to the UK economy. A similar study by the British Chambers of Commerce (BCC), also indicates that business focuses on migrantsâ skills, higher productivity and better work ethic, rather than lower wage costs. The IoD survey reported that migrant workers significantly outperform the existing workforce in terms of productivity, education and skills, work ethic, reliability and the amount of sick leave. The BCC survey found that less than 6 per cent of employers employed migrant workers because of the potential for lower wage costs.
Both IoD and BCC are not renown for their soft touch. Could it be that they have hit the nail in the head? Productivity, education, skills, work ethics, reliability, etc...
Mariusz Kuklinski, London,