Will Pavia
Win a trip to the Ice Hotel in Lapland
The second farmer to fall victim to the foot-and-mouth outbreak wept yesterday as he told how his business had been wiped out after his cattle contracted the disease.
John Gunner, 60, said that his herd of Charollais and Sussex cows, which were grazing on three separate sites, have had to be slaughtered after he noticed signs of the infection in his animals on Monday.
He disclosed that they had been given a clean bill of health only a day before by vets but some then began dribbling from the mouth and limping.
Mr Gunner rented 300 acres around Willey Green, near Guildford, Surrey, just a few miles from the first infected farm at Normandy, owned by the Pride family.
Speaking at his semi-detached home in the village of Wood Street, where he lives with his wife, Joy, he said: “It is a terrible disaster and I just hope no one else goes through this. It has wiped us out. It is our only income and I am just devastated. I will try and recover but it will be difficult.”
Mr Gunner said that he was concerned when news broke last Friday that foot-and-mouth had been discovered at the Pride family farm and said he checked his herd every three hours.
The family also took it upon themselves to block off all the footpaths, seal off the farm and put down disinfectant. He added: “We did everything we could. We phoned and spoke to someone at Defra and they came on Sunday and gave the cattle the all-clear. They gave them a thorough examination and I thought everything was going to be OK and it would bypass us.”
Mr Gunner said that he checked the cattle again on Monday morning at all three of his sites and all seemed fine but by lunchtime he sensed that something was not quite right.
He said: “One was limping and another was dribbling at the mouth. We got back in touch with the veterinary people and they returned.
“By this point my old bull, Ned, wasn’t very well. He was like a pet and was about eight years old. He had great pedigree and was so gentle I could put my arms around him and he would have stayed with me all his life. In the short time I was there he collapsed in front of my eyes. The vet said he feared the worst. We were there and everything was going wrong in front of us. It was just so fast.”
Mr Gunner said he had no idea how the infection could have spread to his land because the cows had not been moved for seven months and since the outbreak neither he or his son Stephen had left the exclusion zone. However, he did reveal that the stream running through the Prides’ grazing field also goes through his land.
Mr Gunner said that the Defra vet asked him if he would be prepared to cull his herd before foot-and-mouth had been confirmed and he told them, “You have got to do your job.” He said: “It was a foregone conclusion — it would have been unfair to keep them alive.”
When asked what he would feel if the disease was found to have spread from the laboratory site at Pirbright, Mr Gunner said: “I would feel annoyed that people who are dealing with such dangerous diseases are so irresponsible. I know that it is a necessity but there should be strict controls and it should not have been allowed to get out. Everything must be shut down because I don’t want another family to go through what we have had to go through.”
Mr Gunner said his son Stephen, 30, had quit the Army where he had been fighting in Iraq to help at the farm with a view to taking it over when his father retired. He did not know if there would be a farm left to run.
Stephen said: “I want to continue farming but we don’t yet know what will happen.” He said he was shocked at the transformation in the herd of just over 100 animals. “They were all going skinny in front of our eyes. It was that fast. They were stumbling and falling over and drooling.”
The culling of the family’s animals began on Monday evening.

Shoppers can expect to see a shortage of British meat by the weekend because of the outbreak of foot-and-mouth disease, retailers said yesterday (Rajeev Syal writes).
British pork, lamb and beef will begin to run out as restrictions on the movement of animals take effect. Consequently, supermarkets are seeking alternative suppliers, industry officials said.
A British Retail Consortium spokesman said that stores may have to import pork and lamb within days. “The longer that suppliers are unable to move livestock, the more likely it becomes that our members will look for ways to fulfil any shortfall. It would mean looking for sources of meat from outside the UK.”
Industry sectors news at a glance. Interactive heatmap, video and podcast
The inside track on current trends in the charity, not for profit and social enterprise sectors
Read our exclusive 100 Years of Fleming and Bond interactive timeline, packed with original Times articles and reviews
Everything the Business Traveller needs to know to make a better trip
Shortcuts to help you find sections and articles
05/2005
£13,500
08/2008
£109,950
2005 / 55
£59,500
Great car insurance deals online
£Excellent+ executive benefits
Torres and Partners
London
£49,229 - £62,035 pro rata
Charity Commission
London/Liverpool/Taunton
Alstom Power
Europe
Six Figure
Rolls Royce
Midlands/Europe
From £89,950
Special Offers now available
At the new sophisticated
Encore Las Vegas Resort!
Cruise the Islands of Hawaii - Pride of America
List your property with two leading travel websites
Great travel insurance deals online
Contact our advertising team for advertising and sponsorship in Times Online, The Times and The Sunday Times, or place your advertisement.
Times Online Services: Dating | Jobs | Property Search | Used Cars | Holidays | Births, Marriages, Deaths
News International associated websites: Globrix | Property Finder | Milkround
Copyright 2008 Times Newspapers Ltd.
This service is provided on Times Newspapers' standard Terms and Conditions. Please read our Privacy Policy.To inquire about a licence to reproduce material from Times Online, The Times or The Sunday Times, click here.This website is published by a member of the News International Group. News International Limited, 1 Virginia St, London E98 1XY, is the holding company for the News International group and is registered in England No 81701. VAT number GB 243 8054 69.
I am so sorry for the losses your farmers are going through. If anyone reading this, knows Mr. Gunner, please let him know we care about him.
Barbara, Catlettsburg, usa, Ky
I don't know whether or not the foot-and-mouth could have been released from the Pirbright lab site, but I do know this ... it had to come from somewhere.
If Mr. Gunner took all the precautions he says were taken, the authorities need to check both the stream he shares with the Prides' farm. I don't know about the survivability of the disease when released from a host, but I'm quite certain the agricultural authorities know all there is to know about such things.
One thing I can say for certain, the Pirbright lab site should be gone over from roof to cellar and all points in between. And lest we forget, what about the drainage ... or vehicles leaving the facilities?
It's a tragic situation. Considering the way this disease is pushing its way through the countryside, one wonders just how much effort the authorities are putting forth. There's far too little in the way of action and far too much in the way of reaction.
Allen Curry, Ypsilanti, Michigan, USA
Me too. I watched him cry and thought this just is so unfair. I want to help. He shouldn't have to lose his livelihood like this
Angela Elliott, London, UK
I agree with Trish, is there a fund people can give money to help out the affected farmers?
Brian, Bristol,
I would like to send Mr. John Gunner in Wood Green, Surrey some money. How would I go about doing this please?
Reading his story brought tears to my eyes.
Thanks
Trish, Northridge, Los Angeles, California
Do many folks reading all this awful,AWFUL 'stuff' have any REAL idea of just HOW emotionally attached suppposedly 'hard-bitten' farming men (& 'their' women!) can become to their, albeit, lumbering, clumsy & dung-spattered herds, I wonder? I was a cowman years ago in Devon; we all made lots of gruff & macho noises about our 'charges', but deep down we loved 'em like CHILDREN, & FEW people realise the innner ANGUISH of the farmer where the ultimate fate of their beasts is concerned, & they'll NEVER tell you, coz. Farmers, as a 'breed' don't & WON'T wear their hearts on their sleeves. (Unlike the new breed of.'BritWimps' who burst into tears at Big Brother, 'Corrie', 'EE' & suchlike utter INANE DRIVEL.)
My heart BLEEDS (& so SHOULD YOURS) for these folk who've been so woefully smitten with yet ANOTHER outbreak of this HORRIBLE curse upon our "SILENT MINORITY"~ cattle & farmers alike. ANYONE with a HEART should support them BIG-TIME from now on. I vote we recognise their DIRE plight.
Richard Neville, Helston, Cornwall UK
Why did the government and DEFRA have to transport infected carcases to Somerset for incineration. This indicates the total ineptitude of both and the fact that no lessons have been learned since the last outbreak.
When the next case (God forbid) is diagnosed along the M4/M5 corridor, who will then admit liability.
I had thought initially that the response was rapid but the idiocy which has followed is beyond belief.
Martin Pengelly, Peterborough,
My heart goes out to all the farmers and their families involved, especially those that have had their herds culled out. Mr Gunner is obviously a very compassionate man and took his animals' best interests into consideration. I hope he will continue with farming - I support our farmers, and always buy British from our Farmers markets. I would also like to say that, if confirmed that the Merial site is at fault here - they should be closed down and ordered to pay 'considerable' compensation to all involved (especially the FARMERS who have lost stock). Finally, maybe it is time to consider moving all research sites of this kind to areas where no livestock live.
T Brown, Cambridgeshire, England
If all this turns out to be the fault of the local government laboratory
or it's integral animal welfare company *and* if there is no official cover up I sincerely hope that the farmers who have lost their stock are fully and entirely compensated for not only their loss but for the trauma and distress this has caused them and their families. If as I fear the relevant government department fails to hold up it's hand and admit fault then I sincerely hope that some fair minded solicitor offers to represent these farmers and get the truth thrashed out.
Jeffers, Maidstone, UK