Download 'Too Hot', an exclusive Specials track from iTunes
Who would you expect to live longer: an east Glaswegian or a man from Colombia, Albania or North Korea? The answer is that the Colombians, Albanians and North Koreans would drink a toast at the Glaswegian’s wake.
Who says so? The World Health Organisation. Male Colombians, despite poverty and narcotraficantes, expect to reach 71; Albanians, despite all those blood feuds, 69; North Koreans, despite living in a concentration camp, 64; east Glaswegians, despite living in one of the richest states on the planet, 63. That is about the same as Bangladesh. They’d have to move to Burma, Nepal or Somalia to drop dead sooner.
East Glaswegians are citizens of a country with average male life expectancy of 77. They live in Labour’s 25th safest parliamentary seat, where on July 24 the party will defend a majority of 13,500. They ought to share the same rights and life span as the rest of us, particularly after 11 years of Labour government – but they don’t.
Above and beyond all the clever political forecasting that is going on about the by-election here and whether or not Gordon Brown would survive losing the constituency, we should never forget this inequitable abuse of human rights in the Labour heartland.
Glasgow East’s last MP, David Marshall, a former bus conductor, resigned precipitously after 19 years for unexplained “personal reasons”. The man most expected to replace him at Westminster, George Ryan, a local councillor, turned down the chance equally mysteriously.
Perhaps it’s not such a mystery. Glasgow East is the hardest, poorest place in Britain. Others may pick a fight about that – but they’d lose. Shettleston, at the heart of the constituency, makes the rough margins of Liverpool look like the Chelsea Flower Show.
The constituency is large and incoherent. It looks like the national museum of pebble dashing – everything that could have the bottom of a fish tank stuck to it has.
The people do not look good here. Often it is difficult to tell men from women, old men from older men. The mean parades of shops are dotted with tanning parlours. Yet the locals have the blotchy pallor of cave-dwelling consumptives; only their first two fingers are stained brown.
In the pubs there are shellsuited angry men with faces like melted funeral candles. Among them are little knots of pensioners who spend their days in a bar because they can’t afford to keep the light and the heat on at home. They get a bit of telly and some warmth and some company. And if they nurse a glass of Irn-Bru for long enough, someone will put a dram in it.
The gossip is all about drug dealers, organised crime and the local celebrities – the inmates of Barlinnie jail, which is also in the constituency. You can buy a knife here called a 10-shot, the street weapon of choice, named because it costs £1 an inch and will go right through you. Drunks turn up at an accident and emergency cupping their amputated fingers in their palms.
The day I’m here the clouds hang at head height; it could be February. My first stop is a shopping precinct where the Scottish Nationalists are shaking hands in a credit union. This is a starter bank for people who are not into joined-up economics yet.
Next door there’s a greetings card shop with a big display of birthday cards. I pick up one that says “Happy 100th” and ask the girl behind the counter if she has ever sold one. She gives me a f*** off look and says no.
John Mason, the Nats’ candidate, is so insignificant that he has to be pointed out to me three times at a distance of 5ft. He is lurking in an oversized suit the colour of wet cement, has wisps of gingery hair and a pair of glasses that must have come free with another pair of glasses.
His voice sounds like rain falling on derelict carpet. Apparently in a previous life he was some sort of councillor, although he might have been a draught excluder or a novelty loo roll cover.
The Westminster excitement over this ballot supposes that the nationalists will rise like Wallace in a fervour; but by choosing Mason the SNP has shown that it doesn’t think it has a shortbread in a teacup’s chance of winning.
This is an overwhelmingly Catholic seat – Celtic’s ground is just down the road – and Catholics always, always vote Labour. They won’t vote for a man called Mason: the freemasons are aligned with the Orange Order, which is Rangers and unionist – and they are having their marching season right now.
All this may seem ridiculously 1960s Belfast and unsophisticated; but if you leave people to stew in squalor, what’s the surprise if they behave tribally?
Not that Labour isn’t doing its best to cut its own throat. Three or four people turned down the job before the party could find one willing to say yes.
She is Margaret Curran, who is a member of the Scottish parliament for a constituency that overlaps this one.
We go to meet her at a kilt-hire warehouse that boasts it sends out 12,000 wedding outfits a week.
That’s more Highlanders than fought at Culloden.
Most end up in England.
Curran is one of those small, sinewy – tough as girders, sharp as a dirk, subtle as a football chant – political women fashioned by the viciously adversarial nature of Scottish politics. Her minders – both English – assure me she will be taking only one parliamentary salary.
But what will she do for her constituents that she doesn’t do already in the Edinburgh parliament?
In this seat nearly half of all households are council or housing association; 60% of them have no car; death from heart attack in the under-75s is more than 80% above the national average; drug-related crime and Aids are endemic.
Teenage pregnancy is 42% above a national average that is already the shame of Europe. Nearly half the children live in long-term unemployed households. About 50% of the population have no qualifications. The biggest single employer is the social security.
So what this place really, really needs – what it’s crying out for – is a part-time MP playing political hide-and-seek with the government in Westminster.
We drive off to find the Tory candidate, Davina Rankin, who sits in the back room of the Tory office, an abandoned shop.
She is young, local, black and a trade unionist, which is something of a coup for the Tories. And there’s more. She grew up in Gartnavel mental hospital where her parents were nurses.
Davina is utterly new Con, right on. She can tick boxes they haven’t even invented yet. She is also the only candidate who talks about local issues eloquently, sensibly and with sympathy – and she doesn’t have a hope in hell. She will be lucky to save her deposit.
At best only 30% of east Glaswegians will turn out for the ballot. They are deracinated, as uncoupled from the political system as they are from the economic one. No one wants to talk to the candidates; they have no questions to ask, no use for a leaflet.
It would be easy to see these people as being the agents of their own misfortune, what with the smoking, the diet, the drugs, the drink, the strokes and the heart attacks, the rotten teeth, the pregnancies and the crime. But why should they get enthused about a system that has for generations taken them for granted?
The citizens of east Glasgow have bigger problems to be getting on with – like how to stay alive.
Win a luxury weekend to Newcastle and its neighbour Gateshead, find out more here
Risk, resilience and embracing new technology
Industry sectors news at a glance. Interactive heatmap, video and podcast
Discover the power of collective thinking. Submit a solution and be in with a chance to win a Media Hub Home Entertainment System
The inside track on current trends in the charity, not for profit and social enterprise sectors
Everything the Business Traveller needs to know to make a better trip
Make the most of the summer and enter our fabulous photographic competition, you could win a £5000 holiday
Corsica is an island of beauty and contrast, an ideal holiday destination
Enjoy further reading from Travel to Fashion, Business to Sport, discover more
Shortcuts to help you find sections and articles
The clever way to lease a new car is with Car leasing made simple™
2009
per month on 36-month
Personal Contract Hire (PCH)
2008
42850
Car Insurance
£24,250 - £30,346
MI5
London
£60,000
The Environment Agency
Bristol
Up to £90K
Boots
Midlands
OTE £85k
Credit Protection Association
Nationwide Opportunities
Completely London
Luxury Condo's in Manhattan with NYC views
The best new homes in Wimbledon?
Nationwide
Fabulous Cruise And Cruise & Stay Offers Including Virgin Atlantic Flights Prices Start From Only £699pp!
Last Minute Cruise And Cruise & Stay Offers. Med From £499pp, Caribbean From £699pp!
5 star quality at a 3 star price.
8 fabulous Canadian cities ...you won’t find cheaper
Contact our advertising team for advertising and sponsorship in Times Online, The Times and The Sunday Times, or place your advertisement.
Times Online Services: Dating | Jobs | Property Search | Used Cars | Holidays | Births, Marriages, Deaths | Subscriptions | E-paper
News International associated websites: Globrix Property Search | Property Finder | Milkround
Copyright 2009 Times Newspapers Ltd.
This service is provided on Times Newspapers' standard Terms and Conditions. Please read our Privacy Policy.To inquire about a licence to reproduce material from Times Online, The Times or The Sunday Times, click here.This website is published by a member of the News International Group. News International Limited, 1 Virginia St, London E98 1XY, is the holding company for the News International group and is registered in England No 81701. VAT number GB 243 8054 69.
Well the turnout was 42% and the Mason who didn't have "shortbread in a tea cups chance" won
Amanda McLauchlan, Glasgow,
As an emigrant to Scotland, the health of many Scots, and their diet horrifies me. Food = takeaway rubbish, drink = getting legless, often. Of course one has to wonder how it has come to this, but increasingly it is why I support independence for Scotland. It couldn't be worse than how it is now!
Pablo, Edinburgh, UK
Catholics always vote Labour? Anne Widdicombe, Norman St John Stevas, John Selwyn Gummer, etc? In my experience British Roman Catholics have the same wide spread of political views as the rest of the population. Your assertion to the contrary stinks of both religious and political bigotry
Gerard Mulholland, Paris, France
I grew up in Carntyne . While I was a catholic ( now an athiest) , there was total integration in carntyne and the East End as a whole. I lived in a four-in-a-block ,where there were two catholic families and two protestant ones. ALL FRIENDS. Thought I was reading The Sun for a moment there.
Paul Nicol, Bishopbriggs,
some of the most eloquent writing to be found on the whole website. mr gill please write a book!
Jon, London, UK
Not got a problem with Kevin of lincoln's comments but less payments = less tax take from Scotland. Also less money being poured into the fiasco that is fast becoming the olympics which are costing us all dear. Also, kevin, Glasgow East has rarely if at all ever recieved any help from government,
Jim Jamieson, Livingston, Scotland
Why do the Catholics vote labour?.... ever wondered how they became the only religious denomination to have their own schools?
AB Leishman, Airdrie, Scotland
A bit over the top but also accurate in places. However, this is not a 'Catholic' seat by any stretch of the imagination and I do not know where he got this information from. More importantly, this seat is a worthy case study on the deleterious effects of decades of municipal Scottish socialism.
Eagle, Drymen, Scotland
entrepreneurship and grammar schools are the only hope for an area like that. grammar schools give kids the opportunity to reach their potential. entrepreneurship gives people something to live for, and obviously brings employment.
not that labour could ever think of these obvious cures.
will, grimsby, uk
Glasgow East is Labour's disgrace.
The sooner Labour is routed the better.
I am a Scottish Catholic and have never voted Labour and never will. No priest in any church I have attended has ever tried to influence the way I vote.
Katherine Longmuir, Eriskay, Scotland
These citizens are far from neglected. They receive the fruits of others' labour in abundance. Free health service, free education, incapacity benefit, housing benefit, council tax benefit. They are the privileged ones.
Michael Evans, Midsomer Norton, UK
nice description. it sounds worse than Hanley near Stoke-on-Trent.
Marco, KrakOw, Poland
How can anybody there vote Labour after what their local MP has been up to.Don't they see he and his family have been laughing all the way to the bank at their expense.
Next MP? she has time left over from the Scots Parliament to be able to afford the time and effort to go to Westminster?
Boughin
james allen, manchester, england
Scotland is a problem state or quasi-state - it is from here that the dependancy mentality that infects the UK today as come. The cure won't be found here and only tough love in the form of reduced payments to the Scottish adminstration will make a difference to how they think.
kevin, Lincoln, UK
And the place will be the same in fifty years time (Unless it is 'gentrified' which simply means removing the people to be a problem somewhere else).
Eric Skelton, Cardiff, Wales
Less of the 'catholic seat' intertwined with Labour voting please. This area has no reliance on Labour success due to it being fuelled solely by Catholic voters (indeed, there is a majority of non-Catholic constituents if Mr Gill had actually reasearched), but by working class stalwarts.
John, Glasgow, Scotland
Pity AA didn't read Bishop Devine's scathing article on Labour and their hopes in Glasgow East as it contains the key phrase, 'you can be forgiven for thinking Labour have a death wish'.
Magrat Gurn is probably 7th choice for this seat though 'Father Cairns' claimed she was first choice all along
Peter Thomson, Kirkcudbright, Scotland
Its been a safe Labour seat for decades but what have they done for the local populace? Nothing, Zilch, Nada.
Bingo, Glasgow, Great Britain
What a pity that the resigning MP is not to be prosecuted for his financial misbehaviour...but that too is part of the Labour background understood and condoned fom Brown downwards
roger tanneau, Paris , France
Gill exaggerates a little, for effect. Especially the bit about Catholics and Labour. But the city has been governed by Catholic council majority for a long time. The East end has had millions of pounds poured into it since the 1970s to change the fabric. The people have not changed.
Glenn, Glasgow,
"All this may seem ridiculously 1960s Belfast". 1960s Belfast? Do you know anything about Belfast! The depressing hatred on the streets in still here in 2008. Spending a few hours in any place is not going to give you a fair view of it. You know nothing about Belfast or Glasgow East.
Kevin, Belfast,
"It is self abuse and they are at liberty to continue like this or the right to change their life styles. No human rights about it."
Ah, the loud voice of ignorance, with no idea whatsoever of the practical realities of being TRAPPED in poverty by New Labour's absurd, obscene benefits system.
S Campbell, Bath, England, UK
"The hardest, poorest place in Britain", and the previous Labour MP claimed 500,000 for a "Home Office" in his semi.
Brian Smith, Edinburgh, Scotland
Thanks AA, insightful and accurate as ever. Eschewing any temptation to sensationalise, careful not to stoke petty and misconceived prejudices. When will you come return to the east end so the locals can endorse your views? Those who can read obviously. Fear not, they wont eat you. Rotten teeth...
Aldo Paldo, Glasgow, UK
'This is an overwhelmingly Catholic seat... and Catholics always, always vote Labour. '
Factualy incorrect.
rakesh s, glasgow,
How is this 'an inequitable abuse of human rights'?
It is self abuse and they are at liberty to continue like this or the right to change their life styles. No human rights about it.
M Wilson, Bidache, france
Fair article. My mum lives near there. IT has to be a Labour constituency. If they voted conservative, things would change, but then if you want to stsick with Labour - go ahead. And yes, that i their own fault. Why is Scotland poorer than England - LABOUR. No other reason. Scots deserve better.
Talese Amer, London, UNITED KINDOM OF BRITAIN AND NORTHERN IRELAND