Jonathan Milne
Download 'Too Hot', an exclusive Specials track from iTunes
Gordon Brown says he is “appalled” by new signs of intimidation and violence in Zimbabwe and has warned President Robert Mugabe that the world's patience is fast running out.
The Prime Minister's criticisms came a few hours after police announced a ban on political rallies in the African nation, in an attempt to subdue public unrest about suppressed presidential election results.
Mr Mugabe dismissed Mr Brown as "a little tiny dot" who could not speak for the world.
"If Brown is the world, sure, he will lose patience. I know Brown as a little tiny dot on this planet,” the 84-year-old Zimbabwean leader said.
Thabo Mbeki, the South African President, held urgent talks in Harare this morning with Mr Mugabe, who is believed to have lost the election.
Hopes of bringing international influence to bear on Zimbabwe rest with the South African leader, after Mr Mugabe pulled out of this weekend's regional summit to discuss his nation's problems.
Mr Brown had talked with Mr Mbeki last weekend in an attempt to persuade him to use his influence to end the elections stand-off. Today, in his second statement about the Zimbabwe election in 12 hours, he added: “We can’t wait any longer for the announcement of these results."
But Mr Mbeki emerged from his hour-long meeting with Mr Mugabe today to insist there was no crisis in Zimbabwe, and to call for patience: “I wouldn’t describe that as a crisis. It’s a normal electoral process in Zimbabwe. We have to wait for Zimbabwe Electoral Commission to release (the results),” he told reporters.
Ahead of the summit in Zambia, both Britain and the US condemned the use of violence by Zimbabwe security forces and supporters of the ruling Zanu-PF party.
Mr Brown said he and African leaders shared the Zimbabwean people's "demonstrated commitment" to democracy.
“I cannot understand why it is taking so long to announce the result of the presidential elections. I am appalled by the signs that the regime is once again resorting to intimidation and violence," Mr Brown said.
“We will be vigilant. The international community will remain careful to do nothing to undermine efforts to secure an outcome that reflects the democratic will of the people of Zimbabwe.
“But the international community's patience with the regime is wearing thin.”
Human rights watchdogs and Zimbabwe's opposition party the Movement for Democratic Change say Zanu-PF has unleashed a campaign against violence since losing control of parliament in the March 29 election.
The US State Department called on the Zimbabwe government to “immediately desist” from acts of violence and allow the electoral process to continue.
“These incidents appear to target individuals who voted against Zanu-PF candidates during the elections,” said Sean McCormack, State Department spokesman.
Today's meeting with Mr Mbeki - the first between the two men since the March 29 election - was a rare sign that Mr Mugabe might be willing to listen to international concerns, though South Africa and other African nations have been loath to criticise the ageing Zimbabwean leader.
Up to 10 African heads of state were expected to participate in today's Southern African Development Community (SADC)emergency summit in Lusaka. It was called by Zambian President Levy Mwanawasa, the only southern African leader who has publicly criticised Mr Mugabe's policies.
Mr Mwanawasa told the assembled leaders: “SADC can no longer continue to stand by and do nothing when one of its members is experiencing political and economic difficulties.”
But he added: “This summit is not intended to put his excellency, Robert Mugabe, in the dock. In fact it would be un-African to even make such a suggestion”
Zimbabwe opposition leader Morgan Tsvangirai also attended. He claims to have won the presidential election outright and has travelled around southern Africa in recent days asking neighbouring leaders to push for Mugabe to resign after 28 years in power.
In Botswana on Friday, Mr Tsvangirai said he was a “prime target” for security forces and feared returning home.
His party has accused security forces and ruling party militants of engaging in a wave of violence against perceived opponents to intimidate voters and ensure Mugabe wins a run-off election. It had been organising a rally for Monday, but that may be jeopardised by the ban on political demonstrations.
Militants this week invaded the country's few remaining white-owned farms, saying they were trying to protect Zimbabweans from encroaching colonialism.
Win a luxury weekend to Newcastle and its neighbour Gateshead, find out more here
Risk, resilience and embracing new technology
Industry sectors news at a glance. Interactive heatmap, video and podcast
Discover the power of collective thinking. Submit a solution and be in with a chance to win a Media Hub Home Entertainment System
The inside track on current trends in the charity, not for profit and social enterprise sectors
Everything the Business Traveller needs to know to make a better trip
Make the most of the summer and enter our fabulous photographic competition, you could win a £5000 holiday
Corsica is an island of beauty and contrast, an ideal holiday destination
Enjoy further reading from Travel to Fashion, Business to Sport, discover more
Shortcuts to help you find sections and articles
The clever way to lease a new car is with Car leasing made simple™
2009
per month on 36-month
Personal Contract Hire (PCH)
2008
42850
Car Insurance
£24,250 - £30,346
MI5
London
£60,000
The Environment Agency
Bristol
Up to £90K
Boots
Midlands
OTE £85k
Credit Protection Association
Nationwide Opportunities
Completely London
Luxury Condo's in Manhattan with NYC views
The best new homes in Wimbledon?
Nationwide
Fabulous Cruise And Cruise & Stay Offers Including Virgin Atlantic Flights Prices Start From Only £699pp!
Last Minute Cruise And Cruise & Stay Offers. Med From £499pp, Caribbean From £699pp!
5 star quality at a 3 star price.
8 fabulous Canadian cities ...you won’t find cheaper
Contact our advertising team for advertising and sponsorship in Times Online, The Times and The Sunday Times, or place your advertisement.
Times Online Services: Dating | Jobs | Property Search | Used Cars | Holidays | Births, Marriages, Deaths | Subscriptions | E-paper
News International associated websites: Globrix Property Search | Property Finder | Milkround
Copyright 2009 Times Newspapers Ltd.
This service is provided on Times Newspapers' standard Terms and Conditions. Please read our Privacy Policy.To inquire about a licence to reproduce material from Times Online, The Times or The Sunday Times, click here.This website is published by a member of the News International Group. News International Limited, 1 Virginia St, London E98 1XY, is the holding company for the News International group and is registered in England No 81701. VAT number GB 243 8054 69.
I am writing from South Africa and have been watching the unfolding of events in Zimbabwe each and every hour. I cannot believe that our president, President Thabo Mbeki has come out of the pre-summit meeting with Robert Mugabe, stating that there is "NO CRISIS IN ZIMBABWE". I have always respected President Thabo Mbeki and felt that he has brought much to our country, in spite of some poor decisions in areas such as HIV and AIDS, Manto Tshabalala-Mtsimang etc. But this denial of what is going on in Zimbabwe and his failure to take a stand to ensure that the people of Zimbabwe are able to get an expedient and honest reflection of teh outcome of the elections on 29th March 2008 is rediculous. The rest of the world stand by and watch on without saying a word . . . surely they would have had an interest in the abuse taking place in Zimbabwe if there was oil and money concerened!!!!!!!
Robyn Schoem, Cape Town, South Africa
Could not more agree with Gilber Phiri
"Which World Mr Brown are you talking about? Is it the same world sick of the occupation of Basra and alliance with human rights abusers.
Which world Mr. Brown? It must indeed be a weird world (politicians) that watches Darfur burn and starve and yet be obsessed with Zimbabwe!
Mary, London,
âI cannot understand why it is taking so long to announce the result of the presidential elections."
Oh, come on, Gordon. You can do it. Take a guess!
Theo Nelson, South Hams,
Pathetic hyperbole from our PM.
Why so much focus on the banana republic of Zimbabwe?
There are loads of terribly run countries in the World: Burma, Angola, Iraq, Iran, Egypt, China, Venezuela, Congo, the list goes on and on.
Simon, Harrogate, UK
Unbelievable! "No crisis" says Mbeki "normal process". He is as much to blame as anyone for Zimbabwe - just what is his problem? Does he beleive the white stooge claims by Mugabe.
Democracy and Africa are obviously incompatible. A real shame
Andrew, Cambridge,
I believe the other African States do bless the Megabe regime
and encourage him with their blessing to keep hold of power.
lets be honest do you think that they want Megabe and his cronies living in any of their countries when he 'retires'.
tooo risky
Sid james, lancashire, england
It makes me wonder if what we are seeing in Zimbabwe is a pre-cursor to South Africa, say, in 10 - 15 years time. I wonder if the ANC would relinquish power in a fairly fought election if some new, popular leader appeared in future? Or would Africas premier state revert to African stereotype and follow the Mugabe route? Surely not as long as Mandela is alive, but afterwards, who knows?
I'm not surprised Mbeki is supporting Mugabe. I'm sure he personally knows right from wrong, but their mutual history of support makes it difficult for him to say so in public. In sure he did so in private however. Either way, it's really quite frustrating given that SA could turn the lights out in Zimbabwe and of Mugabe and his regime at the flick of a switch.
Robert Laundon, Cambridge, Cambridgeshire
Err Mr Brown have you seen what the Israelis are doing to the Palestinians?
John, London,
Why doesn't the world community impose sanctions on South Africa for supporting Mugabe-starting with cancelling the World Football Cup. We are quick to condemn the Chinese so what is so sacred about Africa?
George, Glasgow, UK
Sorry Neil in Gloucestershire, but I as a South African am more than fed up with hearing for the billionth time how the Europeans are always to blame for Africa's ills. True equality will only come to Zimbabwe and South Africa too, when we can look one another in the eye and hold ourselves responsible for our comments and actions irrespective of the colour of our skins. The paternalistic approach adopted particularly by the Brits in regard to African development is anachronistic, and should be regarded with suspicion as yet more closet patronage from the north. If you truly see Mugabe as an equal, then tell him to get the hell out in no uncertain terms and stop bleating about white guilt. The fact that the West in general pussyfoots around the Zimbabwe question is precisely because they are uncomfortably aware of Mugabe as an African leader, and don't know that on earth to do about the lunatic. Imagine him as an African Milosevic and act accordingly.
Julian Begg, Lenham, KENT
It was Peter Mandelson who said "we cant let democracy get in the way of the EU project"
It was Brown who felt so treacherous about signing the Treaty(constitution) he had to do it in private.
As for the manifestos of Liberals and Nu Labour regarding the right of the electorate a vote on the treaty they were not worth the paper they were written on.
Mugabes a tyrant but lets not forget our democratic right was sold for a billion pound rebate,some MEPs pensions and the presidency of europe
Andy Manning, Harpenden, Herts
"Mr Mugabe dismissed Mr Brown as "a little tiny dot" who could not speak for the world.
"If Brown is the world, sure, he will lose patience. I know Brown as a little tiny dot on this planet,â the 84-year-old Zimbabwean leader said."
The ball is in your court....Mr. Dot! Lots of talk...any action?
Garth Strong, San Diego, USA
I can't believe the invective against Gordon Brown (and I'm no Labour supporter). It's not Mr Brown who is delaying the election results (who would believe them now? How long does it take to count votes?). It's not Mr Brown who is banning political meetings. Just get your andt-Labour glasses off anti-Brownites and aim your invective where it belongs - yes, Mugabe and Mbeki. Not a crisis in Zimbabwe - no wonder the ANC voted Mbeki out. Mbeke should remember what happened to a certain Mr Callaghan who wondered where the crisis was. The African leaders are petrified of the MDC because it will show the people that they can get rid of governments - yes, even teh ANC in South Africa. As for those talking about China - well, the last time I looked inflation in China was not at 100,000% nor were people starving.
Ian Burgess, Bristol,
Gordon has spoken!! Mugabe must be shaking in his boots now! Not!!
KMacca, Stoke on T., Staffs
Well I guess Brown knows the signs of people having had enough of useless leaders!
Rob, ex Notts, Vancouver BC
Oh yea. Muagbe must be quaking in his shoes!
Does anybody really think that such a statement will have any impact - except laughter.
Chris, Ashford, Middx, UK
Please Brown may you say the same thing to Presidents Mubarak,Paul Biya,Umar Bongo,PM Zenawi to mention just a few.It may interest you to know that Paul Biya of cameroun has just made himself the life president of that African country,but little or no fuss from the west is coming on that.
Ibrahim Sambo , Abuja, Nigeria
'Little tiny dot' - He got that right!
Rollie, Plymouth, UK
Heard about Quatro? It was a camp in Angola, - lots of ANC skeletons buried in Angola.
Mugabe helped the ANC with camps in Southern Zimbabwe. I wonder how many ANC skeletons are buried in Zimbabwe? Now you can wonder why Mbeki will not say word one to Mugabe.
Pete, Calne, UK
Up until now, I didn't agree with anything that Mr Mugabe says, but to describe Gordon Brown as a "small dot in the world" is about right!
Richard Edwards, Sandy, UK
What if FW de Klerk had held back election results in South Africa in 1994, not allowing Mandela to become the country's first truly democratically elected president?
Would the OAU have said there was no crisis?
Would the OAU have agreed to wait indefinitely while the National Party fudged the results?
RogerP, Pretoria, South Africa
Of course Mbeki will support Mugabe to the end - he is all to aware that where goes ZANU-PF, there goes its fellow "liberation" movement, the ANC.
Arnold Ward, Weybridge, Surrey, UK
Will the ban on political rallies annpounced by the police apply to Zanu PF?
PMS, Southampton, UK
Oh really Mr. Brown! And when, pretty please, is the world going to lose patience with China???
JD, Liverpool,
Big deal ! Brown has a chance to do something and surprise surprise, dithers and obfuscates and finally comes up with more blah, blah, blah.
One would have a hard job to be as incompetent as Mugabe but Brown comes frighteningly close. Definitely the worst British Prime Minister ever.
Dave Reynolds, York, England
Which World Mr Brown are you talking about? Is it the same world sick of your occupation of Basra and dalliance with human rights abusers- China and Saudi Arabia?
Which world Mr. Brown? It must indeed be a weird world that watches Darfur burn and starve and yet be unhealthily obsessed with Zimbabwe!
Gilbert Phiri, Swindon, UK
JMB The operative word is "forms" (of democracy). We have the Democratic Republic of the Congo for one, and the recent "democratic" elections held in Zimbabwe.
Regrettably, the word democracy is one that African leaders hide behind - it is used as a front.
Dave, Knysna,
"Gordon Brown says he is âappalledâ by new signs of intimidation ...."
Gordon Brown should stop criticising other countries and put his own house in order. As the most spied on and overregulated society in the world he has huge room for improvement. Only then can he afford to attack Mugabe, irrespective of how appalling Mugabe is.
Steve, Ruislip, Middx
Sorry Neil to blame Cecil John Rhodes for a problem in 2008 is just not credible. Mugabe wants to cling to power and his crony Mbeki is just as guilty of the vicious events now taking place. Just like Iraq most African countries do not subscrib to majority voting principles. There have always been leaders and even if you are in the majority ,what they say goes. Saddam Hussein was a perfect example of this concept.
George Townsend, Elk Grove, CA USA
It is significant that the only SADC country to criticise Mugabe openly is also the only SADC country that has managed to free itself from the rule from their own 'party of liberation'. Hence Mugabe's 'Who is Mwanawasa?" view of the post-colonial world. Opposition parties present an unecessary threat to all other SADC leaders.
There is a relatively simple way to settle the election result if SADC wanted to look for one that spared Zimabweans the ongoing rape, intimidation and violence by the state. Simply allow the 5 million disenfranchised Zimbabweans in the diaspora to cast our vote by post.
The only reason the election may be claimed as a close call to date is because 5 million of us have already had our votes covertly cast for us by the ruling party, to bolster their other key voting bloc (which has surged in recent years) - our dead relatives back home.
Mike Mhepo, Leicester / Harare,
Unfortunately, Zimbabwe, like a lot of Colonial territiories, was an artificially created country, in this case by Cecil Rhodes. His interests were purely business, profit and Empire Building. The rights, needs and interest of indigenous people didn't even come into his thinking, in fact when there land was needed by the colonists they were simply evicted.. The "country's" borders cut across tribal boundaries in a way which today makes it almost impossible to Govern as a unified and homogenous nation. Added to this are the deep tribal tensions and divisions created by the British colonists with their traditional Divide and Rule policy. Remember, Zimbabawe (or Rhodesia as it was called then) was only colonised in the latter half of the 19th century, and in the mid-10th century, when a white minority Government illegally siezed power, there were native people still alive who remembered the European colonisation and land grab. Sadly, Zimbabwe is another victim of European colonialisation
Neil, Gloucestershire, England
Mr Codner, I think that your comment that "democracy" and "Africans" do not mix is a little simplistic. I think that even the most basic of research will show you that there are states within Africa that practice forms of democracy, some that are more aligned with the West conception of democracy than others!
JMB, London, UK
@ peter codner
It is nonsense to suggest that democracy and africans do not mix. If that was so, Africans in Zimbabwe would be celebrating the Mugabe dictactorship they are living under. Instead they are voting against it, and struggling to overcome it!
Charan Muzaya, London, UK
robert hitlarbe is showing the world that democracy and africans do not mix
peter codner, devizes, england