Francis Elliott
Win a trip to the Ice Hotel in Lapland

Gordon Brown’s allies rounded on David Miliband last night, accusing him of egotism, misjudgment and of damaging the party by setting out his vision for Labour’s future.
MPs close to the Prime Minister denounced as self-serving a newspaper article in which Mr Miliband laid out, without a single mention of Mr Brown, how Labour could beat the Conservatives.
In urging MPs to find the confidence to make Labour’s “case afresh”, Mr Miliband was widely interpreted as preparing the ground for a leadership bid. At the very least, his intervention has ensured that Mr Brown will remain dogged by speculation over his future throughout the summer and into the autumn.
A Labour MP close to Mr Brown accused the Foreign Secretary of handing the Tories a priceless political advantage. “David had the opportunity to close this story down today. I am appalled that his judgment has been so clouded by ego that he has failed to do so. He says his intention is to turn Labour’s fire on David Cameron, but it has had precisely the opposite effect.”
The pressure on Mr Brown increased this morning when Ivan Lewis, the Health Minister, directly criticised his leadership. Mr Lewis said that the Prime Minister should stop being timid, adding that he needed to show “bold and decisive leadership”.
A Downing Street source insisted on Tuesday night that Mr Brown was relaxed about the Foreign Secretary’s article. Mr Miliband’s aides refused to say whether he had sought approval for its contents with No 10. It is thought that Mr Brown was sent the finished version only after it had been submitted.
Yesterday Mr Miliband refused to rule out mounting a challenge and repeated his offer of a “clear vision” and “significant change” for Labour.
His protestations of loyalty to Mr Brown were notably half-hearted when he faced questions at a Foreign and Commonwealth Office press conference, originally convened over the Balkans. He refused to say how long he expected the Prime Minister to remain in the job and emphasised the importance of the Cabinet. “Gordon will lead us forward, with the rest of us having a contribution to make,” he said.
Asked why he had failed to mention Mr Brown in his article, he said: “The debate has to be about issue and argument, not personality.” He added: “There is a very clear Labour vision for the future which offers change, significant change. And there is an emptiness about the Conservative Party that means we can get at them in a very serious way, and that is the right approach for the party.”
Mr Miliband avoided saying that Mr Brown would lead the party into the next election. “His leadership has shown itself to be of strong value, and one which shows itself to have brought a team around it who are able to make a contribution. Do I think Gordon can lead us into the next election and win? Yes, I’m absolutely sure of this,” he said.
His friends countered claims that he had been self-serving. “How can it be self-serving to seek to address Labour’s problems?” one demanded. “We had a terrible result in Glasgow East and a lot of people in Labour are in shock.”
The resolution of Mr Miliband, a Blairite, not to retreat from his call for change, was strengthened by strong private support for his stance from MPs and ministers, according to allies. Mr Brown’s supporters remain convinced, however, that the Foreign Secretary will pull back from the brink of a full-frontal assault this autumn. They believe that his intervention was “finely calibrated” to prevent him being overhauled as Mr Brown’s most likely successor.
Other contenders, such as James Purnell, the Welfare Secretary, and Andy Burnham, the Culture Secretary, have emerged in recent months. Mr Miliband is said to have been worried that the disaffected group of Blairites who will form the core of any rebellion against Mr Brown would transfer their loyalty to another candidate unless he made a clear signal of intent.
Mr Miliband is said to have been deeply affected by his failure to stand against Mr Brown last summer. A desire to escape the fatal “ditherer” tag is likely also to have played its part.
The Foreign Secretary’s decision to rally Labour was taken after a below-par speech by Mr Brown last Friday, the day after the by-election defeat in Glasgow East. “At least two Cabinet ministers have said to me that that was when he lost it,” a senior party figure said yesterday of Mr Brown’s performance at the national policy forum, at the University of Warwick. Another is said to have been particularly bemused when the Prime Minister diverted from his familiar roll call of global challenges to deliver a rambling passage on electric cars.
Mr Miliband made a point of drinking pints of bitter with union leaders and activists, while sharing their dismay, long after Mr Brown left for his holiday in Suffolk.
For the remainder of the weekend and into this week Mr Miliband calculated his options, calling his network of informal advisers, friends and colleagues. He decided that, at the very least, he could not go off for his own two-week holiday in Minorca without leaving a marker.
The Foreign Secretary was advised last summer that he lacked the support, both among MPs and activists, to take on Mr Brown. While the Prime Minister’s support has crumbled, well-placed observers advise against an assumption that loyalties have transferred to the Foreign Secretary. The rump of Blairite former ministers irreconcilable to Mr Brown, which includes Stephen Byers, Charles Clarke, Hilary Armstrong, George Howarth, Janet Anderson and others, is far too small, and too divisive, to deliver a knockout blow to the Prime Minister.
With Mr Brown showing no signs of going quietly, and Mr Miliband determined to stand his ground, it is difficult to disagree with the MP who yesterday predicted that Labour was facing “a very bloody civil war”.
In his own words . . .
“There’s a very clear Labour vision for the future which offers change, significant change”
“Let’s stop feeling sorry for ourselves, enjoy a break and then find the confidence to make our case afresh”
“Gordon Brown is the leader of the Labour Party and he will lead us forward”
“The Labour Party never does mad things. We’ve got to be a responsible party of government”
“Gordon’s leadership, I think, is one that has shown itself to be of strong values”
“Do I think Gordon can lead us into the next election and win? Yes, I’m absolutely sure of this”
“I’m not campaigning for anything other than a successful Labour government”
“The odds are against us, no question”
Make-or-break time for Brown
September
Cabinet reshuffle? If Gordon Brown is to make changes to his top team, he will probably do so in the first week or two of September, before Labour’s annual conference
Economic recovery package? Mr Brown must attempt to address key voter concerns of economic uncertainty, falling house prices and rising food and fuel costs with a credible economic recovery plan
TUC conference: September 8-11 The Prime Minister will address the Trades Union Congress in Brighton, a key audience within the Labour movement
Labour conference: September 20-24 Over five days in Manchester, Mr Brown will seek to regain the momentum – and support of his party – while delivering one of the most important speeches of his political life
October
Parliament returns: October 6 The mood of ministers in the first days could set the tone for Mr Brown
Embryology Bill Final votes in the Commons on embryo research and backbench amendments to liberalise abortion law
42 days’ detention Peersare expected to reject a Commons vote to allow terror suspects to be held for 42 days without charge, followed by a tight vote by MPs on whether to overrule them
November-December
PreBudget Report A critical moment to reveal measures to help cash-strapped families. May scrap higher rates of car tax and rewrite fiscal rules to increase borrowing
Queen’s Speech Programme of legislation for the next parliamentary session, setting the tone for the year
Industry sectors news at a glance. Interactive heatmap, video and podcast
The inside track on current trends in the charity, not for profit and social enterprise sectors
Read our exclusive 100 Years of Fleming and Bond interactive timeline, packed with original Times articles and reviews
Everything the Business Traveller needs to know to make a better trip
Shortcuts to help you find sections and articles
05/2005
£13,500
08/2008
£109,950
2005 / 55
£59,500
Great car insurance deals online
£Excellent+ executive benefits
Torres and Partners
London
£49,229 - £62,035 pro rata
Charity Commission
London/Liverpool/Taunton
Alstom Power
Europe
Six Figure
Rolls Royce
Midlands/Europe
From £89,950
Special Offers now available
At the new sophisticated
Encore Las Vegas Resort!
Cruise the Islands of Hawaii - Pride of America
List your property with two leading travel websites
Great travel insurance deals online
Contact our advertising team for advertising and sponsorship in Times Online, The Times and The Sunday Times, or place your advertisement.
Times Online Services: Dating | Jobs | Property Search | Used Cars | Holidays | Births, Marriages, Deaths
News International associated websites: Globrix | Property Finder | Milkround
Copyright 2008 Times Newspapers Ltd.
This service is provided on Times Newspapers' standard Terms and Conditions. Please read our Privacy Policy.To inquire about a licence to reproduce material from Times Online, The Times or The Sunday Times, click here.This website is published by a member of the News International Group. News International Limited, 1 Virginia St, London E98 1XY, is the holding company for the News International group and is registered in England No 81701. VAT number GB 243 8054 69.
I don't envy the choice of Britons, between the neoliberal New Labour and the reactionary Conservatives. One smiles while he steps on you, the other steps on you then spits on your face (well, Cameron is trying the former tactic as well). It's time for real socialists to rise up again.
robert, vancouver, canada
Ironic that Brown's allies complain about Milliband not having the courage for a direct challenge. After over a decade of plotting behind Blair's back but lacking any discernable courage, Brown can hardly criticise.
It's typically Labour though, to try to stifle all opposition. Sack him indeed!
j griffiths, manchester, England
This just gets better. Swapping grumpy Headmaster Brown for his precocious head boy, though entertaining, will not secure them a victory at the next election. They have taken far too much from all of us over the last ten years whilst lecturing us on how to live. Miliband will only prolong the agony.
Andy Fleming, Liverpool, UK
He's 10 years too early. Cameron has pulled well out in front of Milliband in the "young man" stakes already, also Milliband does not yet have the firepower to handle PMQ's.
John Weaver, San Javier, Spain
The public are fed up with Labout but have no great affection for the Tories (they represent only a small percentage of wealthy UK citizens). A change of leadership combined with a dramatic and brave change of government policies could still do it for Labour.
Duncan, Glasgow,
I wish someone would stand up to Brown and trigger a leadership challenge. Brown has been a woeful Prime Minister, clearly not up to the job and moving backwards every day. Would Miliband be better? Nobody knows for sure, but he can't be worse.
Brown should quit and save the country the contest.
Mike, Cheltenham,
Miliband should either put up or shut up and stop using weasel words. If he's going to challenge for the leadership, then he should gather the necessary votes and do it. If he's not then he should get on with being Foreign Secretary.
Fed up with this self-obsessed bunch of jokers.
Simon, London,
Isn't it sad that in the bosom of the English language there seems to be a lot of people who don't understand the difference between their theres and their theirs!
Maggie's Disciple, Winchester, UK
The mess that Labour is in today reminds me of the song in the television satire "Splitting Image- Election 87 episode", where the Labour Puppets sing-" We are hopeless..."
Vivek, London, UK
Like so many pigs at a trough, they will eat those who get trampled in the stampede for power.
Let them destroy each other and their chances for re-election.
Good ridance to them for the damage they have caused the country. They have blighted us all for a generation to come.
Phil Austin, RAUNDS, Albion
Seems like the rats are now jumping ship!
Caleb , West Midlands, U.K.
The film Khartoum comes to mind when General Gordon comes down the steps and, for a long few moments, the tribesmen are silent in awe, then a young fellow (possibly of the band Milli) gets up the courage to spear him and it's all over.
Kevin Straw, Leicester,
Labour appear to have abandoned the population, content to sit out the next two years gathering their large salaries and returning nothing.
THEY ARE BREAKING THE COUNTRY
Mike, Sole Street, England
he had better be able to walk on water because labours ship is sinking and a change of captain won,t save it and the lifeboats will be full.and this is 1 voter who won,t be throwing them a lifebelt
brian rice, halifax, england
You could respect this mediocrity Miliband more if he came clean and said he was challenging but then he is a mini-Blair after all so truth will be in short supply, as it was yesterday. The lot of them be damned.
Rob, Warfield, England
So, Brown appears to have presided over an ongoing debacle, is the idea to find a big enough carpet to sweep it under?
If I performed like that, I would expect to be dismissed. It appears that our representatives choose to represent our worst characteristics rather than our best.
Kidd Garrett, Bristol, UK
If Milliband is at the brink them I'd like to push him off and watch him fall.
Milliband, Blair, Brown, all the same. What we actually need is a political party that actually knows how to run the country, i.e NOT the Labour party.
When do WE get to choose our countries' leader??
Anto, London, England
David Miliband is an ineffective Foreign Secretary who is rarely seen, heard or made any impact. What would be so different if he became Leader of the Labour Party?
Stuart Murray, Amsterdam, Netherlands
Labour are finished and all this jockeying of musical political chairs is in no way going to help there fortunes, its the policys of this government that the public are sick up to the back teeth of, our over taxed, over spent, over bearing state which has put them where they are now in the polls!
Chris Ryder, Banbury, UK
After eleven years of failing their grass roots supporters, erosion of liberties, stealth taxes and the lowest paid pensioners in the whole of the EU, does it really matter now who leads the Labour party into the next election. If Mr. Milliband is wise he will avoid the poison chalice for now.
William Epps, Broadstairs, UK
The problem of the Labour party is that Brown has made serious errors of judgement, repeatedly, as have many of his key ministers. Let's face it, had Brown's political persuasion been Conservative, he would have been incompetent on the right too! As CE he mortgaged our future and encouraged debt.
Arni, Noumea, New Caledonia
How do friends of GB justify their anger at the rallying call
made by David M?
It is not his ego but their own that stir up such an inappropriate response. He is right to seek change and a focus on the emptiness of the Tories. He has done nothing to damage the
party. It has already imploded.
Barbara Holloway, Chelmsford, UK
I think David Milliband is potential Prime Minister material but not if he carries on this way. In a run off with Gordon Brown, I can't see David winning. Personally I think Gordon will hang on until the general election and after the Tory victory someone will replace Gordon - James Purnell?
Craig Cockburn, Linlithgow, Scotland
Milliband's major acheivement was the suppression of information on dead poultry as head of DEFRA in the Norfolk avian flu scare. Maybe Gordon Brown (the parrot) is not deceased, just resting!!
A.M. Williams, Stafford,
Who is Milliband and what exactly has he achieved? I think we should be told. (Ironic laughter!)
Paul Freeman, London, England
They are so out of touch they think that re-arranging the chairs will save them. WELL IT WON'T.
The British public are sick and tired of Labour and it's high taxes and an obsessive overbearing nanny state.
They want a change just like they did in '97.
Joe, Bristol, UK