Robert Watts
Pick up your copy of Joy Division: Closer at WHSmith today

INVESTIGATORS ordered in by Boris Johnson, the new mayor of London, have found endemic waste in the way millions of pounds of taxpayers’ money was spent by the former regime of Ken Livingstone.
Huge sums are unaccounted for, have gone missing or were spent with little tangible benefit, according to the audit. And as the accountants got to work, Johnson discovered 39 bottles of fine wine, including Château-neuf-du-Pape, left in the mayor’s office by his predecessor.
A separate police investigation, led by John Yates, the Scotland Yard detective who headed the cash for honours inquiry, has uncovered evidence of corruption that it believes will produce criminal prosecutions.
Both inquiries focus mainly on the London Development Agency (LDA), a body overseen by Livingstone, which spent £1.5 billion in four years awarding grants to an array of “community projects”.
Johnson, and the Conservatives, hope the investigations will demonstrate the party is capable of rooting out sleaze and saving taxpayers’ money, despite Tory MEPs recently being accused of abusing their expenses.
Within days of being elected mayor last month, Johnson appointed Patience Wheatcroft, a former financial journalist , to lead a team of forensic accountants to investigate how money was spent under Livingstone.
Speaking before handing an interim report to the mayor on Friday, Wheatcroft said she was horrified by what she had discovered.
“It was an organisation where success seems to have been measured by money [paid] out rather than objectively determined results,” she said.
“Monitoring of projects was scant. Evaluation of effectiveness minimal. The culture of the place was that underspending was deemed to be a failure.” Officials from the LDA have revealed that they were encouraged to compete with their peers to spend the most public funds. Only projects with a budget of more than £6m had to be approved by the LDA’s board. The investigators claim “due diligence” was often not conducted before organisations were given taxpayers’ money, and that there was inadequate monitoring of how money was spent once it had been granted.
In one case, the LDA paid funds into the accounts of a company that was dormant. Investigators have been unable to trace what happened to the money.
Another project was awarded £1.43m over several years – yet only now is the LDA inquiring what it was spent on.
Other projects to fall under Wheatcroft’s scrutiny include the Bernie Grant arts centre in Tottenham, which has spent £4.3m, and Rich Mix, a cinema and community centre in Bethnal Green. The investigators allege that the LDA failed to maintain adequate audit trails and that millions of pounds of taxpayers’ money appears to be unaccounted for.
“What I want is value for money,” said Johnson . “Precious taxpayers’ money should be spent in ways which have maximum impact. Tangible practical measures to address an issue are clearly preferable to vague, abstract but expensive initiatives to highlight a problem.”
Following a tip from Wheatcroft’s team, police have now launched an investigation into Caribbean Showcase, an event set up by Livingstone on the same day and in direct competition to the Notting Hill carnival.
A spokesman for the mayor said: “We believe that there is evidence that GLA [Greater London Authority] systems and processes were not followed, and that cash may have gone missing or been misappropriated and a criminal act may have been committed.”
Caribbean Showcase is the fifth project funded by the LDA to come under police investigation. All of these schemes have links with Lee Jasper, a close associate of Livingstone who earned a six-figure salary as a race adviser to the former mayor. The other schemes being investigated by the police are:
- Diversity International, a company run by an associate of Jasper. It was paid £346,000 to create a website for London businesses that never appeared. The money is said to have vanished.
- Brixton Base, a training centre for young people. Jasper was the patron. Earlier this year LDA auditors found at least £70,000 awarded to the project was missing.
- Green Badge taxi school, also run by Jasper associates, was awarded £350,000 to train people from ethnic minorities to become cab drivers. It is alleged the school trained only a handful of people.
- Ethnic Mutual, a financial services company, which received £350,000 from the LDA. Jasper has admitted that £18,000 from this venture was paid to bail out a company he was a director of.
Wheatcroft will publish her completed report into Livingstone’s regime next month.
Livingstone said at the weekend: “The fact that even a Tory-dominated panel keeps repeatedly coming back to such a small number of projects which allegedly failed and which represents such a tiny fraction of the LDA’s budget actually shows the organisation’s overall success.”
Explore your passion for food with the delights of Thai, Indian & Chinese cooking
In our new series, Tony Hawks takes a dry, wry look at modern life - junk mail, interminable meetings and snooty sales assistants
Read the training tips and advice that helped our London Triathletes
Read our exclusive 100 Years of Fleming and Bond interactive timeline, packed with original Times articles and reviews
The latest travel news plus the best hotels and gadgets for business travellers
Shortcuts to help you find sections and articles
2007
£30,000
2006
£14,337
2008
£39,937
Great car insurance deals online
c.£75,000
GlosFirstmeansbusiness
Gloucestershire
Competitive package
Npower
Midlands
£
£32,795 - £41,545
Universitry of Southampton
Southampton
Competitive Package
Npower
West Midlands
1 & 2 Bed apartments
From £249,995
Great Investment, River Views
Great Dubai Investment Opportunities
from £89,950
low-cost ownership homes in London
Multi–Centre 9 Nights
From only £925pp
View thousands of properties online with your Vacation Rental People
£POA
List your property with two leading travel websites
£POA
Great travel insurance deals online
Contact our advertising team for advertising and sponsorship in Times Online, The Times and The Sunday Times. Globrix Property Search - find property for sale and rent in the UK. Milkround Job Search - for graduate careers in the UK. Visit our classified services and find jobs, used cars, property or holidays. Use our dating service, read our births, marriages and deaths announcements, or place your advertisement.
Copyright 2008 Times Newspapers Ltd.
This service is provided on Times Newspapers' standard Terms and Conditions. Please read our Privacy Policy.To inquire about a licence to reproduce material from Times Online, The Times or The Sunday Times, click here.This website is published by a member of the News International Group. News International Limited, 1 Virginia St, London E98 1XY, is the holding company for the News International group and is registered in England No 81701. VAT number GB 243 8054 69.
so no charges, no evidence but a lot of tongue wagging and specualation .. should keep the tory faithful happy .. until the next bit of spin.
so what does boris have to hide that he needs to play to the gallery?
wendy mann, glasgow,
Wouldn't it have been better to have a "forensic examination" carried out by someone with rather better quaifications than a "former financial journalist"? And prefereably one who would keep quiet until such investigations had ended?
Rick Worth, Rochester, UK
Sounds not only like they were trying to buy votes, but it sounds like the money appears to have been so heavily in favour of ethnic minorities, that they were discriminating against the native population. I want to see a map of Kens handouts. I bet it looks the same as the map of Kens votes.
Paul, Southampton, England
A key question here is will the thieves who took this money be forced to pay it back? A purge across the country would probably inject enough money back into the economy to avoid a recession.
glynn, Horsham, UK
Good call Bob Jones you may have something there I think - I don't trust Boris any more then Ken to be honest. These people have no real control over anything they are all just puppets or at least most of them. We need REAL people in power like your Mum and Dad our friends, people who give a damn.
Robert Nesta, Coventry, England
Is Boris saying it is a waste to leave fine wines for him?
diana, derby, uk
nothing would be finer than seeing Ken frogmarched down to the Old Bailey.
RonP, London, UK
This is only the tip of a Ver y Big Ice berg, if this country is to survive we need all the money we can get, that means no more corruption, Kick the door in Generals, get your Auditers in, Take over the BBC and tell us what has been going on.
adrian peirson, luton, Beds
"A million pounds here, a million pounds there, pretty soon you are talking about REAL money," to paraphrase American Senator Everett Dirksen. No matter what the totals are, some people do not mind waste, fraud, corruption or theft if they are each kept under a million quid. Or more.
Bob Evans, Anaheim, California
I heard something intersting the other day which is related to this story. Council Auditors (the people who check up on public spending at your council) have a policy of not reporting potential frauds of less than £2 million.
Makes you wonder where Ken got the idea from?
Could be worth looking at?
bob jones, wales,
We are all equal but some (Ken Livingstone) are more equal than others. Typical socialist. Do as I say not as I do.
Ruth, London, UK
So why are the papers hyping up that a Tory flew on expenses to his sons wedding, whilst Labour and Red Ken have spent millions and millions of our money unaccounted for.
The storm in a teacup versus the possible fraudulent use of millions of pounds.
Richard K, Nottingham,
I assume Piltdown Man was a beneficiary of LDA grants.
Preventing this sort of rubbish is very simple you allocate a grant to an orgianization, when they bring in proof of paid invoices you advance the funds spent, otherwise you don't. It's amazing the money you save.
Rob, Winnipeg, Canada
Nice to see that no English run projects were under the spotlight.
Cromwell, Leeds, England
This is no surprise.
Other nulabor councils are just as corrupt.
martin brighton, sheffield,
Remember the DOME fiasco? Described as NAFF by Joanna Lumley. An egg shaped pancake, and on the opposite warf the magnificent Millennium corn store that should have been renovated to celebrate the docks. Who had any idea of the cultural expectations of ordinary people.
jane, Whittlesey, UK
Wow, what a surprise. Let's get it all out in the open.
Dr Ian Burgess, Bristol,
We should have independant audits on all local councils and government departments and find out exactly how much of our tax money is being squandered or "lost". I suspect the truth would be horrifying.
Charlie, Nottingham,
Ken Livingstone oversaw a government of sleaze and now its seems outright corruption.
This whisky addicted major should have been ousted years ago.
Londoners only have themselves to blame for electing him in the first place.
James, London, UK
I am perplexed as to how this so called 'wasted millions' claim, if true, can be allowed to happen in this day and age ---it begs the questions who is this department accountable to? and where is the transparency? If these fundamental issues are not addressed, what is to stop the same happening ...
payne, London, UK
Pity that Ken lost . Labour could have had their financial problems (sub £6m) sorted out without even going to the board of the LDA, I am sure that a case for a worthwhile project could have been made or spun.
DonnyB, edinburgh,
"...success seems to have been measured by money [paid] out rather than objectively determined results".
That sums up New Labour's attitude to government. They extract vast sums of money from taxpayers and hurl it wildly at their vague, poorly-defined "targets". Little or nothing is accomplished.
Tom Welsh, Basingstoke,
Well done Boris. But l hope he realises before it's too late the waste potential of some of his own dafter ideas. For example rushing to throw out bendy-buses (high capacity, no stairs to climb, easy to get in and out of) and replace them by buses with conductors who have no fares left to collect.
Barry, Wallington, UK
It is disgraceful that the media is reporting this story in this way. The implication is that the audit panel was somehow independent of Boris Johnson. It was not, it was established by Boris Johnson and consisted almost entirely of Conservatives amd they have uncovered no corruption or illegality.
Tim Paramour, London, UK
seems that "the joke" who was supposed to ruin london has exposed labour corruption in city hall and taken good measures to cut crime on public transport. keep up the good work!
tim, london,
Nice one, Eric Reynolds of Glasgow, but (1) oil does not come from Scotland, unless the Scots have developed a propensity for surviving under sea water; and even if they did the proportion of North Sea oli that is scottish depends on how you project the England/Scotland border into the sea.
John L., London, UK
Just wait till the Tories take over. All those billions thrown at quangos set up under this corrupt Labour government. Then there will be the sheer scale of the waste of tax payers money on Health, Education and the many failed law and order schemes. The Tories will have a field day.
D Case, Newquay,
Same happened when the Poles inspected the books once the Commies had left.
ian payne, walsall,
until there is a police investigation this story could be just 'Boris spin'
Mike, Gravesend, England
I'm wondering whether the police should be brought in to investigate Livingstone and his mates. Let's hope that no one is stupid enough to employ them in the future although, knowing how many of the Kinnock family live off the tax payer, that's perhaps a forlorn hope.
David, Poole,
I am looking forward to reading "Squandered" about the 1.23 trillion labour has lost/wasted in 11 years, including Gordon Brown losing billions by selling our gold reserves. Ken Livingstone and Lee Jasper typify the labour party ideal "what's mine is mine, what's yours is mine".
Tim Wood, London,
Silly little man,Guess what part of UK spends most on lotto ,yep north of the border,and lotto is being milked to sub london games ,londoners and S,E get more per head than any part of uk N,I GETS MOST,dont forget the oil revenue boris that comes from Scotland as well,the cheek of it.
Eric Reynolds, GLASGOW , SCOTLAND
I am sure this is not the last we will hear about misuse of public funds by the Livingstone regime. I would like nothing more than to see Livingstone explain himself in court.
Ralph Lawson, London, United Kingdom
What did anyone expect? Livingstone's 'accounting techniques' were plain to see after he left County Hall first time around.
Belinda, London,
Hardly a surprise, Livingstone was a slimey character who used public money to 'buy' support by various minority groups.
Good interview on Andrew Marr show, Boris ... nice to see a politician talking both common-sense and actually answering a question.
Donna Walker, Effingham, England
From whatever crawls out from under the overturned Livingstones, I very much doubt if anyone will ever end up in the pokey.
Terry , L'Absie, France
Are Labour going to be:
Public accountabilty?
CallFraud squad?
I think not, and just why are we paying such a high pension to Livingstone? Who agreed it?
steve tea, manchester, cheshire
You think this is scary, try and concieve ofr how much tax payers money our glorious Labour government have wasted on 'initiatives' over the last 11 years....*shudders*
Steve, Norwich, Norfolk
No doubt ,in however many years it takes, Boris's successor will eventually be making similar allegations of "mismanagement", waste, incompetence etc etc.
Neil, Gloucestershire, England
Was a panel of Tories ever not going to find "endemic waste"? This would all be far more impressive and compelling if Johnson had had the courage to appoint independent people to do the work. All this is, unfortunately, is politically-motivatd points scoring.
J Wild, Warwickshire,
Wouldn't it have been better to hire a profesional auditor rather than an ex-journalist to perform the audit?
Martin, Poole, UK
Are we to assume that because they were not in breach of any council wheelie bin laws., any of the people found to have misused grant funds will not be prosecuted?
Or is Boris serious? Now that would impress the voters.
Tony Atkins, Cairns, Austalia
Say what you like, but at least the investigators are working at private sector speed. Ever noticed how reports Labour calls for take 18 months to come out with a prelim?
Simon, Wokingham, England
Ken Livingstone's arrogance reaches out from the political grave. Projects below £6 million 'did not need' LDA board approval! Nobody knows what £millions have been spent on. There seems to a common thread involving 'minority' projects and missing cash. Buying votes? Ken must provide answers.
P. Williams, London, England
The LDA along with RDA's and un elected regional assemblies through out England are un accountable to any one. It is time to close them all down .
gadgie, Durham , England
barry of leigh, either one objects to misuse of public funds on principal, or one does not. I do. Only people who care about party politics more than they do about the country are ever relaxed about misuse of taxpayer money.
Oliver Chettle, Bedford,
Why am I not surprised that millions are unaccounted for and millions more appear to have been spent on schemes that came to nothing. I first started taking an interest in politics when Stafford Cripps was launching the ground nut scheme so nothing much changes with Labour over the years.
William Epps, Broadstairs, UK
While there checking how the money was spent, isn't it about time someone looked into the billions of pounds that are being wasted widening pavements. Also installing traffic Islands, railings, bollards, metal posts and oversized speed bumps. Is this really a sensible use of taxpayers money
D SHAW, London, England
More Boris hot air managed by central office. Give it a rest old boy.
barry, leigh,
No wonder Ken L introduced a congestion charge, it deflected the loss of all the other monies it would appear.
How do these people NOT get arrested. It appears the higher up the ladder and the more public money goes missing the less chance of arrest.
keithw, Wirral, UK
I notice that the Guardian aren't running this story if they really cared about Londoners they would.
VJay, London,