Richard Johnson
Download 'Too Hot', an exclusive Specials track from iTunes
Don’t tell Mike Chappell he lives in “the Southwest”. He lives in Cornwall. That’s not “Devon and Cornwall” – as in the Devon and Cornwall Police Authority, the Devon and Cornwall Probation Area, or the Devon and Cornwall Caravan Club – just Cornwall. Devon doesn’t come before Cornwall in the alphabet, for crying out loud. When Cornwall qualified for a subsidy from the EU, it was administered by the South West of England Regional Development Agency. In Devon. Then it went and charged Cornwall for the privilege. It makes a proud Cornishman like Chappell spit.
He’s stuck in tourist traffic on the A30, telling me – in detail – that he carries the MC1R, or “Celtic”, gene. And that he can trace his ancestry back to the bloody warriors who came to Britain when it was still joined to mainland Europe. Being Cornish and Celtic is, to Chappell, about more than wearing a kilt and supporting France when they play England at rugby. It’s about a sense of separateness. As his T-shirt says, “Cornwall is next to England – just like Wales”. Which is why Chappell wants independence.
He’s still behind a caravan. And he’s late for his open meeting in Redruth on “Cornishness”. People have become more interested in Cornishness since last June, when a terrorist organisation called the Cornish National Liberation Army (CNLA) sent an e-mail threatening the celebrity chefs Rick Stein and Jamie Oliver. The e-mail, entitled “directive number one”, said the incomers – and their restaurants’ customers – were legitimate targets in the CNLA’s campaign to remove the “imperialist English flag of St George” from Cornwall. It was followed by a fire at the Redruth brewery. In another e-mail, sent via an Arabic web-hosting service based in Egypt, the CNLA claimed they were testing incendiary devices in “an urban environment”. If, indeed, Redruth constitutes “an urban environment”. But the whole business has put Chappell in a tricky position. As a former policeman, he’s a great respecter of authority, and he doesn’t want to prejudice the pension. But he’s no fool. The CNLA is attracting a lot more press attention than his open meetings on Cornishness.
Press attention isn’t always good. “The IRA?” asked the headline of one tabloid. “No – the Ooh-Arrr-A.” The article ridiculed the Cornish for not being able to run a proper terrorist organisation, and gave instructions on how to distinguish the CNLA from the IRA, Eta and Al-Qaeda. A member of the CNLA would, according to the article, smell of scrumpy, and start any conversation with: “Yer not from roun’ these parts, are yerrrr?” According to Chappell, it’s typical of the racism he encounters every day.
As the traffic slows to a halt, Chappell pulls out a letter he wrote to the Commission for Racial Equality (CRE) on behalf of a bus driver who had heard someone calling the Cornish “a bunch of pissed-off, straw-sucking, inbred wurzels”. But the CRE wouldn’t help. What with the Cornish not being a “race” and all. Some have suggested reclaiming “the W-word” for the Cornish, the way the Afro-Americans reclaimed “the N-word” – as in “Yo, Wurzel, what’s up?” But not Chappell. He doesn’t see the funny side at all.
And nor, it seems, do the Devon and Cornwall police. Since the CNLA’s threats, they have pulled in a significant number of suspects for questioning. They have to be seen to take threats of terrorism seriously. After all, the CNLA’s e-mails have claimed they are receiving “substantial” funding from pressure groups in the US, and practical advice from a group responsible for the arson campaign on holiday homes in Wales.
Hugh Rowe, a member of the Cornish Stannary parliament – the original governing body of Cornwall’s tin-mining community – was taken into custody on suspicion of the illegal possession of a firearm. All because the CNLA talked about having Fifteen Cornwall – Jamie Oliver’s restaurant in Watergate Bay – “in their sights”. As a “stannator”, Rowe is regularly involved in “tackling English cultural aggression in Cornwall”, which can include removing English Heritage signs from tourist destinations. But that involves bolt-cutters. Not a sawn-off shotgun.
The police pulled apart his Camborne home and left with a balaclava (“which I use for fishing or when I’m out with the pigeons,” says Rowe), three flags of St Piran and a book on the commissioning of the twin towers in New York. “I got it in an antique shop in Camborne for £2.” Rowe was released without charge, but the case is still being investigated. He insists his phone is being tapped. “I think the raid was ordered by central government,” he says.
Dave Eddy, a labourer from Padstow, was taken into custody after allegedly making a threatening call to Fifteen Cornwall, demanding to know how many Cornish people worked there. Eddy told the Western Morning News that, while he is happy to be called a Cornish nationalist, he doesn’t condone violence. And he emphatically denied being a member of the CNLA.
The Cornish do have a history of insurgency. In 1980, An Gof – a terrorist organisation named after Michael An Gof, a leader of the Cornish rebellion of 1497 – claimed responsibility for an explosion at a court in St Austell. And, later, for a fire at a hairdresser’s in Penzance, which An Gof allegedly thought was a branch of the Bristol & West. Monopoly capital and all that. An Gof has now, supposedly, changed its name to CNLA. But the CNLA aren’t the only little nationalists looking to devolve from modern Britain. In the Lake District, the self-styled Popular Liberation Army of Westmorland claims it has begun a campaign of arson against holiday homes. In a letter to the press it pledged: “We will one day see an end to the occupation of Westmorland by newcomers, holiday-home owners and the encroaching leech-like scum of that ilk.”
Historically, Cornwall has more right to its independence than Westmorland. The 14th-century Mappa Mundi defines Britain as “Scotia, Wallia, Anglia et Cornubia”. And as late as 1543 it was written that “Britain is divided into four parts, whereof the one is inhabited by Englishmen, the other of Scots, the third of Welshmen and the fourth of Cornish people” (Polydore Vergil, cited by Payton, 1992, 57). Historically, Cornwall is a duchy. Not a county. And it never “officially” became part of England. So it’s distinct from England, but not officially or constitutionally recognised by it. An anomaly.
To those of us in Scotia, Wallia and Anglia, Cornwall is a state of mind – where life passes by a little more slowly, and a little more sunnily, than anywhere else. Every year, 5m people go there on holiday and spend over £1.5 billion in the process. Everyone wants to live there (or own a second house there), according to a recent survey of second-homers, which is why prices are so high. But there’s another story, one that the tourist board likes to keep to itself.
Win a luxury weekend to Newcastle and its neighbour Gateshead, find out more here
Risk, resilience and embracing new technology
Industry sectors news at a glance. Interactive heatmap, video and podcast
Discover the power of collective thinking. Submit a solution and be in with a chance to win a Media Hub Home Entertainment System
The inside track on current trends in the charity, not for profit and social enterprise sectors
Everything the Business Traveller needs to know to make a better trip
Make the most of the summer and enter our fabulous photographic competition, you could win a £5000 holiday
Corsica is an island of beauty and contrast, an ideal holiday destination
Enjoy further reading from Travel to Fashion, Business to Sport, discover more
Shortcuts to help you find sections and articles
The clever way to lease a new car is with Car leasing made simple™
2009
per month on 36-month
Personal Contract Hire (PCH)
2008
42850
Car Insurance
£24,250 - £30,346
MI5
London
£60,000
The Environment Agency
Bristol
Up to £90K
Boots
Midlands
OTE £85k
Credit Protection Association
Nationwide Opportunities
Completely London
Luxury Condo's in Manhattan with NYC views
The best new homes in Wimbledon?
Nationwide
Fabulous Cruise And Cruise & Stay Offers Including Virgin Atlantic Flights Prices Start From Only £699pp!
Last Minute Cruise And Cruise & Stay Offers. Med From £499pp, Caribbean From £699pp!
5 star quality at a 3 star price.
8 fabulous Canadian cities ...you won’t find cheaper
Contact our advertising team for advertising and sponsorship in Times Online, The Times and The Sunday Times, or place your advertisement.
Times Online Services: Dating | Jobs | Property Search | Used Cars | Holidays | Births, Marriages, Deaths | Subscriptions | E-paper
News International associated websites: Globrix Property Search | Property Finder | Milkround
Copyright 2009 Times Newspapers Ltd.
This service is provided on Times Newspapers' standard Terms and Conditions. Please read our Privacy Policy.To inquire about a licence to reproduce material from Times Online, The Times or The Sunday Times, click here.This website is published by a member of the News International Group. News International Limited, 1 Virginia St, London E98 1XY, is the holding company for the News International group and is registered in England No 81701. VAT number GB 243 8054 69.
Cornwall can never become independant until it can pay its own way, and stand on its own two feet. At the moment the only way it gets by is on the back of tourists and hand outs from Europe. When that cash dries up, what do the Cornish intend to live on then?
Independence means not being dependent, Cornwall is the most dependent county in England.
Raymond Bathurst, Plymouth, England
I would like to point out, as a student of journalism that you should always check your facts. I read... "Cornwall does not have a city or a university."
Actually, Cornwall does have a city, the city of Truro, home to a rather striking cathedral. Also the University of Falmouth, with two campuses and one of the best English degrees in the country. (That's country not county.) Truro college and Cambourne college also combine university degrees.
Carly Klineberg, Portreath, England
It is interesting to note that many assume that autonomy would mean that tourists would no longer be welcomed. Quite the contrary. Smaller nations than Cornwall do rather well for themselves, some of them former colonies eg Malta. They have never looked back but welcome tourists. Other nations smaller than Cornwall also do well, Luxembourg, Andorra and so on. Why do countries need to be big ? I also think the Cornish people are very outward looking and embrace Europe readily.
Mike, Redruth, Kernow
Clearly violence is not the way to go, but it must be born from frustration at being ignored and not listened to.
We who have been visiting cornwall from childhood have always known the cornish feeling, but ignored it and proceeded to seek a fortune and a second home without realising that it is local farmers and so called " wurzels" that keep it beautiful for us to visit.
If it were not for " wurzels" then cornwall would have large desolute fields as in England. Ignorance and "wurzels" are not confined just to cornwall, you only have to stop off at Jamica Inn to see that during the start of the holidays.
Democracy is what we are supposed to respect, so why not give the permanent cornish residents the right to vote on it.
Surely we should respect individualism and identity as they are the cornerstone of this united nation and makes it a Great Britian.
Cornwall is leading the way in restoring a philosophy of artisan, organic and job production that this country needs.
Ashley , Nottingham, UK
What do these Cornish nonentities want? Self-rule? I would advise them to get rid of useless Charles Windsor first.He is stealing millions from then to bankroll Camilla and his ridiculous extravagant lifestyle..Bur could they really live on the income from the Duchy and tourism?.What have they actually got that would make them a world leader rather than a backwater? As for Rick Stein,I believe his family has had property there for many years.Why single him out when he has obviously contributed to the local economy.
Jan, London, England
From the article: "... has no city or university."
I'd like to point the author to the cathedral that stands in the middle of Truro and to the Combined University of Cornwall.
While I, as a Cornishman, approve of the attention that this article will hopefully draw to the plight that we face in the Duchy, I would think it prudent that the author researches the article first.
I also find it amusing that he also, quite rightly, points out that Cornwall is a duchy and not a county, then proceeds to contradict himself through out the rest of the article.
John, Heyl, Kernow
Stupidity...
The Cornish are blaming their discontent on the English. Well, I have news for them - the rest of England is just as discontented. Its called 10 years of labour. I live in Surrey and I would like independence too. Is that sensible? Lets give London to Labour and take the rest of the country back and restore civilisation. Well if the Cornish are allowed it, why can't we have it?
The other thing is, what exactly would the cornish to with 'independence'? Stop the english coming in, lose 1.5 billion a year, ie you will have no more welfare, no more hospitals, roads, pensions... and no more tourist industry. Where can you earn that kind of money from now? Unemployment will rise way above current levels. Youre addicted like the rest of us to the machine...
You think Scotland will continue to get its hand outs once this scottish government have gone? Scotland has a chance, if the gas in the north sea continues, but what does cornwall have? Diddly squat.
Get a brain...
Pete , Surrey, UK
Mebyon Kernow will never achieve election success until the electorate becomes receptive to its message i.e. perceiving Cornwall as a nation of Britain as opposed to a county of England. Whilst the English National Curriculum continues to propagandise Cornish childen into believing that the Cornish have always been English, and Cornwall has always been a mere county of England, the critical mass necessary to effect change will never be realised.
This is why Government persists with the existing, forcibly imposed, Curriculum. Moreover, at a May 2007 High Court hearing Government said it will continue to "strongly resist" Cornish inclusion within the Council of Europe Framework Convention for the Protection of National Minorities.
In essence, London's grip on Cornwall is maintained by unlawfully, and forcibly, assimilating Cornish children in to being English and convincing them that Cornwall was always a mere subdivision of England. Is this how democracy is supposed to work?
john, bodmin, cornwall
It's a shame that some feel that violence and intimidation are the ways to get what you want these days, but when you look at the way certain Governments behave to the rest of the world, then why not they reason.
At the same time however, this perceived "thick as two short planks" mentality doesn't just affect the Cornish. I have had it on and off for a long time since moving to the South East, which I call living in exile. Some think that people from the Westcountry are uneducated, that we have straw and sawdust between our ears. It is really sad and divisive when people think like that. Even more so when they act like it.
rob, essex, uk