Report: Michael Bilton
Your last chance to get tickets to Top Gear Live
Connecting a vacuum-cleaner hose to his car, Ian Cubbold, 60, switched on the engine, took sleeping tablets and lay down to inhale the lethal exhaust fumes and die at his home near Yeovil, Somerset, in 1993.
There were no such preparations made by Colin Dreary, aged 31. He simply picked up a knife and stabbed himself to death at his home in Sunderland in 1994.
Mark Crown, 39, died in June 1995. He handcuffed one hand to his car steering wheel, doused himself with petrol and set himself ablaze. He left a wife and two children.
Jim Laker was 37 in September 1997 when he launched himself off the roof of a building in Aldershot. Stephen Rawlins, a guardsman aged 38, hanged himself at his father’s home in south Wales on Remembrance Day, 2000.
Martin Harbert, 44, hanged himself, leaving three children, in May 2001. Charles Bruce, 46, threw himself out of a plane without a parachute in January 2002. John Hunt, 39, took an overdose of pills in June 2002, at his home in Calne, Wiltshire. That same year, Godfrey Williams, 40, died in Llandeilo, south Wales, after stabbing himself in the heart with a bayonet.
They were policemen, teachers, lorry drivers and care workers or simply unemployed. But they had one thing in common. They were all Falklands war veterans, they had all suffered post-traumatic disorders, and they were all failed by the system.
It’s hardly surprising that some soldiers and sailors who experience the full horrors of war fail to readjust to civilian life. Haunted by their experiences, terrorised by flashbacks, they develop psychiatric disorders and, in spite of the support of family or friends, succumb to suicide.
What is surprising is that these nine men represent a roll call that shames Britain.
A total of 255 British servicemen died during the conflict. But around 300 veterans – the equivalent of half a battalion of fighting men – have died by their own hand since the Argentine surrender to the British task force on June 14, 1982, in Port Stanley. This week marks the 25th anniversary. Up and down the country there will be celebrations, parades and reunions to mark the event. It is likely that every ex-serviceman who served knows of a comrade who will not be among the parade participants. The services of remembrance will pay homage to those who lost their lives during the war – but who will pay homage to those who lost their lives during the peace? Those, and their families, consigned by their untreated, unrecognised and largely ignored cries for help to depression, alcoholism, violence and suicide.
And the forgotten army of the post-war Falklands dead raises the terrible spectre of suicide, violence, addiction and family break-up for many thousands more in the decades to come. As servicemen who have returned from the Gulf war, the Balkans, Iraq and Afghanistan develop post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), they find themselves lost in the no-man’s-land of civilian life and the creaking healthcare system.
Amazingly, nobody knows the precise number of Falklands veterans’ suicides. Not the government, the Ministry of Defence, the army, navy, RAF or even the individual regiments themselves.
The figure assessed by the South Atlantic Medal Association (SAMA), which represents the veterans, is roughly 300. Unofficially, some statisticians, citing Gulf war studies, believe this figure may not be wide of the mark. Argentina’s veterans believe 460 of their men have died by their own hand.
There are no official British figures because no government has bothered to commission a study or keep a tally of what happened to the Falklands veterans, despite warnings from psychiatrists and military doctors that thousands of men were suffering from PTSD in the aftermath of the war.
Servicemen with symptoms of traumatic stress got help – if they asked for it. Most did not. Overwhelmingly, Falklands veterans with PTSD were too ashamed or in denial. Many involved in the hand-to-hand fighting in 1982 suffered extreme symptoms, often descending into drug and alcohol dependency.
Because they went undiagnosed, many went untreated. Their lives became chaotic and some saw suicide as a way out. A study by a medical officer in the Parachute Regiment in 1987 showed that 50% of a sample group of paras who fought in the Falklands were suffering PTSD symptoms, including 22% who had the full condition.
They might have been better off coming home from the Napoleonic wars 200 years ago.Military hospitals at Catterick, Woolwich, Wroughton, Plymouth and Portsmouth have closed under Ministry of Defence (MoD) streamlining. They had all built up huge expertise over the years, dealing with servicemen’s health problems including PTSD. The Royal Navy hospital at Haslar in Portsmouth’s naval base finally closed only this spring – after 250 years of providing healthcare. It opened in the 1750s, providing respite for “navy lunatics” – sailors and marines damaged in the line of duty. The patients were given extra comforts. Instead of the regulation 14lb of horsehair stuffed into bedding they had 21lb of horsehair, to provide for sound sleep.
The “naval lunatic” was regarded as someone who had simply lost their reason, either through disease, grief or accident, a latter-day diagnosis of what we call PTSD. These patients differed from hopeless cases, who were described as “idiotic”. In the 1980s and 90s, Haslar – under Surgeon Commander Morgan O’Connell – treated hundreds of Falklands veterans suffering from psychological damage.
Crucial to recovery in Britain’s military hospitals was the very culture in which people were treated. Everyone – patients and staff – understood what these soldiers, sailors and airmen had been through.
In place of service hospitals and clinics, the government presumed the NHS could up huge expertise over the years, dealing with servicemen’s health problems including PTSD. The Royal Navy hospital at Haslar in Portsmouth’s naval base finally closed only this spring – after 250 years of providing healthcare. It opened in the 1750s, providing respite for “navy lunatics” – sailors and marines damaged in the line of duty. The patients were given extra comforts. Instead of the regulation 14lb of horsehair stuffed into bedding they had 21lb of horsehair, to provide for sound sleep.
The “naval lunatic” was regarded as someone who had simply lost their reason, either through disease, grief or accident, a latter-day diagnosis of what we call PTSD. These patients differed from hopeless cases, who were described as “idiotic”. In the 1980s and 90s, Haslar – under Surgeon Commander Morgan O’Connell – treated hundreds of Falklands veterans suffering from psychological damage.
Crucial to recovery in Britain’s military hospitals was the very culture in which people were treated. Everyone – patients and staff – understood what these soldiers, sailors and airmen had been through.
In place of service hospitals and clinics, the government presumed the NHS could carry the burden – paradoxically, the MoD continued closing Britain’s military hospitals while sending more and more troops to fight overseas in Bosnia, Sierra Leone, Kosovo, Iraq and Afghanistan, the greatest number of soldiers, sailors and airmen deployed since the Korean war.
When serving personnel fall ill, the MoD pays for private clinics. But ex-servicemen have to rely on GPs and outpatients departments at NHS hospitals that are under-resourced, inexperienced in the specialist treatment required, and overstretched.
Often veterans need the most desperate help when they are going through an immediate crisis – triggered by flashbacks and haunting memories of death and horror. Many cash-strapped primary care trusts refuse to pay for private treatment of these conditions at psychiatric clinics. The Falklands veterans compete for NHS care with people still in the military. Both serving members of the armed forces and ex-servicemen have been refused private medical insurance cover for PTSD.
Now an even bigger catastrophe looms. Late-onset PTSD often occurs 10 to 12 years after a traumatic event. Major General Robin Short, a retired head of army medical services, says an express train is waiting to hit the NHS buffers when ex-servicemen from Iraq and Afghanistan develop late-onset PTSD.
More than 2,000 soldiers returning from Iraq have already been officially diagnosed with PTSD. More are returning from Afghanistan. Research has shown that former soldiers and sailors are reluctant to seek help from GPs in case they are sectioned under the Mental Health Act, when they admit to suicidal thoughts. They frequently refuse to be treated in psychiatric hospitals with civilians, where the NHS staff have little or no understanding of the traumas of war. When you hear their stories, you begin to understand why.
In Bolton, Lancashire, two former paratroopers are reminiscing. Jim Meredith, 51, and Les Standish, 46, first met nearly 30 years ago when they were posted to Ulster. The two men fought in the same company together at Goose Green.
Meredith refused medication for years. Now he is using antipsychotic drugs to save his long-term relationship. He confirms that veterans have a phobia about being thought mentally ill. They say they have an illness caused by the war.
“You meet me and Les face-to-face and there are two different kinds of people. We are very sociable but there are two people inside us.
A nice guy who will shake your hand and say, ‘It’s my round’, ‘I’ll get you a pint’, ‘I’ll push your car and help start it for you’. But inside is the other psychopathic bastard who will go for you and rip your f***ing head off. Pardon my French, but that’s the way we are.
“Some of the stuff we’ve done you would not believe. They did some terrible things on the Falklands. If you join the Parachute Regiment, you crave war.
You crave a battle. You crave to use your weapon in anger, you are given knives, hand grenades. We are not trained to shoot at targets. We were trained to shoot at people. You cannot begin to imagine the depths of it.”
Lately, Jim Meredith has been helping his friend recover from a relapse of complex PTSD. Standish had been sleeping in his car, afraid he might become violent, “exploding” as he experienced flashbacks he thought were long forgotten. He had been in a road-rage incident and lost it. This year, in the lead-up to the 25th anniversary of the war, he had been dredging up dark thoughts, drinking heavily.
Les Standish’s most urgent desire is to repair his second marriage and be a father once more to his two stepchildren. A thoughtful, articulate man, he loves his family and is desperate to succeed. Agreeing a few months ago to co-operate with the research for this article, he was outwardly buoyant and confident. But as the 25th anniversary neared, more ex-soldiers were calling him, some traumatised by their own memories. Within weeks, Standish was also in despair. He was having nightmares, waking up screaming. He had been taught to write down his dreams on paper. “I get little white flashes that simulate bullets coming through my head and then I am back in the war, and I remember everything and I just relive it over and over again.”
His marriage to Rachel, who trains guide dogs for the blind, had crumbled and he was clearly desperate and frightened. He blamed himself. He had, he said, been in denial about his behaviour at home. He had become selfish and inconsiderate towards his wife, too much of a disciplinarian towards his stepchildren, treating them like they were in the army. He was drinking at home to block out his thoughts – typical behaviour. Eventually Rachel could take no more. Les took off in alarm. For a while he lived in his car until Jim Meredith took him in. Then he made a desperate three-hour journey to re-visit an elderly psychiatrist in Anglesey, who he says saved his life almost 13 years ago. The story of Les Standish’s journey over the past 25 years is remarkable. It does not, however, make comfortable reading.
May, 1982, Goose Green. In a conflict that had seemed unimaginable just two months earlier, 2nd Battalion, the Parachute Regiment (2 Para), was going into action. This was the real thing.
Standish, 21, a lance corporal, had been on his honeymoon in Torremolinos, Spain, when he was summoned back to his barracks at Aldershot. Seven weeks later, 8,000 miles from home, 2 Para were freezing their backsides off, dug in overlooking Falkland Sound where they watched Royal Navy ships bombed and strafed by Argentine jets. Then his section leader got trench foot and Standish found himself in charge of eight men, about to storm a series of enemy trenches.
“Nothing can prepare you for what actually happened. We would throw in grenades, jump in the trench and kill the enemy. In the trench it was him or me. I did that. Then we move on to the next one. The adrenaline takes over. Now, I see the fear in the Argentine faces that I killed. They were trying to kill us but we were elite forces in a battle with conscripts aged 18 or 19. They did not have a cat in hell’s chance. Bang, bang and away you go.
“There was a young boy who knew he was going to die when I shot him. He was not pointing his weapon, but he had it in his hand and potentially he could have shot me. When you get into contact with someone you can see the face just go white, their eyes wide open, and he just knew he was going to die. You had no time to reflect on what you had done.
“In Goose Green itself, later, I thought, ‘F***, yeah, he did not point that weapon at me.’ Did I have to kill him? I saw the look on his face. I thought, ‘Why that particular boy?’ Then I pulled myself together and thought, ‘No, it was either him or me.’ I brushed it away. It’s a brutal process. You do it without thinking. The thinking comes afterwards. I killed nine people. One Argentine I had to kill with a bayonet on my rifle. I stabbed him several times. It troubles me to this day.”
The battle lasted for more than 36 hours. In the early morning light his section was caught in open ground with the rest of their platoon. Pinned down and exposed, fusilades of enemy machinegun fire zinged around them. They withdrew, but as they did so, one soldier was shot through the leg and fell wounded. Standish went back under fire and dragged the soldier to safety. For this he later received the Military Medal for gallantry.
But they were running out of bullets. A fallen para ahead of them had a belt of ammunition, so Standish tasked one of his best mates, Stephen Illingsworth, to move forward to retrieve it. Within seconds Illingsworth was shot dead through the neck by a sniper. It broke his neck and severed his jugular vein. This is another of Standish’s haunting memories.
However, the most traumatic event he experienced happened not on the battlefield, but later, once Goose Green had fallen.
“When they surrendered, the Argentine prisoners got put in the sheep pens in the middle of the settlement. They had booby-trapped their own field guns. My job was to take an Argentine soldier and make the guns safe, so that we could use them if the need arose. When the Argentinian went to make the guns safe, the incendiary device blew up and in doing so blew the flesh and muscles off his legs, from the waist down. His bones were intact, his feet were still there. But you can imagine that from his waist up he was fine, from his waist down he was just bones. Because it was an incendiary, all his veins had fused so he was not bleeding. He was just kicking his bones up and down. The flesh from his legs went all over me and another Argentine prisoner nearby. We had both been standing about 10 or 15ft apart from each other when the explosion happened. He was there with all this gunk of human flesh and muscle all over him, and I was there with all this stuff over me and we had this Argentine soldier kicking his legs and asking for his mother. So we picked him up and took him to our aid post.
“I will never forget it. It was a big wooden table, because that is all we had, and all you could hear were his bones, his legs, banging on the table, tapping on the wood as he shouted for his mother. We tried to get a line in him to give him fluids. We couldn’t find his veins because his veins had retracted. So we had to get our medical officer, Steven Hughes, to cut his wrists, – it is called a cut down – and we got a line in his wrist and pumped a load of fluid into him. And I will never forget it…” And with this, Standish makes a loud rhythmic tapping noise with his knuckles on the table in front of him. Tap. Tap. Tap. Tap. Tap.
“You could hear his legs banging on the table like that, crying for his mum, his bones exposed. There was not much flesh on them at all. You can imagine a skeleton, skeleton legs and from the waist up a normal body. And we just watched him die on the table. We just couldn’t do anything. I was 21 years old.”
More fierce fighting lay ahead. 2 Para joined the Battle for Wireless Ridge, overlooking Port Stanley, a few weeks later in the dying hours of the war.
Soon they were homeward bound. Standish had eight weeks’ leave with his new bride before his battalion was posted to Belize for six months. Four years later, he was out of the army. He wanted to spend time with his newborn son.
He says this was when his problems started. Back in Bolton he joined the prison service, became a PE teacher and ran the heavy-duty cell-removals squad inside Strangeways jail in Manchester. By his own admission he was a very hard man. He seemed to settle down, until the Strangeways prison riot, when 1,000 inmates broke out of their cells. Prison officers feared for their lives as they were attacked with scaffolding poles. Some took refuge inside the cells. Standish’s flashbacks of what happened at Goose Green started a year or so later.
His first marriage fell apart under the strain. He felt responsible for Stephen Illingsworth’s death on the battlefield, he saw the face of a young soldier he had killed and he re-visited the trauma of the Argentine PoW. Standish gave up his job at Strangeways.
What happened next took him to rock bottom. His wife and children needed money, so Standish, with connections in the Bolton underworld, joined the illegal circuit of bare-knuckle fighters who travel around Britain, betting on themselves at ad hoc venues in warehouses, empty factories and barns. A couple of hundred gamblers would turn up at the fights.
He fought 19 times, won 17, drew one and got badly hammered in one. It was vicious, exhausting, brutal stuff, as rough as it can get; blood and broken noses. There was no throwing in the towel. Last man standing was the winner. He walked away with a wad of cash.
He was also a collector for a local drug dealer. Standish never sold or handled drugs, nor did he use them. He says he merely collected the money after the deals were done.
“It was a matter of putting bread on the table,” he says. “My wife and children needed money, I had to pay the bills. I was like an aggressive bailiff. I did have to get hard with a few people, ‘throat’ them up against the wall and say, ‘Look, you have got to pay, and you have got to pay now.’ ”
He hit his own brick wall in the autumn of 1993 when he was arrested for conspiracy to supply drugs. Because he had been a prison officer at Strangeways, he could not be held on remand in jail. Instead he was kept in solitary confinement in a police station in Bolton. On learning of his gallantry medal in the Falklands, some police officers took pity on him. They got him a television for his cell and regularly brought in takeaway curries. Standish went into survival mode. He worked out a fitness regime for his small cell, pacing, moving, squatting, completing circuit after circuit of this tiny space. He did 2,000 press-ups and pull-ups a day. But left alone for hours to think, the flashbacks to the Falklands became more and more frequent. Standish began to plan his suicide.
It took him eight weeks to make a rope in secret. Before his sheets were changed, he would tear a small strip from one end where there was a narrow fold. He hid the strip and then threw the sheet into a bag for collection. He gradually plaited the dozens of tiny strips together, thick enough, strong enough to hang himself. He planned to die at Christmas, after nearly three months of solitary confinement.
What stopped him was a visit by his ex-wife on Christmas Eve. She brought their two young children with her, the first time he had seen them in months. Some weeks later, Standish’s sister Rita made contact with 2 Para’s medical officer, Dr Steven Hughes, who remembered her brother well, because the two had been in the aid post at Goose Green trying to save the life of the Argentine prisoner.
Hughes visited Standish at the police station, accompanied by a psychiatrist called Dr Dafydd Jones, who ran a clinic for ex-servicemen called Ty Gwyn in Llandudno, north Wales. This was a turning point. Standish says that Dr Jones saved his life – a sentiment offered to this day by countless numbers of ex-servicemen who have come under his care.
Sentenced to three years at his trial, Standish was allowed by the Home Office to serve his sentence at Denbigh Hospital in north Wales, where Jones was the consultant psychiatrist.Standish was then taken as a day patient to Ty Gwyn, where he underwent a prolonged treatment. The clinic itself had beds for a dozen or so veterans who could not get treatment elsewhere.
Here, Standish came to terms with his demons and learnt coping mechanisms through cognitive behavioural therapy. Some of the greatest help came from the mutual aid the veterans gave each other.
Ty Gwyn stands on the outskirts of Llandudno and had always struggled for funding. Eventually Jones, who had set up a series of one-day “clinics” around Britain to help ex-servicemen suffering from PTSD, found he was fighting a losing battle to keep Ty Gwyn open. Primary care trusts would no longer fund patients at the clinic.
The building has now been sold and is being re-developed as flats.
Standish finished his sentence, picked himself up and began helping other veterans in trouble with complex PTSD. He got a job in a security company working nights and now has a day job with an environmental cleaning company, clearing asbestos sites. He and his wife, Rachel, are planning a reconciliation.
In 2003 he returned to the Falklands by himself and revisited the exact spot where his friend Stephen Illingsworth died after being sent to retrieve ammunition. He says he can live with this now. It helped to walk the battlefield and take in the enormity of what they had done.
A bigger turning point had come a year earlier. An Argentine conscript called Alejandro Videla, who had fought at Goose Green, contacted a British ex-servicemen’s website. “Most of my mates told him to piss off, but I thought this was unfair. I struck up a correspondence with him.”
They chatted about their lives and families for months. Eventually, Standish raised money to bring Alejandro Videla to England, in November 2002. Standish took him home to Bolton and they attended a remembrance service together at a local war memorial.
It was only when they began chatting in person that the two men made an astounding discovery. “He was defending their left flank at Goose Green, and I was attacking our right flank. We realised that we must have been shooting at each other.
“Then something really scary happened. Alejandro began talking about this incident when it was over, when one of his friends was injured by an exploding booby trap. He had been covered with the flesh of this man, just like me, and had seen it all. He was standing a few feet away from me, when the explosion happened. Neither of us could believe it, meeting like that, after all those years.” They had both had the same nightmare.
Major-General Julian Thompson, who commanded 3 Commando Brigade in the Falklands, is critical of veterans’ treatment: “The defence procurement minister encapsulated the government’s attitude towards the armed services when he said, ‘I do not understand the rationale behind the calls for a dedicated military hospital.’ This ignorance extends to Falklands veterans who suffer from PTSD. They fought for us and are ignored, or consigned to NHS hospitals among people who do not comprehend what they experienced or what they suffer. Not just Falklands veterans; a soldier wounded in Iraq was told to take off his uniform in an NHS hospital because it might ‘offend people’. Truly, ‘making mock of uniforms that guard you while you sleep’. Do we deserve to be guarded any more?”
The shocking truth is that PTSD is not just a potential death sentence for hundreds of ex-servicemen, but also a blight on their families. Since 2003, some 130,000 British men and women have served in Afghanistan and Iraq. Experts say that untreated PTSD cases are a time bomb ticking away in society at large
Additional research by Amy Turner
Who will save their souls?
As war-trauma victims finally cry out for help, a bureaucratic fight is brewing over who will pay for their treatment. By Melanie McFadyean
Hollybush House is a baronial manse set in rolling Ayrshire countryside. It has a welcoming atmosphere, akin to a comfortably battered country hotel. A few men sit quietly in armchairs in the lobby — veterans of wars in Northern Ireland, the Falklands, the Balkans, the Gulf, Afghanistan and Iraq.
Many talk about their traumas only to others they meet here. Jim Mitchell, now in his early fifties, was shot in the head in the Falklands and has never told his wife what he saw. Adrian Greenwood, 46, kept silent about his Falklands experiences for 23 years. Derek Stewart, 36, traumatised by the Gulf war, rarely leaves home. Glenn Miller, 55, shot in Northern Ireland, thinks he’s being followed when he goes to the shops.
A sound, a smell or a sensation can trigger flashbacks and panic attacks. Relationships break down; ex-servicemen are over-represented among the homeless and the mentally ill. Yet Combat Stress, their last refuge, struggles to keep afloat. It offers in-patient care at three centres — Hollybush House, Tyrwhitt House in Surrey, and Audley Court in Shropshire. The centres are run by ex-military staff. There are no other in-patient mental-health military facilities; the last military hospital catering for this was closed in 2004. Combat Stress is part funded by the government, but with referrals having risen by 27% over the past two years, the charity asked for extra funding.
In December 2006 the Health and Social Care Advisory Service (Hascas), an independent research charity, published a paper, commissioned by the MoD, but which they refuse to release publicly, outlining a pilot programme for “implementation of a community mental-health service for veterans”. The pilot is to run for two years and aims to shift responsibility to the NHS.
As Jim Mitchell said, “I don’t like going to civvies.The last psychiatrist I saw hadn’t a clue when you start talking blood, guts and bombs.” One Combat Stress insider, off the record, said the pilot scheme is a smoke screen. He suspects the MoD sees financial trouble ahead as veterans from Iraq and Afghanistan develop mental-health problems. Fearing a rise of costs to care for them, the MoD seeks to transfer services into the NHS, where veterans might vanish into waiting lists.
Lord Lewis Moonie was undersecretary of state at the MoD from 2000-3 and the first Minister for Veterans in the same period. He comments: “I know about the current pilot programme. I don’t agree with it. It may cost less but it won’t be as effective.”
In its 2005 report, Hascas praised Combat Stress but said it needed to expand its skills. The charity’s chief executive, Commodore Toby Elliott, said in February: “We’ve been wrangling with the MoD about funding for five years. We are being told they want us to do better — but there is this irritating little question: who will pay?” The charity asked for an extra £2m to boost the annual budget from £6m to £8m. They needed more clinical staff. With more veterans emerging from Iraq and Afghanistan, said Elliott, there would be a need to cater for “far greater casualty numbers than anticipated”. He said Combat Stress was caught in a “government department-to-department discussion, with one saying to the other, ‘You are responsible for the care of these people.’ ”
At a time when the MoD was spending £2.3 billion on new Whitehall offices, it was quibbling over £2m for those whose lives have been wrecked by wars that politicians never have to experience themselves. Finally, the MoD came through with the extra funding to be phased in over the next year. But it will not be enough. What money goes to Combat Stress from the MoD only covers those with war pensions: 60% of their clientele. The other 40% are funded solely through charity.
War pensions — which veterans have to apply for — are awarded according to severity of disablement as a result of service. It is harder to prove mental damage. The pensions are subject to review; if people show improvement, the amount can be reduced, which creates added stress. Even with a war pension, each new case that Combat Stress takes on is subject to scrutiny, and some are rejected. In April 2005, the MoD replaced war pensions with the Armed Forces Compensation Scheme. James Bond (sic), the pensions manager of the British Legion, explains that under this new scheme it is now even harder to prove mental damage: “It’s a nightmare for lots of people,” he says, “and is clearly done to reduce the number of claims settled in favour of veterans.”
Veterans at Combat Stress diagnosed prior to April 2006 are funded by the Veterans Agency of the MoD. After that, funding is the responsibility of the NHS. Commodore Toby Elliot says: “When funding is supposed to come from the NHS, that is rarely the case. You can understand why we are concerned by proposals that funding our work is transferred to the NHS.”
Those caught in this funding no-man’s-land are extremely vulnerable people, like Adrian Greenwood, a former marine. Greenwood was on HMS Glamorgan in the Falklands, two days before the Argentine surrender, when it was hit by an Exocet. He was 19. Today his shaved head is covered in scabs — the result of self-harming. He had covered up the flashbacks and nightmares symptomatic of post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) since 1982. “I never spoke to anyone about it. I thought it was cowardice. Other people think going to bed is a pleasure. To me it is pain, nightmare and sweating. I haven’t slept properly for 24 years. As soon as I shut my eyes I’m carrying my mate, gouging through bodies, hearing guns going off. If it hadn’t been for Combat Stress I’d have done myself in.”
Keron Fletcher, ex-RAF and an NHS psychiatrist in Shropshire, is a Combat Stress consultant. He admits: “These patients find it hard to engage with the NHS. With its military culture and experience, Combat Stress is a life-saving organisation.”
Dr Morgan O’Connell, a former Royal Navy surgeon, now a private consultant psychiatrist who also works with Combat Stress, says: “There is a greater need than ever for Combat Stress because of the closure of military hospitals. The NHS can’t cope. It’s already struggling with civilian patients.”
Glenn Miller was shot in the chest, shoulder and stomach by IRA snipers in 1973. He spent 18 months in hospital. He kept his PTSD secret, but the lid came off when his marriage broke down in the mid-1990s and he was finally diagnosed. “The doctor signed me off with depression; I didn’t go out for months at a time,” he says. He has spent five Christmases at Hollybush House: “All the bad things happened at Christmas. I was shot in December, divorced on Christmas Eve. If I’m at Combat Stress I’m at peace. It’s our little oasis.”
Miller is deeply troubled by those he killed. “I have shot two or three people in the course of duty. [They have] a mother, brothers, sisters, a wife and children. I felt sick, I was just 17.
The dead and wounded haunt Derek Stewart too. He joined up at 16. He drove a troop-carrier in the Gulf war. “There were bodies, people dying, bits missing, insides spilling out. One guy, the last thing he said to me was ‘Mother’, in English. It comes at me in my dreams. Then he died.”
Stewart left the army two years later. “I started drinking and getting angry. I didn’t know what was going on inside my head.” The years since the Gulf have been “hellish”, he says. He can’t sleep and says his GP doesn’t understand. In 1994 he faced an attempted murder charge after going to the defence of a stranger who had been attacked in the street. “I didn’t do time. I was sent to a psychiatrist who diagnosed PTSD. I was living with my parents. My mum didn’t know how to cope.”
Since 2003, active servicemen with trauma have been treated at The Priory, better known for treating the famous for addiction and drug abuse (daily rate: £572-£676). It has a contract with the MoD to provide all in-patient psychiatric care for personnel. The cost of services so far is £12.5m. Veterans do not qualify for Priory care.
Dr Morgan O’Connell says people coming back from Iraq are developing PTSD symptoms earlier than in past conflicts, partly because it’s such an unpopular war. “Many have been on back-to-back duty — Northern Ireland, Falklands, Kosovo, Sierra Leone, the Gulf, Afghanistan, Iraq. What I’m picking up is that they are being sent back without significant rest periods between.”
Many more leaving the forces will feel alienated, bewildered, abandoned, suicidal. There will be many casualties like Andy Julien. Like older veterans before them, they will suffer emotional torment. Combat Stress is their only hope.
The veterans
Andy Julien
Injured under friendly fire in Iraq, the 22-year-old has had 20 operations
Diagnosed with PTSD, Julien spent 18 months waiting for NHS psychiatric care. His company finally paid for counselling. The MoD has given him no help at all
Jim Mitchell
Shot in the head during the Falklands war
I don’t like going to civvies. The last psychiatrist I saw hadn’t a clue what she was talking about, when you start talking blood and guts and bombs’
Glenn Miller
Shot in the chest, shoulder and stomach by IRA snipers in Northern Ireland in 1973. Not diagnosed with PTSD until the mid-1990s
'The war comes back to me like it was yesterday. it was agony'
Derek Stewart
Gulf War veteran
'I started drinking and getting angry. I didn’t know what was going on inside my head, nobody explained it to me. There was no debriefing. The years since the Gulf have been hellish’
Adrian Greenwood
Falklands war veteran
'I never spoke to anyone about the flashbacks. I thought it was cowardice. I thought it was part of military experience. If it hadn’t been for Combat Stress I’d have done myself in’
Combat stress appeal
It costs £7m a year to run Combat Stress, the only UK charity to look after psychologically injured ex-servicemen and women and their families. To seek help, telephone 01372 841600. To make a donation to Combat Stress, visit fundraising at www.combatstress.org.uk
Explore your passion for food with the delights of Thai, Indian & Chinese cooking
In our new series, Tony Hawks takes a dry, wry look at modern life - junk mail, interminable meetings and snooty sales assistants
Read the training tips and advice that helped our London Triathletes
Read our exclusive 100 Years of Fleming and Bond interactive timeline, packed with original Times articles and reviews
The latest travel news plus the best hotels and gadgets for business travellers
Shortcuts to help you find sections and articles
2007
£30,000
2008
£44,990
2008
£48,489
Great car insurance deals online
c.£75,000
GlosFirstmeansbusiness
Gloucestershire
£32,795 - £41,545
Universitry of Southampton
Southampton
£
£32,795 - £41,545
Universitry of Southampton
Southampton
Competitive Package
Npower
West Midlands
Some of the finest Apts & Penthouses
Across London
Great Investment, River Views
Luxury properties within exclusive development in
Chislehurst Kent
A new experience in Luxury Living
Donations to Combat Stress
Having read this article I am going to send a donation to Combat Stress. If everyone who read the article sent something what a difference it could make.
I was appalled to hear that the veterans are being treated so poorly. The wounded desperately need to be treated in military hospitals by those who truly understand what they have been through. A NHS hospital is not the least suitable.
I hope that Gordon Brown is a caring, compassionate man who will make it a priority to help these brave men.
Carol Rohrbaugh, Galveston, Texas
As former RN (Joined 87) I am disgusted at the Governments treatment of our service personnel.
I've witnessed first hand the effects of PTSD and it's humbling.
Those far away from the front line have no clue about what really occurs.
Our forces put their lives on the line, not only at the time, but for years later.
It's about time that this be made high priority.
You don't need to get a badge or a medal to be a hero. Anyone who puts their life on the line to protect my country, my way of life and my family is a hero.
Shiner, Tadley, Hants
I would like to bring your attention to a radical new programme for helping British veterans overcome PTSD. You can see the effectiveness of this programme here: http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=-2945485599752677481.
There is now hope for casualties of PTSD!
Thank you
David Walters, Lincoln, UK
Good luck to Les and Rachel. Hope everything works out well.
Gillian Crook, Radcliffe, UK
There is a parliamentary defence comittee web consultation on this, accessible on the comittees web site. I found it by being told by an ex colleague!
The comittee meeting on Tuesday is viewable on parliament TV, and there is a link to the comittee consultation which has been extended.
www.parliamentlive.tv
all good stuff
Bill Glanvill, Horsham, Sussex
As one who has been battling for the interests of our veterans for 25 years I do nothing but aplaud the honest truth of this excellent article. But will anybody listen
Steven Hughes RMO 2 PARA 1882
Steven Hughes, RMO 2 PARA 1882, UK
We have an absolute duty of care to these incredibly brave men and women who were prepared to offer the ultimate sacrifice for their country, their lives. How can any Government justify descions not to maintain Military hospitals and centres that will look after our sick, wounded and ill soldiers and ex soldiers
malcolm rougvie, london, united kingdom
As an exPara & NI veteran I am disgusted with the treatment of the armed forces personnel. My family have served for generations, we deserve better.
Tony Linton, Arklow, Ireland
I think each and every Member of the Government should be put into Uniform and sent out to any of the many conflicts that they have our lads in at the moment and be made to go out on Patrol with them and actauly see what it is to walk in the shoes of the men they so eagerly send to War,mabey then they will understand what a Soldiers job entails.They should also donate some of the vast wages they give themselves to the Charities set up to help our Boys,too long have the Fighting Men of this Country been treat like dirt!!!!!
Trevor Watson, Tyne and Wear,
This graphic and frank piece is excellent writing. Every member of the cabinet should be made to read this before taking any decisions with regards to the Armed Forces and their care.
Sadly the current incumbents of government are happy to send men and women to war but discard them as soon as the job is done.
The military convenent needs to be rewritten so that forces only hospitals can be opened to care for those suffering PSTD.
I wonder whether Mr Blair will be donating a sizeable sum to Combat Stress from his lucrative US speaking tour? I won't hold my breath.
R King, Reading,
The reason the Falklands veterans (and eventually other veterans) suffer PTSD is because they are ordinary decent blokes who have been put into a situation where they have to kill 'enemy' decent blokes like themselves with whom they personally have no quarrel.
Trevor Percy, London, UK
We lost our son to suicide. He was one of the first Royal Marine Commandos to be sent to Afghanistan in 2002. His picture was on the cover of many newspapers at the time.
Erskine was the strongest, kindest, wittiest young man. He became a Marine believing them to be the best of the good guys.
I have been looking for an address to write to Michael Bilton but cannot find one. Please help me. I need to know that Erskines name is added to some list somewhere.
He had been trained the hard way to accept very harsh treatment and would never have (never did) ask for psychiatric help. His whole training was geared to accepting great mental and physical hardship.
Are there other parents out there in our position? I just don't know who to tell.
What more guilt can there be than that of a mother who did not realise her son was suffering. What worse nightmare than the image of a son hanging himself?
Elizabeth Synge, Edinburgh, Scotland
As an ex-serviceman, I am apalled to hear of the agony that these veterans have had to endure. These men have given everything for their country when asked to do so and one would expect a certain amount of care in return. Our military enjoys a huge reputation for professionalism - why then are we still not properly debriefing all combatant personnel when returning from a war zone? You would think that a mechanism might be in place, with a specialist for example, which might highlight possible PTSD cases! With our forces stretched to breaking point on active duty around the world, is it too much to ask to keep our military hospitals open for these men?
Craig Ross-Chesneau, Split, Croatia
Excellent, well written, researched and very moving article.
RM, Irvine, Scotland
Sir,
One cannot take a moral human being from civilisation & convert him into a remorseless trained killer without consequences. There is no magic switch that can make a soldier into an automaton at a single stroke. As a society we are responsible for making the transition from civilisation to barbarism, & back again easier, for the sake of our own social fabric.
We as a society need our fellow citizens, of "flesh & blood" like ourselves, to take upon themselves the ultimate sacrifice in order to defend our values. We should not fall victim to short-term jingoism, paranoia & fear-mongering, so that we engage in useless wars, abusing the undoubted loyalty of these brave men. We should put our money where our mouths are, instead of treating our brave sons & daughters as disposable cannon fodder, massaging our national egos.
SC, London, United Kingdom
The use of Armed Forces personnel in foreign wars is always controversial and its voluntary participants will subsequently question their own motives,particularly if public opinion is hostile.
As a volunteer for military conflicts , you are told to expect to see some pretty awful sights. You do not join unless there is an underlying desire to experience warfare, test yourself against it and overcome fear in its rawest state.
The Police Service are similarly confronted by horrific scenes. A police marksman does at a distance what a soldier does up close. A marksman may make a wrong decision but it isn't murder. A soldier does not have the luxury of choice.
Understanding and overcoming perceived guilt is the hardest part. World War veterans did not, by and large, express a liking for what they had to do because their their cause was, and remains, justified.
michael murphy, brightlingsea, england
we need to start buliding the systems to handle this now for all the guys and girls in combat today - this can't be allowed to happen again.
James, Ilford, Essex
Fantastic peace, its disgusting that these men have not been given the appriopriate services they need. I hope that we can learn from this example of "poor duty of care" and for them not to be repeated in conflicts present and in the future.
Robert Carr, Selsey Bill, West Sussex