David Byers
Win a trip to the Ice Hotel in Lapland

The father of a man who died when his foot got stuck in an open drain during yesterday's torrential storms has said that he would have told medics to amputate his limb to free him, but was turned away from the scene by police and learnt of his son's death on television.
Michael Barnett, whose son was one of three people who died in yesterday's downpour, spoke as fire officers desperately pumped water from a reservoir near Rotherham that was close to collapse this afternoon, placing homes at risk, and causing a section of the M1 motorway to be closed as a precaution.
More than 700 residents from close to the site of Ulley Dam, in South Yorkshire, were evacuated in the early hours of this morning, after an expert warned there was a "significant risk" the dam walls could fail after abnormally heavy rain.
Elsewhere, councils began a clean-up after more than a month's rainfall fell on large parts of the North East and Midlands in a single day. The downpour raised questions about Britain's flood defences if, as experts predict, global warming leads to more extreme "tropical" weather.
Phil Rothwell, a senior official at the Environment Agency, told Times Online that the agency itself required £150 million extra per year for the next 20 years to update and improve flood defence systems - and local councils would have to spend hundreds of millions more.
Recounting the death of his son, Mr Barnett said today that he had been turned away from the street in Hessle, near Hull, where the 28-year-old, also called Michael, was trapped and told that he would be taken to see him in hospital as soon as he was released.
Returning home just a few minutes later, the retired panel beater turned on the television to see breaking news headlines that his son had died.
"The television said 'Young man trapped in drain has died'. I just turned the telly off," he said. "I didn’t want to believe it, but I suppose I knew I had lost him."
He added: "I wish I had been allowed to help. I would have got him out. I would have done anything to save him. I wasn’t allowed to go anywhere near and now I will never see him again."
Mr Barnett added that he wanted to tell emergency crews to amputate his son's leg. "I would have said do it. Do anything," he told the Hull Daily Mail newspaper.
Firefighters battled for hours to free Michael, whose foot became wedged as he attempted to clear the overflowing drain, as water rose up to his neck. He is eventually believed to have died of hypothermia rather than drowning.
Mr Barnett, whose son was one of three people who died in the storms that drenched northern England and the Midlands, spoke as fire officers continued to pump water away from a reservoir near Rotherham that was close to collapsing this afternoon, placing people's properties and livelihoods at risk, and causing a junction of the M1 motorway to be closed as a precaution.
Industry sectors news at a glance. Interactive heatmap, video and podcast
The inside track on current trends in the charity, not for profit and social enterprise sectors
Read our exclusive 100 Years of Fleming and Bond interactive timeline, packed with original Times articles and reviews
Everything the Business Traveller needs to know to make a better trip
Shortcuts to help you find sections and articles
05/2005
£13,500
08/2008
£109,950
2005 / 55
£59,500
Great car insurance deals online
£Excellent+ executive benefits
Torres and Partners
London
£49,229 - £62,035 pro rata
Charity Commission
London/Liverpool/Taunton
Alstom Power
Europe
Six Figure
Rolls Royce
Midlands/Europe
From £89,950
Special Offers now available
At the new sophisticated
Encore Las Vegas Resort!
Cruise the Islands of Hawaii - Pride of America
List your property with two leading travel websites
Great travel insurance deals online
Contact our advertising team for advertising and sponsorship in Times Online, The Times and The Sunday Times, or place your advertisement.
Times Online Services: Dating | Jobs | Property Search | Used Cars | Holidays | Births, Marriages, Deaths
News International associated websites: Globrix | Property Finder | Milkround
Copyright 2008 Times Newspapers Ltd.
This service is provided on Times Newspapers' standard Terms and Conditions. Please read our Privacy Policy.To inquire about a licence to reproduce material from Times Online, The Times or The Sunday Times, click here.This website is published by a member of the News International Group. News International Limited, 1 Virginia St, London E98 1XY, is the holding company for the News International group and is registered in England No 81701. VAT number GB 243 8054 69.
who was in overall charge of situation? after assessing all alternative options steps should have been taken to put in place to carry out the worst case scenario ( amputation )
setting a time scale for this to be carried out should all other
possible options fail as the situation was deteriorating this should have been done 2 to 3 hours before the young man's death, I found the whole response very truamatic.
Also " Sky News " showed a news reporter on set with a water level rising on screen up her torso with heavy rain falling who's
idea was that this whilst the poor man was still trapped.
Mick Kelly, newquay, england
who was in overall charge of situation? after assessing all alternative options steps should have been taken to put in place to carry out the worst case scenario ( amputation )
setting a time scale for this to be carried out should all other
possible options fail as the situation was deteriorating this should have been done 2 to 3 hours before the young man's death, I found the whole response very truamatic.
Also " Sky News " showed a news reporter on set with a water level rising on screen up her torso with heavy rain falling who's
idea was that this whilst the poor man was still trapped.
Mick Kelly, newquay, england
Mia from Brisbane, sorry to disabuse you but I very much doubt that Michael Barrett's death was either swift or free from suffering. On the contrary, he appears to have died from hypothermia which takes quite a while and while he was concious I'll bet he was terrified. Personally, I'd swap the pain of an unanaesthetised amputation and its attendant risks for certain death any day. Bleeding to death? Not necessarily by any means. What I want to know - and if were the poor chap's dad, would be yelling from the rooftops - is why did no one take the decision to amputate? Water levels rising, guy's foot stuck, guy slipping into hypothermic coma? Amputate his foot! On the face of it, it's a no brainer. I'm very curious to know why the decision was not taken.
Ross Welford, London,
John Jordan's comment is rather thoughtless, given that people have died a a result of the flooding, and if he is watching News 24 in China tonight (UK time) he will see that hundreds in the Yorkshire area have had their homes ruined. His comment does have some relevance though; we were bombarded with Government warnings last summer regarding the low water levels in the bore holes of the South East.....has anyone heard an update since? Let's get some balance here through the media, because if there's one good thing that can come out of this excessive rainfall it must surely be that long depleted bore holes MUST be getting topped up. Can anyone out there comment with some authority on this?
Al, Buxton, UK
Not taking anything away from the tragedies caused in this flooding, let us not forget that Countries such as Bangladesh live with this type of flooding on many, many occasions ,sometimes daily for months . Perhaps it should make us a little more sympathetic to them as they must have a lot of endurance to live like it, as people of Sheffield will now know. Men,women and children live in stinking conditions in Bangladesh with the added "bonus" of these types of flood on regular basis.
Sergei, London, UK
How heartbreaking it must be for the father. Thank God that your son did not die from drowning. You can take comfort that he did not suffer too much and death was swift. I think that amputation would not have saved him as he would have bled to death and the pain would be unbearable. Somethimes we cant understand some tragedies, but as a father you are commended that your love for your son and would I'm sure exchanged places with him. Let your heavenly Father console you at this very sad time.
mia, Brisbane, Australia
I would like to pay tribute to 13 year old Ryan Parry,who tragically lost his life in the floods.Very like my own son both in age and appearance,lads this age in my view are curious and at the point where they love adventure.
Tragically through no fault of his own Ryan weas taken into the river and lost his life.
RIP son you will be missed
terry, sheffield, south yorks
There is not a power station in the way of any water from bursting of the Ulley dam. I live 2 miles from Ulley, and would have noticed any power station there sometime during the last 30 years.
Please refer to BBC website for the accurate story of the power lines serving Sheffield that are at risk if two pylons are overturned by the floodwaters.
If the Times can't get the details right what hope have we?
Jim Easby, Rotherham, UK
I think the lack of government led mobilisation of rescue teams and support for the northern areas is disgusting. If the thames had flooded in the same way as the river Don I am sure we would be hearing nothing but stories about a crisis and emergency !
This confirms my perception that the booming modern Britain preception provided by the government actually stops at watford. Go further north and you will still see poor housing, ageing industry and unacceptable living standards, while in the south the perception is of a wealthy modernised Britain.
The fact no one seems to raise this issue is a bit like the king with his new clothes, the spin provided by labour has been succesfull in blinkering people's vews if the reality.
peter jackson, london,
Tragic news of that poor man Michael. Sympathies to his family. How about the Government spending the millions on prevention rather than clean-up? Just a thought.
Max D-G, New York, USA
I also saw a tornado on Sunday afternoon, about 4.30pm, above Knowsley near Liverpool. It was high up, so not touching the ground, but was very distinctive. Unfortunately I was driving at the time so could not stop to take a photo.
Duncan Morgan, Macclesfield, UK
It's interesting that when someone is killed in such tragic circumtances all we can think about is jokes about not needing hosepipe bans and our gripes and moans. Let's get real, a man has given his life trying to help others show some respect.
Paul Smith, King's Lynn,
A man has lost his son in heart breaking circumstances. The personal tragedy is bad enough but disaster on a far wider scale awaits the earth and you make crass flippant remarks about hose pipe bans and football teams. Am I missing something? Heaven help us.
Peter Wilson, Bridgnorth,
Ignoring the fact that it was foolish to enter a storm drain during a flood, this poor lad deserved better rescuers. There must have been a better way.
Tim C, Isle of Wight,
Andy Barnes, someone´s lost their son. Is it appropriate to make jokes about the subs in Sheffield Wednesday? Let´s hope you don´t have to go through that situation. How painful, is football the only thing you can think about? What a lack of humanity.
Fiona Shelton , Madrid, Spain
how sad is it that not one of you has tribute to the three lives that have been lost during this terrible time and i especaily dont think the comment john jordan made was approbate seeing as hundreds of people lives have been devasted by this flooding a house pan pipe comment is the last thing on peoples minds! and this is coming from a 19yr old girl!
annoyed, britain,
"Thay tell you thay are doing
everything to stop Global warming,its time thay
though about the British People for once."
Has it ever crossed your mind that stopping climate change may do exactly that? Obviously not. Britain is part of "global", in case you hadn't noticed. It may be that GW/CC is causing this kind of freak weather. Wouldn't stopping it help the British people?
As the Dutch say "please look further than your nose is long" (or as your island is big, in this case).
starling, Lancaster,
I think Sheffield Wednesday's manager had better bring the subs on...
Andy Barnes, Reading, Berkshire
Of course the upside to all of this,is that the folks "up north" shouldn't get a hosepipe ban next month!
John Jordan, chengdu, china
The government is sending more and more of our tax payers money into areas that many of us will never see. Lets sort out our own country first!!!
miles, London,
It makes me think why the Goverment & Local
Councils dont get together to help stop this
sort of thing. Thay tell you thay are doing
everything to stop Global warming,its time thay
though about the British People for once.
Mr B Hughes, Blackpool Lancs, England