Jon Swain, Nakuru
Download 'Too Hot', an exclusive Specials track from iTunes
THE tragedy of Kenya’s violence was etched on the face of James Kamau, a softly spoken 43-year-old biology teacher, as he steeled himself to search Nakuru city mortuary for his murdered brother-in-law this weekend.
“We are glimpsing an enormity of evil in Kenya larger than any of us imagined,” he said. “Look how they have destroyed our people.”
He flinched in a moment of shock as he spotted a familiar pair of brown shoes on the feet of a man burnt beyond recognition who was lying on the floor. “It is Eliud,” he said, turning away in sorrow and comforting his sister.
At least Eliud, 40, could now be buried. Kamau had feared when he could not find him that his brother-in-law had been thrown - like other victims of the violence - into the 1,600ft-deep crater of the dormant Menengai volcano five miles from the city centre. There he would have been devoured by wild animals.
Local legend has it that the steam rising from the bottom consists of the souls of Masai warriors who were hurled into the crater after a battle over land and are now trying to reach heaven. The volcano was a top tourist attraction in the Rift Valley until 10 days ago, when the violence that began over a disputed presidential election on December 27 spread to the streets of Nakuru.
Chaos reigned in and around the town, Kenya’s fourth largest, as tribal gangs fought with knives, pangas, stones and poisoned arrows. After more than 60 people had died, the police imposed a dusk-to-dawn curfew. The tourists left and have not come back.
Kamau and other relatives of the dead milling before the gates of the mortuary said they believed worse bloodshed was to come. The violence had exploded after members of the opposition Orange Democratic Movement (ODM) claimed the government had rigged the elections to prevent their leader, Raila Odinga, 63, replacing Mwai Kibaki, the 76-year-old president.
Immediately after the re-election of Kibaki, the violence was directed against his tribe, the Kikuyu, whose political and economic domination of Kenya since independence in 1963 has exposed them to widespread resentment. But in the past week Kikuyus have hit back at Luos, Luhyas, Kalenjin and other tribes supporting Odinga, who is himself a Luo.
The ODM said the violence was a spontaneous surge of anger at Kibaki’s electoral “fraud”, but activists on both sides fanned the flames of tribal resentment and on Wednesday, after nearly 1,000 people had been killed and 250,000 had been made homeless, the Daily Nation newspaper said the fear of civil war was not far-fetched. Jendayi Frazer, the American assistant secretary of state for Africa, called the violence “clear ethnic cleansing”.
A glimmer of hope emerged late on Friday when Kofi Annan, the former United Nations secretary-general who is mediating, announced that the government and opposition had agreed a plan to end the crisis. Annan said measures would be introduced in a week to 10 days to stop the violence. But 27 more people were killed and a church burnt yesterday.
In the traumatised strife-torn Rift Valley, many Kikuyus driven from their homes said it was too late to stop the tribal hatred. “It is impossible to live together. There will be more blood. It cannot stop now,” said Robert Njoroge, 55, who came to the mortuary to collect the body of his nephew, who had been murdered by the Kalenjin.
The reason why the Rift Valley has become the epicentre of the conflict is rooted in history. Once the homeland of the Kalenjin and Masai, much of it was seized early last century by the British, who turned it into a colonial paradise of farms and Tudor-style mansions. Instead of being returned to those tribes on independence, the farmland was bought by Kikuyus, the tribe of Jomo Kenyatta, Kenya’s first president.
Although the constitution granted Kenyans of any tribe the right to live anywhere in the country, the spread of Kikuyus across the Rift Valley triggered bitterness and grievances.
Many Kikuyus believe that the violence was planned, regardless of the election result. They have accused William Ruto, one of Odinga’s top aides, who is a Kalenjin and an MP in Eldoret, one of the flashpoints in the Rift Valley, of a pre-election hate speech.
“He has become the warlord of the Rift Valley,” said a man called Simon. “He poisoned the Kalenjin against the Kikuyu.”
Kamau said his Kalenjin neighbour, a banker, had warned him two weeks before the election to expect trouble. He said he had heard hate speeches broadcast on the local Kalenjin radio station and had been told that Kalenjin youths were being indoctrinated against the Kikuyu while undergoing circumcision in December as a rite of passage.
“There are no Kikuyus who have been left on their farms in the Rift Valley,” said Kamau, who was burnt out of his Eldoret home with his wife and three children and now lives in a refugee camp.
“They have destroyed all our property. They think the Rift Valley is theirs and no other tribe should be there. That is what they were told during the circumcision ceremonies.”
So powerful was the rhetoric that it seemed to have infected even educated Kalenjins. After being burnt out of his home, one senior figure at Moi University in Eldoret was warned last week that his colleagues were hunting for him and he should not return if he wanted to stay alive.
The growing and seemingly uncontrollable tribal violence has led to inevitable comparisons to Rwanda, where the 1994 genocide claimed nearly 1m lives. But Kenya is not Rwanda. It has 42 tribes, where Rwanda had only two, one of which made up 90% of the population. The brutal ethnic cleansing that divided Bosnia is a fairer analogy.
To combat the Kalenjin attacks, the Kikuyu in the Rift Valley have resurrected a murderous criminal gang notorious for beheading its victims. The gang, called the Mungiki, was established during elections in the 1990s to counter violence by Kalenjin gangs but was later outlawed. Last year the police reportedly killed 500 Mungiki in a crackdown.
According to a priest in Nakuru, Mungiki gangs were on the prowl last week, under police protection and looking for members of other tribes. One Kikuyu youth who would call himself only John described how he was forced to join a gang which beheaded 15 Kalenjin and Luos.
“They killed one man armed with a club and stones. He could not answer a question put to him in Kikuyu so they forced him to the ground and cut off his head. Next we met a big man sharpening two pangas. They cut him so fast that his mouth was still moving when they lifted up his head on the end of a panga.”
His story fitted word from other Kikuyus that a strategy had been devised to wait for most Kikuyus to be in places of safety before striking back against the Kalenjin. “We kept quiet for a month,” said one Kikuyu who was thirsting for vengeance.
“If we had acted before our people were safe, the Kalenjin would have killed them. Now we will chop them in pieces. Raila and Ruto will cry.”
Tribal divisions
* Kenya's main tribes are the Kikuyu 20%, Luo 14%, Luhya 13%, Kalenjin 11%
* President Kibaki is Kikuyu; Odinga is Luo
* The Kalenjin in the Rift Valley resent Kikuyu land purchases there
Win a luxury weekend to Newcastle and its neighbour Gateshead, find out more here
Risk, resilience and embracing new technology
Industry sectors news at a glance. Interactive heatmap, video and podcast
Discover the power of collective thinking. Submit a solution and be in with a chance to win a Media Hub Home Entertainment System
The inside track on current trends in the charity, not for profit and social enterprise sectors
Everything the Business Traveller needs to know to make a better trip
Make the most of the summer and enter our fabulous photographic competition, you could win a £5000 holiday
Corsica is an island of beauty and contrast, an ideal holiday destination
Enjoy further reading from Travel to Fashion, Business to Sport, discover more
Shortcuts to help you find sections and articles
The clever way to lease a new car is with Car leasing made simple™
2009
per month on 36-month
Personal Contract Hire (PCH)
2008
42850
Car Insurance
£24,250 - £30,346
MI5
London
£60,000
The Environment Agency
Bristol
Up to £90K
Boots
Midlands
OTE £85k
Credit Protection Association
Nationwide Opportunities
Completely London
Luxury Condo's in Manhattan with NYC views
The best new homes in Wimbledon?
Nationwide
Fabulous Cruise And Cruise & Stay Offers Including Virgin Atlantic Flights Prices Start From Only £699pp!
Last Minute Cruise And Cruise & Stay Offers. Med From £499pp, Caribbean From £699pp!
5 star quality at a 3 star price.
8 fabulous Canadian cities ...you won’t find cheaper
Contact our advertising team for advertising and sponsorship in Times Online, The Times and The Sunday Times, or place your advertisement.
Times Online Services: Dating | Jobs | Property Search | Used Cars | Holidays | Births, Marriages, Deaths | Subscriptions | E-paper
News International associated websites: Globrix Property Search | Property Finder | Milkround
Copyright 2009 Times Newspapers Ltd.
This service is provided on Times Newspapers' standard Terms and Conditions. Please read our Privacy Policy.To inquire about a licence to reproduce material from Times Online, The Times or The Sunday Times, click here.This website is published by a member of the News International Group. News International Limited, 1 Virginia St, London E98 1XY, is the holding company for the News International group and is registered in England No 81701. VAT number GB 243 8054 69.
did someone actually call anderson cooper fair and balanced? wow, that's scary.
Greg, Walnut Creek, Ca, USA
I am a missionary/journalist living in Kenya and was displaced in the early days of the violence. In response to a few comments I read. Its both side, without a doubt. I have friends on all sides, in all places and it is everyone - the Kisii, Kalenjin, Luo, Luyha, Kikuyu, Embu, Meru, Massi. It most definately is tribal. At the same time I think we must be careful to say THE Kikuyu, THE Luo etc. Its not EVERYONE from those tribes. There are still some who won't join in. It is mainly the young men, who long ago were the warriors, who protected their tribe and raided the other tribes, however they have never been given a subsitute for that time of warrior-hood, instead they sit idle on the roadsides, easy targets for someone with a grudge and money! I hope no one still believes that this was spontanous - it had very little to do with the elections they were just an excuse. 1500 young men from as far as 200 km don't gather in the course of 5 days and start burning spontaneously!
Sarah, Nairobi,
This story is neither fair or balanced
Why not tell of the luos who have systematically killed all the kikuyus in kisumu, even going as far as turnining on their own who are married to kikuyus
of Luos and kalenkins whow were given a chance to leave unhurt by their kikuyu neighbors in limuru,Kari research center, to name afew
Why not tell the truth that hardly anyone from other tribes living in central have been killed kikked by the kikuyu, threats yes but not massacre.
How about telling of the facrt that Kikuyus waited for over a month before starting to defend themselves nad even then, they are showing remarkable restraint, except for the unfortunate event in Naivasha
Why not report that ODM leadership is selectively asking for violence to stop, as awhite wash, why call for schools to reopen and choose not to call for total fighting to stop.
Why not report of the new clashes between Kaelnjins and Kissii, surely Kibaki is not a kiss, keep it balanced
Betty , houston, USA
this article is neither fair or balanced, why try to incite others aganist the kikuyus?, to be credible, borrow a leaf from Aderson cooper, : keep it fair and balanced, tell the whole story
why not tell of the the fact that no one from other tribes living in central has been killed by the kikuyus, except in the Nairobi slums.
Why not tell the truth that Central province is the only place where even though other tribes were displaced no one burnt their homes, or killed thwm enmass, and though unfortumately they have been asked to leave, they have been given safe passage as opposed to kikuyus whow are stranded in RV, and Nyanza
Betty , houston, USA
I am a Kenyan and most people have all this ill thoughts about Kikuyus being favoured but that ia an ill misconception. Moi a Kalenjin was in power for over 20 years of which half he used to try and finish Kikuyus, when he left and K ibaki took over not a single Kikuyu was up against the former tribe. what they are forgetting is that majority of kikuyus are hard working and it is unfortunate most have lost their lives but one thing for sure they will bounce back and it is the high time the other tribes wook up to the reality and stop being in fantasy.
Even if they grab everything in Rift Valley I can bet they will not be in a position to manage and it is the high time also they stopped the violence for their own benefit and the country as a whole.
pat, Nairobi, kenya
What is rather tragic and perhaps more dangerous is the notion that Kikuyu;s have been the only victims. Kikuyu's have pretty much gone on a killing spree and have been more months before the election. Their most heinous crime was the beheading of a Luo child and skinning months before the election. They seem oblivious to their own culpuablity and that is pretty much Kibaki's position.
What Kikuyu's will not tell you is that they have always disenfranchised other Kenyans since independence even more, majority of the prison population is Kikuyu due to their savage acts that most will not concede to.
No loss of life is worth another however I suppose they don't intend to stop the killing. Its a tragic state of affairs that most Kikuyus will not face and would rather bury their head in the sand as they have since 63.
If healing is to come, several generations must play a significant role. Our generation has suffered under Kikuyu and kalenjin wars, and now Luos. What of other Kenyans?
Mwkakale, Nakuru, Kenya
Its not tribal violence if your talking about the population of an entire country. Its quite racist to call it such. People from Wales or Scotland are not a 'tribe'. Tribal violence is an explanatory term used by the media to forgo any real explanation of what is happening. Its entirely meaningless.
Alex, Colchester,
My husband & I have worked alongside both Kikuyus and Luo. I have heard them brag repeatedly even a few months before the election about the peace between these tribes. I have NEVER sensed any tension.
I believe this article hits a point that has been neglected. In Rwanda the genocide was not just tribal hatred, it was planned for years and orchestrated by political leaders who used radio addresses to manipulate and scare Hutu into believing if they didn't kill the Tutsi, they would be killed themselves.
I highly suspect that ODM or some group affiliated with them to organize this violence for some time. There are underground tribal gangs that have been terrorizing Kenyans for generations. They are made up of desperate young men, mostly orphans who have no where else to turn.
I've spent some time interviewing them. The Kenyan gov't as well as the world has ignored the overwhelming number of these abandoned children. This I believe, is one of the consequences.
cherie catron, chillicothe, ohio
None of these people are behaving in a humane manner. Tribal differences seem to have simmered beneath the surface not just for decades, but for generations. Former friends and neighbours who used to help eachother through the tough times now simply axe and murder eachother in the most violent of ways because of being born in a different tribe.
Maybe in the fifties you could get away with that excuse - now it seems to me like a power trip for young testerone fuelled males who, when looking back in years' to come will be thoroughly ashamed off themselves and their actions. Think of the poor young children of The Lord's Army. Forced to rape, pillage and murder before reaching puberty through no choice of their own.
These people lived together; worked together; were friends together; married eachother and were happy together. One election which only needs to be done again through stricter controls could safe the lot. Wouldn't anybody prefer that to picking up a machete & hack away?
LT, Warminster, UK
The other issue that really bothers me is Koffi Anan (Ex UN Chief) saying we may,if lucky, start getting somewhere within eight to ten days whilst setting up the right meetings between everyone etc. The story of his UN Reign - there is no time and action was always too blooming late. Stop Talking Start Acting.
The election was fraudulent - suspend the (Ex) Government; arrange new elections with proper checks. No such protests that UN employees aren't allowed - just, for once, a take it or leave it approach might be the answer. If they don't like it - suspend all aid to the (Ex) President and see how long it will take for them to comply.
What gets me is that we, the public, pay for all this aid which disappears into the pockets of frauds and cheats both here and abroad and we are supposed to just take it and not complain. I, for one, have had enough. Help when help is needed, fine! Black Hole, no accounts? VERY WRONG
The longer you wait, the mor casualties
LT, Warminster, UK
The tribalism in Kenya in particular, and Africa in general, is what will keep them from fully entering into the 21'st century and modern civilization. It is sad.
Bob, Westcliffe, Colorado
Very very sad. I was born in Kenya and remember it as the beautiful country in the world including its peoples. First and foremost they should remember they are Kenyans, even before they are Kikuyus, Luos, etc. only then can the political landscape change. Killing each other is not going to solve any problems.
D. Patel, Richmond, VA
I am amazed that life allows death to happend this wasy. What would it take for the tribes to settle their disputes?
Felipe, Orlando , Florida
This is what happens when elections are stolen. People feel enraged and ready to kill. This is the way that a lot of people felt when Bush stole the US elections in 2000.
al, nyc,
Why do leaders plant seeds of hating each other ? Do not they know we have to co- exist? Ruto watch your words and everyone else.
How long are living on this earth?
Ben, Athol, USA