Murad Ahmed
Your last chance to get tickets to Top Gear Live

A growing band of pensioners who are prepared to go to jail rather than pay their council tax will challenge local authorities again this year.
Richard Fitzmaurice is the latest in a long line of council tax “martyrs”. The 76-year-old former soldier was released last week after being imprisoned for refusing to pay the £1,359 that he owed on his Band D detached home in the village of Heacham, Norfolk. He had been led from the court in handcuffs. After he had served three days of his 34-day sentence for “wilful refusal” to pay, his family paid the money.
It was his second stay in prison after a refusal to pay in 2006.
Mr Fitzmaurice says that his battle with King’s Lynn and West Norfolk Borough Council is not a personal crusade, but one on behalf of struggling pensioners.
“I’m not doing this for me specifically,” Mr Fitzmaurice said. “I don’t wish to pay my council tax, but I can afford to. But there are many old-age pensioners who are as not as well off as I am, who cannot keep facing these increases.”
He admits that next time his fight will stop before the prison gates: “For my family’s sake, I said I wouldn’t go to prison again. That doesn’t mean to say I’m going to pay it.
“They’re going to push me right to the point of a sentence, and then I will pay it.”
Walter Stanisforth, 71, a retired labourer of Swinefleet, East Yorkshire, faced jail after refusing to pay part of his council tax for the past two years. His £484 debt was paid off anonymously before he was jailed but he says that he will still refuse to pay the full tax.
“I’ve got more going out in bills, then I’m getting back in my pension,” Mr Stanisforth said. “Where do they think we’ll be able to get the money for the council tax from?”
Another tax martyr who intends to rejoin the battle is Sylvia Hardy, 75, a retired social worker from Exeter. In 2005, she was jailed for two days after refusing to pay £53.71 from her council tax bill.
“It cost more to send me to jail,” she said.
Ms Hardy said that her dire financial situation this year will force her to refuse to pay part of her council tax bill again.
“Pensioners have come to the point that some people are having to decide whether to keep their homes or eat. They cannot do both,” Ms Hardy said.
“Though I’m not in that situation, I certainly cannot pay all my bills, and the one that I have decided I will not pay if I am short of money in any month is the council tax, because that is so unfair.”
Explore your passion for food with the delights of Thai, Indian & Chinese cooking
In our new series, Tony Hawks takes a dry, wry look at modern life - junk mail, interminable meetings and snooty sales assistants
Read the training tips and advice that helped our London Triathletes
Read our exclusive 100 Years of Fleming and Bond interactive timeline, packed with original Times articles and reviews
The latest travel news plus the best hotels and gadgets for business travellers
Shortcuts to help you find sections and articles
2007
£30,000
2006
£14,337
2008
£39,937
Great car insurance deals online
c.£75,000
GlosFirstmeansbusiness
Gloucestershire
£32,795 - £41,545
Universitry of Southampton
Southampton
£
£32,795 - £41,545
Universitry of Southampton
Southampton
Competitive Package
Npower
West Midlands
1 & 2 Bed apartments
From £249,995
Great Investment, River Views
Great Dubai Investment Opportunities
from £89,950
low-cost ownership homes in London
Las Vegas SALE!
£POA
With Ramblers Worldwide Holidays!
£POA
List your property with two leading travel websites
£POA
Great travel insurance deals online
Contact our advertising team for advertising and sponsorship in Times Online, The Times and The Sunday Times. Globrix Property Search - search houses for sale and rooms and property to rent in the UK. Milkround Job Search - for graduate careers in the UK. Visit our classified services and find jobs, used cars, property or holidays. Use our dating service, read our births, marriages and deaths announcements, or place your advertisement.
Copyright 2008 Times Newspapers Ltd.
This service is provided on Times Newspapers' standard Terms and Conditions. Please read our Privacy Policy.To inquire about a licence to reproduce material from Times Online, The Times or The Sunday Times, click here.This website is published by a member of the News International Group. News International Limited, 1 Virginia St, London E98 1XY, is the holding company for the News International group and is registered in England No 81701. VAT number GB 243 8054 69.
The fatal flaw with council tax is that the people who are setting the rate are the people who are spending the money! No wonder this tax has repeatedly risen at several times the rate of inflation.
The same problem would have arisen with a local income tax, because there is no independent control.
Central government departments are, in contrast, awarded a proportion of what they say they need by the chancellor, who is supposed to be sufficiently impartial to take a balanced overall view in distributing the available revenue.
The remedy is therefore to abolish local taxation entirely, which would have the additional advantage of saving the cost of collecting it.
The support grant, which already accounts for about 75% of council spending, would then be increased to 100% of permitted council spending as determined by the chancellor, the difference being funded by cost savings and adjustments in general taxation.
Council spending would then remain in line with inflation!
Dave, Southampton, UK
Richard Fitzmaurice and Sylvia Hardy are both members of the Isitfair campaign. Sylvia is also a member of the Devon Pensioners. Both wihheld their council tax because they felt that this Government was not prepared to listen to them. How else could they protest?
Of course this Government wants you to save for your old age, and to be able to pay your council tax and possibly income tax, they want their gold plated pensions to continue. Of course this Government wants you to buy your own home, this will mean that they will not have to fund your care in old age and should you fall foul of the council tax system they can put a charge on your property. Of course this Government wants you to buy a pension so that you can continue paying for their pension out of your own pension. It will also keep you above the benefit level but still in the poverty trap.
Unless you are seriously rich or poor saving for the future is a mugs game. As one of our members said 'Born free, taxed to death'.
Christine Melsom, Isitfair, Headley, Hampshire
You can fail to pay a court fine for a criminal or motoring offence and be sent to jail when your fine is commuted to the length of your sentence ( Around £500 for 7 days)
Then not only does the state clothe and feed you while you're inside at incredible expense your fine is expunged after you serve your sentence/
Sounds like a good deal so there is no deterrent for not paying your fines imposed by the court.
But wait a minute........ fail to pay your POLL TAX and it's off to a full jail (They'll squeeze you in anyway) and after your long sentence served with druggies, murderers and general low life, who will have served their so called debt to society, the poor POLL TAX defaulter still has to pay their POLL TAX when they're sentence is served.
And don't think for one minute the Conservatives are the better option, it was they who introduced the Poll Tax amid riots and discontent in the 80's which cost them their ultimate demise.
The country is sinking under Brown!!!
Shaun, Newcastle, Tyne and Wear
Yes Im all for the old folks home for non payers,providing its nearly up to the standards of the prisons,TV, meals,and a descent rest room.With Leave, at times, for good behaviour. Sentence to be at the least 20 years.
derek bevan, huntingdon/cambs, England/UK
Don't imagine that you get poor value for your council tax. The index linked pensions that the higher paid council oficers get are worth a small fortune. For those astronmers out there, Local Government Pension liabilities are a black hole the size of which is yet to be fully appreciated and all funded by council tax. This is why they take is so seriously when someone refuses to pay, it would undermine their pensions.
Paul, London,
Whatever your political views are, the unpalatable truth is that a socilaist welfare state is unsustainable. With each day, government expentiture grows, feeding off the wealth of the ever dwindling middle classes.
Oliver, Cambridge, UK
Thats right Mr. Brown....keep putting the elderly in jail. I consider them all my fathers, mothers, grandparents. This is a disgrace of the highest order. You and your government should rot in hell. Not one of these distinguished citizens deserve to see a moment in prison. Shame.
andrew, London,
This Government and the Country should be ashamed of itself.
Yet we let it carry on.
All I can hope for is that these Brave Pensioners carry on and someone in Government actually makes a stand for these people.
MP's have become (probably always were) very materialistic like all of us and all they seem to be worried about is lining their own pockets without actually doing anything decent for the rest of us.
Dave, London, South East
I totally agree with gerry from devon, why should I work hard all my life and those that choose not to work cause they cant be bothered get away with rent ,council tax, their given money by way of loans to furnish their homes, if we cant afford to buy a new carpet or furniture its to bad. Enough is enough
sue, bournemouth, dorset
if you don't pay a stupid council tax you go to jail.
If you don't declare money for your political campaign, you get a job as Minister...
What are you waiting for a REVOLUTION???????????
Stop drinking tea, and get out in the streets!
riccardo, brussels,
It is clear that this government would rather you did not save for your old age. From the taxation of pension funds, to the provision of minimum pension guarantee there is no point for a person on moderate income to make provision of any sort for their old age. The mantra must now be spend and enjoy what you have now and hope to leave this earth without any assets. After all this is what keeps the economy going !
David Nammory, Liverpool,
I pay £2.5K/yr for two bin bags per week collected, that is £24/bag! I know that the authority have other expenses but that is all I see attributable to me directly. A very poor deal for two 70yr olds don't you think?
I am sorely tempted to join the ranks of the criminal withholders, jail might be a pleasant change from worrying about bills - would they take us both do you think?
Jim Golightly, Prudhoe, England
There are so many people on benefits that the working citizens have to make up for their scrounging lifestyles. The benefits lot pay no rent, no council tax, no school meals and are paid more every time they reproduce. It has gone too far.
gerry, exeter, england devon
If all of we pensioners simple refused to pay would we all get jailed. The jails are full so I don't think so. If we do at least we would get free food and heating. Everyone just don't pay, march on the streets help to repeal this disgraceful tax on the elderly and the poor.
Not since the times of King John have taxes so unfair been forced on the people of this once great Island. How can we let ourselves accept this social injustice? Are our elderly to be taxed into cold and starvation?
Tony Woods, London, UK
It has to go! This ludicrous tax, based on an estate agent's guess as to the value of your property should never have been more than a stop gap while we contemplated something sensible like local income tax and vat. When is Cameron going to wake up to this?
John Ledbury, Kings Lynn, England
As a 50 year old I am not relishing old age in the UK. Something is seriously wrong with our society and it does appear to be going down the drain. I have been a local councillor and believed in our political system but today I see corruption, greed, and a lack of what would appear to be fair. The economy and social fabric is seriously skewed away from reality and is in danger of systemic collapse.
Without a strong Middle Class, social cohesion will break down and the state will exacerbate the problem by seizing more power and raising the burden of taxaxtion on those that remain. Wake up Britain before it is too late!
Steve Marchant, Broadhempston, UK
While I don't believe that pensioners should have to pay the full council tax amounts, it worries me that the examples in this article probably did contribute to pension schemes throughout their lives. Compare this to society today, where people would rather spend money on holidays, dvds and music than have a pension and many have no plans for the future at all. What will the story be like in 30, 40, 50 years?
David, Nuremberg,
The council tax is for everybody to pay. Therefore why not tax everybody at source on there income before standard rate tax is taken at 5%.
And it's about time you left the pensioners out of the loop of income Tax council tax until they have a yearly income of £20000.
When you get to 65+ and paid your dues then it should be up to you how you enjoy spend what little time and money you have,not the goverment.
john , derby, england
Weird how easy it is for magistrates to put old people away for such a serious crime, but bludgeon someone and they'll give a Community order.
Ms Hardy has a point - bed and board being provided by the state. One would hope that such hardened criminals are sent to appropriate institutions - open prison would seem to be perfect.
There might be a case for a national group of interested pensioners to be set up to ensure that prisons are suitably equipped for the physical needs of those who decide that prison is the best place to be. Think about, they'll be away from the muggers and the drugees. Hmm - I'll have to think about that solution myself.
Bill Q, Derby,
That NuLabour has decided impoverishment in the elderly merits a jail sentence, whilst letting violent criminals go free due to an alleged lack of prison space just about sums up this government's priorities. Add to that the unlimited financial assistance (involuntarily provided by British taxpayers) that they're throwing at undeserving immigrants who haven't had to put one penny in the pot, and you have their distorted view of fairness in a nutshell.
arianna, washington, usa
My God, what has happened to England?? These poor people are being jailed for not being able to keep up with the ever increasing financial burden being placed upon them by the gov't, yet radical Islamic clerics are free to preach death and destruction to their followers. Have we all fallen down the rabbit hole?
C. Heathcote, Brick, USA/NJ
Do you feel that rumbling beneath you Mr. Brown ? It ain't an earthquake. Its your former bedrock supporters voting with their feet.
Dr. Jimmy, Nottingham, England