Ben Macintyre
Win VIP tickets

“I cannae wait to get my kids out of here.”
Easterhouse, a grim council estate in the East End of Glasgow, must once have been an attractive place, set on a green hill on the edge of the city. Now — like the woman I am talking to — it seems frayed, close to despair.
Karen Livingston has a tired face, five children, no job and a cramped home in a grey block overlooking a muddy wasteland where gangs fight most nights with knives and golf clubs. She closes the curtains so the children do not see. She is locked in a desperate feud with a neighbour over allegations of drug dealing. She is on medication for panic attacks. And she is 35. In Easterhouse, that is already old.
We are standing outside a dimly lit, ill-stocked supermarket in the mid-morning rain. The library is shuttered. Even the “regeneration centre” has boarded windows. A small knot of wary local residents has gathered to watch John Mason, the SNP candidate, hand out leaflets at the bus stop.
Some of the huddle are drunk, for the peeling, one-eyed pub next door has been open for an hour. Everyone is smoking. Everyone is angry. Most are angry with Gordon Brown.
The mere mention of the Prime Minister's name provokes a blast of fury from the man standing next to Ms Livingston, a beery explosion of rage of which only the expletives are comprehensible.
Kathleen Conaghan, a large purple stud in her tongue and small Scottish flag in her hand, is more lucid: “My vote is going to the SNP. It's the ones that don't vote that end up letting Labour in.”
If she is representative of her fellow constituents, then Mr Brown is in deep political trouble.
Glasgow East is more than just traditional Labour territory: for five decades the party has taken for granted the support of voters here almost as a feudal right. At the last election, David Marshall, the Labour MP since 1979, was returned with a majority of 13,500. To take the seat, the SNP needs a swing of 22 per cent. But the by-election on July 24, triggered when Mr Marshall resigned because of ill-health, takes place in a changed political landscape. The SNP is in government in Scotland and on a roll. David Cameron has also waded in, calling this the “broken society by-election”, payback for Labour's failure to tackle drug addiction, knife crime and poverty.
After Labour's embarrassing defeat in Crewe & Nantwich and its chronic performance at Henley, Mr Brown's enemies predict that a Labour defeat in Glasgow East would carry such unbearable symbolic weight that the Prime Minister may be forced out.
That apocalyptic vision may be premature, ramped up by a Scottish press that is keen to give this by-election heavy national significance. A combination of tradition, apathy and a strong candidate in Margaret Curran, a Member of the Scottish Parliament, may yet see Labour cling on. But the mere fact that defeat is being contemplated is a sign of how much arteries have hardened in Labour's heartland.
Glasgow East is a hard place to live, and a grotesquely easy place to die. In parts of the constituency, male life expectancy is 54, lower than The Gambia, nearly a decade lower than Bangladesh, and about 24 years below the national average. Move just a few miles to leafy Bearsden and you will live, on average, 30 years longer. Despite this, people here do not and cannot leave. For all Ms Livingston's lament, her kids are stuck in a ghetto ringed by some of the saddest statistics in Britain. Glasgow East has the highest proportion of voters on incapacity benefit or disability allowance and the fewest qualifications in higher education; nearly half the constituency's homes are social housing; and, in parts, unemployment has reached 50 per cent.
Money has been spent on the area, including investment in schools and housing, but the visible effect is negligible. A visit to the drug-drenched estates of Easterhouse prompted Iain Duncan Smith, the former Tory leader, to found the think-tank Centre for Social Justice.
Whether the pervasive sense of social injustice in Glasgow East will translate into nationalist votes is more doubtful. Mr Mason has proved an effective city councillor, but in his pinstriped suit on the pavement of Easterhouse he looks oddly out of place: once the rebel on the Scottish political landscape, the SNP has become the party in power.
After an almost comical search for a Labour candidate — the favourite, George Ryan, another city councillor, unexpectedly bowed out citing personal reasons — the party settled on Ms Curran, a former minister in the Scottish Parliament: experienced in the street fight that is Glasgow politics, local and extremely tough. “Ye wouldnae want to take a broken pay packet home tae her,” as one of my Glasgow friends put it.
There is another quality to the East End electorate that is probably best defined by the Scots word “thrawn”, meaning contrary or perverse. If the experts in Westminster are predicting disaster for Mr Brown, then the voters here may well do precisely the opposite, partly out of residual sympathy for an underdog, partly out of defiance, and partly out of habit.
“I've always voted Labour. Always will. Just like my father did,” said Douglas Connor, heading to the shops in Easterhouse. “None of youse is going to tell me how to vote.”
Another important tribal element is religion. Glasgow East is predominantly Roman Catholic, while Mr Mason is a Baptist. The Government's decision to delay the controversial Embryology Bill may prove to be a canny tactic and head off potential resentment.
Inevitably, the Labour campaign is focusing on the rare pockets of success here. To that end, Ms Curran poses manfully among the sporrans and kilts of Britain's largest maker of formal Highland dress, a business that employs 120.
“The things I have to do,” says Ms Curran with a tight smile, holding up a kilt for the cameras.
“What is that tartan?” we ask.
“That,” Tony Burns, general manager of ACS Clothing, says “is the Dress Gordon.”
“Is it popular?”
“Not very,” he says, apparently unaware of the gift he is presenting to the press. “It is just about 8 or 9 per cent.” He shakes his head, and sighs. “No, the Gordon is not too popular.”
Whether Glasgow East changes its political stripes will depend on just how unpopular Gordon has become.
The numbers
Latest poll
SNP 33%
Lab 29%
C 20%
LD 14%
2005 results
Lab 60.7% (18,775)
SNP 11.9% (5,268)
LD 11.9% (3,665)
C 6.9% (2,135)
Turnout: 48.2% (30,939)
Sources: YouGov; Glasgow City Council; Times archives

Sam Coates's blog about Westminster, politics and spin
Win a luxury weekend to Newcastle and its neighbour Gateshead, find out more here
Risk, resilience and embracing new technology
Industry sectors news at a glance. Interactive heatmap, video and podcast
Discover the power of collective thinking. Submit a solution and be in with a chance to win a Media Hub Home Entertainment System
The inside track on current trends in the charity, not for profit and social enterprise sectors
Everything the Business Traveller needs to know to make a better trip
Make the most of the summer and enter our fabulous photographic competition, you could win a £5000 holiday
Corsica is an island of beauty and contrast, an ideal holiday destination
Enjoy further reading from Travel to Fashion, Business to Sport, discover more
Shortcuts to help you find sections and articles
The clever way to lease a new car is with Car leasing made simple™
2009
per month on 36-month
Personal Contract Hire (PCH)
2008
42850
Car Insurance
£23,093 - £56,211
The Office for National Statistics
Newport, South Wales
£60,000
The Environment Agency
Bristol
Up to £90K
Boots
Midlands
OTE £85k
Credit Protection Association
Nationwide Opportunities
Completely London
Luxury Condo's in Manhattan with NYC views
The best new homes in Wimbledon?
Nationwide
Fabulous Cruise And Cruise & Stay Offers Including Virgin Atlantic Flights Prices Start From Only £699pp!
Last Minute Cruise And Cruise & Stay Offers. Med From £499pp, Caribbean From £699pp!
5 star quality at a 3 star price.
8 fabulous Canadian cities ...you won’t find cheaper
Contact our advertising team for advertising and sponsorship in Times Online, The Times and The Sunday Times, or place your advertisement.
Times Online Services: Dating | Jobs | Property Search | Used Cars | Holidays | Births, Marriages, Deaths | Subscriptions | E-paper
News International associated websites: Globrix Property Search | Property Finder | Milkround
Copyright 2009 Times Newspapers Ltd.
This service is provided on Times Newspapers' standard Terms and Conditions. Please read our Privacy Policy.To inquire about a licence to reproduce material from Times Online, The Times or The Sunday Times, click here.This website is published by a member of the News International Group. News International Limited, 1 Virginia St, London E98 1XY, is the holding company for the News International group and is registered in England No 81701. VAT number GB 243 8054 69.
Why does everybody these days have issues ? Is the word problem a dirty word. ? When a town has thugs its not an issue for people, its a serious problem. The only way to stop this knife problem dead is immediate arrest and 12 months HARD labour. 12 hour working days, no TV, no slouching around.
Phil de Buquet, Newport,
Education is needed longer for the young, plus adult education for adults, for a chance of jobs with higher pay. It could be difficult, if there is an attitude against it, though. I well remember when women were told that they did not need educating, because they would marry and it would be wasted
margie , victoria, australia
Yeah just as well the Government delayed the Embryology Bill. I'd imagine that's the hottest topic of conversation round Easterhouse these days!
Neil, Edinburgh, Scotland
Rose in Stirling is correct. I was born and raised in Easterhouse, and expressing any ambition or aspirations does not go down well.
J, Glasgow,
I left Barrhead in 2001 to move down to England and haven't been back to Glasgae since. Thanks for this article for reminding me what an awful place it is - the whiney neds in their shell suits and baseball caps, the extended families in their concrete gray council houses. Here's to another 7 years!
Big Rudy, Canterbury, England
Scot,Reno. I think you're wrong. Never heard of "tall poppy syndrome"? You're looking here at a deeply insular social culture that revels in levelling everyone down to the lowest possible level whilst always expecting someone else to give them a hand-up. I find it peculiarly strong with this lot.
Rose, Stirling, UK
From the other side of the Atlantic:
We have the same issues here in America and have had for years. There are some that do wallow in "victimhood" (Rose). However, there really are people that didn't make the choice to be there and don't know how to get out. If you must..judge the individual.
Scott , Reno, Nevada, U.S.
I'm disappointed with people blaming poorer and under-educated people for their plight. Maybe the reason for this 35 YO woman having 5 children is the lack of knowledge about contraception and money management that the better off have had. We need to improve social conditions before we pass judgment
Celia Collins, Perth, Australia
all that has been wrong with labour policies in the past 10 years stares them in the face in the east end of glasgow,as brown and his minions spend billions on africa, pakistan, and other foriegn countries ,who fights for the poor and disadvantaged in the sink estates ,not labour
steve1511, larbet, scotland
Can't wait that long BEN - Hope New Labour is thrashed at the Glasgow East by-election !!!!
Ian Payne, walsall,
there will never be a tory landslide in scotland. NEVER.
There might however be an SNP landslide. In fact its more than likely that the snp is now scotlands party
karin, glasgow,
i wish Scotland well after independence.labour are a joke .remember it was Labour who gave Scotland its parliament back not snp.So labour are to blame for the break up of the Uk
Eric Reynolds, Blackpool , ENGLAND
Dear All
I have been about Glasgow East, it is going to turn SNP.
Michael Portillo nailed his flag to the mast on This Week saying so.
On one side, John Mason, SNP lives in a tenement in Barlanark.
Labour MSP £750,000 house southside Glasgow
If you are poor, who would you pick?
SNP
George Laird, Glasgow, Scotland
35, no job, 5 children. What more needs to be said? They have more children than they can ever afford and bring them into a place with nothing to do. I have NO sympathy with these people. They bring it on themselves and need to stop whining and accept some personal responsibilty for once.
Colin, Glasgow, UK
Why not put a 'chip' in every person; if it works for identifying dogs why not people?
With scanners in shops, schools etc. linked to CCTV you'd know who was where doing what, and could identify anyone at a crime scene etc.
Not PC enough? How'd you prefer to live; those with nothing to hide?
Terry, Bagnere, France
hatred of gutless Gordon could be almost anywhere in the U.K, everyone you meet is depressed, short of money and generally pessimistic about the future and now just downright angry
peter c, devizes, wessex
In Glasgow & environs, why do the words "predominantly Roman Catholic" seem to go hand-in-hand with "poverty". Having lived throughout the UK I've never known any social group who take less responsbility for themselves but have such a well-developed, self-indulgent, whining cult of victimhood.
Rose, Stirling, UK
Funny how, the longer Nu Labour remains in government, the less popular it becomes right across the board? This may be true of all governments, but one hopes the Conservatives would do less harm less quickly. After all, conservatism boils down to "if it ain't broke, don't fix it".
Tom Welsh, Basingstoke,
they give billions of pounds of aid to africa but they let this sort of poverty happen in the UK. These problems can be fixed but it will take time, money, effort and support from goverment but them seem not to care
knight, aberdeen,
"I've always voted Labour. Always will. Just like my father did, said Douglas Connor, heading to the shops in Easterhouse. None of youse is going to tell me how to vote. "
Maybe one day you'll work out that that's why you're so poor.
S Campbell, Bath, UK
I disagree with Ben Edwards - Come on Scotland!! Lets see the stampeding panic in ZaNuLabour start now. Gordon out in one month and ZaNuLabour destroyed in about a year, after a no-confidence motion or riots in the streets.
The people changed the Gov't here, through street protests. Wake up U K
Riley, Kiev, Ukraine
That poll is across Scotland, not in Glasgow East constituency.
David Boothroyd, London, United Kingdom
I think there is something very condescending about calling this a vote against Brown. The Scots are not idiots, and Brown hasn't been PM long enough. Labour may comfort themselves if they wish, but this is a vote against the entire PC/Labour enterprise and the mess it has left society in.
jon livesey, Sunnyvale, CA/USA
As a Conservative I am rather hoping that Labour will win for 2 reasons:
1/ SNP are are obviously anti-union, which I see as appalling.
2/ If Gordon Brown wins, he might hang on to the Labour party reigns for long enough to ruin their chances of anything at the next general election. Tory landslide!
Ben Edwards, Walsall, Britain