Sam Coates, Chief Political Correspondent
Star musicians and your favourite Times writers at the Albert Hall
Pressure is growing on Michael Martin to stand down as Speaker of the Commons after one of his aides quit for misleading The Times, and after a second complaint about his conduct was submitted to the parliamentary watchdog.
Mike Granatt, who was Mr Martin’s spokesman until Friday, resigned claiming that someone in the Speaker’s office had lied to him – either deliberately or accidentally – over the use of taxis by the Speaker’s wife, Mary Martin.
The Parliamentary Commissioner for Standards has now been asked to investigate whether more than £4,000 spent on taxis for Mrs Martin’s shopping trips amounted to an inappropriate use of public money.
As MPs continued to refrain from criticising the Speaker, Martin Bell, a former independent MP, claimed that there was a “wall of silence”. He said: “MPs can talk about anything they like, inside or outside the House, except their views about the Speaker. They do not speak up. We know there is widespread disquiet on both sides of the House and no one dare speak up.”
David Davis, the Shadow Home Secretary, became the first MP to acknowledge the difficulties that Mr Martin was facing. He told The Andrew Marr Show on BBC One: “Clearly, he has got problems. The House of Commons needs to be much more transparent.”
Several MPs contacted yesterday by The Times criticised Mr Martin’s conduct privately, saying they hoped that he would stand down at the next general election, but they refrained from speaking publicly. However, many Labour MPs now see this as a witch-hunt and have rallied round the Speaker. The Tories fear that if Mr Martin stands down now and a Conservative is elected, Labour will insist on reverting to one of their own after a general election.
Mr Martin’s problems stem from December when The Times revealed his wife’s use of taxis. Mr Granatt, who represented the Speaker, said at the time: “She goes shopping for food and so on for entertaining official visitors.” He added: “She is always accompanied by an official from the Speaker’s office in this task.”
Yesterday The Mail on Sunday revealed that the “official” was Gloria Hawkes, the Martins’ housekeeper, who is also a friend of Mrs Martin, and that the Commons’ catering services provide all the food for official functions. This prompted Mr Granatt, a well-known figure in Whitehall departments, to resign for “ethical reasons”.
In a statement he said: “I have found it no longer possible to work as the media adviser to the House of Commons Commission and I have informed Mr Speaker that I am stepping down immediately.”
“I learnt on Friday that I had been led to mislead journalists over material facts in a story concerning the Speaker’s household and the use of taxis. I want to make it clear this arose through no fault of the Speaker.
“In the statement I gave to journalists the obvious implication was that Mrs Martin was accompanied by an administrative official. It was in fact the housekeeper who provides domestic support to Speaker’s House. The statement was approved by people who knew the facts. No one brought this discrepancy to my attention.”
Mr Granatt would not disclose yesterday whom he had spoken to in the Speaker’s office or who had approved the original statement given to The Times.
Yesterday a complaint was submitted to John Lyon, the Parliamentary Commissioner for Standards, by Mark Wallace of the TaxPayers’ Alliance.
He asked the commissioner to investigate whether the £4,000 was claimed improperly for the unofficial shopping trips, whether the money should be paid back, why the public was misled and when the Speaker was aware of this. He also questioned whether the Speaker should continue to oversee the investigation into expenses after the Derek Conway scandal.
Mr Wallace said: “If an iconic figure like the Speaker has done so then people will be appalled, especially as he has responsibility for making sure other MPs follow the rules. An investigation will allow us to know the truth once and for all.”
Mr Martin also faces new criticism over his expenses after it came to light that he has claimed thousands of pounds to cover costs for his home in Glasgow when the property does not have a mortgage. He received £17,166 for the property last year. He is also using his Scottish home as an office – a practice that is discouraged – claiming £7,595 last year for running costs.
Sir Alistair Graham, the former sleaze watchdog, called on Mr Martin to hand over the entire investigation to an independent body. “It’s unfortunate and really does undermine the credibility of this review that he himself has become part of this story, although it’s clear that he hasn’t broken any rules,” Sir Alistair told the BBC.
Sir Alistair said that the Committee on Standards in Public Life, which he chaired until last year, should be given charge of the review that is being undertaken by the Members Estimate Committee.
Labour friends of Mr Martin rallied to his defence yesterday.
Lord Foulkes of Cumnock, a leading Scottish Labour politician, said that the stories about Mr Martin were “a lot of unsubstantiated smear and innuendo” and part of a battle drawn out along class lines. He said that the campaign against Mr Martin was started years ago by “people who went to private schools and Oxbridge who didn’t like someone from a working-class background in Glasgow getting into the highest office in the land”.
Tony McNulty, the Home Office Minister, agreed that greater transparency was necessary but said that allegations about MPs’ expenses were being thrown around “like confetti”.
Margaret Beckett, the former Foreign Secretary, told Andrew Marr that there had been “a whole string of nasty stories” about the Speaker. She added: “Clearly someone is out to get him. Whether any of it is valid, I cannot judge.”
The Speaker’s bill
£137,000 Salary; he also gets a grace-and-favour apartment
£17,346 Expenses he claimed for a second home last year
£7,595 Expenses he claimed last year for running costs for using his Scottish home as an office, a practice from which MPs are discouraged
£50,000 Amount of public money he spent on air travel for his wife, Mary. She also spent more than £4,000 on taxis
£21,500 Amount of public money spent on legal challenges by Mr Martin’s office to newspapers, including The Times
£3,000 Value of Air Miles used by Mr Martin to fund flights between Scotland and London for his family. Guidelines stipulate that Air Miles should be used to reduce the cost of travel paid for by the taxpayer
£15,201 He also claimed £3,138 in car allowances, £10,587 in flights and £1,476 on stationery and postage
Follow our three athletes' progress in their preparations for the London Triathlon, and pick up training tips and more
Enjoy screenings of all the classic films you love, plus take advantage of two-for-one tickets
We explore leisure activities that are safe and suitable for all of the family
Times Online's new TV show helps you make the right decisions for your pet
Read our exclusive 100 Years of Fleming and Bond interactive timeline, packed with original Times articles and reviews
The latest travel news plus the best hotels and gadgets for business travellers
Shortcuts to help you find sections and articles


A treasure trove of baubles, booty and stylish quests


Overseas contacts and local business information

£129,500
Bentley Edinburgh
£79,850
Mercedes-Benz of Northampton
£26,995
Unit 1, Woodfield Business Unit, Kidderminster Road, Ombersley, Worcester.
Great car insurance deals online
90k + Bonus + Options
Confidential
London
£23,716 +
Highways Agency
National
£
£43,405 - £48,228 pa
Notting Hill Housing
London
£30,000 base, £100,000 OTE
Riches Consulting
London/South
with annexe accommodation and 5.25 acres
£1,100,000
Beautiful Gardens w/ stunning Thames Views
Studios £33K, 1 Beds £60K, 2 beds £79K
Mortgages, bank acc & money transfers to help you buy abroad
Explore mystical Jordan
From £1030 for 7nts 4*
to USA's Most Cosmopolitan City; San Francisco!
£POA
Book Now for Winter 08/09 and Get 10% off!
Great travel insurance deals online
Contact our advertising team for advertising and sponsorship in Times Online, The Times and The Sunday Times. Search globrix.com to buy or rent UK property. Visit our classified services and find jobs, used cars, property or holidays. Use our dating service, read our births, marriages and deaths announcements, or place your advertisement.
Copyright 2008 Times Newspapers Ltd.
This service is provided on Times Newspapers' standard Terms and Conditions. Please read our Privacy Policy.To inquire about a licence to reproduce material from Times Online, The Times or The Sunday Times, click here.This website is published by a member of the News International Group. News International Limited, 1 Virginia St, London E98 1XY, is the holding company for the News International group and is registered in England No 81701. VAT number GB 243 8054 69.
Well said Steve of Glasgow
Rodney of Lecstershire. Exactly the words i used to my friends so well said to you also
Mandy, Liverpool, UK
Mr Speaker and his son both represent the same constituency of Springburn which is one of the country's most deprived constituency in the whole of the UK. One as an MP and one as an MSP.
Here in Springburn we have a man who cannot speak up for his constituents, so what good is he to them ?.
It would seem that the only person that he represents in Westminster Parliament is himself.
They both come from the great one party fifedom of Glasgow, where if you put a monkey up for election with a Labour Party rosette on, then they would get elected automatically, as the majority of the people are either blind to reality or brain dead.
Thankfully people are starting to wake up to reality, so change is coming slowly.
If they would only spend some of their energy on improving their constituency that would minimise the expenses row a little.
What have they done for Springburn ?. Not a lot.
Why should an MP be paid for having his house OUTSIDE of his constituency ?.
.
Remember 1820, Glasgow, Scotland
And so the saga of MPs allowances and expenses goes on whether in connection with election expenses or with MPs salaries. It has for some time been extending itself to MEPs and what is noticeable here is that the problem, which has existed for some time, occasionally rears its head and then disappears.
All our MPs, whether members of the House of Commons or the European Parliament, should be made to declare their expenses now and if found to be "on the fiddle" prosecuted like anyone else. Someeone found to be working whilst seeking Job Seekers Allowance would ,on discovery, soon be prosecuted
Rodney Barker, Lincolnshire, UK
If MP's were as ill equiped and underfunded as the armed forces have been then we would soon have the best equiped army in the world.Let's strip the sods of all expenses and make them live on the wages they recieve.I bet more than half of them would chuck it.
Steve, Glasgow,
Send him to Brussels. The trough is bigger there and above all very secretive, as their expenses are sealed in secret vaults.
George, london, uk
Anyone in the real world would have been dismissed and probably have received legal action against them for such conduct. How much longer are politicians going to be allowed to wallow in the trough of the gravy train before any action is taken?
Is there a special department that is available to our members of parliament to guide them through the process of ripping the rest of us off?
J Spencer, York,
Martin may be due all the respect his 'honoroubale' office gives him, but not his unelected wife. She should be arrested and investigated for conspiracy to defraud the taxpayer by dishonestly using public money to pay for her taxis.
Julian, London, UK
The gravy train must be derailed!
The thought of these people sitting in judgement on their own questionable practices is contrary to natural law!?
The origins of the speaker are not an issue, his conduct is!
The cry of "ignorance" so often heard from politicians in recent issues must be treated in the same fashion as for humbler folk, "no defence"
Jim Golightly, Prudhoe, England
The problem is that MP's - having made the law - then think they are above it. Also in this weekend's newspapers is the revelation that the Revenue have assumed the same powers as Customs. Many small businesses are now subject to having investigations for minor offences, and yet MP's, who legislated this change upon us, swan around having free food up to £250 a pop, without receipts, free taxis to go and get the food, and free allowances for houses. If the Revenue were applying the law equally, they would be in Parliament charging most of the MP's with tax evasion.
Who thinks that will happen?
Frank Keegan, Alderley Edge,
Dear oh dear. He lost his future Lordship.
john, Bristol, uk
The man is clearly incompetent, a classic illustration of the Peter Principle (A person gets promoted to their own level of
incompetence) he is also manifestly partisan in his actions and decisions, now it appears that there are questions about how far his snout is in the trough. He must go and for the sake of his office and Parliament he should go soon. For he and his supporters to claim that there is class hatred aspect to this is despicable, after all the last two Labour speakers were also working class and were held in universal admiration. It is time the administration realised that in many ways Mr Speaker Martin is a large part of the problem the House of Commons and politicians in general are having with their image.
FEF, Cheltenham, UK
Will everyone else who has abused the system ALSO step down please. We can use that time when we have an empty parliament to spring clean.
Farrukh, Woking, UK
Add it all up. That's almost 1/4 of a million pounds. Nice pickings for an ex sheet metal worker? Is this what Labour mean by redistribution of wealth?
BWilliamson, Stockport,
I always found the present Speaker, Michael Martin, to be far less impartial than either of his predecessors, since the days of televised House of Commons. I think it sad we have a Speaker who is biased towards our Labour Government and therefore I do not feel at all sorry for his present predicament. He should go!
Chris Bovey, TOTNES, UK / Devon
By the wqy, you cannot lie accidentally: a lie is a deliberate falsehood.
Nu-Labour took less time to get its snouts in the trough than the Conservative government that it castigated for the same behaviour. As they say, after hubris comes nemesis - let us hope so
George Farber, Garston,
As a hard pressed self employed taxpayer struggling to pay my bills and educate my children i find all this DISGUSTING. Heads must roll.
iain , edinburgh, scotland
I went to neither public school or Oxbridge, and have more in common with Mr Martin's background than many of his accusers, but I don't think I'm alone in wanting to know exactly what has been going on. One of the implicit arguments in favour of a DNA database, one not discouraged by government, is that you have nothing to fear if you've done nothing wrong. Why is it any different for MPs?
Chris, Worthing, England
I think that the public have had our noses rubbed into the fact that politicians can shmooze around in bucket-loads of OUR money that the thought of their distress is like the colliseum. Big arrogant man, down in the dust, thumbs down then the sound of cheering.
Ken Wyatt, Todmorden, UK
I dare not comment as if I do I am likely to be commited for contempt of Parliament and locked up in Big Ben - the traditional destiny for those found to be guilty of such a heinous offence. I would not mind the opportunity of getting away from it all for a short time but the proximity of the Speaker's private quarters and the MP's expences claim office would be a problem. One would need some form of cordone sanitaire so as to avoid the smell of corruption
Stephen Green, Correns, France
Is it any wonder MP's are considered to be on a level with Estate agents and second hand car salesmen. Roll on election time.
Terry Beardsley, Newcastle,
If Brown not convince him to go today aiin, the electorate will remind Brown of his error of judgement ... when he himself is finally to allow allow our itsy, witsy piece of democracy.
Edwin, Bucharest,