David Byers
Win Sky+HD for a year and a trip to Barcelona

A senior Tory MP was forced to apologise "unreservedly" to Parliament today after an investigation recommended he be suspended for paying his "all-but-invisible" son £1,000 per month in taxpayers' money.
The House of Commons Standards and Privileges Committee was scathing about the £11,773 per year salary, plus bonuses, paid by Derek Conway to his son, Frederick, who was studying at Newcastle University at the time.
Recommending a 10-day suspension – and that Mr Conway apologise personally to the House – the committee said it was "astonished" to find there appeared to be no evidence of any aspect of Frederick's work.
As well as his yearly salary, he also received four one-off bonuses between September 2005 and May 2007 totalling just over £10,000.
Mr Conway, a former whip who ran David Davis's failed campaign for the party leadership in 2005, later made a personal statement to MPs in which he apologised for "my administrative shortcomings and the misjudgements I made".
In its report, the committee said: "This arrangement was, at the least, an improper use of Parliamentary allowances: at worst, it was a serious diversion of public funds. Our view is that the reality may well be somewhere between the two."
Adding that it was "astonished" at a lack of documentation about Frederick Conway's appointment, it added: "We note that FC (Frederick Conway) seems to have been all but invisible during the period of his employment.
"For the majority of that time he was based at Newcastle where he was engaged in a full-time degree course at the university. He had little or no contact with his father’s office, either in the House or the constituency.
"No record exists of the work that he is supposed to have carried out, or the hours kept. The only evidence available to us of work carried out was that provided by FC and his family."
In a statement to MPs today following the conclusion of the investigation – which took place after an article in The Sunday Times – Mr Conway said he had let down his family, constituents and local Conservative association.
"I unreservedly apologise to the House for my administrative shortcomings and the misjudgements I made," he said. "No judgment from any quarter could be more harsh than that which I apply to myself."
In a formal statement following the report's release, he said: "The commissioner in his report accepted that there was a need for the tasks I had set my son, that he was qualified to undertake them and that he did indeed do so. The committee has questioned the extent of that work and I accept they are entitled to have reached that conclusion.
"The pay-scales available to MPs for their staff are published and on the basis of those figures I paid my son 6 per cent above the mid-point of the lowest scale and, as the Commissioner notes in his report, well below the upper level.
"However, I accept that what is retrospectively considered an ’appropriate sum’ was a matter for the committee and I shall comply fully with their requirements."
The committee said Mr Conway should repay £3,962.97 in respect of the bonuses – rising to £7,161.05 if the House was unable to reclaim the tax and National Insurance – and £6,000 in respect of the salary.
"Taking together our assessments of the salary level paid to FC, and the number of hours for which he was remunerated, we are of the view that Mr Conway misused the staffing allowance," it said.
"He should have exercised his judgment more carefully, particularly as a family member was involved, as he could be seen as having a clear personal motivation for paying his son over-generously.
"He also seemed to be oblivious to the broader reputational risks to the House of any perception of personal benefit to his family."
The House of Commons will now vote on the committee's recommendations to decide whether to implement the suspension.
Explore your passion for food with the delights of Thai, Indian & Chinese cooking
In our new series, Tony Hawks takes a dry, wry look at modern life - junk mail, interminable meetings and snooty sales assistants
Read the training tips and advice that helped our London Triathletes
Read our exclusive 100 Years of Fleming and Bond interactive timeline, packed with original Times articles and reviews
The latest travel news plus the best hotels and gadgets for business travellers
Shortcuts to help you find sections and articles
2007
£30,000
2006
£14,337
2008
£39,937
Great car insurance deals online
c.£75,000
GlosFirstmeansbusiness
Gloucestershire
£32,795 - £41,545
Universitry of Southampton
Southampton
£
£32,795 - £41,545
Universitry of Southampton
Southampton
Competitive Package
Npower
West Midlands
1 & 2 Bed apartments
From £249,995
Great Investment, River Views
Great Dubai Investment Opportunities
from £89,950
low-cost ownership homes in London
Las Vegas SALE!
£POA
With Ramblers Worldwide Holidays!
£POA
List your property with two leading travel websites
£POA
Great travel insurance deals online
Contact our advertising team for advertising and sponsorship in Times Online, The Times and The Sunday Times. Globrix Property Search - find property for sale and rent in the UK. Milkround Job Search - for graduate careers in the UK. Visit our classified services and find jobs, used cars, property or holidays. Use our dating service, read our births, marriages and deaths announcements, or place your advertisement.
Copyright 2008 Times Newspapers Ltd.
This service is provided on Times Newspapers' standard Terms and Conditions. Please read our Privacy Policy.To inquire about a licence to reproduce material from Times Online, The Times or The Sunday Times, click here.This website is published by a member of the News International Group. News International Limited, 1 Virginia St, London E98 1XY, is the holding company for the News International group and is registered in England No 81701. VAT number GB 243 8054 69.
Hello! Wake up public! MP's are using your money to maintain their probably already over priveleged offspring.
Benefit frauds, who are in essence commiting the same crime as this MP, would see a possible prison sentence!
Remember the rule of law everyone - we are all equal under the law and should all receive the same justice.
Hugely disillusioned voter.
Debbie, Oxford, Oxfordshire
MP's employes wives as secretaries. I wonder how many actually do any work.
steve tea, Manchester, cheshire
This is yet another example of one rule for the politcians and one rule for everyone else. When I read the original article I was astonished. The action, or rather lack of it, reported in this article is utterly frustrating. As a 25-year-old voter I am thoroughly disappointed with the absolute dishonesty with which some politicians conduct themselves. It is a disgrace.
Young voter, London,
I do hope Mr cameron will be calling for a police investigation. Surely stealing the taxpayers money is a very serious offence.
daid, exeter, UK
Derek Conway and his son, without further delay or prevarication, should be fully investigated by the police.
Based on the current ,publically available information,he/they almost certainly should be prosecuted for financial fraud & misbehaviour in public office. If this was "an administrative oversight" , I'm a banana.
Rob Webb, Macclesfield, UK
Old Bexley and Sidcup now looking for a new MP at the next election? I think they will be looking - of course the public could exact retribution at the ballot box!!
Frank Keegan, Alderley Edge,
In addition to a Register for Researchers there ought to be another register showing all others on MPs payroll i.e. wives, children, girlfriends etc. It is very common for partners to be on the payroll and have full pension, sickness benefits etc. In the interest of accountability this should be public knowledge. The name and salary should available. Perhaps this already is?
moc, london, uk
He should resign or be sacked. If David Cameron does not act then I do not belive that the core of the Conservative MP's have changed. This is very damaging.
No ifs no buts just GO
Alan, Southampton,
This MP must resign immediately! Why must we listen to him defend any aspect of this travesty?
Floyd Smith, London,
People who volunteer for public life have to be seen to be above board. To have been found guilty of fraud, no playing with words can lessen the crime, means he should face the penalty and recive a custodial sentence. If he had any moral fibre he should resign. Mr cameron should make an example of him and have him removed from the party asap. Otherwise he too becomes implicit in accepting this criminal behaviour of MPs.
R. Swim, Torquay, UK
So whats new aren't most of them guilty of fiddling allowances one way or another. Until someone Honest & Upright is appointed to regulate these Politicians this sort of thing will keep happening. It starts at the very top like the EU, since when have they been regulated there is more fraud going on,no one will sign off the accounts and the only person that spoke out about this was sacked by Neil Kinnock ,it just happens to be one long gravy train and every tax payer is paying dearly. We have to rely on you the papers to expose these people so thankyou and keep up the good work.
June Sumner, Retford, England
If a person on benefits cheated the public purse of a tenth of the money the Thatcherite Conway did, the same MP would be the first to call for a prosecution. No ifs, no buts- as the current government slogan says. It is a disgraceful and breathtaking piece of abuse.
Keith, Gateshead, UK
That will show them. Not !
Who do the gluttons at the Westminster trough think they are kidding ? Joe Public is treated more severely for putting his bin out on the "wrong day".
jasper, chelmsford,
This is fraud - pure and simple. This man should not be allowed to continue as an MP and should be prosecuted. If the various Labour members are investigated by the Police, so should he. Scandalous. And I vote Tory.
Peter Wright, West Kilbride, Ayrshire
I can only assume that the reason he doesn't have to repay most of the money he has defrauded from the tax payers is that too many MPs feel there but for the Grace of God go I.
MPs have just voted to increase their Staffing allowance by £10,000 per annum - rather more than the 1.9% increase to Nurses and Police!
Dave Burns, London, Kent
We in Britain seem to think it is our god given right to interfere in other country's politics at every opportunity imposing democracy the world over, when we can't even eliminate basic corruption at such a low level.
Hassan Azam, Banbury, Oxfordshire, England
This man has been defrauding the taxpayer and should be sacked!
Peter Morris, High Wycombe, Bucks
The arrogance and sense, by MPs,that they are apart and different from the rest of us is exemplified by the fact that Conway apologises to the House and not to us, the taxpayers. It was OUR money he diverted, allegedly to no benefit other than his son!
Howard, St Ives, UK
If you or I stole this money we would be doing a little more than just apologising. I rule for the pigs...........................
Colin Hughes, Chester,
The man should be arrested for theft. Any other employee who misappropiated funds in this way from his employer would find himself without a job and being friendly with the local constabulary.
Steve Williams, Swindon, Wilts
He should think himself lucky he only got a 10 day suspension and have to pay back some of the money. In my company like many others, i would be out of a job and subject to a visit from the police.
phil, kent, uk
Is Dave dithering? Surely he needs to step into this situation and tell his backbencher that its time for him to go. For a party that wants to be elected to get better value from spending taxpayers money this is a funny way of demonstrating how they would cut down on waste. It seems that a lot of Tory M.P's spend their days working in the City while employing secretaries to do their constituency work. If they want to be part-timers then they should pay for their Assistants out of their full-time salaries rather than out of an expenses budget.
bill edmunds , Basingstoke, UK
It is surely QUITE unacceptable that M.Ps expenses are not made public and published for all to see .
This piece of knavery is QUITE obviously just the tip of a large iceberg .
The present system of accountability is a disgrace and should be changed as a matter of urgency.Shame on the so-called Mother of Parliaments which also enables these same M.Ps to vote themselves increased salaries.
We seem to be not much better that politicians in Africa!
Criminal charges should follow for Conway.
michael moorhouise, Bazauges, france
misjudgments? Shortcomings? Euphemisms if ever i heard them.
Why can their not be an entirely independent board of laymen presiding over MP's salaries/perks etc? They are after all public servants with the added bonus of holidays galore come summertime. They make profess to working hard, but there are a great deal many people that do so. I trust they will be planning a staged salary rise for themselves in line with policemen and women who serve to protect the public? Im sure the inflationary pressure brought on by MP wages in London is far too great to risk on the ever prudent PM.
tim, london,
If an MP can't be relied upon to apply sound judgement and morality in his dealings in such matters, he is unworthy of the postion and should be de-selected at the earliest opportunity. However, it also shows that the rules on such matters are equally lax - or maybe were drawn up when one COULD rely upon the standards of behaviour exhibited by MP's.
mx8_man, Cheshire,
He employs his wife as a secretary too...
Will Duffay, London,
MPs chould not receive allowances like this themselves, as they just consider it their own money. There are way too many misuses of funds.
Allowances should go to the party in the MP's constituency, where an office can be set up and run in a more accountable fashion.
Austin, London,
I am quite surprised that everything from fundraising to employing family can be explained by a mere administrative oversight. Politicians do not seem to draw parallels between managing their affairs in a business like manner and representing the public on important issues. Are they so foolish to think that we the public may not draw some parallels of their own.
John, Egremont,
I'm amazed the police were not called in to investigate. How could his son have done anything for him while in full time study?
He cannot be considered for reselection at the next election.
D Case, Newquay,
Wouldn't it be simpler if the rules didn't allow the employment of family members?
Sue Burnett, Pontypridd, Wales
Another thief at work.Behave in this way in any other walk of life and one would be fired and facing police charges.As an MP expect a 10 day suspension.
p robinson, audierne, france