Download 'Too Hot', an exclusive Specials track from iTunes

A childminder was jailed for three years yesterday for shaking an 11-month-old baby to death.
Keran Henderson, 42, collapsed in the dock as a jury at Reading Crown Court convicted her of killing Maeve Sheppard in a fit of temper.
The infant was taken to hospital critically ill in March 2005, but her life-support machine was switched off two days later, after a bedside christening.
Medical experts told the court that the child’s fatal brain injuries could only have been caused by a shaking so violent that it caused her neck to snap back and forth.
Henderson, a registered childminder from Iver Heath, Buckinghamshire, wept as she was convicted of manslaughter after a five-week trial.
Outbursts from Henderson’s relatives in the public gallery meant the court had to be adjourned before Mr Justice Keith could sentence her. He told her: “You are going to have to live the rest of your life with the knowledge that Maeve died in your care. We do not know what really happened to make you snap in the way the jury found that you did.”
The court was told that Henderson, a mother of two, was an experienced childminder and a Beaver Scout leader. She began her childminding business seven years ago, and was hired by Ruth and Mark Sheppard in January 2005.
At 11am on March 2, Henderson noted in the diary that she kept for Maeve’s parents that she was “whizzing around in her baby walker”. Minutes later, the emergency services were called.
Experts for the defence argued that the injuries could have been months old. Henderson claimed that the baby had been repeatedly ill almost from the first day in her care – a claim that Maeve’s parents denied.
She said that as she changed her nappy, Maeve “stiffened and jerked back”. Her eyes rolled back into her head, her body went floppy and she was gurgling as if something was stuck in her throat, Henderson claimed. Days after Maeve’s death, she gave up childminding.
The prosecution admitted that Henderson was “good with children”, and a website set up by her husband is full of messages of support from children she has cared for and their parents. But after deliberating for more than 12 hours the jury rejected her account by ten to two.
Henderson’s family, including her husband, Iain, a former Royal Parks police officer, reacted angrily to the verdict.
Amid emotional scenes in court, Mr Justice Keith said that he no longer wanted Mrs Sheppard’s victim impact statement to be read by her in open court. He said that he had read it twice in private and assured Mr and Mrs Sheppard that he had fully digested its contents. In her statement Mrs Sheppard said: “Keran Henderson not only took my daughter’s life away, but she took away our right as her parents to grieve her, to mourn her, to think and remember her in any other way than with pain and anguish. She also took away our right to say goodbye to Maeve.”
Mrs Sheppard, who was pregnant with the couple’s second daughter when Maeve died and now also has a son, said: “When we left Maeve at 7.30am that morning with Keran, she was healthy and smiling, having played blowing raspberries with her dad on the bed prior to leaving home.
“The next time we saw Maeve she was unconscious fighting for her life. I just don’t know how to get past the pain and memory of holding her in our arms after turning the machine off in hospital and watching her die.”
After the hearing, the Sheppards said in a statement: “No sentence will ever bring back our daughter and we will never be able to forgive this woman for what she took away from us.” They added: “We carried out the relevant checks to make sure Keran was a good, trustworthy childminder and our gut instinct was to trust her. If only she had told us that it was not working out between her and Maeve, then we would have our baby daughter with us today.”
Win a luxury weekend to Newcastle and its neighbour Gateshead, find out more here
Risk, resilience and embracing new technology
Industry sectors news at a glance. Interactive heatmap, video and podcast
Discover the power of collective thinking. Submit a solution and be in with a chance to win a Media Hub Home Entertainment System
The inside track on current trends in the charity, not for profit and social enterprise sectors
Everything the Business Traveller needs to know to make a better trip
Make the most of the summer and enter our fabulous photographic competition, you could win a £5000 holiday
Corsica is an island of beauty and contrast, an ideal holiday destination
Enjoy further reading from Travel to Fashion, Business to Sport, discover more
Shortcuts to help you find sections and articles
The clever way to lease a new car is with Car leasing made simple™
2009
per month on 36-month
Personal Contract Hire (PCH)
2008
42850
Car Insurance
£24,250 - £30,346
MI5
London
£60,000
The Environment Agency
Bristol
Up to £90K
Boots
Midlands
OTE £85k
Credit Protection Association
Nationwide Opportunities
Completely London
Luxury Condo's in Manhattan with NYC views
The best new homes in Wimbledon?
Nationwide
Fabulous Cruise And Cruise & Stay Offers Including Virgin Atlantic Flights Prices Start From Only £699pp!
Last Minute Cruise And Cruise & Stay Offers. Med From £499pp, Caribbean From £699pp!
5 star quality at a 3 star price.
8 fabulous Canadian cities ...you won’t find cheaper
Contact our advertising team for advertising and sponsorship in Times Online, The Times and The Sunday Times, or place your advertisement.
Times Online Services: Dating | Jobs | Property Search | Used Cars | Holidays | Births, Marriages, Deaths | Subscriptions | E-paper
News International associated websites: Globrix Property Search | Property Finder | Milkround
Copyright 2009 Times Newspapers Ltd.
This service is provided on Times Newspapers' standard Terms and Conditions. Please read our Privacy Policy.To inquire about a licence to reproduce material from Times Online, The Times or The Sunday Times, click here.This website is published by a member of the News International Group. News International Limited, 1 Virginia St, London E98 1XY, is the holding company for the News International group and is registered in England No 81701. VAT number GB 243 8054 69.
As someone who has gone through the same thing as Keran but with the grace of God, the jury found innocent, I can truly understand the anquish that all sides have in this tragedy.
We must never forget that the Shepperds have lost a child, the most devastating thing any parent can go through.
However, the prosecution argument that if a baby has the 'triad' of injuries then foul-play has occurred is flawed. This current mechanism of prosecuting potentially innocent people just on the basis of medical opinion (not evidence) must stop. So called medical experts must try to stop being so blinkered in their views. Just as much as they say that 'common things happen commonly', then surely 'uncommon things can happen uncommonly'. Just because science / medicine cannot explain things doesn't mean that it hasn't occurred.
Let us hope that in the future, medico-legal 'experts' take a more open-minded approach as what they say in court can ruin innocent peoples and their families' lives.
Alan, Bristol,
As a carer of children, the day that the tragedy was unveiled I remember feeling disgusted at the news. Now I am appauled at my reaction to the case and also feel, having watched Panorama tonight, that there has been a miscarriage of justice for both families. We all tend to look at the facts put before us wether scientific or from pure comment made about someones character. Whilst the profession can be hard work it is also rewarding. I feel without a doubt that any adverse behaviour to one child would also have a detrimental affect on the other children emotionally. Had Keran been aggresive in such a way to Maeve the other children may have been frightened by this and would have been reluctant to enter in to her care each day. Maeve, even at 11 months would have been also. I also think having watched the report that there are more questions to be answered & previous evidence is inconclusive. For the sake of this little one and for Keran, this should be looked at again.
Melanie, Morpeth, Northumberland
I doubt we would see so many objections to this conviction if it were not for the - totally separate- Sally Clarke etc case. This shows the influence of the media in creating a 'controversy' to sell papers. When one story fizzles out, create another one. No evidence - scientific or otherwise - is perfect but we know it takes a lot of force to create the damage associated with SBS. Vaccines etc just do not explain it. I cannot believe the same people who questioned the evidence for not being robust are also saying Keran must be innocent because she 'seems such a nice person'. What an insult to the grieving parents.
brian, bucks,
All of the people that are having a bad say about Keran, they are completly wrong i must say.... Keran Henderson is a kind loving woman that as you can see and have probably heard has worked with children for a long time and would never do something as cruel as this!
As one woman has said as i have read through all of these reports, havent the judges or jurers or who-ever asked the children what they had seen on the day of the incident?
Well obviosly not! They should
James L, Iver Heath, Bucks, England
I have just spent my evening reading through the different newspaper reports on this truly sad story and even with the mixture of reporting arguing both sides, I am sure that there has been a miscarriage of justice for Keran and baby Maeve's family. There are so many unanswered questions and so many things pointing to other possibilities as to what could have happened. As they say, There but for the grace of god go I. Lets pray that none of us are ever in the unfortunate position to have our freedom taken away with such little evidence and I hope I never have to put my faith in our so called justice system when it is quite clearly all weighted in one direction. Good luck to Keran's family and friends, I hope that someone in authority sits up and takes notice. An overhaul of the British Justice system is long overdue in many areas and this highlights yet another.
Clare, Northants, Northants
Lack of professionalism & no integrity ,if any of the people supporting this woman, ie: protesting her innocence ,if it was your child you would expect the same sort of justice .
It's mainly the "Iver Heath Trinny & Suzanna Club " putting their five cents worth in .There is a house on the Slough road that has been turned into a freak show display showing support for this baby killer .How must the the Sheppard family feel having to still have to go about their daily routine when they are made to feel like the victims by a bunch of parochial inbreds .
Burt , Iver , Bucks
First and foremost it is a terrible tradegy what has happened, the loss of a baby's life. But there has to be some radical change in our laws in convicting innocent women in these circumstances. Emotions run high. How many more innocent women are going to be convicted of a similar crime only to be revoked and new evidence found some time later ?
I hope there is an early appeal for Keran - my sympathy goes to the Sheppards and also Keran's family too ........ I hope the family can eventually find some solace with whats hapened but I do believe in reading and listening to this case that unequivacably this woman is the victim of a set of circumstance that cannot be revoked but she is innocent
Joanne Cantor, London, UK
Re. the conviction of the childminder for shaking baby Maeve Shepperd,.. Some babies, whose parents were wrongly accused of harming them, had been prescribed the (now withdrawn) drug CISAPRIDE/PREPULSID to prevent vomiting. This contained benzene-related chemicals which could cause babies to suffer breathing problems, cot death or cardiac arrest. The BNF reference book which GPs prescribe from, lists 200 prescribed drugs as causing blood thinning & low blood counts. This can cause bruising & bleeding - which can falsely give symptoms of shaking a baby. All relevant cases of alleged harm should be
investigated to find if these infants were prescribed a
benzene-related medicine.
ann, Middx, United Kingdon
keran henderson would never do anything like this to any one....
SHE IS INNOCENT CANT YOU SEE!!
James .L., Iver Heath, England
Can this paper check pleaseeeeeeeee to see if this child received any vaccines in the days before this incident??
I do not have their address to check and would not disturb them, but it a chance and could bring justice.
I say this because it does happen to babies because of ingredients in vaccine.
But self professed experts are covering for pharmaceutical companies.
heck out thinktwice vaccines
Lilith Barrett, London., UK
When it comes to to understanding the human body - scientists are only scratching the surface. For goodness sake they have not even come up with a cure for the common cold. Why is it then many individuals put so much faith in these so called experts.
Keran has never shown anything in her personality that she is possibly capable of 'snapping'. She is an amazingly loving kind and warm person.
Meenu Baker, Hemel Hempstead, UK
My little girl was there at the time Maeve fitted - and had been on all previous occasions. Anyone who knows Keran knows that she is not capable of this crime - and yet again our British justice system has failed us. Keran is a CARER not a KILLER.
A mother, Gerrards Cross, UK
A total miscarriage of justice. This is NOT in Keran's nature, she was helping a sick baby and happened to be in the wrong place at the wrong time. This baby could have died anywhere - it was ill. Where Keran's children taken away from her if she was liable to just 'snap'? - No they weren't. Obviously she is NO RISK whatsover and her reaction in court was real - she is INNOCENT. Please fight to release her.
Helen, East Riding of Yorkshire,
Quite shocking to read this in the news and left me with a heavy heart. It is saddening for everyone involved. It does also bring one glaring fact to light, for all those who are and would like to be in childcare as it is such a rewarding career, would be really apprehensive after reading such news!! In a system where there are so many incentives towards these professions it is no surprise why so less people are actaully in teaching and childcare!!
Vineet Kaur, London, U.K.
Who decides these people are experts anyway? Why were the other children who were in her care at the time not asked to give evidence?! And why were the poor baby's previous fits not taken into consideration? Very much a miscarriage of justice.
Melissa, Buckinghamshire,
Most people don't realize that hundreds of people around the world have told the identical story Keran did, people with sterling character, reputations and histories. How could so many people "snap", some just a few minutes after being observed by others to be unstressed? "Experts" continue to maintain that the ONLY possible explanation for the symptoms is shaking, despite the fact that at least three natural causes are known. I strongly suspect there are natural causes that are as yet unknown to science. It concerns me greatly that no one is investigating that possibility, that officials are content to accuse and imprison on the basis of medical opinions in the absence of ANY other evidence of abuse. There are cases where children have come to hospital, been admitted, then collapsed 16 hours later and died, with the "telltale" SBS symptoms. Yet "experts" continue to say the last person with the child is the only possible perpetrator. This IS a travesty of justice a la Sally Clarke!
Susan, Anchorage, Alaska USA
I believe we have another travsity of justice. Keran had been worried about the baby and was going to ask her parents to take her away. I also wonder who else had access to shake Maeve if as I believe Keran did not. Maeve's mother also stated during the trial that she did not believe Keran was guilty. We have yet again so called experts disagreeing with one another so how can one person be convicted. I believe our legal system is no better than some third world countries. God help Keran
Pat , slough, berks
Total Miscarriage of Justice, Keran is one of the most trustworthy and Community focused people I know and if you knew her, know she was not capable of such a hideous crime.
I would not hesitate even now for Keran to run the local cubs & beavers again or look after my two young children.
My Heart goes out to Maeve's family for their great loss, but please spare a thought for Keran and her family also suffering!
Daryl, Iver Heath
Daryl Maskell, iver heath, Bucks
I hope this isn't another miscarriage of justice a la Sally Clarke, Trupty Patel et al.
I feel very sorry for all parties involved in this case.
However, my gut reaction - and I feel I have to say this - is that if more couples took responsibility for looking after their own children, instead of trying to 'have their cake and eat it', we wouldn't keep seeing cases like this in the news.
Mrs Sheppard should have given up work on having a family. Sorry, but these are my firm beliefs. You have children, you look after them.
Darren, Rathfriland, Northern Ireland
Did the police interview the 8 year old children that was there the whole time? No. I say no more!
Caroline Snoch, Stoke Poges, Bucks
Is this another rubbish jury verdict without forensic evidence. there are too many wrong verdicts turning up in the British system, A 10 to 2 majority should give the defendant the benefit of the doubt, ruining someones life on dubious evidence does not do anything for the so called victim or justice.
dave, Stoke,
Very depressing story of course, but I'm also left with a sense of unease. Victim impact statements leave little room for grace, responsibility, or expressions of forgiveness and as such I find they have an adverse effect.
I guess it's possible that a mature, experienced and highly regarded childminder 'just snapped' but who knows.
philip, cambridge,