Philip Webster, Political Editor
Win Sky+HD for a year and a trip to Barcelona
For a man who was famous for rarely apologising for anything, Gordon Brown is swiftly learning the art of saying sorry.
Had the latest Labour funding crisis broken in the summer when Mr Brown was riding high, he would probably have closed it down with the resignation of Peter Watt, the party’s general secretary, and moved on seamlessly to the next natural disaster . . . floods, foot-and-mouth, bluetongue, whatever.
But the problems that have piled up for him since he allowed speculation of an early election to mount and then called it off are political and not caused by the weather or viruses.
Only a week ago Mr Brown was apologising for the personal details of 25 million people being lost in the post. Northern Rock’s problems were not of the Government’s making and the rescue efforts were generally supported but did anyone really expect the Bank of England to lend the institution £24 billion?
The reason Mr Brown is now so damaged is that the central planks of his appeal to the electorate – competence, trust, cleaning up politics – look threadbare after the latest astonishing turn of events. The cumulative impact of the misfortunes befalling Mr Brown has left his party in despair and reminded all at Westminster of the dying years of the Major Government. Mr Brown’s attempted “relaunch” at the CBI on Monday was holed below the waterline even before it got under way. Yesterday the fourth “middle person” used by David Abrahams to channel cash to Labour, a Janet Dunn, turned out not to have known anything about it. What’s more she and her husband are Tory voters. You could not make it up.
Mr Brown stated that he knew nothing until Saturday night – he was in Kampala at the Commonwealth summit – about the weird practice of a big donor using associates to fund Labour, in clear breach of electoral law.
The leader who for years has been labelled a control freak was looking startlingly as if he was not in charge of events inside his own party.
Mr Brown, to be fair, made no attempt to play down the scale of the funding calamity, and did what he had to do. He promised to return the £600,000 – money that his party desperately needs to keep paying the staff bills – to Mr Abrahams, and announced the umpteenth inquiry of his short reign, with a former bishop and retired judge advising him on how to clean up the donation process.
But the questions left last night were greater than before. Downing Street said that Mr Brown’s support for Harriet Harman was “unambiguous”. But in taking money from another of the “middle persons”, Janet Kidd, for her deputy leadership campaign, Ms Harman clearly acted unwisely at best. Her action contrasted uncomfortably with that of Hilary Benn, another deputy candidate, and Mr Brown himself, whose campaign teams rejected the offer of cash. She, too, is paying back the money, but did she ask enough questions about its provenance?
We were told that Mr Benn refused an offer of cash from Mrs Kidd on the advice of Baroness Jay of Paddington, the former Cabinet minister, who was a member of a special vetting committee set up in 2002 to have a special look at donations over £5,000. She apparently knew that the money was being given on behalf of Mr Abrahams.
If this was known to Lady Jay it is strange, to say the least, that no one else at the top of the party, apart from the hapless former general secretary, will admit being aware of this idiosyncratic funding stream.
Mr Brown appears to have an unshakeable belief in his ability to get himself and his party out of the mess they are now in. His mantra is to focus on the long term where Labour, and not its opponents, will prove to have the answers. But for the moment his nightmare is the short term. If it gets any worse than this, he may find the mountain ahead of him is too big to climb.
Explore your passion for food with the delights of Thai, Indian & Chinese cooking
In our new series, Tony Hawks takes a dry, wry look at modern life - junk mail, interminable meetings and snooty sales assistants
Read the training tips and advice that helped our London Triathletes
Read our exclusive 100 Years of Fleming and Bond interactive timeline, packed with original Times articles and reviews
The latest travel news plus the best hotels and gadgets for business travellers
Shortcuts to help you find sections and articles
2007
£30,000
2006
£14,337
2008
£39,937
Great car insurance deals online
c.£75,000
GlosFirstmeansbusiness
Gloucestershire
£32,795 - £41,545
Universitry of Southampton
Southampton
£
£32,795 - £41,545
Universitry of Southampton
Southampton
Competitive Package
Npower
West Midlands
1 & 2 Bed apartments
From £249,995
Great Investment, River Views
Great Dubai Investment Opportunities
from £89,950
low-cost ownership homes in London
Las Vegas SALE!
£POA
With Ramblers Worldwide Holidays!
£POA
List your property with two leading travel websites
£POA
Great travel insurance deals online
Contact our advertising team for advertising and sponsorship in Times Online, The Times and The Sunday Times. Globrix Property Search - find property for sale and rent in the UK. Milkround Job Search - for graduate careers in the UK. Visit our classified services and find jobs, used cars, property or holidays. Use our dating service, read our births, marriages and deaths announcements, or place your advertisement.
Copyright 2008 Times Newspapers Ltd.
This service is provided on Times Newspapers' standard Terms and Conditions. Please read our Privacy Policy.To inquire about a licence to reproduce material from Times Online, The Times or The Sunday Times, click here.This website is published by a member of the News International Group. News International Limited, 1 Virginia St, London E98 1XY, is the holding company for the News International group and is registered in England No 81701. VAT number GB 243 8054 69.
The whole govt is proving itself completely "unfit for purpose" . TB must be enjoying this hugely. The "great clunking fist" is making a complete fist of controlling nothing while his miopic and dundering band of fools havent the collective intellect to tie their shoelaces in the dark.
When do things become so inept that a vote of no confidence can be considered and the political equivelant of a mercy killing be administered?
zugerman, zurich, switzerland
Micah - you forgot the 'slight' error in funding for the Olympics!!
Addie, Manchester, England
So the main planks of Gordon Brown's appeal to the electorate are threadbare. What's wrong with that?
JPW
James Wadsworth, London,
You make an interesting comment - "Northern Rockâs problems were not of the Governmentâs making".
OK, but what about regulation - the current system was designed by Brown when he was appointed Chancellor? Given our current knowledge of the world it is reasonable to speculate that this was primarily regulatory failure.
OK 2 - what about the dithering over how to prop up the wholesale markets.
OK 3 - what about the proposed takeover during the Summer - failed because the Chancellor would not allow the Bank to provide funding.
You might reasonably state that the US sub-prime problems were not of the British Governments making, but you seem to be going a lot further than this.
alastair harris, DERBY,
Whether you like Gordon Brown or not, the thing that bugs me most is the opportunists who blame the government for everything that goes wrong in the country.
The government can't be responsible for everyone's actions!
I'm amazed that the tories haven't yet blamed Mr Brown for England failing to Reach the European Champhionships. But then again, I'm sure they will try that soon.
The tory leader and his party seem to be focused on just criticising Mr Brown for everything in the hope that this will enable him to get into power. How sad indeed!
Will I vote Labour? Probably not with all of the ungodly and immorral laws that Blair has brought in and which Gordon hasn't fully disassociated himself from yet.
I will probably not vote for anyone because politically everyone is pandering to minority groups that do not represent to country at large.
Andy, Windlesham,
Best Recruiting Sergeant the Conservative Party ever had.
Please can he stay as long as possible?
John C, Warwick, UK
Many of Gordon Brown's problems stem from the fact that he occupies the position of PM in the deluded belief that he has the right to be there. He has spent years ensuring that all his serious rivals to office were removed. Heavyweight Labour politicians who could have supported him have all been stabbed in the back. Now that he needs friends they are conspicuous by their absence. He does not have a party behind him who truly believe in his right to be there. Neither does he have a mandate from the country to deliver the 'vision' he espouses. Even where people agree with policies he champions,they just don't like or trust the man or want him to be the one to enact them. His motto "not flash, just Gordon" is chillingly apt. His controlling personality is such that he has created a party where there is 'just Gordon' and just Gordon is proving not to be enough.
Mark, Derby,
Will somebody please focus on what was known by the previous Prime Minister and his fund-raising team about Mr Abrahams and his methods of donation?
Graham, Marnhull,
So when is he going to say "sorry", for playing a major part in robbing and reducing peoples pension. While putting his nose in the trough to increase his. And there are so many other examples of a man in the wrong job.
A Walton, Leicester, England
How qabout dumping Gordon and having a younger, fresher, more voter friendly face - maybe David Miliband for PM???
Simon Albion, London, Uk
It isn't just lack of leaderships, there is a strong smell of corruption surrounding this man and his Government.
Neil, Gloucestershire, England
Brown has lost his political compass, and looks totally defeated. He is wholly out of his depth. For the country's sake he needs to go and go now. The true damage of his Chancellorship will not be revealed whilst he still occupies the role of PM. Northern Rock and the data fiasco are just the tip of the ice berg. No doubt when he eventually goes we will find out the full extent of the damage to the economy and our pension funds.
Brown is perhaps the worst Prime Minister since Lord North, who was removed from office on a vote of no confidence. Let us hope he too is removed sooner rather than later.
Richard K, Nottingham,
Nothing more than I expected from this totally incompetent mob of a government. Let5s not forget Mr Brown has presided over this last 10 years as chancellor!!! God forbid if the electorate vote him and his merry bunch of spinners back with a comfortable majority at the next election!! So beware and get them out!!!!
Bill Wareham, Bodmin, England
Ah... has the Government lost its power of "spin"? Thank goodness for that! Too many years of covering up what's been going on. I appreciate our Prime Minister having the guts to stand up and admit when something he has inherited from the last PM is not in order. It is his job to put things right so give him a chance. Mr Brown HAS started to look into the dark corners and is sweeping out the rubbish that is found there. Who thinks that 10 years of what has been swept under the deep carpets at No 10 for the last decade can be put right in a few months?
Liz, East Anglia,
a total embarrassment to the country nationally and internationally.
cant really say any more that that
steve , moscow,
So much for the "Big Clunking Fist"
More like the "Big Blundering Oaf"!
It's like a cartoon, the big lummox lumbering around crashing into things as he swats at irritating flies, causing more and more damage. Was Brown elevated just to make Blair look palatable? At least the latter was decisive, (even if misguided or wrong), had charisma and a sense of humour, which is what Brown needs now.
Overall, New Labour's M.O. when anything of note occurs remains the same: Panic, lie, scapegoat, spin. Repeat until another event buries the bad news.
An election is badly needed before this collection of bungling congenital liars does irrevocable harm to this country. Blair's former pet Rottweiler Dr. Reid was notable for continuing to blame every conceivable ill possible on the previous Tory administration, even when they'd been gone more than 10 years. We know about pensions, debt, Iraq and dentistry. But what other horrors will a future government uncover in the wake of this lot ?
JfK, Woking, Surrey
He needs to apologise for his apoplgy of a goverment.
Frank Leader, Bournemouth,
Brown spent ten years trying to get into No10 , but those who worked closely with him Blair, Blunkett , Clarke ,Alastair Campbell etc. obviously all had severe doubts as to his suitability for the roll & it is now obvious that he was not.
If ever there was an example of someone being promoted beyond their ability Gordon Brown is it.
He lost the trust of the people after promising a referendum on the Eu treaty and then renging on it. This was followed by his ridiculous statement that the polls had no bearing on his election decision, treating the electorate with contempt .
He stated he wanted more time to fulfil his vision, but out comes the Queen's speech, totally lacking in any vision.
Then week after week we have been stunned by the total incompetence that he & the political pygmies in his cabinet have demonstrated. Losing the records of 25000000, N. Rock, four announcements as to the number of foreign workers there are etc. . Humiliated each week at PMQs. Time for change.
micah, Hull,