Valerie Elliott, Countryside Editor
Win a trip to the Ice Hotel in Lapland

The image of the country vet, accompanied by his dog, driving up hill and down dale to reach outlying farms was made famous by James Herriot in All Creatures Great and Small.
But under a new edict government vets, responsible for the protection of millions of farm animals, will no longer be free to take their pets with them.
Animal Health, the agency responsible for the state veterinary service, has banned vets and other staff from taking their dogs in cars on visits to farms or other premises when on official business. It is also to extend the ruling to another 2,000 private vets for work carried out under contract to the Government.
The diktat was introduced after a member of the public complained about a dog locked inside an employee’s car at an agency car park on a hot day. The employee was not a vet or anyone trained for animal health work but senior agency staff were concerned that the practice of allowing dogs on duty risked the possibility of a prosecution and also compromised bio-security on farms.
Vets across the country are outraged by the new working conditions, which took effect last week. It is still fairly common in rural Britain for a dog to accompany the vet in the car on rounds.
The James Herriot books and television series were based on the life of Alf Wight, a vet for more than 50 years in Thirsk, North Yorkshire. He wrote about being accompanied on his rounds by a series of dogs, from Danny, a white Highland cross-bred terrier, to Dinah, a beagle, Hector, a Jack Russell, Bodie, a border terrier, and Dan, a black labrador.
Vets often exercise their dogs for 15 minutes or so while out and about in the countryside. But dogs are kept inside the car on farm visits to prevent spread of disease.
Teresa Exell, a state vet for 11 years who visits farms in Leicestershire and Northamptonshire, is always accompanied by Muffin, her trusted Jack Russell-poodle cross. “It’s security and companionship while I’m visiting on my own. Muffin is part of my life. It would be heart-wrenching to leave her pining at home all day — it would seem as if I was punishing her.”
She is finding it difficult to make alternative arrangements. “It’s not like finding childcare. I don’t know what I’m going to do.”
It is understood that at least three vets might have to resign and that others have asked to work part-time. One has only recently bought a puppy and would never have done so if he had been given more warning of the new ruling. Staff were told in June.
Prospect, the white-collar union that represents state vets and animal health employees, is urging the agency to think again. Catherine Donaldson, vice-president, said: “This edict is ridiculous. Vets are trusted for the health of the national flock and the national herd yet they are now not trusted to look after their own dogs. These people know when not to take a dog and know how to look after their animals.”
Jim Wight, son of Alf and also a vet, said: “This is another attack on rural life. My father didn’t go anywhere without his dog. It can be very lonely for a vet travelling all over the place in the countryside. Now my father never let the dogs out on a farm, and that is right, but this ban is ludicrous.”
Iain Richards, junior vice-president of the Society of Practising Veterinary Surgeons, and a vet for 20 years in Kendal, Cumbria, said that the ruling was “extraordinary”. He often takes Rosie, an 11-year-old flat-coated retriever, to work. “There are ten of us at our practice and eight regularly bring dogs, except if you are going for a long visit to a farm or if it is a screamingly hot day,” he said.
“I can see the Government don’t want the finger pointed at them for poor animal welfare or for bio-security reasons. But they have tackled this with crass idiocy. A sensible option would have been to remind vets and staff to keep dogs in the car when they visit farms.”
An Animal Health spokesman confirmed yesterday that staff could no longer take dogs in their cars on “official business”. He said that the change had been introduced after the public and staff raised concerns about the welfare or pets being left in cars.
David Catlow, president of the British Veterinary Association, backs the move. He accepted that the decision would not be popular with all vets but said: “There is a bio-security issue and the vet does not want to be blamed for bringing disease to a farm.”
Faithful companion
“I wasn’t really alone. There was Sam and he made all the difference . . . He
would be about two years old when I first saw him and I had no way of
knowing that he was to be my faithful companion, my car dog, my friend who
sat by my side through the lonely hours of driving till his life ended at
fourteen. He was the first of a series of cherished dogs whose comradeship
has warmed and lightened my working life”
Vet in Harness
Industry sectors news at a glance. Interactive heatmap, video and podcast
The inside track on current trends in the charity, not for profit and social enterprise sectors
Read our exclusive 100 Years of Fleming and Bond interactive timeline, packed with original Times articles and reviews
Everything the Business Traveller needs to know to make a better trip
Shortcuts to help you find sections and articles
05/2005
£13,500
08/2008
£109,950
2005 / 55
£59,500
Great car insurance deals online
£Excellent+ executive benefits
Torres and Partners
London
£49,229 - £62,035 pro rata
Charity Commission
London/Liverpool/Taunton
Alstom Power
Europe
Six Figure
Rolls Royce
Midlands/Europe
From £89,950
Special Offers now available
At the new sophisticated
Encore Las Vegas Resort!
Cruise the Islands of Hawaii - Pride of America
List your property with two leading travel websites
Great travel insurance deals online
Contact our advertising team for advertising and sponsorship in Times Online, The Times and The Sunday Times, or place your advertisement.
Times Online Services: Dating | Jobs | Property Search | Used Cars | Holidays | Births, Marriages, Deaths
News International associated websites: Globrix | Property Finder | Milkround
Copyright 2008 Times Newspapers Ltd.
This service is provided on Times Newspapers' standard Terms and Conditions. Please read our Privacy Policy.To inquire about a licence to reproduce material from Times Online, The Times or The Sunday Times, click here.This website is published by a member of the News International Group. News International Limited, 1 Virginia St, London E98 1XY, is the holding company for the News International group and is registered in England No 81701. VAT number GB 243 8054 69.
It is both maddening and somehow comforting to know that no matter where you live, governments are crazy.
T.L. Kay, Dunsmuir, California, US
Iâm curious to know which parts of the civil service Mike Medina would like to see trimmed down? Government vets perhaps, as they are among the numerous professional and specialist civil servants on which the country relies.
Yet it is these specialist skills which are being lost to government by the application of policies driven by cash savings instead of quality of service, fuelled in part by the mistaken belief that civil servants are bowler-hatted desk-bound bureaucrats.
Drop the clichés and recognise that todayâs civil service relies on physicists, chemists, engineers, electronic experts, veterinary staff, environmentalists and other important specialisms.
Katherine Beirne, London,
I have reservations concerning pets in vehicles, not least from the consequences of a loose object within a vehicle when involved in an accident. This ban however impinges on the right of the individual in what can be considered their own environment, the interior of their own vehicle. Providing the presence of a companion animal does not constitute a hazard to the safety of that vehicle, the welfare of that animal is not compromised and biosecurity is maintained then this ban can be demonstrated as a typical 'knee jerk' reaction to an isolated incident.
denzil, tiverton,
Chantel UK, said it - "jobsworths" - but don't blame this particular government even if you despise it(as I do). Blame the countless little creeps securing their public service index-linked pensions by producing important directives; I had understood that the civil service was going to be trimmed down - what a hope!
Watch out all you people, they're coming for you even if you're not a social Pariah like me (a smoker).
To government vets, I say unite and tell them you'll all resign, and to present non-government vets, tell them you're not interested under the new ruling.
We could run a contest now to predict what is going to be banned next - last year two glasses of red wine a day were good for your heart, this week your heart may be OK but you are going to die of cancer instead.
Dogs have been described as "man's best friend" rightly - they notice things we are unable to, even maybe the smell of a disease - the Civil Service.
Mike Medina, St. Albans, England
This ban is very sensible. Surely vets, of all people, should be setting an example to the large number of people who seem to believe it fine to take pets to work and then leave them in the car all day, except for the odd walk. One would very rarely take a child to work, making alternative arangements for them. Therefore, owners should do the same for their pets. Many people do not appear to think about whether they have a suitable lifestyle, for looking after a pet, before obtaining one.
Michael, Templecombe, UK
Children spread a lot more germs than dogs. Should they be left at home too?
Tina, read 'The Machine Stops' by E. M. Forster. In it he predicts the hideous state of societies taken over by the state in a prophetic work which I notice coming to pass more and more in Britain and the US.
A Fairfax, Veliko Turnovo, Bulgaria
What's next? I thought the UK really had a love of their animals... this is absurd. To much government means less of your freedoms, Wake up!
caw Sarasota, Fl
Catherine, Sarasota, Florida
I cant take my cat to work with me so why should they be allowed to take their dogs? Having said that I work in a Chinese Restaurant so I've always preferred to leave him at home.
Rod Munch, Northampton, UK
Yet more lunacy. In the end, no-one will be allowed out of their own homes, nor will they be allowed to do anything more than press government-approved buttons so that sterilised food will appear out of a chute in their residential cube. Mustn't move - you might have an accident. Mustn't have anything like a living organism near you - might get ill.
To me, it sounds like something Ray Bradbury might have written.
Tina, Düsseldorf, Germany
What are they going to do if the vets simply ignore the new rule? Sack them? What would a tribunal say to that? Is it a human right to keep a dog in your car? Prepare for expensive litigation and another pay day for the lawyers. This can only apply to vets in the public service, and most vets are self-employed, so one rule for some and another for the others. Rules which are silly and unenforceable simply bring the whole system into disrepute.
Alexandria, Sheffield, UK
Absolute stupidity. If for no other reason than that the recent right to roam legislation allows anybody to take one dog wherever they walk, including over most farms.
Peter, Newbury, UK
Is there a secret government department that looks for subjects to make stupid rulings about? As one of the quotes says, if you can't trust the vets, who can you trust?
And what about tradesmen visisting farms and other farmers? Rural life is full of people who are accompanied by their dogs.
Duncan, London,
Well well,
how much more craziness can a country take from meddling half wits?
Our hospitals are being choked with immigrants flooding into this country with a whole host of deseases (recent survey showed 7 out of 10 new AIDS cases are immigrants), but it seems to be more important to stop vets taking their dogs to work because of "Bio Security"!!!!!!
Lets start getting our priorities right please, and stop infringing the few freedoms the indiginous population has please.
Pete, St Albans,
It's how this ludicrous government works. and, to be fair, it fools people into voting for them. Someone was cruel to a doggy. The govenrment has done something. Let us all bow dowen to , and vote for, such a caring governemt.
The reaality is that they have achieved nothing but have diverted attention from all the things they haven't done (fixed the NHS and flood defences to name but two).
Morons will vote for them because they have looked after our dumb friends.
Roger Tilbury, Worthing, England
The French ignore laws they disagree with. Our vets should do likewise.
Sophie, norwich, norfolk
As usual, our Nanny-State Government gives thoughtless edicts from above; they feel any reaction is better than none when some bureaucrat does a risk assessment from their insulated little office in Whitehall!
I sincerely hope that Vets ignore this stupid ban and send the message that bureaucrats do not have the right to erode our way of life for no good reason.
John Robinson, Thetford, UK
How typical of jobsworths in the UK: Simply because they lack common sense and the ability to think and reason, they think the rest of us do!
A bit like the female council worker that was trying to tell Buddhists they should be offended by a restaurant called: The Fat Buddha (opened by a Buddhist). Did she hand her brain in at the door...? Surely, Buddhists know enough about their own religion to know what should offend them and surely VETS know enough about dogs to know how to care for them?
Chantel, UK,
Yet another example of the over zealous political correctness that is becoming more common in the UK.
Rural life seems to becoming more and more under attack from politicians and civil servants in London who have no idea how rural life works...vets without dogs just doesn't make sense!
Please someone have some common sense and stop this nonsense!
Jason Marr, Basingstoke,
Boo-hoo sentimentalising paper-pushers should be sent down to do some pro bono work. for a week with a country vet to see how the real carers for animals go about their work. This ruling comes from the government who abolished the motorway foot and mouth inspectors, torched thousands of sheep and cattle, and destroyed unique lines. Splash their hands with red paint this time.
rsb, Zhuhai, Guangdong, China
This does seem rather like an over-the-top, knee-jerk reaction to a complaint, which was in fact nothing to do with the veterinary service. Immediate withdrawal of the order and thorough consultation with vets and their representatives is surely called for.
akai ringo, Tokyo,